Downsides to running too much methanol with SSC other than too rich & Less HP
#1
Team Owner
Thread Starter
Member Since: Apr 2001
Location: Elmhurst, IL (West Suburb of Chicago) & Home of MEGA Horsepower
Posts: 26,714
Received 584 Likes
on
399 Posts
St. Jude Donor '06
Downsides to running too much methanol with SSC other than too rich & Less HP
The reason I ask is b/c my goal for my new ECS D1SC BLown 02 Z with it 100% bone stock Z06 LS6 motor, is to have the stock motor LAST as LONG AS POSSIBLE, and at the same time have as much fun with the car as possible. (a fine line to walk no doubt).
I realize that if my motor lives often in the area of 10lbs of boost making 600rwhp on the my stock LS6 motor, its just a matter of time that the car is going to go KABOOM, so i am implementing my own detuning methods for everyday driving such as short shifting so i only see 7 lbs of boost, etc. I realize i can put on a bigger 7.5lb (boost) pulley than the 10lb boost pulley I am running, but I want to have the that extra THRUST/POWER when i need it once in a while, for those special occassions like when a VIPER or 06 Z06 comes up on me on the highway, etc.
I am running straight methanol as added protection and if i turn up the control **** lets say all the way up to the position that it is releasing/misting the most amount of methanol that the ECS kits allow, is there ANY POSSIBILITY of this having any NEGATIVE EFFECTS on my set-up, motor, etc., (REGARDING RELIABLITIDY/ENGINE LONGEIVTY) other than the following factors which i am aware of and could be perceived as other as a negative effect of running the methanol at its richest setting on the ECS kit:
1. RUNNING TO RICH WHILE MAKING OVER 4 lbs of boost (when it kicks in) and;
2:: Being down some on power b/c its runnnig too rich;
3. Going through more methanol than is necessary.
Thanks for your useful positive info!!!
I realize that if my motor lives often in the area of 10lbs of boost making 600rwhp on the my stock LS6 motor, its just a matter of time that the car is going to go KABOOM, so i am implementing my own detuning methods for everyday driving such as short shifting so i only see 7 lbs of boost, etc. I realize i can put on a bigger 7.5lb (boost) pulley than the 10lb boost pulley I am running, but I want to have the that extra THRUST/POWER when i need it once in a while, for those special occassions like when a VIPER or 06 Z06 comes up on me on the highway, etc.
I am running straight methanol as added protection and if i turn up the control **** lets say all the way up to the position that it is releasing/misting the most amount of methanol that the ECS kits allow, is there ANY POSSIBILITY of this having any NEGATIVE EFFECTS on my set-up, motor, etc., (REGARDING RELIABLITIDY/ENGINE LONGEIVTY) other than the following factors which i am aware of and could be perceived as other as a negative effect of running the methanol at its richest setting on the ECS kit:
1. RUNNING TO RICH WHILE MAKING OVER 4 lbs of boost (when it kicks in) and;
2:: Being down some on power b/c its runnnig too rich;
3. Going through more methanol than is necessary.
Thanks for your useful positive info!!!
Last edited by Mopar Jimmy; 09-04-2005 at 03:16 PM.
#2
Le Mans Master
Originally Posted by MTI 427 Roadster
The reason I ask is b/c my goal for my new ECS D1SC BLown 02 Z with it 100% bone stock Z06 LS6 motor, is to have the stock motor LAST as LONG AS POSSIBLE, and at the same time have as much fun with the car as possible. (a fine line to walk no doubt).
I realize that if my motor lives often in the area of 10lbs of boost making 600rwhp on the my stock LS6 motor, its just a matter of time that the car is going to go KABOOM, so i am implementing my own detuning methods for everyday driving such as short shifting so i only see 7 lbs of boost, etc. I realize i can put on a bigger 7.5lb (boost) pulley than the 10lb boost pulley I am running, but I want to have the that extra THRUST/POWER when i need it once in a while, for those special occassions like when a VIPER or 06 Z06 comes up on me on the highway, etc.
I am running straight methanol as added protection and if i turn up the control **** lets say all the way up to the position that it is releasing/misting the most amount of methanol that the ECS kits allow, is there ANY POSSIBILITY of this having any negative effects on my set-up, motor, etc., other than:
1. RUNNING TO RICH WHILE MAKING OVER 4 lbs of boost (when it kicks in) and:
2:: Being down some on power b/c its runnnig too rich?
3. Going through more methanol than is necessary.
Thanks for your useful positive info!!!
I realize that if my motor lives often in the area of 10lbs of boost making 600rwhp on the my stock LS6 motor, its just a matter of time that the car is going to go KABOOM, so i am implementing my own detuning methods for everyday driving such as short shifting so i only see 7 lbs of boost, etc. I realize i can put on a bigger 7.5lb (boost) pulley than the 10lb boost pulley I am running, but I want to have the that extra THRUST/POWER when i need it once in a while, for those special occassions like when a VIPER or 06 Z06 comes up on me on the highway, etc.
I am running straight methanol as added protection and if i turn up the control **** lets say all the way up to the position that it is releasing/misting the most amount of methanol that the ECS kits allow, is there ANY POSSIBILITY of this having any negative effects on my set-up, motor, etc., other than:
1. RUNNING TO RICH WHILE MAKING OVER 4 lbs of boost (when it kicks in) and:
2:: Being down some on power b/c its runnnig too rich?
3. Going through more methanol than is necessary.
Thanks for your useful positive info!!!
i spoke to julio, i bought ecs alchy too, and he told me that running rich on alchy doesnt kill power, as gas does, when rich, so that good.
#3
Team Owner
Originally Posted by NICK YOSKIN
running rich on alchy doesnt kill power
MTI - just shift at 6,000 - 6,200 RPM and enjoy your car.
Mark
#4
Team Owner
Thread Starter
Member Since: Apr 2001
Location: Elmhurst, IL (West Suburb of Chicago) & Home of MEGA Horsepower
Posts: 26,714
Received 584 Likes
on
399 Posts
St. Jude Donor '06
Originally Posted by mdhmi
I don't buy it. My car is faster without the meth. I run the meth to keep the motor together.
MTI - just shift at 6,000 - 6,200 RPM and enjoy your car.
Mark
MTI - just shift at 6,000 - 6,200 RPM and enjoy your car.
Mark
MARK,
Not trying to be a smart azz buddy and sorry if i'm coming off that way, but how about your informed opinion as to the topic at hand in this thread and you and I shifting our cars where we choose to do so (under any given driving circumstance be it on the street, highway, road race track or drag strip)!!
The last thing i want is for this thread to get off topic like some recent threads here (as you may recall) and this is an interesting subject and i want to educate myself, etc. (as that to me is one of the big things that make this forum kick azz)
Last edited by Mopar Jimmy; 09-04-2005 at 02:56 PM.
#5
Melting Slicks
Member Since: Apr 2005
Location: Chicagoland Area IL
Posts: 3,418
Likes: 0
Received 1 Like
on
1 Post
MTI,
I have seen dyno graphs that you could easily see alky turn ON point. It was a dip in graph followed by recovery. Now with progressive controllers in which flow starts gradually then increases, this should not be the case.
If you have an older style system (I know you don’t) that relied on pressure switch and flow was fixed, then you would go way rich and loose some HP at turn on point. Don’t want to start anything here, but too rich is too rich.
Mike
I have seen dyno graphs that you could easily see alky turn ON point. It was a dip in graph followed by recovery. Now with progressive controllers in which flow starts gradually then increases, this should not be the case.
If you have an older style system (I know you don’t) that relied on pressure switch and flow was fixed, then you would go way rich and loose some HP at turn on point. Don’t want to start anything here, but too rich is too rich.
Mike
#6
Team Owner
Thread Starter
Member Since: Apr 2001
Location: Elmhurst, IL (West Suburb of Chicago) & Home of MEGA Horsepower
Posts: 26,714
Received 584 Likes
on
399 Posts
St. Jude Donor '06
Before I crank up the dial for more methanol on ECS KIT (and yes when it gets cooler out i know this is recommended but still warm in Chicago through September) how about a few more intelligible responses from some knowleagable f/i follk!!!
ps-YES, i have changed my name to get current and away from my old ride and in tune (no pun intended) with my new BLOWN ECS Z06!!!
ps-YES, i have changed my name to get current and away from my old ride and in tune (no pun intended) with my new BLOWN ECS Z06!!!
Last edited by Mopar Jimmy; 09-04-2005 at 11:41 PM.
#7
Team Owner
Your best bet is to put a datta logger in like Doug and myself run with a wideband like this one.
www.zeitronix.com
If your car was tuned like ours then you rely on the meth to be a suplimental fuel source. I run 2 boost settings for 2 different tunes, low is half gain @ 12.8 and high @ 16 is full gain.
When I run full gain on my low setting and log I see no difference in my A/F running rich. If I only run it @ 1/4 gain I do hear I slight ping and a slight lean condition.
The benefit of running more meth is that you will lower your iat's that over what you consider to be your normal gain setting. Both of us have seen this as we have logged it while road tunning.
I have seen no evidence on the dyno or logging on the road that @ my low boost setting with it set @ full gain any rich condition or a loss in hp.
BTW I spray @ 3 psi through dual nozzles.
Hope this helped to clear the air for you.
www.zeitronix.com
If your car was tuned like ours then you rely on the meth to be a suplimental fuel source. I run 2 boost settings for 2 different tunes, low is half gain @ 12.8 and high @ 16 is full gain.
When I run full gain on my low setting and log I see no difference in my A/F running rich. If I only run it @ 1/4 gain I do hear I slight ping and a slight lean condition.
The benefit of running more meth is that you will lower your iat's that over what you consider to be your normal gain setting. Both of us have seen this as we have logged it while road tunning.
I have seen no evidence on the dyno or logging on the road that @ my low boost setting with it set @ full gain any rich condition or a loss in hp.
BTW I spray @ 3 psi through dual nozzles.
Hope this helped to clear the air for you.
#8
Burning Brakes
If you increase the gain **** more alky will be shot into the motor. This will bring down your AF ratio. Bringing down the AF ratio will cuase it to lose power. Which by some is ok. So a loss in power can occur when too much alky is shot in combined with too much gas. So if your tuned to run 12.1 then crank the **** it will drop into the 11's..10's..even 9:1 AFR depending on nozzle setup and controller settings.
Motor will make the most power when its rite on the edge of knocking.. even knocking just a smidge.. and that fine line is where it really comes alive. Its tuning.
For street settings I run more aggressive on the alky than I do at the track. Since the motor will be more heat soaked, hotter, etc.. which contribute to detonation. At the track.. then we can get it to the edge
So if your "tuned" 1/2 way up on your controller.. mark the **** and increase it 1/4 way up. When you get to the track.. start pulling out a little at a time and watch the performance/knock activity.
Small adjustments make big pressure changes So keep that in mind when turning on the ****'s'
And a big to any monitoring or logging device when trying to get a car figured out.
Motor will make the most power when its rite on the edge of knocking.. even knocking just a smidge.. and that fine line is where it really comes alive. Its tuning.
For street settings I run more aggressive on the alky than I do at the track. Since the motor will be more heat soaked, hotter, etc.. which contribute to detonation. At the track.. then we can get it to the edge
So if your "tuned" 1/2 way up on your controller.. mark the **** and increase it 1/4 way up. When you get to the track.. start pulling out a little at a time and watch the performance/knock activity.
Small adjustments make big pressure changes So keep that in mind when turning on the ****'s'
And a big to any monitoring or logging device when trying to get a car figured out.
#10
Safety Car
Member Since: Sep 2002
Location: Aurora IL
Posts: 3,948
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
St. Jude Donor '06
Originally Posted by BLOWN ECS Z06
JULIO:
GREAT INFO man and nothing like getting the facts straight right from the horses mouth!!!!!!!!!!!!
GREAT INFO man and nothing like getting the facts straight right from the horses mouth!!!!!!!!!!!!
#11
Melting Slicks
And a big to any monitoring or logging device when trying to get a car figured out.
My stock shortblock is still together and it is not because I'm a master tuner. I just put in a monitoring system before I tried to make big power and have learned a ton along the way. Data logging equipment should be required for FI IMHO. It was expensive and difficult to do a few years back, but the cost and complexity have come way down recently.
#12
Race Director
Member Since: Nov 2000
Location: CA
Posts: 11,218
Received 897 Likes
on
403 Posts
2017 C5 of the Year Finalist
St. Jude Donor '08
Originally Posted by Julio
If you increase the gain **** more alky will be shot into the motor. This will bring down your AF ratio. Bringing down the AF ratio will cuase it to lose power. Which by some is ok. So a loss in power can occur when too much alky is shot in combined with too much gas. So if your tuned to run 12.1 then crank the **** it will drop into the 11's..10's..even 9:1 AFR depending on nozzle setup and controller settings.
I've seen my power drop off from too much Alky on the dyno... We still made real good power being a bit rich, but if you crank up the Alky too much, you will lose power.
JB
#13
Instructor
Member Since: Jul 2002
Location: Atlanta ga
Posts: 178
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
f-body here but same motor. I have a 346 with incon twins....i have my old SMC kit running methanol and at WOT am providing 24% of my total fueling with methanol. I logged the a/f and adjusted the PE table so my a/f curve is smooth...even when the meth kicks in. The methanol will not harm the motor in any way. Being a little rich at WOT will not hurt anything either. Meth will help keep the IATs in line and helped me make 736rwhp with 93 octane
#14
Melting Slicks
Originally Posted by cablebandit
f-body here but same motor. I have a 346 with incon twins....i have my old SMC kit running methanol and at WOT am providing 24% of my total fueling with methanol. I logged the a/f and adjusted the PE table so my a/f curve is smooth...even when the meth kicks in. The methanol will not harm the motor in any way. Being a little rich at WOT will not hurt anything either. Meth will help keep the IATs in line and helped me make 736rwhp with 93 octane
The best thing to do is to set the system up to pump as much meth as possible and then dial back your regular fuel. You will be in big trouble if you run out of meth, but I would rather have that risk than the alternative.
#15
Le Mans Master
Originally Posted by jbsblownc5
I've seen my power drop off from too much Alky on the dyno... We still made real good power being a bit rich, but if you crank up the Alky too much, you will lose power.
JB
JB
true jb but not at the rate that you would if it were gas.
#16
Team Owner
Thread Starter
Member Since: Apr 2001
Location: Elmhurst, IL (West Suburb of Chicago) & Home of MEGA Horsepower
Posts: 26,714
Received 584 Likes
on
399 Posts
St. Jude Donor '06
Originally Posted by cablebandit
f-body here but same motor. I have a 346 with incon twins....i have my old SMC kit running methanol and at WOT am providing 24% of my total fueling with methanol. I logged the a/f and adjusted the PE table so my a/f curve is smooth...even when the meth kicks in. The methanol will not harm the motor in any way. Being a little rich at WOT will not hurt anything either. Meth will help keep the IATs in line and helped me make 736rwhp with 93 octane