Save the manuals
#1
Team Owner
Thread Starter
Member Since: Mar 2001
Location: Boston, Dallas, Detroit, SoCal, back to Boston MA
Posts: 30,606
Received 239 Likes
on
167 Posts
Save the manuals
No, I don't mean the FSM's
http://www.caranddriver.com/features...car_and_driver
a stick shift wasn't even an option on my truck when I bought it.
http://www.caranddriver.com/features...car_and_driver
a stick shift wasn't even an option on my truck when I bought it.
#2
Safety Car
Member Since: Nov 2000
Location: Shenandoah Valley Virginia
Posts: 4,549
Likes: 0
Received 27 Likes
on
24 Posts
Unfortunately, we better get used to it. With Govt regs on mileage and emissions, manuals are going to disappear before long. Look at the mileage that the europeans are getting on the large high HP sedans with 6 - 7 - and now 8 speed trannys. If GM would offer a really good double clutch unit on the Vette, I would purchase one in an instant.
#3
Safety Car
My wife tried the DSG on her GTI and still bought a 6 speed manual. I never tried it, but she said "it just didn't feel right."
Of course, same woman I threw out on Sears Point and Laguna Seca as her first two tracks in a car she'd never driven before -- Mazda RX-7 prepped to Pro7 rules when she'd never driven RWD -- and she hung in, even in the absolute downpour at Laguna. So take it for what it is. She's said recently she'd like an automatic Corvette to commute in.
Of course, same woman I threw out on Sears Point and Laguna Seca as her first two tracks in a car she'd never driven before -- Mazda RX-7 prepped to Pro7 rules when she'd never driven RWD -- and she hung in, even in the absolute downpour at Laguna. So take it for what it is. She's said recently she'd like an automatic Corvette to commute in.
#4
Melting Slicks
I've driven a lot of "automated manual" transmisions, mostly the "DSG" type but even a F430 w/ the F1 single clutch (the new 458 has a dual clutch). The earlier systems were pretty poor around town, but all of them were pretty impressive at "race pace." The newest systems are really, really good.
The reality is they're better than even a professional driver with a "real" manual. Lightning quick upshifts that don't upset the chassis, never a missed gear, perfect rev-matched downshifts every time..
All that being said, I still prefer shifting myself. Especially for a fun street car where I'm not worried about extracting tenths of a second. I'd love to have the sequential that LG offers for my Z06, or if Chevy ever put a DSG in the 'vette and it could get retrofitted in my Z I'd have to think about it.
-TJ
The reality is they're better than even a professional driver with a "real" manual. Lightning quick upshifts that don't upset the chassis, never a missed gear, perfect rev-matched downshifts every time..
All that being said, I still prefer shifting myself. Especially for a fun street car where I'm not worried about extracting tenths of a second. I'd love to have the sequential that LG offers for my Z06, or if Chevy ever put a DSG in the 'vette and it could get retrofitted in my Z I'd have to think about it.
-TJ
#5
Le Mans Master
Member Since: Oct 2007
Location: Akron Ohio
Posts: 8,867
Received 1,741 Likes
on
939 Posts
2023 C5 of the Year Finalist - Modified
2022 C5 of the Year Finalist - Modified
St. Jude Donor '09-'10-'11
I went to a BMW ride and drive event on Monday and both the BMW 535i and the Mercedes E350 I tested were autos, and both felt unresponsive and boring. The E350 had paddle shifters and even in sport mode it shifted very sluggishly. The BMW did feel a lot better with its auto-stick shifter but neither was very "sport" inspiring. I drove both cars as if they were my own, so you know it was a good test!
If this becomes the only option for Corvettes I hope they get it right.
If this becomes the only option for Corvettes I hope they get it right.
#6
Melting Slicks
I went to a BMW ride and drive event on Monday and both the BMW 535i and the Mercedes E350 I tested were autos, and both felt unresponsive and boring. The E350 had paddle shifters and even in sport mode it shifted very sluggishly. The BMW did feel a lot better with its auto-stick shifter but neither was very "sport" inspiring. I drove both cars as if they were my own, so you know it was a good test!
If this becomes the only option for Corvettes I hope they get it right.
If this becomes the only option for Corvettes I hope they get it right.
-TJ
#7
Le Mans Master
The speed and efficiency of these DSG's makes them pretty inevitable. I doubt we'll see DSG-only in the Vettes in C7 but by the time C8 rolls around we might. I do however think it is very important that C7 has that available to keep Corvette world-class in performance. I think the question would be more if they offer two automatics in C7 to provide a lower price point or if manufacturing costs would insist on only offering one.
#9
Drifting
Member Since: Sep 2002
Location: Suwanee,Ga
Posts: 1,642
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
The speed and efficiency of these DSG's makes them pretty inevitable. I doubt we'll see DSG-only in the Vettes in C7 but by the time C8 rolls around we might. I do however think it is very important that C7 has that available to keep Corvette world-class in performance. I think the question would be more if they offer two automatics in C7 to provide a lower price point or if manufacturing costs would insist on only offering one.
What's the question? One more "edge" to minimize driver error?
The future is a Nintendo generation that can run with less skill, because it won't be needed?
Heck?! Why get IN the car!!! Use cameras, remote controls, a couple vibrating devices in your pants, and your good to go? Stay at home, write a check, win a race?
No danger, no effort? That's the way things are going?? aren't they??
TJM
#10
Le Mans Master
What's the question? One more "edge" to minimize driver error?
The future is a Nintendo generation that can run with less skill, because it won't be needed?
Heck?! Why get IN the car!!! Use cameras, remote controls, a couple vibrating devices in your pants, and your good to go? Stay at home, write a check, win a race?
No danger, no effort? That's the way things are going?? aren't they??
TJM
The future is a Nintendo generation that can run with less skill, because it won't be needed?
Heck?! Why get IN the car!!! Use cameras, remote controls, a couple vibrating devices in your pants, and your good to go? Stay at home, write a check, win a race?
No danger, no effort? That's the way things are going?? aren't they??
TJM
I wasn't expressing my opinion, just commenting on market realities for these guys. I absolutely love driving a manual, having the control and testing MY skills not just the car and while I understand and appreciate your passion it ignores the reality that our view is a small, small percentage. Corvette has almost always had a significant majority of volume with automatics. They gotta be able to sell them to more than just the truly hardcore and the fact is the vast majority of their customers don't enjoy the cars in the fashion we do. So if that means DSGs get built so be it because it allows them to sell enough volume to still build the cars we love, and with any luck that will continue to be proper cars with 3 pedals for a long, long time.