Bonding "adhesive" vs. Epoxy for front end install
#1
Melting Slicks
Thread Starter
Bonding "adhesive" vs. Epoxy for front end install
Seems the trend for bonding front end pieces on is an Epoxy type - either a Fusor product, 3M or a "Marine" type. When this type of product is used, I would think future individual panel replacement seperation (in the event of a accident etc.) would be nearly impossible. OTOH, a "Bonding Adhesive" (like used oem) makes panel seperation probable, though difficult. Sermersheim seems to make a adhesive similar to what was used oem. Ecklers does also but a poster had problems with that product. To those that have used epoxy based adhesives, I then assume you have no concerns about a maybe future needed panel replacement?
Last edited by TWINRAY; 07-24-2012 at 09:37 AM.
#7
Team Owner
Member Since: Jun 2000
Location: Southbound
Posts: 38,928
Likes: 0
Received 1,469 Likes
on
1,248 Posts
Cruise-In II Veteran
SEM or SMC? SEM is good quality automative interior dye. SMC is sheet molded compound fiberglass. From 72 up, C3 bodies are SMC.
TWINRAY: I'm not sure what you want. After the whack, it isn't going to make much difference if the panels serparate or whether you have to spearate them. It's still going to be a mess.
TWINRAY: I'm not sure what you want. After the whack, it isn't going to make much difference if the panels serparate or whether you have to spearate them. It's still going to be a mess.
Last edited by Easy Mike; 07-24-2012 at 01:16 PM.
#9
Former Vendor
Member Since: Aug 2006
Location: Jeffersonville Indiana 812-288-7103
Posts: 76,656
Received 1,813 Likes
on
1,458 Posts
St. Jude Donor '08-'09-'10-'11-'12-'13-'14-'15
I use SEM 39747 epoxy.. and for multiple reasons.
The stuff Sermershiem's sells is a great product and I used it for years. However you'd better know your horse before you ride it. The cure time is very fast and you'd better have every detail down before you use it. Changing the color of the hardener will not change the cure time either. For years Jim Sermershiem's had this in his book that one color would increase or delay cure.. Not true and Jim and I got in a debate about this to a point where I called the company that makes the hardener and they gave me the chemist... They all cure at the same rate the colors are made to offer varied colors to the glue. The hotter the temp the faster the cure..
The SEM epoxy is a slower curing product what will allow you way more working time. Slower cure time means less mistakes and a perfect installation. Application is way easier unless you use a cake decorator with the other stuff and even that isn't as fast as the Sem product that is ready to roll.
If properly scuffed before application you'll never have to worry about it coming loose.
Downfalls.. the gun to mix it with.. but if you have a friend who has a friend you can probably locate one.
Willcox
The stuff Sermershiem's sells is a great product and I used it for years. However you'd better know your horse before you ride it. The cure time is very fast and you'd better have every detail down before you use it. Changing the color of the hardener will not change the cure time either. For years Jim Sermershiem's had this in his book that one color would increase or delay cure.. Not true and Jim and I got in a debate about this to a point where I called the company that makes the hardener and they gave me the chemist... They all cure at the same rate the colors are made to offer varied colors to the glue. The hotter the temp the faster the cure..
The SEM epoxy is a slower curing product what will allow you way more working time. Slower cure time means less mistakes and a perfect installation. Application is way easier unless you use a cake decorator with the other stuff and even that isn't as fast as the Sem product that is ready to roll.
If properly scuffed before application you'll never have to worry about it coming loose.
Downfalls.. the gun to mix it with.. but if you have a friend who has a friend you can probably locate one.
Willcox
#10
Drifting
I use SEM 39747 epoxy.. and for multiple reasons.
The stuff Sermershiem's sells is a great product and I used it for years. However you'd better know your horse before you ride it. The cure time is very fast and you'd better have every detail down before you use it. Changing the color of the hardener will not change the cure time either. For years Jim Sermershiem's had this in his book that one color would increase or delay cure.. Not true and Jim and I got in a debate about this to a point where I called the company that makes the hardener and they gave me the chemist... They all cure at the same rate the colors are made to offer varied colors to the glue. The hotter the temp the faster the cure..
The SEM epoxy is a slower curing product what will allow you way more working time. Slower cure time means less mistakes and a perfect installation. Application is way easier unless you use a cake decorator with the other stuff and even that isn't as fast as the Sem product that is ready to roll.
If properly scuffed before application you'll never have to worry about it coming loose.
Downfalls.. the gun to mix it with.. but if you have a friend who has a friend you can probably locate one.
Willcox
The stuff Sermershiem's sells is a great product and I used it for years. However you'd better know your horse before you ride it. The cure time is very fast and you'd better have every detail down before you use it. Changing the color of the hardener will not change the cure time either. For years Jim Sermershiem's had this in his book that one color would increase or delay cure.. Not true and Jim and I got in a debate about this to a point where I called the company that makes the hardener and they gave me the chemist... They all cure at the same rate the colors are made to offer varied colors to the glue. The hotter the temp the faster the cure..
The SEM epoxy is a slower curing product what will allow you way more working time. Slower cure time means less mistakes and a perfect installation. Application is way easier unless you use a cake decorator with the other stuff and even that isn't as fast as the Sem product that is ready to roll.
If properly scuffed before application you'll never have to worry about it coming loose.
Downfalls.. the gun to mix it with.. but if you have a friend who has a friend you can probably locate one.
Willcox
I used the SEM 39747 when I bonded my front bumper and it worked like a champ... I was able to use my Fusor Gun for application...
Rogman
#11
Race Director
The Marine-Tex we used to bond the panels will release if heated with a heat gun. Found that out after I messed up the location of one of the exhaust filler panel braces.
#12
Former Vendor
Member Since: Aug 2006
Location: Jeffersonville Indiana 812-288-7103
Posts: 76,656
Received 1,813 Likes
on
1,458 Posts
St. Jude Donor '08-'09-'10-'11-'12-'13-'14-'15
E..
#14
Melting Slicks
Thread Starter
Thanks all for the added info. I'll pick something that gives me a bit of time. Sure as heck don't want a gallon of the mixed stuff to start hardening while I'm in the middle of setting panels
Last edited by TWINRAY; 08-29-2012 at 09:51 AM.
#15
Red Road Warrior
Member Since: Dec 2000
Location: Lansdale 19446 PA
Posts: 3,345
Received 282 Likes
on
199 Posts
St. Jude Donor '10-'11, '15, '19
I use SEM 39747 epoxy.. and for multiple reasons.
The stuff Sermershiem's sells is a great product and I used it for years. However you'd better know your horse before you ride it. The cure time is very fast and you'd better have every detail down before you use it. Changing the color of the hardener will not change the cure time either. For years Jim Sermershiem's had this in his book that one color would increase or delay cure.. Not true and Jim and I got in a debate about this to a point where I called the company that makes the hardener and they gave me the chemist... They all cure at the same rate the colors are made to offer varied colors to the glue. The hotter the temp the faster the cure..
The SEM epoxy is a slower curing product what will allow you way more working time. Slower cure time means less mistakes and a perfect installation. Application is way easier unless you use a cake decorator with the other stuff and even that isn't as fast as the Sem product that is ready to roll.
If properly scuffed before application you'll never have to worry about it coming loose.
Downfalls.. the gun to mix it with.. but if you have a friend who has a friend you can probably locate one.
Willcox
The stuff Sermershiem's sells is a great product and I used it for years. However you'd better know your horse before you ride it. The cure time is very fast and you'd better have every detail down before you use it. Changing the color of the hardener will not change the cure time either. For years Jim Sermershiem's had this in his book that one color would increase or delay cure.. Not true and Jim and I got in a debate about this to a point where I called the company that makes the hardener and they gave me the chemist... They all cure at the same rate the colors are made to offer varied colors to the glue. The hotter the temp the faster the cure..
The SEM epoxy is a slower curing product what will allow you way more working time. Slower cure time means less mistakes and a perfect installation. Application is way easier unless you use a cake decorator with the other stuff and even that isn't as fast as the Sem product that is ready to roll.
If properly scuffed before application you'll never have to worry about it coming loose.
Downfalls.. the gun to mix it with.. but if you have a friend who has a friend you can probably locate one.
Willcox
And the SEM 39747 was $27.49 per tube.
I got it delivered today and all looks good.
John
Last edited by Go Vette Go; 07-27-2012 at 02:13 PM.
#16
Melting Slicks
Thread Starter
I use SEM 39747 epoxy.. and for multiple reasons.
The stuff Sermershiem's sells is a great product and I used it for years. However you'd better know your horse before you ride it. The cure time is very fast and you'd better have every detail down before you use it. Changing the color of the hardener will not change the cure time either. For years Jim Sermershiem's had this in his book that one color would increase or delay cure.. Not true and Jim and I got in a debate about this to a point where I called the company that makes the hardener and they gave me the chemist... They all cure at the same rate the colors are made to offer varied colors to the glue. The hotter the temp the faster the cure..
The SEM epoxy is a slower curing product what will allow you way more working time. Slower cure time means less mistakes and a perfect installation. Application is way easier unless you use a cake decorator with the other stuff and even that isn't as fast as the Sem product that is ready to roll.
If properly scuffed before application you'll never have to worry about it coming loose.
Downfalls.. the gun to mix it with.. but if you have a friend who has a friend you can probably locate one.
Willcox
The stuff Sermershiem's sells is a great product and I used it for years. However you'd better know your horse before you ride it. The cure time is very fast and you'd better have every detail down before you use it. Changing the color of the hardener will not change the cure time either. For years Jim Sermershiem's had this in his book that one color would increase or delay cure.. Not true and Jim and I got in a debate about this to a point where I called the company that makes the hardener and they gave me the chemist... They all cure at the same rate the colors are made to offer varied colors to the glue. The hotter the temp the faster the cure..
The SEM epoxy is a slower curing product what will allow you way more working time. Slower cure time means less mistakes and a perfect installation. Application is way easier unless you use a cake decorator with the other stuff and even that isn't as fast as the Sem product that is ready to roll.
If properly scuffed before application you'll never have to worry about it coming loose.
Downfalls.. the gun to mix it with.. but if you have a friend who has a friend you can probably locate one.
Willcox
Thanks, Fred
#18
Melting Slicks
Member Since: Jul 2001
Location: Massapequa Park NY
Posts: 2,604
Likes: 0
Received 10 Likes
on
8 Posts
https://www.foxruntools.com/paneladh...ulti-purp.aspx
Jim
#19
Drifting
Member Since: Aug 2005
Location: East Waterboro Maine
Posts: 1,289
Likes: 0
Received 3 Likes
on
1 Post
I used epoxy adhesives almost exclusively when I did my body panel replacement. My overriding concern was fit-up time. When they built these cars on the assembly line they were tremendously efficient through the use of jigs and sheer repetition. As a result, they could fit up a body panel in no time. On the other hand, most folks working in their garage (myself included) work much slower. Depending on the temperature, with bonding compound you typically have 10-15 minutes to apply the compound, align the panel and secure it in place. It may sound like plenty of time, but it really isn't. For me the consequences of a potential mis-fit was a bigger consideration than future panel replacement.
Worst case scenario, future panel replacement would require grinding the body panel away down to the bonding strip. It's not a great solution, but it would allow panel replacement if needed.
I used Lord Fusor's 127 EZ and it had plenty of working time. I highly recommend it. I think I used about two tubes doing my one-piece front clip, inner fender skirts and front valence panel. If your using fusor (which I think comes in bigger tubes than SEM adhesive) I'd buy 3 tubes - better safe then sorry. You'll be some pizzed if you get half way through and find out your short on adhesive.
Worst case scenario, future panel replacement would require grinding the body panel away down to the bonding strip. It's not a great solution, but it would allow panel replacement if needed.
I used Lord Fusor's 127 EZ and it had plenty of working time. I highly recommend it. I think I used about two tubes doing my one-piece front clip, inner fender skirts and front valence panel. If your using fusor (which I think comes in bigger tubes than SEM adhesive) I'd buy 3 tubes - better safe then sorry. You'll be some pizzed if you get half way through and find out your short on adhesive.
Last edited by Maine Vette; 08-04-2012 at 10:35 AM.
#20
Le Mans Master