Patched Tire Still Safe?
#1
Advanced
Thread Starter
Member Since: Jan 2005
Location: Upstate New York
Posts: 93
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Patched Tire Still Safe?
OK, this is probably a dumb question, but here goes: I ran over something and got a hole in my front passenger side tire. It has been successfully patched and does not leak. I assumed that this tire is no longer fit for high speed track day events, but I spoke to a fellow at Bestusedtires (an internet site specializing in used tires) who claims patched tires are safe for high speed driving, so long as the patch is on the bottom and not near the edge of the tire. I'd like to hear from others their opinion on this.
#2
Originally Posted by MIZR1
OK, this is probably a dumb question, but here goes: I ran over something and got a hole in my front passenger side tire. It has been successfully patched and does not leak. I assumed that this tire is no longer fit for high speed track day events, but I spoke to a fellow at Bestusedtires (an internet site specializing in used tires) who claims patched tires are safe for high speed driving, so long as the patch is on the bottom and not near the edge of the tire. I'd like to hear from others their opinion on this.
When I was bleeding my brakes with the tires off prior to a track event this weekend, I noticed BOTH a plug and a new nail in one of my rear tires. I brought the car to two tire shops, and both confirmed that I should not run on the tire, even with proper patches. I panicked and called TireRack for two new rear F1 Supercar tires, to be Fedexed Saturday Delivery to Sebring, as I could not find the tires anywhere locally (Goodyear dealer, Chevy dealer, and a few others). The cost of this was uncomfortable, but I needed insurance that I wouldn't waste a whole track weekend because I had a tire problem.
I had the tire shop dismount the tire and do proper patching from the inside for the drive to the track, expecting to have to have the new rear tires mounted there. The tires held air without a problem on the drive to the track. Consulting with a half dozen DE Instructors, two of whom are family members, they recommended running the tire and just checking pressure after each run, being careful to note any signs of instability or problems while out on track. They all admitted to running on track with plugged/patched tires without a problem and felt that with proper precaution, all would be safe.
Personally, a tire plug is not something I'd run on. I had the tire shop do a proper tire repair from the inside - and only on the tread, not anything near the sidewalls.
Now, I'm not recommending to anyone else what to do - it's your safety at risk - but I went the whole weekend without any pressure loss or performance impact. I now have to ship the tires from FL to home in SC, incurring even more cost, but I know I'll use the tires soon anyway just from normal street driving.
I'll probably get flamed something fierce by the community here for running on this "bad" tire and risking my safety and the others on track -but in consulting with those folks, I was told that catastrophic tire failure was extremely unlikely, and that the tire would generally just have a slow leak if there was any failure of the patch. I stand by my decision to run on the tire, and I'd do it again, just being extra careful to check pressures before/after each run and check the tire for any outwardly apparent damage.
#5
Melting Slicks
Originally Posted by MIZR1
OK, this is probably a dumb question, but here goes: I ran over something and got a hole in my front passenger side tire. It has been successfully patched and does not leak. I assumed that this tire is no longer fit for high speed track day events, but I spoke to a fellow at Bestusedtires (an internet site specializing in used tires) who claims patched tires are safe for high speed driving, so long as the patch is on the bottom and not near the edge of the tire. I'd like to hear from others their opinion on this.
#6
Le Mans Master
I was told it depends on how close it is to the sidewall (flexing issues). If it's more than a couple inches away, you should be good.
As a matter of fact...I think everyone of my street tires has a patch somewhere. I ran plenty of times with patches.
As a matter of fact...I think everyone of my street tires has a patch somewhere. I ran plenty of times with patches.
#7
Advanced
Thread Starter
Member Since: Jan 2005
Location: Upstate New York
Posts: 93
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Thanks folks for the quick input. I feel a lot better now about using the tire. And you saved me quite a few bucks. Now, lets see, what upgrade should I spend that money on?
#8
Safety Car
there is a thing called a "patch-plug" combo. it pulls through the tire from the inside, and is a patch at the same time. the plug portion prevents water from seeping in there and destroying the cords from the inside out.
that is the only thing I would run at the track.
however, I have seen personal friends of mine run on PLUGS !!! (against my advice) speeds up to 145-150 mph on a plug.
nothing happened... and he still has the plug in the tire till this very day.
I always have extra tires with me. one lost event is enough dough to cover a spare tire. that's how I look at it, and that's why I always save my old R tires. My tire rack is always packed to the max.
that is the only thing I would run at the track.
however, I have seen personal friends of mine run on PLUGS !!! (against my advice) speeds up to 145-150 mph on a plug.
nothing happened... and he still has the plug in the tire till this very day.
I always have extra tires with me. one lost event is enough dough to cover a spare tire. that's how I look at it, and that's why I always save my old R tires. My tire rack is always packed to the max.
#10
Drifting
Member Since: Feb 2004
Location: Champaign, IL
Posts: 1,485
Likes: 0
Received 1 Like
on
1 Post
St. Jude Donor '05
If it's a plug-patch from the inside on a small puncture as mentioned above you've got nothing to worry about, it's safe.
A regular plug on the other hand I'd be worried about coming out at higher speeds with the tire heating up and expanding/distorting with speed.
A regular plug on the other hand I'd be worried about coming out at higher speeds with the tire heating up and expanding/distorting with speed.
#11
Advanced
Thread Starter
Member Since: Jan 2005
Location: Upstate New York
Posts: 93
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Its not a plug. and I will confirm that it is satisfactory when I switch to the new wheels I just bought. Bearing in mind I'm just about to start the autoX and track day stuff (although I am a longtime MotoX rider), please dont flame me if I acknowledge that I don't know the following: what is a DE? thanks again for the input
#12
Melting Slicks
Depends on extent of damage and qaulity of repair. I say, small damage and patched correctly (from the inside) is acceptable. How hard due plan to push the car should be considered.
I patch a Goodrich R1 tire from the outside to finish a track weekend without issues.
I patch a Goodrich R1 tire from the outside to finish a track weekend without issues.