please help! clutch dilemma
#1
please help! clutch dilemma
My 2000 c5 has 98 thousand miles on it. I decided to have the clutch replaced as preventive maintenance and the shop has had it for weeks unable to properly repair my vehicle. First, I was told that they received a defective part with a bad release bearing. Then, when they tried to install the second clutch, it still wasn't right. (Stick shift wouldn't go to neutal; no spring centering it, just a floppy stick)
I am now being told that the clutch listed for my car according to the VIN number does not fit. They claim the VIN number lists heavy duty clutch but it needs a regular duty clutch (something about the slave cylinder doesn't move parts far enough to disengage the flywheel?? Idk). Needless to say, I am beyond fed up with their excuses and waiting for my car to be properly repaired. Has anybody ever encountered parts listed according to the VIN number that don't actually fit the vehicle or am I being given the runaround? I feel like I've been as patient and understanding as possible but this whole repair has been a disaster. Have any of you experienced this nonsense? Please advise. Thanks.
I am now being told that the clutch listed for my car according to the VIN number does not fit. They claim the VIN number lists heavy duty clutch but it needs a regular duty clutch (something about the slave cylinder doesn't move parts far enough to disengage the flywheel?? Idk). Needless to say, I am beyond fed up with their excuses and waiting for my car to be properly repaired. Has anybody ever encountered parts listed according to the VIN number that don't actually fit the vehicle or am I being given the runaround? I feel like I've been as patient and understanding as possible but this whole repair has been a disaster. Have any of you experienced this nonsense? Please advise. Thanks.
Last edited by Brad S.; 09-09-2015 at 01:18 AM.
#2
Race Director
Member Since: Dec 2010
Location: Atlanta, GA
Posts: 10,426
Received 1,261 Likes
on
1,056 Posts
2020 Corvette of the Year Finalist (performance mods)
C5 of Year Winner (performance mods) 2019
sounds like a load of crap to me, I'm guessing this is not a performance shop or one accustomed to doing clutches on c5/c6 vettes?... the slave will be the same for a coupe, vert, or z06 as far as I know which should have no effect on it's ability to disengage the pressure plate from the disc... the flywheel, pressure plate, and disc might be different part numbers between different trim levels but they are all interchangeable and should work fine as long as everything is installed properly
#3
Drifting
They probably can't bleed the hydraulics properly and there is air in the system. That would be my guess as to what they are trying to tell you. Did you have them install a remote bleeder?
My first question to them is HOW DID YOU BLEED the CLUTCH system??? [ don't let them get away with "they know what they are doing and they did bleed it"]
I would guess you can't, but running not walking from this shop is probably the best solution. If they are replacing the clutch with a GM, then there is no "heavy duty" listed for the C5 in the OEM parts listing.
My first question to them is HOW DID YOU BLEED the CLUTCH system??? [ don't let them get away with "they know what they are doing and they did bleed it"]
I would guess you can't, but running not walking from this shop is probably the best solution. If they are replacing the clutch with a GM, then there is no "heavy duty" listed for the C5 in the OEM parts listing.
#4
Le Mans Master
1st... always check in with the FORUM before you have anything done to your C5
2nd Why did you replace your clutch if it was working properly?
3rd It really sounds like the shop your C5 is at, has NO IDEA what they are doing and you NEED to take it somewhere that they DO know what they are doing and get the job done right, or it will NEVER be right.
4th Might want to see about getting a good lawyer for this deal...
Good luck and sorry this is happening to you
2nd Why did you replace your clutch if it was working properly?
3rd It really sounds like the shop your C5 is at, has NO IDEA what they are doing and you NEED to take it somewhere that they DO know what they are doing and get the job done right, or it will NEVER be right.
4th Might want to see about getting a good lawyer for this deal...
Good luck and sorry this is happening to you
#5
Race Director
sounds like the bleed or they did not measure or shim the clutch correctly
c5 is one of the harder cars to do a clutch right simply because of all the things no one tells you
like
the balance issue
shimming if need be
why the sticky pedal is so common and how to fix it when you replace the clutch
the tech at that shop needs to talk with someone who knows the ins and outs for 10 minutes, your car will be fine.
and LOL at the braniac who said get a lawyer. how smart is that, spend $2k on a guy to argue a case you might not win....probably won't win would be a better way to say it.
c5 is one of the harder cars to do a clutch right simply because of all the things no one tells you
like
the balance issue
shimming if need be
why the sticky pedal is so common and how to fix it when you replace the clutch
the tech at that shop needs to talk with someone who knows the ins and outs for 10 minutes, your car will be fine.
and LOL at the braniac who said get a lawyer. how smart is that, spend $2k on a guy to argue a case you might not win....probably won't win would be a better way to say it.
#6
Le Mans Master
sounds like the bleed or they did not measure or shim the clutch correctly
c5 is one of the harder cars to do a clutch right simply because of all the things no one tells you
like
the balance issue
shimming if need be
why the sticky pedal is so common and how to fix it when you replace the clutch
the tech at that shop needs to talk with someone who knows the ins and outs for 10 minutes, your car will be fine.
and LOL at the braniac who said get a lawyer. how smart is that, spend $2k on a guy to argue a case you might not win....probably won't win would be a better way to say it.
c5 is one of the harder cars to do a clutch right simply because of all the things no one tells you
like
the balance issue
shimming if need be
why the sticky pedal is so common and how to fix it when you replace the clutch
the tech at that shop needs to talk with someone who knows the ins and outs for 10 minutes, your car will be fine.
and LOL at the braniac who said get a lawyer. how smart is that, spend $2k on a guy to argue a case you might not win....probably won't win would be a better way to say it.
#7
They probably can't bleed the hydraulics properly and there is air in the system. That would be my guess as to what they are trying to tell you. Did you have them install a remote bleeder?
My first question to them is HOW DID YOU BLEED the CLUTCH system??? [ don't let them get away with "they know what they are doing and they did bleed it"]
I would guess you can't, but running not walking from this shop is probably the best solution. If they are replacing the clutch with a GM, then there is no "heavy duty" listed for the C5 in the OEM parts listing.
My first question to them is HOW DID YOU BLEED the CLUTCH system??? [ don't let them get away with "they know what they are doing and they did bleed it"]
I would guess you can't, but running not walking from this shop is probably the best solution. If they are replacing the clutch with a GM, then there is no "heavy duty" listed for the C5 in the OEM parts listing.
#8
how do you bleed the clutch
Does the clutch have to be bled at the slave cylinder BEFORE the bell housing is put on? What is the proper method for this and other tips to avoid sticky pedal on a 2000 c5 coupe? Trying to make sure that repair shop properly installs my new clutch. (slave cylinder was replaced, had new clutch put in at same time and now the shop seems to be in over their head.)
#9
They probably can't bleed the hydraulics properly and there is air in the system. That would be my guess as to what they are trying to tell you. Did you have them install a remote bleeder?
My first question to them is HOW DID YOU BLEED the CLUTCH system??? [ don't let them get away with "they know what they are doing and they did bleed it"]
I would guess you can't, but running not walking from this shop is probably the best solution. If they are replacing the clutch with a GM, then there is no "heavy duty" listed for the C5 in the OEM parts listing.
My first question to them is HOW DID YOU BLEED the CLUTCH system??? [ don't let them get away with "they know what they are doing and they did bleed it"]
I would guess you can't, but running not walking from this shop is probably the best solution. If they are replacing the clutch with a GM, then there is no "heavy duty" listed for the C5 in the OEM parts listing.
#10
Please give me info so I can know what needs to be done and point these turds in the right direction as I tell them what they may not know. I'm a total newbie by the wsy, bit I guess you guys have figured that out. I know the ranger method for freshening up the clutch fluid, and that's it.
#11
sounds like the bleed or they did not measure or shim the clutch correctly
c5 is one of the harder cars to do a clutch right simply because of all the things no one tells you
like
the balance issue
shimming if need be
why the sticky pedal is so common and how to fix it when you replace the clutch
the tech at that shop needs to talk with someone who knows the ins and outs for 10 minutes, your car will be fine.
and LOL at the braniac who said get a lawyer. how smart is that, spend $2k on a guy to argue a case you might not win....probably won't win would be a better way to say it.
c5 is one of the harder cars to do a clutch right simply because of all the things no one tells you
like
the balance issue
shimming if need be
why the sticky pedal is so common and how to fix it when you replace the clutch
the tech at that shop needs to talk with someone who knows the ins and outs for 10 minutes, your car will be fine.
and LOL at the braniac who said get a lawyer. how smart is that, spend $2k on a guy to argue a case you might not win....probably won't win would be a better way to say it.
#12
Race Director
Member Since: Apr 2007
Location: South Western Ontario
Posts: 11,061
Received 845 Likes
on
721 Posts
Every slave has a bleeder screw. It works like a brake bleeder doing the pedal pump, pedal hold and then bleeder opening and closing to release air and fluid. You bleed it once assembled before putting the tunnel plate and exhaust back on.
Here is info on the spacer shims, read the description and look at the second image.
http://www.tickperformance.com/tick-...nder-shim-180/
Here is info on the spacer shims, read the description and look at the second image.
http://www.tickperformance.com/tick-...nder-shim-180/
#14
Drifting
So, .... How DO you bleed it, etc.?
Please give me info so I can know what needs to be done and point these turds in the right direction as I tell them what they may not know. I'm a total newbie by the wsy, bit I guess you guys have figured that out. I know the ranger method for freshening up the clutch fluid, and that's it.
Please give me info so I can know what needs to be done and point these turds in the right direction as I tell them what they may not know. I'm a total newbie by the wsy, bit I guess you guys have figured that out. I know the ranger method for freshening up the clutch fluid, and that's it.
That is why everyone that has ever done a clutch job recommends putting in a remote bleeder.
If you would post your home location and it is near one of the forum members maybe someone wouldn't mind looking over your situation.
Even though you probably want to shell the mechanic's building with mortars, you are at his mercy to some extent until you get your problem sorted out. That being said, I would save the father-son talk until you get your car out of there in one piece and working. There needs to be serious negotiations when it came time to write a check.
The photo below show a group of us dropping the drivetrain from a friend's C6Z. This was before the beer bell rang, so my garage is not so cluttered. Much more plumbing to clear on this car vs. a C5, but the point is, if your mechanic doesn't have a fixture like this to support the drivetrain/power train (I made this one, copying the fixture at the Corvette Assembly plant in BG) then they were the wrong guys.
We dropped the drive train, replaced the clutch and slave, ADDED a remote bleeder. The owner took the car to cali and back-no problems.
#15
Racer
This is not going to end well if you continue down this road. Even if they manage to get the clutch in and bled properly there is a good chance it is not going to be balanced properly. I would do my best to get the car back (with as little out of pocket as possible) and take it to real shop.
Read as much as you can about the C5 clutches, so you can approach this a little more informed.
Good luck
Read as much as you can about the C5 clutches, so you can approach this a little more informed.
Good luck
#17
Le Mans Master
#18
I argu ed w ith them about the bill as well as their incompetence and negligence. They continued to make excuses and apologies but in the end, I had to pay $500 just to get the car back. They had installed the shifter properly and it would pop out of first gear when I was trying to drive it home. they installed my factory shifter because they said my short shifter wasn't working right. (Worn out. ... but it wasn't) hey had absolutely no idea how to even install a shifter in a c5. the clutch fluid in my reservoir was still dirty even after they supposedly replaced the clutch and the slave cylinder. I paid for the clutch part which was $500. I installed the short shifter myself, and the car no longer pops out of first gear. I have no idea if they actually replace the slave cylinder or the clutch, but it cost me $500 to get the car back. The whole fiasco was an absolute disaster! Grrrrr!
#19
Le Mans Master
I argu ed w ith them about the bill as well as their incompetence and negligence. They continued to make excuses and apologies but in the end, I had to pay $500 just to get the car back. They had installed the shifter properly and it would pop out of first gear when I was trying to drive it home. they installed my factory shifter because they said my short shifter wasn't working right. (Worn out. ... but it wasn't) hey had absolutely no idea how to even install a shifter in a c5. the clutch fluid in my reservoir was still dirty even after they supposedly replaced the clutch and the slave cylinder. I paid for the clutch part which was $500. I installed the short shifter myself, and the car no longer pops out of first gear. I have no idea if they actually replace the slave cylinder or the clutch, but it cost me $500 to get the car back. The whole fiasco was an absolute disaster! Grrrrr!
Hope your enjoying your car now
#20
Racer
You did the right thing getting you car back. Cut you losses, and chalk it up to experience. No telling how much more damage they could have caused.