New method of changing C6 fuel pumps
#23
Pro
OP, what made you go looking that you uncovered this cluster?
I don't know if I would have opened up the car as I would have "trusted" the shop to do the job correctly.
I don't know if I would have opened up the car as I would have "trusted" the shop to do the job correctly.
#24
Safety Car
#25
Burning Brakes
I know its common among the F body guys to cut a hole in the rear trunk floor to get to the fuel pump but Id never imagine that on a vette. I couldnt even bring myself to do it on my camaro.
#26
Le Mans Master
I like the idea...but I do not know if structural rigidity is compromised...and therefore this idea is a complete failure.
So, is this technique a valid technique?
There are many posts about the difficulty of steps needed when installing new fuel pumps.
Is this repair technique a need that some proven shop can better and provide?
Last generation Pontiac Firebirds have a similar issue.
The fuel pump is onto of the tank and there seems to be a proven technique to cut the trunk floor and install an access panel.
Pontiac should have made this fuel pump repair easier from the get go.
4 hour job now a 1 hour job and very easy for a DIYer.
BUT you do have to modify the OEM design.
Ferrari 355 requires engine removal to install a timing belt. Their 360 model was updated to have an access panel behind the seats for the same job.
So for a C6 cut an access hole on top behind the seats to remove the pumps and install the transfer tube and cut an access hole on the left side wheel well to access wiring and tubes. Lastly, create a study access panel to bolt in over the cut access holes.
Again I like the idea, but do not know if the idea is a complete failure.
Interesting topic.
Yet, for the OP this repair technique was a surprise and the duct tape is a fail. I hope his invoice was heavily discounted from book time with this short cut. I'd be upset if it was my Vette.
So, is this technique a valid technique?
There are many posts about the difficulty of steps needed when installing new fuel pumps.
Is this repair technique a need that some proven shop can better and provide?
Last generation Pontiac Firebirds have a similar issue.
The fuel pump is onto of the tank and there seems to be a proven technique to cut the trunk floor and install an access panel.
Pontiac should have made this fuel pump repair easier from the get go.
4 hour job now a 1 hour job and very easy for a DIYer.
BUT you do have to modify the OEM design.
Ferrari 355 requires engine removal to install a timing belt. Their 360 model was updated to have an access panel behind the seats for the same job.
So for a C6 cut an access hole on top behind the seats to remove the pumps and install the transfer tube and cut an access hole on the left side wheel well to access wiring and tubes. Lastly, create a study access panel to bolt in over the cut access holes.
Again I like the idea, but do not know if the idea is a complete failure.
Interesting topic.
Yet, for the OP this repair technique was a surprise and the duct tape is a fail. I hope his invoice was heavily discounted from book time with this short cut. I'd be upset if it was my Vette.
#27
Team Owner
I seriously doubt it hurts it structurally, but who knows.
They didn't cut the frame. Frame is below that and not touched. They did hack into parts attached to the frame.
Even with the top hole, no idea how they would swap a pump. It only takes ~45 minutes to drop the tank in a manual car. I did it last week, it isn't bad.
They didn't cut the frame. Frame is below that and not touched. They did hack into parts attached to the frame.
Even with the top hole, no idea how they would swap a pump. It only takes ~45 minutes to drop the tank in a manual car. I did it last week, it isn't bad.
#28
Burning Brakes
Thread Starter
Some more of the story
It is true, I have had a nightmare with a Aeromotive Fuel Pump that was heating up and causing cavitation or vapor lock or whatever you call it, but it left me stranded numerous times on the side of the road. I had a shop order a new dual pump system and had them do (what is now known as) the creative engineering install. During the install, the check valve was not put on, so I went back to have it fixed. As it turned out, the shop installed a "used" AN Fitting as part of the check valve install. Later that day we smelled gas, so I made arrangements to have a smoke test done on the fuel system. Test was negative, but there was a very strong odor of fuel coming from the rear drivers side wheel well. After removing the inner wheel well liner, I was asked if I knew anything about duct tape on what I would call the bulkhead behind the wheel. Well, after inspecting this area, the gruesome discovery was made. The smell there was coming from a "used" AN Adapter installed by the owner, so I bought a new one and shelled out another $110.00 to the dealership for doing the smoke test.
Thinking about this does cause me distress, and I am unsure of how to proceed. Everyone tells me to call an attorney, so if there are any "Corvette Attorney's" out there (please nobody with non-legal advise) please PM me with some ideas.
Thinking about this does cause me distress, and I am unsure of how to proceed. Everyone tells me to call an attorney, so if there are any "Corvette Attorney's" out there (please nobody with non-legal advise) please PM me with some ideas.
#29
Team Owner
Before getting an attorney, see what the shop will do. If they are willing to fix it, or have a shop nicely weld in a plate, and grind/paint/etc then that is a better option. You only need a lawyer if they won't make you happy. Get some quotes to fix it, and then present them with them, and see if they pay. No reason to get a lawyer until they refuse to play ball.
#30
Burning Brakes
Thread Starter
Advise
Good advise, thank you.
Before getting an attorney, see what the shop will do. If they are willing to fix it, or have a shop nicely weld in a plate, and grind/paint/etc then that is a better option. You only need a lawyer if they won't make you happy. Get some quotes to fix it, and then present them with them, and see if they pay. No reason to get a lawyer until they refuse to play ball.
#31
Tolero Apto Victum
Before getting an attorney, see what the shop will do. If they are willing to fix it, or have a shop nicely weld in a plate, and grind/paint/etc then that is a better option. You only need a lawyer if they won't make you happy. Get some quotes to fix it, and then present them with them, and see if they pay. No reason to get a lawyer until they refuse to play ball.
#32
Before getting an attorney, see what the shop will do. If they are willing to fix it, or have a shop nicely weld in a plate, and grind/paint/etc then that is a better option. You only need a lawyer if they won't make you happy. Get some quotes to fix it, and then present them with them, and see if they pay. No reason to get a lawyer until they refuse to play ball.
#33
Le Mans Master
Before getting an attorney, see what the shop will do. If they are willing to fix it, or have a shop nicely weld in a plate, and grind/paint/etc then that is a better option. You only need a lawyer if they won't make you happy. Get some quotes to fix it, and then present them with them, and see if they pay. No reason to get a lawyer until they refuse to play ball.
I'd also be VERY leery about anyone welding in close proximity to the gas tank, especially with the history of fuel leakage in that area (boom!), and, given the tank is plastic, it could easily be damaged by careless welding splatter. I would think the only proper way to do it would be to drop the tank and *then* perform the frame repair.
Last edited by Kent1999; 08-26-2015 at 11:55 PM.
#34
Team Owner
Either way, get some quotes, figure out what it takes it fix, then go ask them in writing, to cut you a check for whatever that is that makes you happy. I wouldn't let them fix it either, but I would expect them to pay for it.
#35
Le Mans Master
wow what a butcher job, nothing against butchers.
I did the trap door mod on my Camaro Z28 and I did a real nice job.
If it becomes necessary to replace the fuel pump on my Corvette I might do something similar to my Camaro but nothing this Horrible. I've heard people talk about having to drop the rear to Change the pump, I will not go that route.
On another note.....If I did not authorize a shop to cut into my Corvette like what has happened here I would contact legal help because for me there is nothing that could make this car "as good as original" in my mind. Shame on them.
I did the trap door mod on my Camaro Z28 and I did a real nice job.
If it becomes necessary to replace the fuel pump on my Corvette I might do something similar to my Camaro but nothing this Horrible. I've heard people talk about having to drop the rear to Change the pump, I will not go that route.
On another note.....If I did not authorize a shop to cut into my Corvette like what has happened here I would contact legal help because for me there is nothing that could make this car "as good as original" in my mind. Shame on them.
#36
Race Director
Member Since: May 2004
Location: Raleigh, NC
Posts: 16,664
Received 1,193 Likes
on
1,052 Posts
St. Jude Donor '15
wow what a butcher job, nothing against butchers.
I did the trap door mod on my Camaro Z28 and I did a real nice job.
If it becomes necessary to replace the fuel pump on my Corvette I might do something similar to my Camaro but nothing this Horrible. I've heard people talk about having to drop the rear to Change the pump, I will not go that route.
On another note.....If I did not authorize a shop to cut into my Corvette like what has happened here I would contact legal help because for me there is nothing that could make this car "as good as original" in my mind. Shame on them.
I did the trap door mod on my Camaro Z28 and I did a real nice job.
If it becomes necessary to replace the fuel pump on my Corvette I might do something similar to my Camaro but nothing this Horrible. I've heard people talk about having to drop the rear to Change the pump, I will not go that route.
On another note.....If I did not authorize a shop to cut into my Corvette like what has happened here I would contact legal help because for me there is nothing that could make this car "as good as original" in my mind. Shame on them.
You can pull the tank out without dropping the rear cradle. It is easier with the transmission out of the way for sure.. but many have done it without dropping everything. I've pulled the passenger tank before with everything installed and the driver tank with everything removed
I would not cut into the car regardless..
#38
It seems like you'd waste more time with that hack job. Granted, removing the tank is a PITA job with tight access and a virtual guarantee of skinned knuckles, but once you've done it a few times it really doesn't take all that long.
#39
Burning Brakes
Thread Starter
Mechanics
It is funny you should say that, I heard these rocket scientists have done some real "chop jobs" on a few of those too, I think they found a time saving method of removing those tanks too.
It is really nice to know there are shops out there that after spending thousands of dollars, they do such juvenile ****** surgery on a nice Vette and don't blink an eye. After confronting the surgeon with his handy work, he made it sound so "as a matter of fact" it was scary. Some people just don't give a f__k, I see this business nose diving as the list of **** work continues thru the performance vehicle scene in this city..
It is really nice to know there are shops out there that after spending thousands of dollars, they do such juvenile ****** surgery on a nice Vette and don't blink an eye. After confronting the surgeon with his handy work, he made it sound so "as a matter of fact" it was scary. Some people just don't give a f__k, I see this business nose diving as the list of **** work continues thru the performance vehicle scene in this city..
#40
Race Director
Member Since: May 2004
Location: Raleigh, NC
Posts: 16,664
Received 1,193 Likes
on
1,052 Posts
St. Jude Donor '15
It is funny you should say that, I heard these rocket scientists have done some real "chop jobs" on a few of those too, I think they found a time saving method of removing those tanks too.
It is really nice to know there are shops out there that after spending thousands of dollars, they do such juvenile ****** surgery on a nice Vette and don't blink an eye. After confronting the surgeon with his handy work, he made it sound so "as a matter of fact" it was scary. Some people just don't give a f__k, I see this business nose diving as the list of **** work continues thru the performance vehicle scene in this city..
It is really nice to know there are shops out there that after spending thousands of dollars, they do such juvenile ****** surgery on a nice Vette and don't blink an eye. After confronting the surgeon with his handy work, he made it sound so "as a matter of fact" it was scary. Some people just don't give a f__k, I see this business nose diving as the list of **** work continues thru the performance vehicle scene in this city..