Dex-Cool or Death Cool ???????
#1
Melting Slicks
Thread Starter
Dex-Cool or Death Cool ???????
I was wondering if any of you are having problems with Dex-Cool. GM has a bulletin on it and I see there are several lawsuits out there alledging that the stuff forms a crystal residue that blocks cooling passages. I think the problem gets much worse if you ever let your system get low and introduce oxygen. Other manufactures will void your warranty if you ever use Dex-Cool. GM has been the only manufacturer that stood behind it. I have had machinists, mechanics and radiator people tell me to get rid of it. To be safe, I recently changed over to Prestone's new yellow bottle formula which mixes with ALL types and colors of antifreeze, even Death-Cool.
#2
Race Director
I've been meaning to ask how long most members wait before having theirs flushed. I've been watching posts here in this forum since 2000 and to be honest, have not seen many complaints regarding the antifreeze. I believe the owner's manual calls for 5 year flushes?
#3
Resident moron
I always hear some people complaining about it, but I've never seen any proof.
Used properly it's great. I have 81k miles on my 98 daily driver and the coolant has never been touched, looks fine. I've had it in my last 3 cars in fact, never a problem.
I'm also pretty sure every manufacturer uses some variant of it, no one uses the old 'green' stuff in the last 10 years or so.
Dope
Used properly it's great. I have 81k miles on my 98 daily driver and the coolant has never been touched, looks fine. I've had it in my last 3 cars in fact, never a problem.
I'm also pretty sure every manufacturer uses some variant of it, no one uses the old 'green' stuff in the last 10 years or so.
Dope
#7
Team Owner
This problem has been around a while. It was found to be low coolant and some mitigating circumstances. I actually switched all my cars from Prestone to Dexcool because I was so impressed with its characteristics. Have been using in all my cars for several years, absolutely no problems. I even went into my block and radiator with a boroscope, cleaner than any Prestone engine I have seen. Stick with the Dexcool, just keep it full and maintained.
#8
Team Owner
I use Dex-Cool and distilled water (only) and I am now at 106K miles. I changed and flushed at about 60K so I am on my second batch. No problems whatsoever.
Robert
Robert
#9
Le Mans Master
I drained mine at 5 years, it was very clean. I switched to dex-cool in all my vehicles, no problem.
I know if you have a leak and air gets into system, it can be a problem. But then a leak is also a problem.
I know if you have a leak and air gets into system, it can be a problem. But then a leak is also a problem.
#12
Melting Slicks
Member Since: Jan 2004
Location: Currently living in and loving... Chico, CA
Posts: 3,225
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I read somewhere (maybe it could have been on the actual bottle ) that a 50/50 Dexcool mix has better heat exchange properties than a 50/50 green stuff mix. If so, putting a green stuff mix into a cooling system sized for Dexcool heat exchange properties may cause the motor to run hotter than usual and be more prone to overheating.
When I replaced the factory fill green stuff mix with a 50/50 Dexcool mix in my '95 Caprice, the motor ran cooler. Just my $0.02, folks.
When I replaced the factory fill green stuff mix with a 50/50 Dexcool mix in my '95 Caprice, the motor ran cooler. Just my $0.02, folks.
#13
Tech Contributor
Member Since: Oct 1999
Location: Charlotte, NC (formerly Endicott, NY)
Posts: 40,087
Received 8,927 Likes
on
5,332 Posts
I wouldn't switch. GM specifically tells you in the owners manual that you are supposed to use DexCool by trademark not by a specification number. That means DexCool by Texaco not anybody else's orange fluid when replacing the coolant. This is key since they don't have any interest in what you do to the car after the warranty runs out but have clearly taken an interest in this case. They have been sticking by this product for many years now and if it was causing as many problems as opiniated mechanics think it would have been ditched. I've had 5 vehicles with DexCool in the radiator and have never seen a problem with any of them. Any A''hole can file a lawsuit and even win by being a nuisance. Doesn't make them right and GM wrong.
Bill
Bill
#14
Team Owner
Originally Posted by Bill Dearborn
I wouldn't switch. GM specifically tells you in the owners manual that you are supposed to use DexCool by trademark not by a specification number. That means DexCool by Texaco not anybody else's orange fluid when replacing the coolant. This is key since they don't have any interest in what you do to the car after the warranty runs out but have clearly taken an interest in this case. They have been sticking by this product for many years now and if it was causing as many problems as opiniated mechanics think it would have been ditched. I've had 5 vehicles with DexCool in the radiator and have never seen a problem with any of them. Any A''hole can file a lawsuit and even win by being a nuisance. Doesn't make them right and GM wrong.
Bill
Bill
#15
Burning Brakes
We've had dexcool in our last 3 chevy's and in my vette. The other 3 have gone to at least 80k miles (one went ove 100k on the original fluid) and we never had a problem with overheating or anything coolant related. It was always nice and orange. I'm not worried about the coolant in my car. GM says it's good for at least 5 years so I'm gonna trust them. Sometimes it's just not worth trying to create a better a mouse trap.
#16
Originally Posted by my6thvette
Drained mine last year, after 5 years, and it looked absolutely perfect. No residue at all.
#17
Originally Posted by Sandra Bigwoode
So what about all the people with C5's that have less than 3,000 miles on them and more than 5 years?
Should they be driven more or just parked and left to rot?
Should they be driven more or just parked and left to rot?
#18
Drifting
Originally Posted by my6thvette
Drained mine last year, after 5 years, and it looked absolutely perfect. No residue at all.
60K and 5 years
#19
Drifting
Member Since: Jul 2002
Location: Spring Tx
Posts: 1,613
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Dozens of lawyers spent tens of thousands of dollars trying make a class action suit out of this so called problem, and I know for a fact that their cases were thrown out of court in California and Ohio
#20
Melting Slicks
Member Since: Jan 2004
Location: Currently living in and loving... Chico, CA
Posts: 3,225
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Just changed the original Dexcool in my wife's '00 Denali 5.7 cast iron with a hair under 33,000 on it this morning, and all came out clear. The vehicle will be 5 years old in August with a build month of July. I think that speaks for itself.