Don't let MIDAS do your brakes!!!!
#1
Pro
Thread Starter
Don't let MIDAS do your brakes!!!!
Had the brakes done on my 96 LT1 this Saturday at the local MIDAS shop...co-workers said they did good work...well, the work was ok, but the parts prices were outrageous!!!! Original phone conversation with them put the job at around $260-$280....after pulling the tires and inspection, it was obvious two rotors (LF & LR) would need replacement..the other two could be turned...but get this:
front pads: $180.00
rear pads: $105.00
front rotor: $115.00
rear rotor: $175.00
rotors turned: $15.00 ea.
out the door for $692.00
called the local parts stores later and every one of them were at least 50% cheaper on pads & rotors....
phoned MIDAS this morning and told them about their "gold plated" prices and they said, "that's what the computer tells us to charge and that's what we charge" period!!!!!!!!!!!
wish i was more mechanical minded...it would have saved me a good $300 !!! if you can do it yourself, go for it!!!!!!!!!
front pads: $180.00
rear pads: $105.00
front rotor: $115.00
rear rotor: $175.00
rotors turned: $15.00 ea.
out the door for $692.00
called the local parts stores later and every one of them were at least 50% cheaper on pads & rotors....
phoned MIDAS this morning and told them about their "gold plated" prices and they said, "that's what the computer tells us to charge and that's what we charge" period!!!!!!!!!!!
wish i was more mechanical minded...it would have saved me a good $300 !!! if you can do it yourself, go for it!!!!!!!!!
#2
Team Owner
Member Since: Oct 2004
Location: altered state
Posts: 81,242
Received 3,043 Likes
on
2,602 Posts
St. Jude Donor '05
Don't feel bad. I got nailed for 1200 smackers on a 480 quote years ago. That was for brakes and shocks on a beater Toyota p/u! Took me awhile before I could walk straight if ya know what I mean
#3
Safety Car
Member Since: Feb 2001
Location: Looks like I picked the wrong week to stop sniffin glue Orlando
Posts: 4,397
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by LT1SPUD
wish i was more mechanical minded...it would have saved me a good $300 !!! if you can do it yourself, go for it!!!!!!!!!
#4
Le Mans Master
Member Since: Jul 2000
Location: Global Warming My Butt
Posts: 7,836
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by LT1SPUD
front pads: $180.00
rear pads: $105.00
front rotor: $115.00
rear rotor: $175.00
rotors turned: $15.00 ea.
out the door for $692.00
rear pads: $105.00
front rotor: $115.00
rear rotor: $175.00
rotors turned: $15.00 ea.
out the door for $692.00
Front Pads: $60 (GM)
Rear: $45 (GM)
Front Rotors: $50/each (GM)
Rear Rotors: $65/each (GM)
New caliper pins (4): $20 (GM)
So...a car with new rotors and pads ran $350 (you should replace the pins and bolts when doing a brake job as they could be getting weak from the heat stress). 45mins/wheel of $80/hr shop time $240 so that's $590...not that "gold plated".
The only thing that disturbs me, they turned one side of the car and put new disks on the other side?? Tell me that's not true! You always replace disks in pairs...
Last edited by MinnesotaWhite; 10-25-2004 at 03:01 PM.
#5
Race Director
Member Since: Sep 2004
Location: St. Peters MO Sometimes you have to prove yourself by doing alot of killing or alot of dying...
Posts: 13,793
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by IBEAM700
Purchase a factory service manual, and start reading. You could have a saved a lot doing it yourself.
#6
Safety Car
Member Since: May 2001
Location: Liberal KS
Posts: 4,426
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
But aren't you covered now for the life of your vehicle. If my memory serves me correctly, that's what the recent commercial out there states. If it's true, you should never have to pay for brake service again.
Last edited by 383 Stroker; 10-26-2004 at 12:15 AM.
#7
Pro
Thread Starter
Originally Posted by MinnesotaWhite
We did two Vettes in my garage a month or so ago, here is what it ran:
Front Pads: $60 (GM)
Rear: $45 (GM)
Front Rotors: $50/each (GM)
Rear Rotors: $65/each (GM)
New caliper pins (4): $20 (GM)
So...a car with new rotors and pads ran $350 (you should replace the pins and bolts when doing a brake job as they could be getting weak from the heat stress). 45mins/wheel of $80/hr shop time $240 so that's $590...not that "gold plated".
The only thing that disturbs me, they turned one side of the car and put new disks on the other side?? Tell me that's not true! You always replace disks in pairs...
Front Pads: $60 (GM)
Rear: $45 (GM)
Front Rotors: $50/each (GM)
Rear Rotors: $65/each (GM)
New caliper pins (4): $20 (GM)
So...a car with new rotors and pads ran $350 (you should replace the pins and bolts when doing a brake job as they could be getting weak from the heat stress). 45mins/wheel of $80/hr shop time $240 so that's $590...not that "gold plated".
The only thing that disturbs me, they turned one side of the car and put new disks on the other side?? Tell me that's not true! You always replace disks in pairs...
#8
Pro
Thread Starter
Originally Posted by 383 Stroker
But aren't you covered now for the life of your vehicle. If my memory serves me correctly, that's what the recent commercial out there states. If it's true, you should never have to pay for brake service again.
..lifetime warranty covers pads only, labor is extra....
#10
Racer
Member Since: Sep 2004
Location: Muncie Indiana
Posts: 323
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Midas Warranty
My father had a 1960 vette. that he had midas put the exhaust on with a lifetime warranty.
I believe he had a new muffler installed about every 6 months after that because as you may remember they were angled back and the moisture rusted the ends out of them. Since my father drove the car 250,000 miles until he died in 1976. It got to the place where midas was almost begging him to sell the car. I think he kept it just to anoy them. My advice to you is do the same thing on your brake job. Paybacks are H---. But in the future do as others have suggested and get a manual and read it and read it and then get brave and pickup a wrench and get the feeling off having done it yourself.
I believe he had a new muffler installed about every 6 months after that because as you may remember they were angled back and the moisture rusted the ends out of them. Since my father drove the car 250,000 miles until he died in 1976. It got to the place where midas was almost begging him to sell the car. I think he kept it just to anoy them. My advice to you is do the same thing on your brake job. Paybacks are H---. But in the future do as others have suggested and get a manual and read it and read it and then get brave and pickup a wrench and get the feeling off having done it yourself.
#13
Le Mans Master
On ething i have learned is never do or have something done to your car without asking the forum first, people will always give you options and opinions you would have never thought of.
#14
Le Mans Master
Member Since: Jul 2000
Location: Global Warming My Butt
Posts: 7,836
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by LT1SPUD
yep, turned right side rotors...replaced left side.........
#15
Safety Car
Originally Posted by MinnesotaWhite
We did two Vettes in my garage a month or so ago, here is what it ran:
Front Pads: $60 (GM)
Rear: $45 (GM)
Front Rotors: $50/each (GM)
Rear Rotors: $65/each (GM)
New caliper pins (4): $20 (GM)
So...a car with new rotors and pads ran $350 (you should replace the pins and bolts when doing a brake job as they could be getting weak from the heat stress). 45mins/wheel of $80/hr shop time $240 so that's $590...not that "gold plated".
The only thing that disturbs me, they turned one side of the car and put new disks on the other side?? Tell me that's not true! You always replace disks in pairs...
Front Pads: $60 (GM)
Rear: $45 (GM)
Front Rotors: $50/each (GM)
Rear Rotors: $65/each (GM)
New caliper pins (4): $20 (GM)
So...a car with new rotors and pads ran $350 (you should replace the pins and bolts when doing a brake job as they could be getting weak from the heat stress). 45mins/wheel of $80/hr shop time $240 so that's $590...not that "gold plated".
The only thing that disturbs me, they turned one side of the car and put new disks on the other side?? Tell me that's not true! You always replace disks in pairs...
GM J55 rotors for $50 each??? Please tell me where to get them...
#16
Pro
Thread Starter
Originally Posted by n1kki6
are you kidding
nope....it seems to track straight and true when applying the brakes..no pull to either side...am i looking at trouble down the road though???
#17
Pro
Thread Starter
Originally Posted by IBEAM700
Purchase a factory service manual, and start reading. You could have a saved a lot doing it yourself.
..do you order the service manual direct from GM? what's the price tag??
#18
Team Owner
Member Since: Dec 2000
Location: SE NY
Posts: 90,675
Likes: 0
Received 300 Likes
on
274 Posts
Cruise-In II Veteran
Sorry to hear about that bad deal you got; hope the brake job holds up well.
Even just taking that $300 you would have saved you could have picked up a GM Shop manual, a nice Sears tool set and a good torque wrench for the same money. And you would have then had the job done right, the manual & tools and the experience. It's something to think about the next time a R&R comes up.
When you think of the $75 shop flat rates & jobber's mark up on parts it really pays to do your own work if you do or think you would like to learn to turn wrenches on your Vette. And you have the Forum should you need any help.
Even just taking that $300 you would have saved you could have picked up a GM Shop manual, a nice Sears tool set and a good torque wrench for the same money. And you would have then had the job done right, the manual & tools and the experience. It's something to think about the next time a R&R comes up.
When you think of the $75 shop flat rates & jobber's mark up on parts it really pays to do your own work if you do or think you would like to learn to turn wrenches on your Vette. And you have the Forum should you need any help.
#19
Le Mans Master
Originally Posted by LT1SPUD
nope....it seems to track straight and true when applying the brakes..no pull to either side...am i looking at trouble down the road though???
#20
Le Mans Master
Member Since: Jul 2000
Location: Global Warming My Butt
Posts: 7,836
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by pettvette
GM J55 rotors for $50 each??? Please tell me where to get them...