Auto vs manual Z06
#1
Auto vs manual Z06
Hey guys
I currently have a 2011 Grandsport and am looking at getting a new Z06. I recently drove a auto Zo6 and it felt very fast. I want to get a manual but have driven two and they just don't feel as fast as the auto. I realize the auto is faster due to transmission but the manual felt considerably slower Did GM tune the manuals differently. Any of you guys that have tested both notice this too?
Thanks. John
I currently have a 2011 Grandsport and am looking at getting a new Z06. I recently drove a auto Zo6 and it felt very fast. I want to get a manual but have driven two and they just don't feel as fast as the auto. I realize the auto is faster due to transmission but the manual felt considerably slower Did GM tune the manuals differently. Any of you guys that have tested both notice this too?
Thanks. John
Popular Reply
05-30-2016, 12:18 AM
Racer
There is no automatic that can replace the connection between you and a manual transmission car. I love the feeling of me and the car working together. I also have a grand sport, manual transmission, unless I was to loose an arm or leg, I'll always choose the extension of the car to me through a manual transmission.
#2
Team Owner
Hey guys
I currently have a 2011 Grandsport and am looking at getting a new Z06. I recently drove a auto Zo6 and it felt very fast. I want to get a manual but have driven two and they just don't feel as fast as the auto. I realize the auto is faster due to transmission but the manual felt considerably slower Did GM tune the manuals differently. Any of you guys that have tested both notice this too?
Thanks. John
I currently have a 2011 Grandsport and am looking at getting a new Z06. I recently drove a auto Zo6 and it felt very fast. I want to get a manual but have driven two and they just don't feel as fast as the auto. I realize the auto is faster due to transmission but the manual felt considerably slower Did GM tune the manuals differently. Any of you guys that have tested both notice this too?
Thanks. John
The M7 has a 7.96 in 1st. The A8 is going to win the 0-60.
It is a trade off the A8 quicker 0-60
vs the manual much more a driver experience.
Then you have to remember we are talking .2-.3 tenths of second.
Then once going 60 or so the 0-60 advantage goes away with the advantage back to the M7.
Go drive both decide for yourself no one can decide for you which to buy.
Both great.
#3
Racer
There is no automatic that can replace the connection between you and a manual transmission car. I love the feeling of me and the car working together. I also have a grand sport, manual transmission, unless I was to loose an arm or leg, I'll always choose the extension of the car to me through a manual transmission.
The following 10 users liked this post by Rjhctrapp:
BigBird440 (07-01-2016),
DAC17 (06-03-2016),
Fastmikefree (05-30-2016),
Hemi Dave (06-30-2016),
JJB500 (06-01-2016),
and 5 others liked this post.
The following 2 users liked this post by mowe:
3 Z06ZR1 (05-30-2016),
yellow1974 (06-06-2016)
#5
Le Mans Master
Raced a stick both of us have cai, I won all 3 runs, Two from 50 to 120ish and 1 from 40..It has alot to do with the driver behind the stick, also the auto should have "Performance Shift Active" when roll running, makes a big difference. Both great cars. Drive both the choice is up to you..
Last edited by DRLC5; 05-30-2016 at 05:17 AM.
The following users liked this post:
NoSlipN (06-15-2016)
#7
Racer
My only experience with my M7 Vs A8 on a Z07 a few weeks back at RPM Raceway, Pacific Jct, Iowa. Last turn coming onto main straight is a fairly tight right hander with speed at apex normally 40 mph or so. I was down shifting to 2nd for the turn and was tailing the Z07 going in. We both cleared the apex and came onto straight door to door and my M7 left him in the dust. Perhaps he was moving paddles manually or something, but I sure liked the way my car pulled. Not really a driver experience discrepancy since it was basically a drag race.
#8
Le Mans Master
I am certain that any difference in speed or/and acceleration would not be noticeable as it's only a few 10ths of a second. If you noticed that it felt "considerably" slower, then you're not driving it properly.
#9
Le Mans Master
Its all in the gearing. I would be wary of the A8 with all the transmission problems they have been facing. Also if you have any desire to track I think the manual would be a better choice.
#12
Tech Contributor
Member Since: Oct 1999
Location: Charlotte, NC (formerly Endicott, NY)
Posts: 40,081
Received 8,924 Likes
on
5,330 Posts
In manual mode the shifting experience is pretty much the same between the two. You are just as involved in controlling the car through the paddles as you would be through a stick coming up from the tunnel the only difference is the location of your hand and the fact you aren't pumping a clutch pedal with your left foot. Deciding what gear to be in and how much to hit the throttle is still the driver's choice which is all you do with the manual. The driver can still screw up the selection. Since the A8 has a better selection of gears it kills the manual in acceleration off from slow corners. Once the cornering speed increases into the 50s and above they are pretty much equally matched. At cornering speeds above 80 or 90 mph the only thing that matters is how big the Cajones are.
There are tracks where you can enter a series of turns at over 100 mph and exit them at over 140. While you are doing this you are pulling some high lateral Gs and need to be aware of car balance as you go from left to right and back. If a shift is required in that kind of a sequence I suspect it would be easier to do it in the A8 than the M7. The A8 wouldn't interrupt the power flow to the rear wheels as severely as pushing in the clutch, moving the shifter and releasing the clutch which can really change car balance if not done at the correct time.
Bill
There are tracks where you can enter a series of turns at over 100 mph and exit them at over 140. While you are doing this you are pulling some high lateral Gs and need to be aware of car balance as you go from left to right and back. If a shift is required in that kind of a sequence I suspect it would be easier to do it in the A8 than the M7. The A8 wouldn't interrupt the power flow to the rear wheels as severely as pushing in the clutch, moving the shifter and releasing the clutch which can really change car balance if not done at the correct time.
Bill
The following users liked this post:
george vee (06-09-2016)
#13
Safety Car
In manual mode the shifting experience is pretty much the same between the two. You are just as involved in controlling the car through the paddles as you would be through a stick coming up from the tunnel the only difference is the location of your hand and the fact you aren't pumping a clutch pedal with your left foot. Deciding what gear to be in and how much to hit the throttle is still the driver's choice which is all you do with the manual. The driver can still screw up the selection. Since the A8 has a better selection of gears it kills the manual in acceleration off from slow corners. Once the cornering speed increases into the 50s and above they are pretty much equally matched. At cornering speeds above 80 or 90 mph the only thing that matters is how big the Cajones are.
There are tracks where you can enter a series of turns at over 100 mph and exit them at over 140. While you are doing this you are pulling some high lateral Gs and need to be aware of car balance as you go from left to right and back. If a shift is required in that kind of a sequence I suspect it would be easier to do it in the A8 than the M7. The A8 wouldn't interrupt the power flow to the rear wheels as severely as pushing in the clutch, moving the shifter and releasing the clutch which can really change car balance if not done at the correct time.
Bill
There are tracks where you can enter a series of turns at over 100 mph and exit them at over 140. While you are doing this you are pulling some high lateral Gs and need to be aware of car balance as you go from left to right and back. If a shift is required in that kind of a sequence I suspect it would be easier to do it in the A8 than the M7. The A8 wouldn't interrupt the power flow to the rear wheels as severely as pushing in the clutch, moving the shifter and releasing the clutch which can really change car balance if not done at the correct time.
Bill
Might be trying to find them because of the turn of the steering wheel.
I would have liked to have all 8 gears on the floor.T way it
wouldn't bother me what position the steering wheel was at.
The following users liked this post:
conlaurant (05-30-2016)
#14
Melting Slicks
Member Since: Oct 2010
Location: Fair Oaks, California
Posts: 2,162
Received 335 Likes
on
243 Posts
2017 C7 of the Year Finalist
Here are your 8 steps in cornering.
Last edited by jaden61; 05-30-2016 at 01:34 PM.
The following users liked this post:
Hemi Dave (06-30-2016)
#15
Racer
I know you guys will say its me and maybe it is but this is how I a doing it.
floor the break,,,floor the accelerator...engine backs down to about 2k on the tack...let fly...3.6 to 3.8 according to the car.
I am in track mode with the double punch on the button. I get 0 wheel spin, none. I couldn't do a burn out if I wanted to. So what am I doing wrong!!!! rrm
#16
Safety Car
No way! I have tried everyway I can to beat 3.6 0-60 in my A8. Can't do it and it's driving me nuts. My wife has a 2014 GTMC Mazi with 445hp and I can just beat her.
I know you guys will say its me and maybe it is but this is how I a doing it.
floor the break,,,floor the accelerator...engine backs down to about 2k on the tack...let fly...3.6 to 3.8 according to the car.
I am in track mode with the double punch on the button. I get 0 wheel spin, none. I couldn't do a burn out if I wanted to. So what am I doing wrong!!!! rrm
I know you guys will say its me and maybe it is but this is how I a doing it.
floor the break,,,floor the accelerator...engine backs down to about 2k on the tack...let fly...3.6 to 3.8 according to the car.
I am in track mode with the double punch on the button. I get 0 wheel spin, none. I couldn't do a burn out if I wanted to. So what am I doing wrong!!!! rrm
Motortrend also.Don't feel bad most of us can't reach those times.
The following 3 users liked this post by docb:
#18
Burning Brakes
No way! I have tried everyway I can to beat 3.6 0-60 in my A8. Can't do it and it's driving me nuts. My wife has a 2014 GTMC Mazi with 445hp and I can just beat her.
I know you guys will say its me and maybe it is but this is how I a doing it.
floor the break,,,floor the accelerator...engine backs down to about 2k on the tack...let fly...3.6 to 3.8 according to the car.
I am in track mode with the double punch on the button. I get 0 wheel spin, none. I couldn't do a burn out if I wanted to. So what am I doing wrong!!!! rrm
I know you guys will say its me and maybe it is but this is how I a doing it.
floor the break,,,floor the accelerator...engine backs down to about 2k on the tack...let fly...3.6 to 3.8 according to the car.
I am in track mode with the double punch on the button. I get 0 wheel spin, none. I couldn't do a burn out if I wanted to. So what am I doing wrong!!!! rrm
#19
No way! I have tried everyway I can to beat 3.6 0-60 in my A8. Can't do it and it's driving me nuts. My wife has a 2014 GTMC Mazi with 445hp and I can just beat her.
I know you guys will say its me and maybe it is but this is how I a doing it.
floor the break,,,floor the accelerator...engine backs down to about 2k on the tack...let fly...3.6 to 3.8 according to the car.
I am in track mode with the double punch on the button. I get 0 wheel spin, none. I couldn't do a burn out if I wanted to. So what am I doing wrong!!!! rrm
I know you guys will say its me and maybe it is but this is how I a doing it.
floor the break,,,floor the accelerator...engine backs down to about 2k on the tack...let fly...3.6 to 3.8 according to the car.
I am in track mode with the double punch on the button. I get 0 wheel spin, none. I couldn't do a burn out if I wanted to. So what am I doing wrong!!!! rrm
#20
Banned Scam/Spammer