160 or 180 t-stat?
#1
160 or 180 t-stat?
Which t-stat is best. I have the stock programming for now with the 185 degree aux fan switch. I'm concerned that with the 160 t-stat and in cold weather the car may not get into closed loop - is this true?
#2
Race Director
Member Since: Dec 1999
Location: Almost all Skyline Cruises Vettes at Waterside 1-5
Posts: 11,182
Likes: 0
Received 1 Like
on
1 Post
Cruise-In I Veteran
Cruise-In II Veteran
Cruise-In III Veteran
Cruise-In IV Veteran
Cruise-In V Veteran
Cruise-In VI Veteran
Cruise-In VII Veteran
Re: 160 or 180 t-stat? (zzz)
The thing to keep in mind is that once your engine reaches Thermo opening temps, it will probably stay there.
Here's what I mean. My 88 runs about 177 degrees on the road. With a 160 thermo, that means coolant is passing through the rad and the engine. With a 180 thermo, theoretically it is closed and coolant is not circulating.
But yet the engine is still running 177 degrees, regardless of the thermo setting.
In my case I have a small 1/16 " hole in the thermo flange which allows some coolant through at all times, but the principle remains...thermo preset really doesn't effect operating temps once the preset temps are reached.
Here's what I mean. My 88 runs about 177 degrees on the road. With a 160 thermo, that means coolant is passing through the rad and the engine. With a 180 thermo, theoretically it is closed and coolant is not circulating.
But yet the engine is still running 177 degrees, regardless of the thermo setting.
In my case I have a small 1/16 " hole in the thermo flange which allows some coolant through at all times, but the principle remains...thermo preset really doesn't effect operating temps once the preset temps are reached.
#3
Team Owner
Member Since: Sep 2001
Location: Athens AL
Posts: 59,647
Received 1,400 Likes
on
1,016 Posts
C7 of the Year - Unmodified Finalist 2021
C4 of Year Finalist (performance mods) 2019
Re: 160 or 180 t-stat? (zzz)
That depends on how cold it gets where you live in winter.
In SC, it stays about 50F during winter, so i'm running a 160.
If i lived in VA, NY, MI, etc. where it gets snowy and cold, i'd prolly run a 180. Although most people up there put their vettes up for winter for the most part.
In SC, it stays about 50F during winter, so i'm running a 160.
If i lived in VA, NY, MI, etc. where it gets snowy and cold, i'd prolly run a 180. Although most people up there put their vettes up for winter for the most part.
#4
Race Director
Member Since: Aug 2002
Location: tucson AZ
Posts: 13,356
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
St. Jude Donor '04 & '05
Re: 160 or 180 t-stat? (zzz)
Always change your thermostat to an 160 degree....it will still go uto operating temps.......but it will help in the long run....also change your temp. sensor.....to start at 200*, and off at 185*
You can't go wrong....parts available from Mid America.....Ecklers....CorvetteCentral.. or Zip products........read all the catalogs.....
Its all good....
any questions????
tony
oldace1@earthlink.net
I'll try to help....as everyone else will on this great forum....
Try it...you"ll like it...
:cool: :cool: :chevy :cool: :cool:
You can't go wrong....parts available from Mid America.....Ecklers....CorvetteCentral.. or Zip products........read all the catalogs.....
Its all good....
any questions????
tony
oldace1@earthlink.net
I'll try to help....as everyone else will on this great forum....
Try it...you"ll like it...
:cool: :cool: :chevy :cool: :cool:
#5
Team Owner
Member Since: Dec 2000
Location: SE NY
Posts: 90,675
Likes: 0
Received 300 Likes
on
274 Posts
Cruise-In II Veteran
Re: 160 or 180 t-stat? (zzz)
I run a 160 deg stat year around in the Vette, with a 160 deg F aux fan sw wired to control both fans.
This evening I was racing in 41deg F weather and was launching at 155deg F, the same temp as on the drive home.
So long as the weather is in the 70s or lower coolant temp runs at 155-160deg; on hotter days it can climb to 175deg F on the highway and 190 deg in city traffic.
Each Christmass I drive from NY to OH in 30deg weather with coolant at 155deg and get over 30mpg; it goes closed loop at around 140-145 deg F.
You will definitely gain power from dropping to a 160deg F stat and fan sw. In warm weather my trap speed is always higher if I can launch at 145-155deg F compared with a launch at say 165-170deg F.
This evening I was racing in 41deg F weather and was launching at 155deg F, the same temp as on the drive home.
So long as the weather is in the 70s or lower coolant temp runs at 155-160deg; on hotter days it can climb to 175deg F on the highway and 190 deg in city traffic.
Each Christmass I drive from NY to OH in 30deg weather with coolant at 155deg and get over 30mpg; it goes closed loop at around 140-145 deg F.
You will definitely gain power from dropping to a 160deg F stat and fan sw. In warm weather my trap speed is always higher if I can launch at 145-155deg F compared with a launch at say 165-170deg F.
#6
Team Owner
Member Since: Mar 2001
Location: Cincinnati, Oh USA
Posts: 53,930
Likes: 0
Received 26 Likes
on
23 Posts
Re: 160 or 180 t-stat? (zzz)
Early C4's had 195 thermostats and later C4's had 180. For everyday driving , use the thermostat your cooling system was designed for. In cold climates and winter, your cooling system can get rid of heat fast enough so the 160 stat can control the temperature and 160 is too low to operate an engine at. In summer temps, your cooling system cannot get rid of heat fast enough to maintain 160 and the 160 stat will always be wide open and you will run the same temps as with the factory stat (under 35 mph). This subject has been hashed many times in the past and some members claim better times at the track, but thermodynamics predicts lower hp with lower coolant temps. One member did a dyno run with a 160 and then a 180 stat and measured no difference. Continental Motors ran some small engines (40 hp) at different coolant temps and tore down the engines afterward and learned by actual measurement that the higher the coolant temperature, higher hp , lower specific fuel consumption and lower cylinder wear was measured. The C4 was not designed to operate at 160 and I see no compelling reason to install a 160 thermostat . But its your car and you can do whatever you want.
#7
Re: 160 or 180 t-stat? (zzz)
Why not run the AC/Delco PN 10220957 170 t-stat, that way you can get heat if you need it and run cool enough in the summer. That's what I've done, rather than switch to 180 for winter and 160 for summer (I'm running the Derale adj. stat controlling both fans.
#8
Re: 160 or 180 t-stat? (Ky_Vette)
Good info! Thank you! I didn't realize that GM had a 170 degree stat. I should have mentioned that I have an 86 in case that influences a choice. I'm not worried about the heater.
I recognize that thermodynamically the warmer block would produce more HP and have less ring friction. I was also concerned with heating the incoming air in the L98 runners reducing HP. I didn't know the lowest temperature that the car remains in closed loop too.
[Modified by zzz, 6:28 AM 11/2/2002]
I recognize that thermodynamically the warmer block would produce more HP and have less ring friction. I was also concerned with heating the incoming air in the L98 runners reducing HP. I didn't know the lowest temperature that the car remains in closed loop too.
[Modified by zzz, 6:28 AM 11/2/2002]
#10
Melting Slicks
Member Since: Apr 2002
Location: down that one road next to that big tree
Posts: 3,019
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: 160 or 180 t-stat? (zzz)
sort of but as said above times are better when the engine is colder, it's rather simple, the colder air is; the more oxygen it can carry with it. the word "dense" gets used a lot around here. anyway i have a drilled 160 in the car now & think i'm going to try a 170 straight for winter, & switch back to the 160 in the summer. it's a very simple job to change therm's so i might as well get the best of both worlds. i, like you have my fans come on at 185. a 180 therm is just too hot for that, your fans would never stop running
#11
Pro
Re: 160 or 180 t-stat? (Ky_Vette)
I decided to run the 170* for the same reason.
#12
Re: 160 or 180 t-stat? (jfb)
Please explain how higher coolant temps help increase hp when the extra heat will also make knock more likely thus resulting in retardation of timing (LT1/LT4). The cylinder wear issue found in the test of the 40hp engines is not comparable to an engine using an advanced multi-vis motor oil, especially something such as Mobil 1, not when you're only talking a difference of approx. 10 - 12 degrees on average with 160 tstat vs. 180. The C4 was only designed to operate at the higher temps for emissions reasons.
Early C4's had 195 thermostats and later C4's had 180. For everyday driving , use the thermostat your cooling system was designed for. In cold climates and winter, your cooling system can get rid of heat fast enough so the 160 stat can control the temperature and 160 is too low to operate an engine at. In summer temps, your cooling system cannot get rid of heat fast enough to maintain 160 and the 160 stat will always be wide open and you will run the same temps as with the factory stat (under 35 mph). This subject has been hashed many times in the past and some members claim better times at the track, but thermodynamics predicts lower hp with lower coolant temps. One member did a dyno run with a 160 and then a 180 stat and measured no difference. Continental Motors ran some small engines (40 hp) at different coolant temps and tore down the engines afterward and learned by actual measurement that the higher the coolant temperature, higher hp , lower specific fuel consumption and lower cylinder wear was measured. The C4 was not designed to operate at 160 and I see no compelling reason to install a 160 thermostat . But its your car and you can do whatever you want.
#13
Intermediate
Member Since: Jan 2001
Location: Orland Park IL
Posts: 46
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: 160 or 180 t-stat? (zzz)
Go with the 160. I've been running a Robert Shaw 1" for years in my 1986 Z-51. On the warmest days of the summer, with both fans running, the engine never gets over 185 degrees.
#14
Race Director
Re: 160 or 180 t-stat? (zzz)
I run the 180 in the winter time for a couple of reasons, Get the water hotter for the heater and get the oil hotter that way it cooks off the moisture in the oil faster..
#15
Team Owner
Member Since: Mar 2001
Location: Cincinnati, Oh USA
Posts: 53,930
Likes: 0
Received 26 Likes
on
23 Posts
Re: 160 or 180 t-stat? (Lone Ranger)
C4 engines have knock sensors for extreme loads that cause pinging, not for typical operation at normal operating temperatures and spark is rarely retarded during normal operation. The thermal efficiency of ALL heat engines (and automobile engines are heat engines) is inversely proportional to the difference between the inlet and outlet temperatures. The larger the difference in these two temperatures, the less work (hp) the engine can do, partly because energy is lost in raising the inlet air/fuel temps to the combustion temperature and partly due to energy that was not extracted from the heat energy of the exhaust (if you could convert every calorie of the air/fuel mixture to mechanical hp, your exhaust temp would be the same as or lower than the inlet temperature). I am sure that Continental used modern engine oil in their test engines and that cylinder wear is comparable to running the exact tests with a V8 automobile engine.
Another reason to run C4 engines at higher temps is to allow a smaller radiator.
Another reason to run C4 engines at higher temps is to allow a smaller radiator.
#16
Melting Slicks
Re: 160 or 180 t-stat? (jfb)
C4 engines have knock sensors for extreme loads that cause pinging, not for typical operation at normal operating temperatures and spark is rarely retarded during normal operation....
Eric
#17
Re: 160 or 180 t-stat? (jfb)
C4 engines have knock sensors for extreme loads that cause pinging, not for typical operation at normal operating temperatures and spark is rarely retarded during normal operation. The thermal efficiency of ALL heat engines (and automobile engines are heat engines) is inversely proportional to the difference between the inlet and outlet temperatures. The larger the difference in these two temperatures, the less work (hp) the engine can do, partly because energy is lost in raising the inlet air/fuel temps to the combustion temperature and partly due to energy that was not extracted from the heat energy of the exhaust (if you could convert every calorie of the air/fuel mixture to mechanical hp, your exhaust temp would be the same as or lower than the inlet temperature). I am sure that Continental used modern engine oil in their test engines and that cylinder wear is comparable to running the exact tests with a V8 automobile engine.
Another reason to run C4 engines at higher temps is to allow a smaller radiator.
Another reason to run C4 engines at higher temps is to allow a smaller radiator.