C4 problems
#1
Safety Car
Thread Starter
C4 problems
I'm disgusted with my 96.
Brand New Moog Inner tie rod end completely destroyed after 5 track days. There is so much slop in this new moog, I should have kept the original GM. Does anybody make decent tie rods ?????
The steering rack was apparently sliding back and forth in the bushings, so the steering wheel center line was changing after every turn. This is with new rack bushings when the inner tie rods were done. I tightened down the rack bolts, and it became better, but still noticeable. Anybody try the energy suspension rack bushings?
New AutoZone Timken bearing totally trashed after 1 track day. Once again the OE GM bearing had less play after 40 track days, but Timken can't tolerate 1 track day.
Maybe I'm just too cautious, and replace parts too soon ? I don't tolerate any play in any part what so ever. I carefully inspect the car before every event, and replace anything with even minor play. But this time my plan has backfired, and every new part is even worse off than the originals...............
Brand New Moog Inner tie rod end completely destroyed after 5 track days. There is so much slop in this new moog, I should have kept the original GM. Does anybody make decent tie rods ?????
The steering rack was apparently sliding back and forth in the bushings, so the steering wheel center line was changing after every turn. This is with new rack bushings when the inner tie rods were done. I tightened down the rack bolts, and it became better, but still noticeable. Anybody try the energy suspension rack bushings?
New AutoZone Timken bearing totally trashed after 1 track day. Once again the OE GM bearing had less play after 40 track days, but Timken can't tolerate 1 track day.
Maybe I'm just too cautious, and replace parts too soon ? I don't tolerate any play in any part what so ever. I carefully inspect the car before every event, and replace anything with even minor play. But this time my plan has backfired, and every new part is even worse off than the originals...............
#2
Melting Slicks
Its a tough call, but I dont believe in replacing parts unnecessarily. Small tolerances are acceptable. Race cars do have parts changed at certain intervals regardless, but street cars are a bit different.
My steering is still original and going strong, although I do have a urethane bushing in my steering rack. Reduced deflection for increased responsiveness is a priority for me.
I have always replaced my front bearings with CR brand. Same as GM for a considerably lower cost. I have heard and seen pictures of Timken bearings over the years and I am wary of failure rather than wear.
My steering is still original and going strong, although I do have a urethane bushing in my steering rack. Reduced deflection for increased responsiveness is a priority for me.
I have always replaced my front bearings with CR brand. Same as GM for a considerably lower cost. I have heard and seen pictures of Timken bearings over the years and I am wary of failure rather than wear.
#3
Melting Slicks
Member Since: Dec 1999
Location: Austin, TX
Posts: 2,813
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I've had good luck with Moog outer ends in the past, but never changed the inners yet.
I had a very similar thing with my rear bearings last year. Brand new Autozone rears. One track day and a couple thousand street miles. Bearing was trashed. the grease seal was baked off and no grease left at all -- just burnt powder crap. I actually put the gm bearing back on since I didn't have a spare.
I had a very similar thing with my rear bearings last year. Brand new Autozone rears. One track day and a couple thousand street miles. Bearing was trashed. the grease seal was baked off and no grease left at all -- just burnt powder crap. I actually put the gm bearing back on since I didn't have a spare.
#4
Burning Brakes
Member Since: Apr 2004
Location: Stanfield NC
Posts: 792
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I had a similar problem until I started wrapping my tie rod ends with header wrap. Keeps the grease from cooking out. I also use an industrial high temp grease. No problems since I made the changes.
I also had this problem with Timken bearings purchased at Autozone. One track day and one of the new bearing was shot. AZ replaced it without any questions and I haven't had any trouble since. I do carry a used spare in my track box just in case. Fronts are pretty easy to change out, unlike the rear.
I also had this problem with Timken bearings purchased at Autozone. One track day and one of the new bearing was shot. AZ replaced it without any questions and I haven't had any trouble since. I do carry a used spare in my track box just in case. Fronts are pretty easy to change out, unlike the rear.
#5
Burning Brakes
Member Since: Apr 2004
Location: Stanfield NC
Posts: 792
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
[QUOTE=ZR1 MK]I have always replaced my front bearings with CR brand. Same as GM for a considerably lower cost.
Where do you find CR bearing. I went to NAPA, they didn't have them and I wound up using the Timkens. It would be nice to have options. Thanks in advance for the help.
Where do you find CR bearing. I went to NAPA, they didn't have them and I wound up using the Timkens. It would be nice to have options. Thanks in advance for the help.
#6
Drifting
The good bearing supplier was new departure. It dosent matter the brand you just need to make sure that you take it out of the box and inspect it to make sure its New Departure. It could be an off the wall brand it could be a Delco bearing. I killed a Federal Mogul Bearing in about 10 runs at one auto x. The heat wrap to isolate the rod ends is good from what I hear but no personal exp. myself.
#7
Safety Car
Thread Starter
I am referring to INNER tie rods, not outer. Heat is not a problem with inners. Inners are a b!tch to change, as the rack has to come out again......
The front bearings are nothing to change, but taking the rack in & out is a full day.
The front bearings are nothing to change, but taking the rack in & out is a full day.
#9
Melting Slicks
[QUOTE=WNDOPDLR]
Pep Boys for the bearings.
Originally Posted by ZR1 MK
I have always replaced my front bearings with CR brand. Same as GM for a considerably lower cost.
Where do you find CR bearing. I went to NAPA, they didn't have them and I wound up using the Timkens. It would be nice to have options. Thanks in advance for the help.
Where do you find CR bearing. I went to NAPA, they didn't have them and I wound up using the Timkens. It would be nice to have options. Thanks in advance for the help.
#10
Le Mans Master
IIRC, there was a post in the C4 Tech section I read where the
contributor mentioned receiving instructions to drive with moderation
for a distance (100 mi?) following installation.
Is it possible that eliminating a 'burn in' step from the production
process is how the bearing mfrs were able to reduce their prices
so much down from the ACDelco figures?
Were the bearings that failed immediately run at the track at ten
tenths after installation?
.
contributor mentioned receiving instructions to drive with moderation
for a distance (100 mi?) following installation.
Is it possible that eliminating a 'burn in' step from the production
process is how the bearing mfrs were able to reduce their prices
so much down from the ACDelco figures?
Were the bearings that failed immediately run at the track at ten
tenths after installation?
.
#11
Safety Car
Thread Starter
where did you read that???? I just checked the instructions for my Timken bearing, it said nothing of importance.
But like you said, I did install the bearing, put the car on the trailer, and when directly to the track. The bearing was trash within 100 track miles.
But like you said, I did install the bearing, put the car on the trailer, and when directly to the track. The bearing was trash within 100 track miles.
#12
Tech Contributor
Originally Posted by larryfs
where did you read that???? I just checked the instructions for my Timken bearing, it said nothing of importance.
But like you said, I did install the bearing, put the car on the trailer, and when directly to the track. The bearing was trash within 100 track miles.
But like you said, I did install the bearing, put the car on the trailer, and when directly to the track. The bearing was trash within 100 track miles.
#13
Le Mans Master
Originally Posted by larryfs
where did you read that????
Here is a link to the post by Cashmo, 2006-02-12
Originally Posted by Cashmo
"I've been told any bearing should have 100 miles of street
driving to break them in before autocrossing on them."
driving to break them in before autocrossing on them."
.
#14
Le Mans Master
Of interest perhaps is the phenomenon of False Brinelling. I'd
heard about the example of the cars failing after rail transport.
In the link above, this appears at the end:
heard about the example of the cars failing after rail transport.
In the link above, this appears at the end:
"False Brinelling has also been observed in unmounted stationary
bearings exposed to vibration. The weight of the bearing pieces being
enough load to cause failure.
.
bearings exposed to vibration. The weight of the bearing pieces being
enough load to cause failure.
#15
Melting Slicks
Originally Posted by Slalom4me
IIRC, there was a post in the C4 Tech section I read where the contributor mentioned receiving instructions to drive with moderation for a distance (100 mi?) following installation.
#16
Safety Car
Thread Starter
I just yanked my 100 mile timken bearing. I can actually feel the play with the bearing in my hands.
Are you guys saying bearings need to be broken in on the street? Like a new motor needs 500 miles......
Are you guys saying bearings need to be broken in on the street? Like a new motor needs 500 miles......
#18
Tech Contributor
Member Since: Oct 1999
Location: Charlotte, NC (formerly Endicott, NY)
Posts: 40,078
Received 8,919 Likes
on
5,328 Posts
Larry,
Sounds like you had a rough weekend at the Glen. Other than the mentioned problems how did it go?
Bill
Sounds like you had a rough weekend at the Glen. Other than the mentioned problems how did it go?
Bill
#19
Safety Car
Thread Starter
The A group ecaped every single rain drop. So I wasn't swapping tires at all. And with mothers day, I had to leave early on sunday....
But I did spend a better part of 1 day working on the car, but I still ran most of my sessions. But I'm sure you remember BMW only offers 3 sessions per day, so track time is limited.....
But I did spend a better part of 1 day working on the car, but I still ran most of my sessions. But I'm sure you remember BMW only offers 3 sessions per day, so track time is limited.....