Electric water pump...How much Horsepower?
#21
Race Director
Member Since: Dec 2006
Location: Fort Worth, Texas
Posts: 11,117
Received 2,051 Likes
on
1,304 Posts
just installing an EWP will free up ~5hp...now take off the belts as many hardcore drag guys and loose the parasitic losses of the power steering, alternator, a/c do and you're talking more like 15...usually good for atleast a tenth, depending on your goals
#22
Racer
Member Since: Apr 2005
Location: Louisville Kentucky
Posts: 351
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
http://www.meziere.com/ps-1144-1112-wp319s.aspx
Has anyone used this, or a similar electric h20 pump? And can you verify/estimate how much hp this pump is worth? I don't want to buy this if the hp claims are not true.
Also would there be even more hp with more mods, or should the extra hp stay consistent regardless of how many mods are done?
Thanks!
Has anyone used this, or a similar electric h20 pump? And can you verify/estimate how much hp this pump is worth? I don't want to buy this if the hp claims are not true.
Also would there be even more hp with more mods, or should the extra hp stay consistent regardless of how many mods are done?
Thanks!
The gains from the pump should not be interactive with other gains.
#23
I run the Meziere on my ProCharged C6.
Meziere offered the following:
1. Expect approx. a 12 hp gain.
2. Stock LS2 water pump puts out 22 ghh @ 5500 rpm.
3. Meziere puts out 55 gph constant.
4. Meziere + 160* t'stat + Ron Davis radiator + LPE oil cooler = a setup that never allows oil temps above 220* when pushing the engine with OAT above 100*.
5. Oil temp with normal driving w/ ac and OAT above 100* = 200*.
6. Coolant temps per above runs around 10* less across the board.
7. When OAT fall below 50* you will need to swap to a higher degree t'stat, as engine will never get to proper operating temps.
8. I have approx 2 1/2 years and 20+k miles on my Meziere and it has never failed to perform for me.
Meziere offered the following:
1. Expect approx. a 12 hp gain.
2. Stock LS2 water pump puts out 22 ghh @ 5500 rpm.
3. Meziere puts out 55 gph constant.
4. Meziere + 160* t'stat + Ron Davis radiator + LPE oil cooler = a setup that never allows oil temps above 220* when pushing the engine with OAT above 100*.
5. Oil temp with normal driving w/ ac and OAT above 100* = 200*.
6. Coolant temps per above runs around 10* less across the board.
7. When OAT fall below 50* you will need to swap to a higher degree t'stat, as engine will never get to proper operating temps.
8. I have approx 2 1/2 years and 20+k miles on my Meziere and it has never failed to perform for me.
#24
Premium Supporting Vendor
The stock LS2/LS7 water pump flowed 63gpm based on Katech's testing. Brand X electric water pump flowed 18gpm, not 55gpm as advertised. Since it's electric, it's flow is a flat line where a mechanical pump is a curve that increases with RPM. I'm guessing the advertised flow numbers are from directly testing the pump itself into an open bucket. Real world scenario bolted to an engine things are very different. Electric water pumps are for drag racers. In my opinion they are not for street cars and definitely not for road race cars. I doubt they make 1 horsepower more due to the law of conservation of energy as stated before. The engine is driving the alternator that's powering the electric motor. Unless somebody invents a solar-powered electric water pump I'm skeptical of any power gains. You are also spinning an idler pulley, because the belt still goes over the electric water pump.
#25
Race Director
I could only guess what HP percentage an elecrical water pump could free up, but I can tell you how much power an oil pump "consumes."
Of course, it depends upon how viscous the oil is, but it's quite a bit.
Of course, it depends upon how viscous the oil is, but it's quite a bit.
#27
Race Director
If its time trials & I have an Hr + its no problem, however if I'm in eliminations, and win 2 or 3 rounds the amount of cars left is quite a bit less...if we start with 50 then its 25 then 13 after 3 rounds... of course the time to cool the engine down is only 15 -20 min
So with an Electric WP and an electric Fan (both can be run manually with the engine off) I can get my engine from 200 deg to 140 deg in 10 min..
Then do my burn out and I'm back to my "ideal" running temp... not only am I at my best temp, but any cars ET will change if he makes run #1 at 150 .. then Run #2 at 170... by now he had a lot of heat soak, and run 3 he will never get it under 180+ so now the driver has to figure in Engine temp, weather, track condition, etc..
But by being able to get my engine back to 150 deg. and my trans at the same, I'm eliminating some variables, & I only have to worry about the weather and track conditions..
Actually the HP is "SECOND" in priorities because I can dial (Bracket Race) my ET...so if the WP eats 12 hp its no problem because its using 12 hp an EVERY RUN nothing changes EXCEPT THE ENGINE TEMP if its hotter it will run slower (in my case anyway) So I use the electric WP more for "Consistency" I could care less if I run 12.10 or 12.30 as long as I know the variables...
Now if I were running an "Index" class i.e. 11.50 or 12.00 and have to run the # and my car is running 12.10 I can take the belt off for the run to pick up the .10 I need for that run....
Those are just my thoughts and experiences....don't know if I'm a smart thinker or a jackazz.... but its been working for me....
#28
Race Director
Member Since: Sep 2007
Location: Peoria/Phoenix AZ
Posts: 16,555
Received 2,061 Likes
on
1,505 Posts
C6 of Year Finalist (performance mods) 2019
So with an Electric WP and an electric Fan (both can be run manually with the engine off) I can get my engine from 200 deg to 140 deg in 10 min..
But by being able to get my engine back to 150 deg. and my trans at the same, I'm eliminating some variables, & I only have to worry about the weather and track conditions..
But by being able to get my engine back to 150 deg. and my trans at the same, I'm eliminating some variables, & I only have to worry about the weather and track conditions..
#29
Safety Car
Member Since: Sep 2007
Location: Los Alamitos California
Posts: 4,359
Likes: 0
Received 6 Likes
on
6 Posts
St. Jude Donor '09
The stock LS2/LS7 water pump flowed 63gpm based on Katech's testing. Brand X electric water pump flowed 18gpm, not 55gpm as advertised. Since it's electric, it's flow is a flat line where a mechanical pump is a curve that increases with RPM. I'm guessing the advertised flow numbers are from directly testing the pump itself into an open bucket. Real world scenario bolted to an engine things are very different. Electric water pumps are for drag racers. In my opinion they are not for street cars and definitely not for road race cars. I doubt they make 1 horsepower more due to the law of conservation of energy as stated before. The engine is driving the alternator that's powering the electric motor. Unless somebody invents a solar-powered electric water pump I'm skeptical of any power gains. You are also spinning an idler pulley, because the belt still goes over the electric water pump.
San
#30
The stock LS2/LS7 water pump flowed 63gpm based on Katech's testing. Brand X electric water pump flowed 18gpm, not 55gpm as advertised. Since it's electric, it's flow is a flat line where a mechanical pump is a curve that increases with RPM. I'm guessing the advertised flow numbers are from directly testing the pump itself into an open bucket. Real world scenario bolted to an engine things are very different. Electric water pumps are for drag racers. In my opinion they are not for street cars and definitely not for road race cars. I doubt they make 1 horsepower more due to the law of conservation of energy as stated before. The engine is driving the alternator that's powering the electric motor. Unless somebody invents a solar-powered electric water pump I'm skeptical of any power gains. You are also spinning an idler pulley, because the belt still goes over the electric water pump.
Interesting claims. I installed the EWP so in case I tossed a belt, I could still get the car home without the fear of overheating. Of course, I could have simply carried a spare belt and the tools to replace it.
Sure would like to see a rebuttal from someone at Meziere.
#31
Premium Supporting Vendor
Interesting claims. I installed the EWP so in case I tossed a belt, I could still get the car home without the fear of overheating. Of course, I could have simply carried a spare belt and the tools to replace it.
Sure would like to see a rebuttal from someone at Meziere.
Sure would like to see a rebuttal from someone at Meziere.
Who ever said it was Meziere?
#32
Race Director
it must be the humidity, because it works that way in n.j. Jpee is a very good bracket racer, and knows what hes doing, with an electric fan switch, and a pump the temps will go down quickly
#33
Racer
Member Since: Apr 2005
Location: Louisville Kentucky
Posts: 351
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
#34
Race Director
I haven't done it yet but because my Trans Temp has never gone over 200 and its down to 180 for the run...
However you can get a small Tranny cooler that mounts in front near your radiator... If you get a trans cooler (about $50-70) be sure to get a STACKED PLATE TYPE it cools much faster and more temp drop than the finned aluminum...
You can do the whole job in 1 hr... Another way is the get a larger transmission finned aluminum pan with a 2 qt larger capacity..
I personally prefer the cooler.. its cheaper & better !!
#36
I used to run a B&M 70264 (plate design) which worked very well at keeping my trans temps low while driving but not so well at the track. I switched over to a Perma-Cool 1024 (tube and fin design) and found the exact opposite to be true – the temps would hit 190 while driving on the freeway but at the track they wouldn’t go over 200 even while hotlapping the car.
The temps will usually spike while coming back along the return road and with the B&M they would regularly hit 230 while taking quite a while to drop back down. With the Permal-Cool I’ve been able to run several back to back passes without having to worry and as long as they stay below 230 I’m ready to go again right away.
The temps will usually spike while coming back along the return road and with the B&M they would regularly hit 230 while taking quite a while to drop back down. With the Permal-Cool I’ve been able to run several back to back passes without having to worry and as long as they stay below 230 I’m ready to go again right away.
http://forums.corvetteforum.com/c6-t...y-be-over.html
Seems the Perma-Cool 1024 would be a better option all around.
#37
Premium Supporting Vendor
#38
#39
Race Director
Actually, check out this comment:
From this thread:
http://forums.corvetteforum.com/c6-t...y-be-over.html
Seems the Perma-Cool 1024 would be a better option all around.
From this thread:
http://forums.corvetteforum.com/c6-t...y-be-over.html
Seems the Perma-Cool 1024 would be a better option all around.
#40
Racer
Member Since: Apr 2005
Location: Louisville Kentucky
Posts: 351
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Thanks. Preserving the anonymity of your testing is prudent, perhaps even graceful.
After reflecting on the posts in this thread and others on this topic which seem to present relevants facts, I was interested in the Meziere pump for my street-only Corvette. I found your posted test results counter to that interest. I have contacted Meziere about the issue. Presumably, they'll respond. If I discover anything, I'll let you know.
Keep making cool Corvette stuff!
After reflecting on the posts in this thread and others on this topic which seem to present relevants facts, I was interested in the Meziere pump for my street-only Corvette. I found your posted test results counter to that interest. I have contacted Meziere about the issue. Presumably, they'll respond. If I discover anything, I'll let you know.
Keep making cool Corvette stuff!
Last edited by VetteNo2; 09-29-2010 at 03:32 PM.