How would you extract this broken bolt from the worst of all places?
#21
Thanks for the reply. This brings up another question. I removed my stock camshaft tonight. The FSM and everything else I've read states to have crank dot at 12 O clock and Camshaft at six-o-clock. This puts #6 at TDC. Then when I install my heads and begin to set rocker clearance all literature states to have #1 at TDC. which puts camshaft dot at 12 -o-clock and crank at 12-0-clock. I've changed camshafts in non-LT1s and it's always done with #1 at TDC. Can anyone explain why?
#23
Instructor
Portable welder will or should have there own power source being a gas powered welder or generator to power the welder all mounted on the truck. Your issue if any could be the truck too tall to get in the garage.
#24
i sooo feel your pain.
welding is your best bet. i called a guy on my local classified ad when this happened to me. he backed in, had a nut on in very short order, out it came.
as mentioned, heat cycle it of you can, spray on penetrating oil while it cools.
i have had success buying a cheap socket and mini sledging it over the stud. then backing it out. that lication makes the whacking to get the socket on problematic. it takes alot of force.
i paid a guy 60$ to weld my nut on. cheap considering.
welding is your best bet. i called a guy on my local classified ad when this happened to me. he backed in, had a nut on in very short order, out it came.
as mentioned, heat cycle it of you can, spray on penetrating oil while it cools.
i have had success buying a cheap socket and mini sledging it over the stud. then backing it out. that lication makes the whacking to get the socket on problematic. it takes alot of force.
i paid a guy 60$ to weld my nut on. cheap considering.
#26
Slim chance but might be worth a try. Drill a hole in a piece of dry ice put it on the stud. Warm the crank.
#27
OP - your parking garage should have a MAX HEIGHT advertised/posted so you check the height (maybe actually measure to confirm) and call a welding service. Maybe a Craigslist find? Maybe if you're a subscriber to other lists.
All others are "waste of time" and maybe like "Churchkey" mentioned if it was "bottomed" so is this.
Post a snapshot of the head of the bolt that you twisted off.
#28
#29
I would try shocking it off with a hammer instead of constant force. More like a impact driver.
Last edited by antfarmer2; 03-29-2016 at 10:17 AM.
#30
Melting Slicks
Member Since: Sep 2008
Location: Cherokee National Forest TN
Posts: 2,376
Likes: 0
Received 102 Likes
on
92 Posts
Bolt color indicates it is a grade 8.
80 ft lbs of torque is maximum for its diameter. SWAG on breaking torque: Its bottomed in the crank with 100+ ft lbs of torque. The stud still has 100+ ft lbs of torque on it.
As stated in an earlier post a surface welded nut on a small diameter is not strong enough the weld will break.
Pondering the problem the following weld technique may work.
A short length of 1/2 or 5/8 round bar stock placed on the end of the stud 90* to the stud. Weld the bar to the stud around the stud diameter. This technique should provide sufficient weldment to the bolt shank to avoid weld failure. A length of pipe over the welded on round stock long enough to contact the vehicle frame on the drivers side.
Engage the starter the shock from the pipe hitting the frame + the starter torque may loosen the broken stud. If not cut the stud off flush with the crank snout & drill it out.
Good luck.
80 ft lbs of torque is maximum for its diameter. SWAG on breaking torque: Its bottomed in the crank with 100+ ft lbs of torque. The stud still has 100+ ft lbs of torque on it.
As stated in an earlier post a surface welded nut on a small diameter is not strong enough the weld will break.
Pondering the problem the following weld technique may work.
A short length of 1/2 or 5/8 round bar stock placed on the end of the stud 90* to the stud. Weld the bar to the stud around the stud diameter. This technique should provide sufficient weldment to the bolt shank to avoid weld failure. A length of pipe over the welded on round stock long enough to contact the vehicle frame on the drivers side.
Engage the starter the shock from the pipe hitting the frame + the starter torque may loosen the broken stud. If not cut the stud off flush with the crank snout & drill it out.
Good luck.
#31
Bolt color indicates it is a grade 8.
80 ft lbs of torque is maximum for its diameter. SWAG on breaking torque: Its bottomed in the crank with 100+ ft lbs of torque. The stud still has 100+ ft lbs of torque on it.
As stated in an earlier post a surface welded nut on a small diameter is not strong enough the weld will break.
Pondering the problem the following weld technique may work.
A short length of 1/2 or 5/8 round bar stock placed on the end of the stud 90* to the stud. Weld the bar to the stud around the stud diameter. This technique should provide sufficient weldment to the bolt shank to avoid weld failure. A length of pipe over the welded on round stock long enough to contact the vehicle frame on the drivers side.
Engage the starter the shock from the pipe hitting the frame + the starter torque may loosen the broken stud. If not cut the stud off flush with the crank snout & drill it out.
Good luck.
80 ft lbs of torque is maximum for its diameter. SWAG on breaking torque: Its bottomed in the crank with 100+ ft lbs of torque. The stud still has 100+ ft lbs of torque on it.
As stated in an earlier post a surface welded nut on a small diameter is not strong enough the weld will break.
Pondering the problem the following weld technique may work.
A short length of 1/2 or 5/8 round bar stock placed on the end of the stud 90* to the stud. Weld the bar to the stud around the stud diameter. This technique should provide sufficient weldment to the bolt shank to avoid weld failure. A length of pipe over the welded on round stock long enough to contact the vehicle frame on the drivers side.
Engage the starter the shock from the pipe hitting the frame + the starter torque may loosen the broken stud. If not cut the stud off flush with the crank snout & drill it out.
Good luck.
#32
Le Mans Master
Member Since: Oct 2002
Location: Las Vegas - Just stop perpetuating myths please.
Posts: 7,098
Received 373 Likes
on
356 Posts
Bolt color indicates it is a grade 8.
80 ft lbs of torque is maximum for its diameter. SWAG on breaking torque: Its bottomed in the crank with 100+ ft lbs of torque. The stud still has 100+ ft lbs of torque on it.
As stated in an earlier post a surface welded nut on a small diameter is not strong enough the weld will break.
Pondering the problem the following weld technique may work.
A short length of 1/2 or 5/8 round bar stock placed on the end of the stud 90* to the stud. Weld the bar to the stud around the stud diameter. This technique should provide sufficient weldment to the bolt shank to avoid weld failure. A length of pipe over the welded on round stock long enough to contact the vehicle frame on the drivers side.
Engage the starter the shock from the pipe hitting the frame + the starter torque may loosen the broken stud. If not cut the stud off flush with the crank snout & drill it out.
Good luck.
80 ft lbs of torque is maximum for its diameter. SWAG on breaking torque: Its bottomed in the crank with 100+ ft lbs of torque. The stud still has 100+ ft lbs of torque on it.
As stated in an earlier post a surface welded nut on a small diameter is not strong enough the weld will break.
Pondering the problem the following weld technique may work.
A short length of 1/2 or 5/8 round bar stock placed on the end of the stud 90* to the stud. Weld the bar to the stud around the stud diameter. This technique should provide sufficient weldment to the bolt shank to avoid weld failure. A length of pipe over the welded on round stock long enough to contact the vehicle frame on the drivers side.
Engage the starter the shock from the pipe hitting the frame + the starter torque may loosen the broken stud. If not cut the stud off flush with the crank snout & drill it out.
Good luck.
#33
Well I took your good advice to use a pipe wrench but it didn't work out. I'm pretty sure it was the ideal pipe wrench to use; a mini 8-inch one with jaws about the width of the bolt sticking out. It grabbed on at first, but with more force it soon torqued forwards wrt. the car and twisted its way loose, spiraling off the bolt. The threads got smeared the rest of the way off and there's a lot of loose metal flaking off of the bolt.
Next step for me might be trying to center drill it. I don't trust myself to bore a new hole that's centered, but could I at least use a small drilled hole to apply an extractor? Could I even generate as much torque with an extractor as I've already applied with the pipe wrench / vise grips? Seems like a waste of time but I don't know what else to try.
Getting someone out here to weld it might be a bit weird because it's an underground shared parking garage and I'd have to steal electricity from somewhere.
Last resort is towing it to a professional. I really, really don't want to have to do that. Last time it look up two days and 1200 dollars for them to plug a new engine block into my transmission, although this time I suppose they could pull them both out together and save a few steps.
Next step for me might be trying to center drill it. I don't trust myself to bore a new hole that's centered, but could I at least use a small drilled hole to apply an extractor? Could I even generate as much torque with an extractor as I've already applied with the pipe wrench / vise grips? Seems like a waste of time but I don't know what else to try.
Getting someone out here to weld it might be a bit weird because it's an underground shared parking garage and I'd have to steal electricity from somewhere.
Last resort is towing it to a professional. I really, really don't want to have to do that. Last time it look up two days and 1200 dollars for them to plug a new engine block into my transmission, although this time I suppose they could pull them both out together and save a few steps.
Or weld it, and if that does not work drill a hole in it and put something through it to turn it out with leverage hoping it won't break.
Last edited by pologreen1; 03-29-2016 at 11:11 PM.
#35
Drifting
How about an impact gun stud remover? It's big so you'll have to measure to see if it fits but it's reviews and ratings are very good.
Used with an impact it supposedly tightens the more you twist it.
Used with an impact it supposedly tightens the more you twist it.
Last edited by Silver96ce; 03-29-2016 at 11:53 PM.
#36
How about an impact gun stud remover? It's big so you'll have to measure to see if it fits but it's reviews and ratings are very good.
Titan Tools 16023 Drive Stud Extractor, 3/8" - Socket Wrenches - Amazon.com
Used with an impact it supposedly tightens the more you twist it.
Titan Tools 16023 Drive Stud Extractor, 3/8" - Socket Wrenches - Amazon.com
Used with an impact it supposedly tightens the more you twist it.
Last edited by THE 383 admiral; 03-30-2016 at 11:16 AM.
#37
I just tried the Titian 16023 jaw chuck extractor. On manifold bolts. It locked on flawlessly!
It would either break your bolt or remove it. I highly recommend this tool. Very nice.
It would either break your bolt or remove it. I highly recommend this tool. Very nice.
Last edited by THE 383 admiral; 04-08-2016 at 01:53 PM.
#38
Burning Brakes
get someone with a mini-ductor, it's a portable induction heating tool for bolts, it will heat the bolt without heating the crank much. let it cool, lose the temper of the bolt. it will be softer and easier to drill. then you want to take a piece of pipe to slip over the crank snout, weld on a washer and bushing to use as a pilot for the drill bit to drill down perfectly straight. it will come out with an extractor at that point, even if bottomed out.
since that's probably beyond your available tools, have it towed to a shop that is experienced in doing that kind of work. believe it or not, it happens a lot and you may even find a shop that already has a the tools for it. I have bought vehicles in the past with the exact problem as you with the owner thinking the motor was junk, only to fix it relatively easily ....
good luck.
since that's probably beyond your available tools, have it towed to a shop that is experienced in doing that kind of work. believe it or not, it happens a lot and you may even find a shop that already has a the tools for it. I have bought vehicles in the past with the exact problem as you with the owner thinking the motor was junk, only to fix it relatively easily ....
good luck.
#39
op sid u solve this?
get someone with a mini-ductor, it's a portable induction heating tool for bolts, it will heat the bolt without heating the crank much. let it cool, lose the temper of the bolt. it will be softer and easier to drill. then you want to take a piece of pipe to slip over the crank snout, weld on a washer and bushing to use as a pilot for the drill bit to drill down perfectly straight. it will come out with an extractor at that point, even if bottomed out.
since that's probably beyond your available tools, have it towed to a shop that is experienced in doing that kind of work. believe it or not, it happens a lot and you may even find a shop that already has a the tools for it. I have bought vehicles in the past with the exact problem as you with the owner thinking the motor was junk, only to fix it relatively easily ....
good luck.
since that's probably beyond your available tools, have it towed to a shop that is experienced in doing that kind of work. believe it or not, it happens a lot and you may even find a shop that already has a the tools for it. I have bought vehicles in the past with the exact problem as you with the owner thinking the motor was junk, only to fix it relatively easily ....
good luck.
#40
Melting Slicks
I can't tell how much of the stud sticks out, but if there is enough, run a die on it and cut threads, get two shallow shouldered nuts, and put them on. back the inner nut up against the outer and then hit it with an impact wrench.