Should I Switch to S/S Brake Lines??
#1
Racer
Thread Starter
Should I Switch to S/S Brake Lines??
I'm looking to do an HPDE at Willow Springs in a couple of months and I was wondering if I should switch to stainless steel brake lines. I've done a couple of HPDEs so far and some hard canyon driving with no issues. I'm just trying to find out if it's worth the effort. If so, what brand do you recommend?
#2
Melting Slicks
I'm looking to do an HPDE at Willow Springs in a couple of months and I was wondering if I should switch to stainless steel brake lines. I've done a couple of HPDEs so far and some hard canyon driving with no issues. I'm just trying to find out if it's worth the effort. If so, what brand do you recommend?
Goodridge and Stoptech seem to be often used.
Last edited by Racingswh; 06-22-2014 at 02:07 AM.
#3
Team Owner
Are the lines now in the car original? Year of car? If so, definitely replace them!!
SS lines typically give the pedal a slightly firmer feel. Goodridge lines and Earls' are quality products. I don't know anything about Stoptech, but they may be Goodridge lines in a different package.
And it would be a good time to do a complete brake fluid flush. Use a good DOT4 fluid like Motul, ATE TYP200, or other fluids that are mentioned here.
SS lines typically give the pedal a slightly firmer feel. Goodridge lines and Earls' are quality products. I don't know anything about Stoptech, but they may be Goodridge lines in a different package.
And it would be a good time to do a complete brake fluid flush. Use a good DOT4 fluid like Motul, ATE TYP200, or other fluids that are mentioned here.
#4
Safety Car
Member Since: Nov 2000
Location: Shenandoah Valley Virginia
Posts: 4,549
Likes: 0
Received 27 Likes
on
24 Posts
Sorry to hear about the above accident, this type of occurrence is the exception rather than the rule. There are thousands of folks yearly running events on the factory stock fubber hoses.
IMHO, The decision should be based on several factors including the age and condition of the existing hoses and your skill level. If the hoses are more than about 5 years old, or have any cracks showing in the rubber, replace them. If you are an advanced driver and really stress the car with heavy threshold braking, or are running on R compound tires, replace them. If it gives you additional peace of mind - replace them.
I ran the Goodridge hoses for 10 years and never had a problem.
IMHO, The decision should be based on several factors including the age and condition of the existing hoses and your skill level. If the hoses are more than about 5 years old, or have any cracks showing in the rubber, replace them. If you are an advanced driver and really stress the car with heavy threshold braking, or are running on R compound tires, replace them. If it gives you additional peace of mind - replace them.
I ran the Goodridge hoses for 10 years and never had a problem.
#5
Safety Car
Good ridge are the gold standard of brake hoses.
Richard
Richard
#6
Racer
Thread Starter
The car is a 2008 with the original lines (20K miles on the car). They're in good shape and I'd still consider myself a novice driver, but from what you guys have said it's well worth the switch. I've been running fresh Motul 600 in it for over a year now and love it. Looks like it's time to order the lines and do a fresh flush.
#7
Race Director
What about the "alleged" interference with the abs electronics & steel lines?
Garbage/true/other?
Never have seen this settled to my satisfaction.
Is there a GM TSB re: steel lines?
Date Reported: SEPTEMBER 01 2010
NHTSA Reference: #10036084
TSB Reference: #PIC-5368
Description: CHEVROLET: ABS/TCS LIGHT ON AND DTCS C1225/C0035 AND/OR C1226/C0040 DUE TO AFTERMARKET BRAIDED STAINLESS STEEL BRAKE LINES. *PE
Repair Information for NHTSA #10036084
Looking for answers.
Garbage/true/other?
Never have seen this settled to my satisfaction.
Is there a GM TSB re: steel lines?
Date Reported: SEPTEMBER 01 2010
NHTSA Reference: #10036084
TSB Reference: #PIC-5368
Description: CHEVROLET: ABS/TCS LIGHT ON AND DTCS C1225/C0035 AND/OR C1226/C0040 DUE TO AFTERMARKET BRAIDED STAINLESS STEEL BRAKE LINES. *PE
Repair Information for NHTSA #10036084
Looking for answers.
Last edited by froggy47; 06-22-2014 at 01:58 PM.
#8
Safety Car
What about the "alleged" interference with the abs electronics & steel lines?
Garbage/true/other?
Never have seen this settled to my satisfaction.
Is there a GM TSB re: steel lines?
Date Reported: SEPTEMBER 01 2010
NHTSA Reference: #10036084
TSB Reference: #PIC-5368
Description: CHEVROLET: ABS/TCS LIGHT ON AND DTCS C1225/C0035 AND/OR C1226/C0040 DUE TO AFTERMARKET BRAIDED STAINLESS STEEL BRAKE LINES. *PE
Repair Information for NHTSA #10036084
Looking for answers.
Garbage/true/other?
Never have seen this settled to my satisfaction.
Is there a GM TSB re: steel lines?
Date Reported: SEPTEMBER 01 2010
NHTSA Reference: #10036084
TSB Reference: #PIC-5368
Description: CHEVROLET: ABS/TCS LIGHT ON AND DTCS C1225/C0035 AND/OR C1226/C0040 DUE TO AFTERMARKET BRAIDED STAINLESS STEEL BRAKE LINES. *PE
Repair Information for NHTSA #10036084
Looking for answers.
Last edited by ErnieN85; 06-22-2014 at 07:14 PM.
#10
Tech Contributor
Member Since: Oct 1999
Location: Charlotte, NC (formerly Endicott, NY)
Posts: 40,078
Received 8,919 Likes
on
5,328 Posts
The interior line of both the rubber and stainless hoses is made of Teflon. A stock hose actually holds up pretty well. Are stainless better? I think so. Both types of hoses can fail due to mistreatment. When working on the brakes I have dropped calipers several times over the last 22 seasons. When that happens that can apply a shock load on the crimped ends of both rubber and stainless lines that can loosen them in their fittings. Whenever that happens I replace the brake line. Last year when it happened several days before a track event I threw out a new stainless line and purchased a stock rubber line from the local dealer and used it.
Bill
Bill
#11
Drifting
I am a big fan of the SS hoses, and I like the DRM's lines; they use an -AN fitting on the end that I prefer; I've seen banjo bolts break on a couple other cars.
#12
Safety Car
For HPDE only It's a "feel good" mod.
You won't notice a difference in pedal feel even though the entire internet will tell you how much better it is because your brake lines "will no longer swell under pressure". You'll be into ABS long before you reach enough pressure to expand your brake lines.
And I bet GM has done a lot more durability testing with the rubber lines on a Corvette than Goodrich has done on the SS lines. I am sure there are OEM ones that have failed, see post above. By the same token, I have had a SS line fail (Goodrich brand, BTW). It happens. Inspect your equipment before you go 120+ mph to mitigate the risk.
Are they better? Probably - with the caveat that they are a potential wear item just like rubber lines. Are they worth the money for a novice driver in a fairly new car? Your call.
On track I run the stock rubber hoses on my C6 street car and SS on my C5Z race car.
You won't notice a difference in pedal feel even though the entire internet will tell you how much better it is because your brake lines "will no longer swell under pressure". You'll be into ABS long before you reach enough pressure to expand your brake lines.
And I bet GM has done a lot more durability testing with the rubber lines on a Corvette than Goodrich has done on the SS lines. I am sure there are OEM ones that have failed, see post above. By the same token, I have had a SS line fail (Goodrich brand, BTW). It happens. Inspect your equipment before you go 120+ mph to mitigate the risk.
Are they better? Probably - with the caveat that they are a potential wear item just like rubber lines. Are they worth the money for a novice driver in a fairly new car? Your call.
On track I run the stock rubber hoses on my C6 street car and SS on my C5Z race car.
Last edited by ScaryFast; 06-23-2014 at 04:33 PM.
#13
Tech Contributor
Most important thing is to inspect and replace brake lines regularly. One of my former instructors lost his life at a far too young age at Summit Point due to a brake line failure.
#14
The car is a 2008 with the original lines (20K miles on the car). They're in good shape and I'd still consider myself a novice driver, but from what you guys have said it's well worth the switch. I've been running fresh Motul 600 in it for over a year now and love it. Looks like it's time to order the lines and do a fresh flush.
#16
Drifting
Kicking this alive ....
So whats the consensus for a 2000 C5 w/30kmi. Only do about four HPDE days / year with PFC 01 pads, ATE fluid, and NT01's. Never had an issue with a spongy pedal.
The stock lines still LOOK good. But should I change them due to age? Always have made sure never to drop the caliper like Bill mentioned.
Thanks
So whats the consensus for a 2000 C5 w/30kmi. Only do about four HPDE days / year with PFC 01 pads, ATE fluid, and NT01's. Never had an issue with a spongy pedal.
The stock lines still LOOK good. But should I change them due to age? Always have made sure never to drop the caliper like Bill mentioned.
Thanks
#17
Welllllll gollllllly, I just replied to an 18 moth old thread.
Last edited by Reggie Dunlop; 02-20-2016 at 08:47 PM.
#18
Safety Car
Kicking this alive ....
So whats the consensus for a 2000 C5 w/30kmi. Only do about four HPDE days / year with PFC 01 pads, ATE fluid, and NT01's. Never had an issue with a spongy pedal.
The stock lines still LOOK good. But should I change them due to age? Always have made sure never to drop the caliper like Bill mentioned.
Thanks
So whats the consensus for a 2000 C5 w/30kmi. Only do about four HPDE days / year with PFC 01 pads, ATE fluid, and NT01's. Never had an issue with a spongy pedal.
The stock lines still LOOK good. But should I change them due to age? Always have made sure never to drop the caliper like Bill mentioned.
Thanks
#19
IMHO, it just seemed common sense to replace old lines with braided ones before stressing brakes on a track. They are subjected to excessive heat, harsh detergents, ozone, constant vibration and flex, hot shards from braking, etc. Watch the video at Essex of bedding brakes on a c5z--sparks flying like a grinder. Also at Essex? a video of stock brakes catching fire. I put on Goodrich, but honestly am not all that impressed. Since have ordered a high end endurance BBK, and they sent Spiegler lines which look extremely well made and swivel. They also have a lifetime warranty. I'd be happier if they didn't swivel, but won't go back to rubber ever.
#20
Drifting
So they should be changed for preventive maintenance. I just hate fix'n what ain't broke especially when reading ScaryFast had a Goodridge fail and evidently there may or may not be an issue with throwing codes.
With all the brands mentioned in this thread, is there one that stands out from the rest?
With all the brands mentioned in this thread, is there one that stands out from the rest?