[ZR1] Why no automatic for ZR1?
#21
Burning Brakes
I would imagine that there is no automatic option for the same reason there is no DOHC engine option, the majority of buyers do not want it.
An auto tranny could be built to handle the demands of the ZR1 or Z06, and with the 6 speeds and paddle shifters, it would be a fun choice.
But, it's all about status, consumer demand, and available options across the line-up. The Grand Sport with an aftermarket supercharger would be a nice choice for someone that wants an auto tranny and high horsepower machine.
I personally would be torn between an auto equipped car or a manual ZR1. I really like the 6 speeds of the auto now, and the paddle shifters would still allow for control of gear selection and be fun to boot. But, in the end, it just seems that a car like the ZR1 or Z06 should just have a manual tranny.
An auto tranny could be built to handle the demands of the ZR1 or Z06, and with the 6 speeds and paddle shifters, it would be a fun choice.
But, it's all about status, consumer demand, and available options across the line-up. The Grand Sport with an aftermarket supercharger would be a nice choice for someone that wants an auto tranny and high horsepower machine.
I personally would be torn between an auto equipped car or a manual ZR1. I really like the 6 speeds of the auto now, and the paddle shifters would still allow for control of gear selection and be fun to boot. But, in the end, it just seems that a car like the ZR1 or Z06 should just have a manual tranny.
#22
Team Owner
I'm sure they could, but my guess is that it all comes down to spending a lot of money for something with very limited demand at a time when research dollars are tight.
#23
Le Mans Master
What Mercedes has more than 638hp? Only car I can think of off the top of my head is the SL65 Black Series and you're mistaken if you think Mercedes automatics don't have issues, especially that seven-speed. The 5-speed is a bit stouter, but it's archaic and doesn't have very good shift quality and speed.
#24
Burning Brakes
If it's the F1 paddles you want, I'd be fine with that, as long as you have the foot clutch, and a sequential manual. Alonso doesn't have a torque converter and his gear box is not an automatic.
#25
Pro
Member Since: Feb 2007
Location: Flower Mound, TX
Posts: 674
Likes: 0
Received 232 Likes
on
96 Posts
Forget an automatic with a converter, why don't they invest in new transmission technology like everybody else. I know 3 pedal cars are nostalgic, but a car of the ZR1's caliber should really be offered with a modern dual clutch gear box.
#26
Tech Contributor
Member Since: Mar 1999
Location: Northern VA
Posts: 10,066
Received 3,805 Likes
on
1,145 Posts
"Ask Tadge" Producer
So knowing that they're not throwing big dollars at the development of that platform any longer, how would you fit a DCT that can handle over 600lb-ft of torque to the ZR1? Would it fit where the existing Tremec sits? What would it cost?
Now that you've got that DCT added, what's the take rate you're proposing? Do you think... 10% of the buyers would opt for it? 20%? Force it down the throat of 100% of the buyers? What are you charging for this bit of technology?
Show your work, please.
(I'm quite sure you won't be able to, but I'm giving you the benefit of the doubt).
Note I'm not discounting the wonders of a DCT. Just that they're not applicable to the existing platform unless GM can basically do it for free. Which they can't. Will we see one on the C7? Dunno.
jas
#27
Le Mans Master
I disagree with that. From what I've seen more hard-core drivers buy the ZR1 than the Z06. Again, this is purely from what I've seen with my own eyes and read here of new car purchases. I see far more Z06's on the road being granny shifted and babied than a ZR1. Those who can afford the ZR1 seem to be true car enthusiast with a passion to "drive!" Those who buy the Z06, which can be had used for $40k easily, are buying them because they have a "427" in them and they want the status of owning a big block when it's not even a big block.
Now this can't be said true in "every" purchase but in more cases than some realize this is the case. Go to a car show and see how many "track ready" Z06's are show queens with every chrome under hood piece available. Blows my mind.
#28
Melting Slicks
#29
Le Mans Master
Try this one: http://www.motorauthority.com/blog/1...buts-in-geneva
#30
Burning Brakes
And there is a CTS-v with all the bolt on's and a 300 shot of NOS running 9's with the STOCK auto in a 4200 lb car.
#31
Safety Car
Yeah, those stupid flappy paddles should be replaced with a cluch and a manual tranny on F1. For maximum racing performance, you do NOT want a manual transmission nor do you want what GM has available currently. Give me what Porsche and Ferrari have, flappy paddles and all.
Contrary to your belief, MOST people that own sports cars like to shift the gears themselves.
Would that transmission be fast? You bet your *** it would be, but it wouldnt allow for the same amount of control and "fun" factor. Atleast not in my eyes.
Its a street car, not a F1 car, not even in the same ballpark....
#32
Team Owner
Yup and lets jack up the price 20K while were at it as well..
Contrary to your belief, MOST people that own sports cars like to shift the gears themselves.
Would that transmission be fast? You bet your *** it would be, but it wouldnt allow for the same amount of control and "fun" factor. Atleast not in my eyes.
Its a street car, not a F1 car, not even in the same ballpark....
Contrary to your belief, MOST people that own sports cars like to shift the gears themselves.
Would that transmission be fast? You bet your *** it would be, but it wouldnt allow for the same amount of control and "fun" factor. Atleast not in my eyes.
Its a street car, not a F1 car, not even in the same ballpark....
I guess the people driving 458's aren't in the MOST category, as you put it, since Ferrari doesn't even offer a manual transmission in that model. I never said manual transmissions weren't fun, I said they don't perform as well. And they don't.
As JVP pointed out, it is not an issue for the C6.
By the way, have you ever driven a car with a true F1-type transmission? I was fortunate to do so a couple of years ago in a 430. I came away very impressed.
#33
Melting Slicks
It's not cost effective for them to bother. The transmission in the V won't fit in the rear end of the Corvette without... work. And that work costs money. And they won't sell enough cars to make it worth their effort.
So essentially the answer stays: they don't have an automatic that'll work with the ZR1's (or the Z06's) torque output. Trust me, they'd do it if it were cost effective.
jas
So essentially the answer stays: they don't have an automatic that'll work with the ZR1's (or the Z06's) torque output. Trust me, they'd do it if it were cost effective.
jas
#34
Burning Brakes
#35
Safety Car
Just doesnt feel like im "driving" it otherwise...
#36
Team Owner
#37
Transmissions do not hold hp, they hold lbs-ft!
And all the 65 models (not only the B.S.) have their torque limited to 1000 Nm, which translates to about 740 lbs-ft.
The new 63 models with the 5.5 Liter twin turbo also put out 700 Nm base and 800 Nm (about 590 lbs-ft) with the optional performance package.
So the ZR1 would be in good company torque-wise.
Best, Bernd
And all the 65 models (not only the B.S.) have their torque limited to 1000 Nm, which translates to about 740 lbs-ft.
The new 63 models with the 5.5 Liter twin turbo also put out 700 Nm base and 800 Nm (about 590 lbs-ft) with the optional performance package.
So the ZR1 would be in good company torque-wise.
Best, Bernd
#38
Team Owner
I don't disagree, manual transmissions are fun. Different strokes. I would think, though, that more and more performance cars will go the DCT route. It is all about $$$.
#39
Racer
Member Since: Jul 2008
Location: Bradenton Florida
Posts: 255
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Shiftless in Bowling Green
Now that ALMS has approved automatic transmissions for the GT2 class, Pratt and Miller has been doing a lot of development and already have them in their Corvette race cars. We should see them in Sebring in a couple of weeks. There is no argument that a automatic can shift faster than any human. If Pand M can make it live in the race cars, than the R and D has already been done and who knows, it may be available for the public from GM or at worst case, from Pratt and Miller.
#40
Melting Slicks
What Mercedes has more than 638hp? Only car I can think of off the top of my head is the SL65 Black Series and you're mistaken if you think Mercedes automatics don't have issues, especially that seven-speed. The 5-speed is a bit stouter, but it's archaic and doesn't have very good shift quality and speed.
The SL65 Black is the only M-B that has more hp and torque. However, the only M-B auto transmission that can handle it is the older (tech-wise) five speed transmission. Their "revolutionary" 7-speed multiclutch setup is not stout enough past the SL 63 AMG and the SLS. Furthermore, the 7-speed has been plagued by software and other issues (which M-B was very slow to acknowledge). Finally, the SL has a price point well north of $300,000 and is in very limited production. The discontinued SLR McClaren 772 Edition had about the same hp and torque numbers as the ZR1 but costs 5 times as much.
Last edited by fts; 03-04-2011 at 04:09 PM.