Does the brand of oil make much of a difference with synthetic oils?
#1
Safety Car
Thread Starter
Does the brand of oil make much of a difference with synthetic oils?
About to change my oil again. I usually run Mobile 1 20/50. I run the car pretty hard while autocrossing and such. But I'm thinking of lowering down to 10w 30 or possibly 5w 30.
I've been doing a lot more normal driving of late. Does the brand oil I use make a big difference? What brans do you run? What viscosity?
And does anyone have a good filter to suggest? I'd like part #s if possible.
Thanks
I've been doing a lot more normal driving of late. Does the brand oil I use make a big difference? What brans do you run? What viscosity?
And does anyone have a good filter to suggest? I'd like part #s if possible.
Thanks
#2
Team Owner
Given the superior lubricating properties of today's synthetics, and tighter machining tolerances from the factory, I really doubt that 20w50 oil is necessary, even while auto-xing. I would probably run a 10w30, and if the weather get a little colder where you are, the 5w-30 would be fine. I highly doubt that one brand is better than another, except in the testing lab, under VERY controlled conditions. I've always used Mobil1, but only because I can usually find it cheaper than the other brands.
I bought a bunch of the AC Delco synthetic filters from Ficthner Chevrolet, a forum sponsor, a few years ago. They were supposed to be the "hot tip". I don't know if they're still available, as AC Delco was considering dropping them, but since Ficthner's was buying them in large quanties, as a single source, it appeared that they could justify making several thousand a year, as long as they were going to one delivery point, rather than 2-3 to every Delco retailer around the country.
If they're no longer available, I'd go with a Mobil1 filter. K&N is a good filter too, but people have sais that the hex nut on the bottom of the K&N case can hang low, and be a point of impact/damage.
I bought a bunch of the AC Delco synthetic filters from Ficthner Chevrolet, a forum sponsor, a few years ago. They were supposed to be the "hot tip". I don't know if they're still available, as AC Delco was considering dropping them, but since Ficthner's was buying them in large quanties, as a single source, it appeared that they could justify making several thousand a year, as long as they were going to one delivery point, rather than 2-3 to every Delco retailer around the country.
If they're no longer available, I'd go with a Mobil1 filter. K&N is a good filter too, but people have sais that the hex nut on the bottom of the K&N case can hang low, and be a point of impact/damage.
#3
Team Owner
I think so and go by the viscosity at 100 degrees "C". German Castrol is around 12.3 Cst while Mobil-1 is around 10 or so even though both are a 30 weight oil at temperature. Castrol is at the upper end of the range and Mobil-1 at the lower end of the range.
#4
goto ls1 tech theres all kinds of great links to oil info
personally, i run rotella 15W 40 in nearly everything i own, including the Z06.
yes there is a difference between synthetics, the links at ls1tech will help you.. or you can google bob is the oil guy or something like that (off the top of my head, but give it a shot)
for autocross, i too would run a thicker than recommended oil. BUT, personally, i'd run straight 40 weight. more stable.
a 10W-30 or xW-anything kind of has an identity crisis, it tries to be two things at one time, and of course there are sacrifices as far as protection goes.
i run oil designed for diesels for the high anti metal to metal contact additives (ZnP04) though i know you have to watch the rotella bottles close, as they have decreased the additive content for emissions equipment. plus, all those diesels have huge turbos seeing all kinds of high EGT's and they dont fail to lubricate or coke-up like regular gasoline engine oil can.
thats just my take on it, and what i live by.. because it works for me and lets me sleep at night. i've also built more engines than you could shake a stick at :thumbs
thats just my take
oh yeah. german castrol is supposedly nearly = penzoil platinum synthetic which is supposed to be some of the best. the german stuff is impossible to find in some areas.
in applications when i do run a plain gasoline oil that is synthetic, i choose castrol.
personally, i run rotella 15W 40 in nearly everything i own, including the Z06.
yes there is a difference between synthetics, the links at ls1tech will help you.. or you can google bob is the oil guy or something like that (off the top of my head, but give it a shot)
for autocross, i too would run a thicker than recommended oil. BUT, personally, i'd run straight 40 weight. more stable.
a 10W-30 or xW-anything kind of has an identity crisis, it tries to be two things at one time, and of course there are sacrifices as far as protection goes.
i run oil designed for diesels for the high anti metal to metal contact additives (ZnP04) though i know you have to watch the rotella bottles close, as they have decreased the additive content for emissions equipment. plus, all those diesels have huge turbos seeing all kinds of high EGT's and they dont fail to lubricate or coke-up like regular gasoline engine oil can.
thats just my take on it, and what i live by.. because it works for me and lets me sleep at night. i've also built more engines than you could shake a stick at :thumbs
thats just my take
oh yeah. german castrol is supposedly nearly = penzoil platinum synthetic which is supposed to be some of the best. the german stuff is impossible to find in some areas.
in applications when i do run a plain gasoline oil that is synthetic, i choose castrol.
#5
Team Owner
#6
Melting Slicks
Here's the GM approved list.Any one of the name-brand Hi Perf oils should be fine.
\db2
Carolina
http://www.gm.com/corporate/responsi...ngine_oils.pdf
\db2
Carolina
http://www.gm.com/corporate/responsi...ngine_oils.pdf
#11
Le Mans Master
I think Mobil 1 quality may be slipping, and other brands are improving.
I just switched to Valvoline Synpower because Valvoline and Castrol EDGE both showed better wear protection than Mobil 1 in the standard wear test.
I only use WIX filters on all my cars.
Just make sure the oil meets the GM 4718M spec for the Corvette and you should be OK. I use 10W30 in Texas.
I just switched to Valvoline Synpower because Valvoline and Castrol EDGE both showed better wear protection than Mobil 1 in the standard wear test.
I only use WIX filters on all my cars.
Just make sure the oil meets the GM 4718M spec for the Corvette and you should be OK. I use 10W30 in Texas.
#13
Safety Car
Member Since: Oct 1999
Location: Mt Juliet TN
Posts: 4,524
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Cruise-In 2, 9 & 10 Veteran
St Jude donor '09
To save money. As long as your oil meets the spec "GM 4718M," your OK. That spec will be on the label of your preferred brand.
Example, I stopped in at Advance Auto Parts today, Mobil 1 was $6.99/quart. Didn't price compare other GM 4718M spec brands, but some are less expensive.
Zippy
Example, I stopped in at Advance Auto Parts today, Mobil 1 was $6.99/quart. Didn't price compare other GM 4718M spec brands, but some are less expensive.
Zippy
#14
To save money. As long as your oil meets the spec "GM 4718M," your OK. That spec will be on the label of your preferred brand.
Example, I stopped in at Advance Auto Parts today, Mobil 1 was $6.99/quart. Didn't price compare other GM 4718M spec brands, but some are less expensive.
Zippy
Example, I stopped in at Advance Auto Parts today, Mobil 1 was $6.99/quart. Didn't price compare other GM 4718M spec brands, but some are less expensive.
Zippy
i don't earn a great living, most likely alot less than most vette owners, and i wouldn't skimp on something so stupid, i'd use exactly what gm recomends.
#15
Le Mans Master
I think Mobil 1 quality may be slipping, and other brands are improving.
I just switched to Valvoline Synpower because Valvoline and Castrol EDGE both showed better wear protection than Mobil 1 in the standard wear test.
I only use WIX filters on all my cars.
Just make sure the oil meets the GM 4718M spec for the Corvette and you should be OK. I use 10W30 in Texas.
I just switched to Valvoline Synpower because Valvoline and Castrol EDGE both showed better wear protection than Mobil 1 in the standard wear test.
I only use WIX filters on all my cars.
Just make sure the oil meets the GM 4718M spec for the Corvette and you should be OK. I use 10W30 in Texas.
I also use WIX or NAPA GOLD oil filters.
#16
Safety Car
Above quotes from 2000 Owner's Manual, and 2000 oil filler cap..
#17
Melting Slicks
It is nothing more than an advertisement. Mobil provided Mobil 1 oil to GM at a reduced price. In return, GM advertises Mobil 1 on the oil cap. Period. End of story. The motor isnt designed for Mobil 1 oil. Mobil just happend to be the low bidder when GM asked "Who wants their name on our Corvette oil caps?".
#18
Race Director
you guys ever notice the 5qt jugs of syn at wal-mart for $20? mobil1, valvoline, castrol, Penzoil platinum etc.
www.bobistheoilguy.com has a lot of useful information on oils. as far as i know only redline is a true ester oil which means it's a 100% created in a lab syn.
what weight of oil to use is also a bit of a hard question. 99% of the time following OEM recommendations is the way to go, of course this means 5-30w. higher operating temps are the only reason i can think of to move to a heavier weight.
also, 5-30 and 10-30 are both 30w oils. the split represents weight at different temperature. you can probably google to find out where the ratings are done.
www.bobistheoilguy.com has a lot of useful information on oils. as far as i know only redline is a true ester oil which means it's a 100% created in a lab syn.
what weight of oil to use is also a bit of a hard question. 99% of the time following OEM recommendations is the way to go, of course this means 5-30w. higher operating temps are the only reason i can think of to move to a heavier weight.
also, 5-30 and 10-30 are both 30w oils. the split represents weight at different temperature. you can probably google to find out where the ratings are done.
#19
Safety Car
Member Since: Oct 1999
Location: Mt Juliet TN
Posts: 4,524
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Cruise-In 2, 9 & 10 Veteran
St Jude donor '09
Regarding my earnings...I've been on fixed income and haven't worked for over 9 years, so most likely, I earn a lot less too.
Little background on why I psoted about oil. Have worked as a Sr Engineering Tech at Detroit Diesel Corp with over 34 years experience before gong on medical disability. We worked on future products, dyno testing, current products, 2 cycle & 4 cycle diesels, competitors brands, foreign brands, Wankel diesels (experimental), emissions testing, durability testing (ran enignes 24/7 for weeks at a time, stopping only to check and/or add oil), ran engines in every way imaginable, and each time we took oil samples that were evaluated by metallurgy and/or chemical engineers. We tested various types, brands of oils, and I can not tell you how many times I've changed oils in engines ranging from 40 hp to over 2,000 hp. Granted heavy duty diesels have different requirements than gasoline engines, however lube oil also have similar properties. Have also attended engineering seminars on lube oil, talked at length with engineers and chemists ragarding eninge oil.
I've owned and maintained 12 different Corvettes, most of which required GM 4718M specific oil. C3, C4, C5, and C6 Vettes have been part of me since 1983.
I don't believe I'm stupid if I use oil other than Mobil 1 in my vehicles.
For the record, I DO use Mobil 1 (partly because I only buy it on sale, and save money) in my Corvettes.
Almost forgot, also read and follow what GM says in their owner's manual.
Tony