Harness bar adding chassis stiffness?
#1
Safety Car
Thread Starter
Harness bar adding chassis stiffness?
Just installed a Brey-Krause harness bar on my 2001 C5 coupe. SOTP feels like it added some stiffness to the chassis. Feels like it tied the B-pillars together. My imagination or does this thought have merit?
#2
Drifting
Member Since: Feb 2005
Location: in ur mirror, 'bout to pass.. CA
Posts: 1,770
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
SOTP is correct. The harness bar ties the car together somewhat. Body flex is reduced, and the car feels tighter in turns. I discovered that too with my B-K bar the first day on Waterford. Then I pitched it into the sand trap...! When I remove the harness bar, the car feels 'wiggly' again. (there's a racing term...'wiggly'..)
#4
Le Mans Master
#5
Team Owner
Member Since: Mar 2001
Location: Boston, Dallas, Detroit, SoCal, back to Boston MA
Posts: 30,607
Received 239 Likes
on
167 Posts
The SCCA used to make you put slip fits on them so they wouldn't stiffen the chassis.
Stupid rule, but it does tell you how much they stiffen just about any car up.
Stupid rule, but it does tell you how much they stiffen just about any car up.
#6
CF Senior Member
Member Since: Feb 2006
Location: Tucson Arizona
Posts: 23,313
Likes: 0
Received 19 Likes
on
18 Posts
I have a B-K harness bar and I feel it helps increase rigidity. The beefier tunnel plate also helps. I plan on installing a roll bar/cage in the near future primarily for safety but the additional benefit will be to tighten-up the car.
#7
Team Owner
I felt nothing adding one to my C5Z06. Maybe it's just me or maybe it's due to the Z06 already having the 'vert's brace right under where the bar goes.
#8
A harness bar may take away some nvh(noise, vibration, harshness), but I guarnatee you it does not stiffen up the chassis. Put it on a chassis jig and twist before and after. The torsional stiffness will not change. Its just along for the ride. Even a simple 4 point roll bar doesn't do anything for stiffness. Both of those items are built for installing a harness on a car without a proper cage. The roll bar adds some roll over protection. Absolutely nothing more. If anyone thinks it does they have been fooled. In order to properly stiffen a chassis a proper structure needs to connect all the critical points of the bare chassis. It has to be done with triangulation and sheer panels.
#9
Instructor
Member Since: Mar 2006
Location: Fairborn Ohio
Posts: 110
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
A harness bar may take away some nvh(noise, vibration, harshness), but I guarnatee you it does not stiffen up the chassis. Put it on a chassis jig and twist before and after. The torsional stiffness will not change. Its just along for the ride. Even a simple 4 point roll bar doesn't do anything for stiffness. Both of those items are built for installing a harness on a car without a proper cage. The roll bar adds some roll over protection. Absolutely nothing more. If anyone thinks it does they have been fooled. In order to properly stiffen a chassis a proper structure needs to connect all the critical points of the bare chassis. It has to be done with triangulation and sheer panels.
#10
And what makes it feel more rigid?
Trust me, it doesn't do anything for chassis rigidity. I'll bet real money on it. Connecting b-pillars to themselves does nothing. The imortant parts of the chassis will still flex.
Trust me, it doesn't do anything for chassis rigidity. I'll bet real money on it. Connecting b-pillars to themselves does nothing. The imortant parts of the chassis will still flex.
#11
Tech Contributor
Member Since: Jun 2004
Location: I tend to be leery of any guy who doesn't own a chainsaw or a handgun.
Posts: 18,355
Received 768 Likes
on
550 Posts
A harness bar may take away some nvh(noise, vibration, harshness), but I guarnatee you it does not stiffen up the chassis. Put it on a chassis jig and twist before and after. The torsional stiffness will not change. Its just along for the ride. Even a simple 4 point roll bar doesn't do anything for stiffness. Both of those items are built for installing a harness on a car without a proper cage. The roll bar adds some roll over protection. Absolutely nothing more. If anyone thinks it does they have been fooled. In order to properly stiffen a chassis a proper structure needs to connect all the critical points of the bare chassis. It has to be done with triangulation and sheer panels.
I spent several months modifying a C3 frame to improve the ridiculously low production torsional stiffness value, even doing some modeling (one of the test iterations pictured below), and was amazed at what it took to stiffen things up. After each change I put 2000 ft-lbs (or pounds-feet, if you prefer) of torque on the actual frame, and measured the torsional twist. It convinced me that it takes more than one bar, or even a four point cage, to significantly stiffen up any frame.
#12
Simple models are great to prove things like this. I simply think many don't understand. They often confuse NVH with rigidity. A single stiffener can make a difference if done correctly. However, it is true that an entire system needs to be designed and implemented in order to produce a positive result. A simple model to prove proper design is to take four popsicle sticks and glue them at the ends to form a box. Clamp one to a table to hold the box up then push on a top corner towards the opposite side. Do another one with an additional stick glued in the middle. Then do a third one with the additional stick glued at two opposing corners to form a diagonal. One will find that the second example really doesn't do much. The third example triangulates everything and makes a noticable difference.
Another thing to point out is that if stiffening is done it must be done all the way around to work well unless there the chassis has a weak spot. If you made one end of the car extremely rigid with something like a roll bar (it would have to be a very elaborate one) then more stress would be put on all the other components (when driven hard) and possibly break something as well as reduce handling performance. Anything is only as strong as its weakest link.
Personally, I'm just passing on information that I"ve learned over the years from building real race cars and actually racing them. I don't give all my information away for free, but if I am attacked with information that is purely subjective I might as well not help anyone.
Another thing to point out is that if stiffening is done it must be done all the way around to work well unless there the chassis has a weak spot. If you made one end of the car extremely rigid with something like a roll bar (it would have to be a very elaborate one) then more stress would be put on all the other components (when driven hard) and possibly break something as well as reduce handling performance. Anything is only as strong as its weakest link.
Personally, I'm just passing on information that I"ve learned over the years from building real race cars and actually racing them. I don't give all my information away for free, but if I am attacked with information that is purely subjective I might as well not help anyone.
#13
Safety Car
Thread Starter
Wow. I sure didn't expect the later responses. I liked the early one better since they agreed with my SOTP analysis. I don't care!!! I'll never put in a full cage in my C5 and I'll go on believing that it feels stiffer...that too
#14
Tech Contributor
Member Since: Jun 2004
Location: I tend to be leery of any guy who doesn't own a chainsaw or a handgun.
Posts: 18,355
Received 768 Likes
on
550 Posts
(The above comments are not intended to sound rude. They're just my opinions. The fact that you drive your car the way it was meant to be driven (hard and fast) puts you in a rare group of Corvette owners. I respect that.)
#15
Safety Car
Thread Starter
Whatever. Remember though, there's a reason they call them "laws of physics", rather than "suggestions of physics". But hey, it's a free country. Believe what you like. Some of us (I'm a design engineer) just prefer actual data.
(The above comments are not intended to sound rude. They're just my opinions. The fact that you drive your car the way it was meant to be driven (hard and fast) puts you in a rare group of Corvette owners. I respect that.)
(The above comments are not intended to sound rude. They're just my opinions. The fact that you drive your car the way it was meant to be driven (hard and fast) puts you in a rare group of Corvette owners. I respect that.)
#16
Instructor
Member Since: Jun 2006
Location: Siloam Springs AR
Posts: 107
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
What about tunnel plates?
What are you opinions about all of the billet tunnel plates that claim to increse rigidity? You sound like you are knowedgable about the c5 frame. What would you suggest sans the harness bars and roll cages?
#17
Race Director
Whatever. Remember though, there's a reason they call them "laws of physics", rather than "suggestions of physics". But hey, it's a free country. Believe what you like. Some of us (I'm a design engineer) just prefer actual data.
(The above comments are not intended to sound rude. They're just my opinions. The fact that you drive your car the way it was meant to be driven (hard and fast) puts you in a rare group of Corvette owners. I respect that.)
(The above comments are not intended to sound rude. They're just my opinions. The fact that you drive your car the way it was meant to be driven (hard and fast) puts you in a rare group of Corvette owners. I respect that.)
Is a single brace going between the pillars enough to give a NOTICEABLE difference? I certainly have my doubts about that, but I'm guessing that it will certainly add something.
Last edited by RedLS1GTO; 02-04-2009 at 09:54 PM.
#18
triangulation is done for a reason so that cranes don't collapse. It increases dimension without adding a ton of weight as would a solid structure.
A-pillars hold the roof up and do not connect suspension pickup points. Just so we are all clear I myself have a harness bar. The only reason is to properly mount harnesses on a street vehicle that I take to the track.
I have a tunnel plate that has been sitting on my bench for almost a year. Only reason I have it is so that when I install headers (soon) I can replace my original one with the coated one I have to reduce heat in the cockpit. I got the lightest one I could find. I could have used heat insulation, but it ended up costing more and the plate is simpler as well as cleaner to install. Kinda like wrapping headers vs. coating them. The only time can see an aftermarket tunnel plate stiffening anything more so than the factory one is with a side impact and even then the outer frame rails are really only tied to the inners at the ends (with the exception of the wood floors) so the plate wouldn't be all that effective. It most likely is a NVH thing. Venders who advertise the thicker ones as adding stiffness to the chassis are fooling the customers. Suckers are out there.
Personally, if something gives you the impression that you are benefiting from it and that makes you happy then go ahead and do it. Nothing wrong with that. I just have seen so many be completely brainwashed that something works as advertised when it really doesn't.
A-pillars hold the roof up and do not connect suspension pickup points. Just so we are all clear I myself have a harness bar. The only reason is to properly mount harnesses on a street vehicle that I take to the track.
I have a tunnel plate that has been sitting on my bench for almost a year. Only reason I have it is so that when I install headers (soon) I can replace my original one with the coated one I have to reduce heat in the cockpit. I got the lightest one I could find. I could have used heat insulation, but it ended up costing more and the plate is simpler as well as cleaner to install. Kinda like wrapping headers vs. coating them. The only time can see an aftermarket tunnel plate stiffening anything more so than the factory one is with a side impact and even then the outer frame rails are really only tied to the inners at the ends (with the exception of the wood floors) so the plate wouldn't be all that effective. It most likely is a NVH thing. Venders who advertise the thicker ones as adding stiffness to the chassis are fooling the customers. Suckers are out there.
Personally, if something gives you the impression that you are benefiting from it and that makes you happy then go ahead and do it. Nothing wrong with that. I just have seen so many be completely brainwashed that something works as advertised when it really doesn't.
#19
Race Director
Everything I've read says that it was to add needed rigidity to the structure because of the aluminum frame.
If the roof just sits on the pillars, you're saying that it can't add any stiffness.
If the roof can add stiffness to the structure by just tying the pillars together, why can't a solid bar between them do the same?
Bob
#20
Instructor
Member Since: Jun 2006
Location: Siloam Springs AR
Posts: 107
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Venders who advertise the thicker ones as adding stiffness to the chassis are fooling the customers. Suckers are out there.
Personally, if something gives you the impression that you are benefiting from it and that makes you happy then go ahead and do it. Nothing wrong with that. I just have seen so many be completely brainwashed that something works as advertised when it really doesn't.
Personally, if something gives you the impression that you are benefiting from it and that makes you happy then go ahead and do it. Nothing wrong with that. I just have seen so many be completely brainwashed that something works as advertised when it really doesn't.
I have not heard many people on here dispell the tunnel plates effectiveness and I am glad to hear a dissenting opinion. I would challenge you to post back after you install the plate with your first hand experience. I am always reading, so either way it turns out I'd like to hear the follow up.
I wonder if it is more of a game of inches. Hard to quantify all these small things but as a whole they begin to add up. Thanks again for the responses, you can never know too much.