GMPP 1.6 Roller vs. Comp Magnum 1.6 Roller Tip Rockers - Noise
#1
Melting Slicks
Thread Starter
GMPP 1.6 Roller vs. Comp Magnum 1.6 Roller Tip Rockers - Noise
Ok, some of you may have seen my other posts concerning my noisy GMPP 1.6 RRs (Crane Gold). I found they tick/rattle a little too much for my taste. I like my car to be quiet under the hood. Also, with hot oil, at certain RPMs they would tick so bad I was getting a few knock counts while sitting in neutral in my garage. It was NOT adjustment. I tried 1/4, 1/2, 3/4, 1 turn and it made no difference at all. Even installed a new set of lifters... no difference.
I read some other posts here that Comp-Cams 1.6 Magnum roller tip rockers are much quieter. A couple of folks in particular had my exact problem. So today I installed a set and can confirm that they are MUCH quieter. No problem with knock counts and the tick/rattle sounds are gone. Engine sounds nice and smooth again. I can still hear the sewing machine sound but that's normal IMO and not so loud. I think I'll be happy with the roller tips.
Performance? I notice no difference in the SOTP meter. I also did a few runs using my G-Tech Pro and got results identical to the GMPP full rollers. Moral of the story.... if you don't like ticky full roller rockers then buy CompCams Magnum p/n 1418-16.
P.S. Anyone want a set of GMPP 1.6 RR with 1800 miles on them? Make an offer if you do.
I read some other posts here that Comp-Cams 1.6 Magnum roller tip rockers are much quieter. A couple of folks in particular had my exact problem. So today I installed a set and can confirm that they are MUCH quieter. No problem with knock counts and the tick/rattle sounds are gone. Engine sounds nice and smooth again. I can still hear the sewing machine sound but that's normal IMO and not so loud. I think I'll be happy with the roller tips.
Performance? I notice no difference in the SOTP meter. I also did a few runs using my G-Tech Pro and got results identical to the GMPP full rollers. Moral of the story.... if you don't like ticky full roller rockers then buy CompCams Magnum p/n 1418-16.
P.S. Anyone want a set of GMPP 1.6 RR with 1800 miles on them? Make an offer if you do.
#5
Racer
Member Since: Jan 2006
Location: Forest Hill Maryland
Posts: 287
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Ok, some of you may have seen my other posts concerning my noisy GMPP 1.6 RRs (Crane Gold). I found they tick/rattle a little too much for my taste. I like my car to be quiet under the hood. Also, with hot oil, at certain RPMs they would tick so bad I was getting a few knock counts while sitting in neutral in my garage. It was NOT adjustment. I tried 1/4, 1/2, 3/4, 1 turn and it made no difference at all. Even installed a new set of lifters... no difference.
I read some other posts here that Comp-Cams 1.6 Magnum roller tip rockers are much quieter. A couple of folks in particular had my exact problem. So today I installed a set and can confirm that they are MUCH quieter. No problem with knock counts and the tick/rattle sounds are gone. Engine sounds nice and smooth again. I can still hear the sewing machine sound but that's normal IMO and not so loud. I think I'll be happy with the roller tips.
Performance? I notice no difference in the SOTP meter. I also did a few runs using my G-Tech Pro and got results identical to the GMPP full rollers. Moral of the story.... if you don't like ticky full roller rockers then buy CompCams Magnum p/n 1418-16.
P.S. Anyone want a set of GMPP 1.6 RR with 1800 miles on them? Make an offer if you do.
I read some other posts here that Comp-Cams 1.6 Magnum roller tip rockers are much quieter. A couple of folks in particular had my exact problem. So today I installed a set and can confirm that they are MUCH quieter. No problem with knock counts and the tick/rattle sounds are gone. Engine sounds nice and smooth again. I can still hear the sewing machine sound but that's normal IMO and not so loud. I think I'll be happy with the roller tips.
Performance? I notice no difference in the SOTP meter. I also did a few runs using my G-Tech Pro and got results identical to the GMPP full rollers. Moral of the story.... if you don't like ticky full roller rockers then buy CompCams Magnum p/n 1418-16.
P.S. Anyone want a set of GMPP 1.6 RR with 1800 miles on them? Make an offer if you do.
#7
Drifting
great.the only thing i kept out of the hotcam kit was the rockers.and i sold my comp 1.6 roller tips to the guy who bought the cam kit.i hope it is'nt too noisy as my budget is near bankrupt after the engine build.
#9
Team Owner
Member Since: Oct 2004
Location: Bergen County, NJ Democrats, doing for the country what they did for Michigan
Posts: 35,065
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
#12
Melting Slicks
Thread Starter
#13
Melting Slicks
Thread Starter
#14
Melting Slicks
Thanks for the response...I think I am going to order them today. I will post my results also. Just so you know, I also changed my lifters!
Was it quieter with the stock rockers, or is it quieter now?
Thanks again,
Steve
#17
Team Owner
Member Since: Oct 2004
Location: Bergen County, NJ Democrats, doing for the country what they did for Michigan
Posts: 35,065
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I am looking at new heads. I probably will go with 7/16ths studs.
I'll part with the Scorpions if anyone's interested. They are 3/8ths 1.6 narrow body self aligning.
I'll part with the Scorpions if anyone's interested. They are 3/8ths 1.6 narrow body self aligning.
#18
Melting Slicks
Thread Starter