PCA's fire extinguisher requirement
#1
Drifting
Thread Starter
PCA's fire extinguisher requirement
So PCA requires a fire extinguisher within reach of the driver for anyone other than green beginner group.
Who has run with them with a street car and where did you mount it?
I figure in front of the pass seat doesn't qualify.
Maybe front of driver's seat, problem is the extinguisher bracket I have from Vetteworks does not fit well with my Arizen seat sliders unless I push the seat back so much I can't reach the pedals.
So maybe mounted on my harness bar. I can reach it if I unbuckle my 6 pts, but not strapped down. Wondering if that suffices for them.
anyone?
"FIRE EXTINGUISHER: Must be securely mounted (metal to metal) within reach of driver. Must be BC or ABC rated, 2.5 lb minimum and must be fully charged. HALON/HALOTRON type is highly recommended. Required in White run group and above; highly recommended for all others."
Who has run with them with a street car and where did you mount it?
I figure in front of the pass seat doesn't qualify.
Maybe front of driver's seat, problem is the extinguisher bracket I have from Vetteworks does not fit well with my Arizen seat sliders unless I push the seat back so much I can't reach the pedals.
So maybe mounted on my harness bar. I can reach it if I unbuckle my 6 pts, but not strapped down. Wondering if that suffices for them.
anyone?
"FIRE EXTINGUISHER: Must be securely mounted (metal to metal) within reach of driver. Must be BC or ABC rated, 2.5 lb minimum and must be fully charged. HALON/HALOTRON type is highly recommended. Required in White run group and above; highly recommended for all others."
#2
Racer
Member Since: Oct 2010
Location: Huntington Massachusetts
Posts: 440
Likes: 0
Received 4 Likes
on
2 Posts
"FIRE EXTINGUISHER: Must be securely mounted (metal to metal) within reach of driver. Must be BC or ABC rated, 2.5 lb minimum and must be fully charged. HALON/HALOTRON type is highly recommended. Required in White run group and above; highly recommended for all others."
If you are willing to give up the back piece of your console for the day (just 3 nuts to remove), you can reuse the bolts on top of the tunnel to secure your fire extinguisher bracket. Here is my setup (note that this is a 2.5lbs, it wouldn't work with a 5lbs):
In my C4, I had it bolted horizontally behind the 2 seats in the middle. Can't do that anymore with my rollcage bar in the way but that might still be an option for you.
#3
I ran PCA FOR seven years. Mine was mounted just in front of my seat.
The rule doesn't really specify if you have to reach the bottle while buckled in so some took liberty with the location.
I'd try really hard to fab a bracket brace to get it as close as you can get it.
Otherwise it's kind of useless really.
Your PCA Chapter should have a tech Chair. He's the one you really should ask. He may not understand any limitations with Vettes.
The market for Pcar seats, brackets and fire bottles is better developed with easier options than I've found in this community.
Good luck.
I need a bottle in my C6Z too.
The rule doesn't really specify if you have to reach the bottle while buckled in so some took liberty with the location.
I'd try really hard to fab a bracket brace to get it as close as you can get it.
Otherwise it's kind of useless really.
Your PCA Chapter should have a tech Chair. He's the one you really should ask. He may not understand any limitations with Vettes.
The market for Pcar seats, brackets and fire bottles is better developed with easier options than I've found in this community.
Good luck.
I need a bottle in my C6Z too.
#6
Drifting
Thread Starter
#7
Melting Slicks
I would strongly suggest you not put the extinguisher on the drivers side. If it ever came loose from the bracket- and I've seen it happen- you sure don't want that thing rolling around your feet and pedals. Same for the console mount,
#9
Drifting
This is what I use. I have mine mounted on my PFADT roll bar between the driver and passenger seat diagonal bar.
http://www.drakeautomotivegroup.com/...G.aspx?wid=141
http://www.drakeautomotivegroup.com/...G.aspx?wid=141
#10
Good discussion guys. Great thread OP. "Within reach" isn't very explicit. I'd still call the club tech chair.
CVR Porsche Club in CT didn't seem to have an issue mounting on either seat.
CT BMW tech form says nothing about it. Their annual inspection form does however: Make sure the bottle mounting is secure with a metal bracket. The driver must be able to reach the extinguisher or the firing button or lever while seated and belted in.
SCDA and the NEQ Audi Club don't specify so you could run with either and do what works for you.
I couldn't even find a reference in the Solo SCCA rules. The Brey Krause website shows it mounted to the driver seat. How else could you really reach it in an accident?
I think the mount is more the issue, is it correctly mounted.
What clubs specifically don't allow driver seat mounting?
It is a great discussion either way. Can someone post a link to a club rules page that does not allow driver side fire bottles?
CVR Porsche Club in CT didn't seem to have an issue mounting on either seat.
CT BMW tech form says nothing about it. Their annual inspection form does however: Make sure the bottle mounting is secure with a metal bracket. The driver must be able to reach the extinguisher or the firing button or lever while seated and belted in.
SCDA and the NEQ Audi Club don't specify so you could run with either and do what works for you.
I couldn't even find a reference in the Solo SCCA rules. The Brey Krause website shows it mounted to the driver seat. How else could you really reach it in an accident?
I think the mount is more the issue, is it correctly mounted.
What clubs specifically don't allow driver seat mounting?
It is a great discussion either way. Can someone post a link to a club rules page that does not allow driver side fire bottles?
Last edited by 12zo; 05-29-2014 at 10:16 AM. Reason: Added BMW info
#11
Drifting
For me on the scenarios I ran!!
From what I can tell many mounting locations in a Corvette end up being show pieces.
If something passes tech but cant be used in a fire is it anything else?
Besides the smartest move of clearing the car and letting someone well trained with a large extinguisher attack it. Many involve opening the hood on the way out of the car, or dealing with a passenger side door.
Have to think of the scenarios where you, or a brave corner worker may need access to it.
"For me" or a corner worker.
I tried and found I cant access it in any situation at all mounted to the harness bar with race seats installed. "But it does look nice!"
Tried to mount to the armrest area with no luck, flailing arms on metal edges are bad.
To access it from a secure bracket in front of the passenger seat I would have had to bail out of a burning car "that possibly didn't have battery power", run around get the passenger door open reach into a burning car to unlatch the door, ext ext.? And with the door closed there is almost no way for anyone to know its there or access it.
The Corvette fires I have seen are from the fuel line at manifold, oil from a departing connecting rods, trans fluid from cooler on header, engine oil from cooler, or electrical in nature. Think of the locations, electrical and fluid paths, egress, and attack options?
A secure mount with 3 locking options on bottle just made sense in "my" situation that I hopefully will never need.
From what I can tell many mounting locations in a Corvette end up being show pieces.
If something passes tech but cant be used in a fire is it anything else?
Besides the smartest move of clearing the car and letting someone well trained with a large extinguisher attack it. Many involve opening the hood on the way out of the car, or dealing with a passenger side door.
Have to think of the scenarios where you, or a brave corner worker may need access to it.
"For me" or a corner worker.
I tried and found I cant access it in any situation at all mounted to the harness bar with race seats installed. "But it does look nice!"
Tried to mount to the armrest area with no luck, flailing arms on metal edges are bad.
To access it from a secure bracket in front of the passenger seat I would have had to bail out of a burning car "that possibly didn't have battery power", run around get the passenger door open reach into a burning car to unlatch the door, ext ext.? And with the door closed there is almost no way for anyone to know its there or access it.
The Corvette fires I have seen are from the fuel line at manifold, oil from a departing connecting rods, trans fluid from cooler on header, engine oil from cooler, or electrical in nature. Think of the locations, electrical and fluid paths, egress, and attack options?
A secure mount with 3 locking options on bottle just made sense in "my" situation that I hopefully will never need.
Last edited by blkbrd69; 05-29-2014 at 10:30 AM.
#12
Racer
Member Since: Oct 2010
Location: Huntington Massachusetts
Posts: 440
Likes: 0
Received 4 Likes
on
2 Posts
NEHA rules (http://www.hillclimb.org/rules_regs/...s/14tech.pdf):
"All portable extinguisher brackets shall be securely mounted to vehicle. Portable extinguishers must not be mounted on the floor in the driver foot well if the car is equipped with suspended pedals. It should be mounted within reach of the driver. Additional extinguishers may be mounted beyond the driver’s immediate reach. No non-metal or elastic straps, latches, or brackets are permitted. Brackets for 2.5-lb net and
smaller extinguishers may use a single latching metal strap. Extinguishers over 2.5-lb net must have at least one additional metal restraining feature that secures the tank of the extinguisher to the bracket. The additional restraint(s) may consist of a second strap, a receiver on the bracket to secure the bottom of the tank, or a similar device and should still permit rapid removal of the extinguisher"
"All portable extinguisher brackets shall be securely mounted to vehicle. Portable extinguishers must not be mounted on the floor in the driver foot well if the car is equipped with suspended pedals. It should be mounted within reach of the driver. Additional extinguishers may be mounted beyond the driver’s immediate reach. No non-metal or elastic straps, latches, or brackets are permitted. Brackets for 2.5-lb net and
smaller extinguishers may use a single latching metal strap. Extinguishers over 2.5-lb net must have at least one additional metal restraining feature that secures the tank of the extinguisher to the bracket. The additional restraint(s) may consist of a second strap, a receiver on the bracket to secure the bottom of the tank, or a similar device and should still permit rapid removal of the extinguisher"
#13
Racer
Member Since: Oct 2010
Location: Huntington Massachusetts
Posts: 440
Likes: 0
Received 4 Likes
on
2 Posts
To access it from a secure bracket in front of the passenger seat I would have had to bail out of a burning car "that possibly didn't have battery power", run around get the passenger door open reach into a burning car to unlatch the door, ext ext.? And with the door closed there is almost no way for anyone to know its there or access it.
The best thing remains a real fire suppression system.
#14
Drifting
Thread Starter
Tech chair confirmed that in front of pass seat is acceptable. I may mess with the center console idea by removing the rear piece but for this event will probably do the easy thing and mount in pass footwell. Thanks all.
#16
Tech Contributor
Member Since: Oct 1999
Location: Charlotte, NC (formerly Endicott, NY)
Posts: 40,094
Received 8,928 Likes
on
5,333 Posts
When they state you have to be able to reach the bottle while belted in that limits your options considerably. Even the front of the driver seat isn't reachable when you are belted in. Mounting on a harness or roll bar behind the seats isn't reachable either.
Bill
Bill
#17
Safety Car
Keep in mind that in an accident this thing can be a missile. I know of at least one fatality caused by the extinguisher coming loose. I really hate the cage mounts.
I think the whole rule is stupid. I'm running if my car catches fire. Most of the drivers at the track have never tried to put out a real fire. It's takes a little bit of skill. Skills that you have probably never practiced.
Here's an article I did last year on fire systems.
Richard Newton
I think the whole rule is stupid. I'm running if my car catches fire. Most of the drivers at the track have never tried to put out a real fire. It's takes a little bit of skill. Skills that you have probably never practiced.
Here's an article I did last year on fire systems.
Richard Newton
#18
Instructor
Member Since: Oct 2012
Location: Pinehurst North Carolina
Posts: 222
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Is this being enforced in (at) all PCA HPDE events? First I have heard of it. I instruct at First Settlers and Zone 2 PCA. I have no such device in my Z06.
vz
vz
#20
Ok, I'm willing to be educated, where do you mount yours?