[Z06] Faulty lifter ate the camshaft
#21
Safety Car
#22
Racer
Thread Starter
Some people like them, some people don't. I can't get a straight answer now. I just want to get this fixed with reliable parts and never experience this again.
#23
Melting Slicks
Are you putting a factory cam back in? No real reason to deviate from GM lifters.
Even if you are putting a mild cam in, GM lifters are ok as well. Im running a BTR Stage 2 cam which is on the bigger side of mild and i went with GM lifters. Had I gone to a bigger cam I would have explored some of the different lifter options.
With MOST of the after market lifter options you will also need new push rods.
Even if you are putting a mild cam in, GM lifters are ok as well. Im running a BTR Stage 2 cam which is on the bigger side of mild and i went with GM lifters. Had I gone to a bigger cam I would have explored some of the different lifter options.
With MOST of the after market lifter options you will also need new push rods.
#24
Racer
Thread Starter
Are you putting a factory cam back in? No real reason to deviate from GM lifters.
Even if you are putting a mild cam in, GM lifters are ok as well. Im running a BTR Stage 2 cam which is on the bigger side of mild and i went with GM lifters. Had I gone to a bigger cam I would have explored some of the different lifter options.
With MOST of the after market lifter options you will also need new push rods.
Even if you are putting a mild cam in, GM lifters are ok as well. Im running a BTR Stage 2 cam which is on the bigger side of mild and i went with GM lifters. Had I gone to a bigger cam I would have explored some of the different lifter options.
With MOST of the after market lifter options you will also need new push rods.
#25
Team Owner
TONS of cars run those same lifters. All the camaros, vans, trucks, etc. There is a TON on the road.
The problem is you don't know if the cam failed or lifter failed. I had one fail, and put stock ls7 lifters back in. No regrets.
The problem is you don't know if the cam failed or lifter failed. I had one fail, and put stock ls7 lifters back in. No regrets.
#26
Safety Car
#27
Racer
Thread Starter
#28
Team Owner
Stock.
#29
Racer
Thread Starter
#30
Melting Slicks
out of what all LS7's having what problems?
IMO lifter and cam issues on stock motors are pretty rare.
LS lifters have had a few revisions, all relatively minor. The current lifter is used in all LS motors(LS1/2/3/7/9/A). I helped a local guy last spring replace his factory LS2 lifters and we put in the current lifters, they were slightly different(the new lifters have a full skirt around the roller axle, his factory LS2 lifters did not have the full skirt). I dont remember if the factory LS7 lifters I took out of my motor were any different than the replacements I put in this spring.
IMO lifter and cam issues on stock motors are pretty rare.
LS lifters have had a few revisions, all relatively minor. The current lifter is used in all LS motors(LS1/2/3/7/9/A). I helped a local guy last spring replace his factory LS2 lifters and we put in the current lifters, they were slightly different(the new lifters have a full skirt around the roller axle, his factory LS2 lifters did not have the full skirt). I dont remember if the factory LS7 lifters I took out of my motor were any different than the replacements I put in this spring.
Last edited by rjacobs; 12-07-2016 at 10:37 PM.
#31
I would not call the LS7 lifters horrible. They are quite frequently used as an upgrade to other other LS platforms. The "caddie" lifter is another GM option. I just prefer the larger wheel, so that means aftermarket (or Ford in some cases). Bigger the better. I also think that is more important with this engine because of the 1.8 rocker ratio. I like Morel. They've been good to me for many years. Doesn't mean they are best, just what I like to use when Jesel are simply too expensive for the build. A lot of guys speak higher of Johnson, but I have not used them, so I don't have an opinion. I will however say that there are vendors who talk smack about Morel, but they don't sell them, and can't get a dealer licence to sell them. Morel has a very small dealer network. To weed out the BS recommendations and opinions, you can always call Kip at CamMotion. He sells both Morel and Johnson, and will shoot you straight on your options, including the use of OEM lifters. Just don't get short travel lifters, whatever you do.
#32
Safety Car
They are long life parts they are also high lift and tied to an aggressive valve train being a very high horsepower engine.
They generally don't have a lot of issues or bad reputation.
Failure is not a norm, valve guides? well yes that is a problem also dynamic tied to aggressive valve train and lack of QC on GM's part. Cam and lifters not so much.
#33
Premium Supporting Vendor
Pontiac GTO.R Katech LS2, 24 Hours of Daytona 2005, 2006 - stock lifters
Pontiac GXP.R Katech LS2, 24 Hours of Daytona 2007, 2008 - stock lifters with ceramic check ball (predecessor to GM High Speed)
IMSA PC Spec Katech LS3, 24 Hours of Daytona 2011, 2012, 2013, 2014, 2015, 2016 - GM High Speed lifters
Maybe it's not the lifter. Maybe it's the valvetrain dynamics.
Pontiac GXP.R Katech LS2, 24 Hours of Daytona 2007, 2008 - stock lifters with ceramic check ball (predecessor to GM High Speed)
IMSA PC Spec Katech LS3, 24 Hours of Daytona 2011, 2012, 2013, 2014, 2015, 2016 - GM High Speed lifters
Maybe it's not the lifter. Maybe it's the valvetrain dynamics.
#34
Team Owner
Or since it was a bone stock car, just a freak accident and move on. The stock stuff is as reliable as it gets IMO. You can spend 4-8x as much, but odds of failing are not going to be less.
I think the vast majority of the time the lifter is the victim in a poor setup, and poor valve train dynamics like Jason said. My first lifter that failed I believe was from a crappy setup, because I had a hack local shop spec a cam. They picked the most aggressive race style lobes possible with no concern for it being a street car, or daily driver. That killed a lifter quickly.
I think the vast majority of the time the lifter is the victim in a poor setup, and poor valve train dynamics like Jason said. My first lifter that failed I believe was from a crappy setup, because I had a hack local shop spec a cam. They picked the most aggressive race style lobes possible with no concern for it being a street car, or daily driver. That killed a lifter quickly.
The following users liked this post:
outhouse (12-20-2016)
#40
Burning Brakes
Pontiac GTO.R Katech LS2, 24 Hours of Daytona 2005, 2006 - stock lifters
Pontiac GXP.R Katech LS2, 24 Hours of Daytona 2007, 2008 - stock lifters with ceramic check ball (predecessor to GM High Speed)
IMSA PC Spec Katech LS3, 24 Hours of Daytona 2011, 2012, 2013, 2014, 2015, 2016 - GM High Speed lifters
Maybe it's not the lifter. Maybe it's the valvetrain dynamics.
Pontiac GXP.R Katech LS2, 24 Hours of Daytona 2007, 2008 - stock lifters with ceramic check ball (predecessor to GM High Speed)
IMSA PC Spec Katech LS3, 24 Hours of Daytona 2011, 2012, 2013, 2014, 2015, 2016 - GM High Speed lifters
Maybe it's not the lifter. Maybe it's the valvetrain dynamics.