Ruined my Differential - Options Please
#1
Burning Brakes
Thread Starter
Ruined my Differential - Options Please
I finally made it to Wakins Glen, a track I've always wanted to drive. 3rd lap of first session my differential starts whining horribly and smoke fills the cockpit. I pulled it into the pits and found oil dripping badly from left side, I think it may have been out of the vent. I drained the oil and it was full of metalic particles.
I've been running this car pretty hard with no cooler on the diff or trany. Don't know if this is the cause but I think I'm going to go ahead and put both coolers in now.
At any rate, I've done a little reaseach and would like some opinions on what to do:
- Gear Ratio - I've been using the 3.42 but now could go to 3.73. I drive Summit Point, Pocono, NJMSP the most. I wouldn't mind a little more jump out of the corners. Any thoughts on the ratio?
- New or "built" Rebuild - I can get a brand new GM 3.42 Diff for $1300-1500. Or I can get a DTE or RPM "Stage 2" for $1795 (3.42 or 3.73). What do you guys think, is it worth the extra money to get a "built" one.
- Based on some past posts I have read, I do not think I'm interested in the Quaife diff. It doesn't sound like a good option if you like to trail brake. But...If you have a Quaife I'd be interested in your thoughts.
EDIT: I have a 99FRC with approx 390 RWHP. Thus its the MN6 tranny
Thanks a bunch for any info - Brad
I've been running this car pretty hard with no cooler on the diff or trany. Don't know if this is the cause but I think I'm going to go ahead and put both coolers in now.
At any rate, I've done a little reaseach and would like some opinions on what to do:
- Gear Ratio - I've been using the 3.42 but now could go to 3.73. I drive Summit Point, Pocono, NJMSP the most. I wouldn't mind a little more jump out of the corners. Any thoughts on the ratio?
- New or "built" Rebuild - I can get a brand new GM 3.42 Diff for $1300-1500. Or I can get a DTE or RPM "Stage 2" for $1795 (3.42 or 3.73). What do you guys think, is it worth the extra money to get a "built" one.
- Based on some past posts I have read, I do not think I'm interested in the Quaife diff. It doesn't sound like a good option if you like to trail brake. But...If you have a Quaife I'd be interested in your thoughts.
EDIT: I have a 99FRC with approx 390 RWHP. Thus its the MN6 tranny
Thanks a bunch for any info - Brad
Last edited by argonaut; 08-18-2009 at 12:17 PM.
#2
Drifting
Member Since: Dec 2005
Location: Dayton, OH
Posts: 1,822
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
What do you have? Coupe or Z06?
I have a '99 coupe (stock motor) and run a 3.73 gear. Since I'm down on power compared to the z06's it does help out of the corner BUT I run out of gear everywhere! I find my self having to short shift and ending up in 5th gear in many places which with the coupe is a handicap on the long straights (over drive and low horsepower).
In a Z06 a 3.73 may not be such a bad idea as you have a higher rev limit 6500 vs. 6000 in the coupe. That 500 rpm would fix some of the shifting I have to do and with more horsepower and a lower 5th gear it may work out for the better. It may also make 1st, 2nd and 3rd to short...something to think about.
I think I have decided when I replace my rearend I'm going back to a 3.42 AND up my rev limit to 6500. I have been running slicks and I can get them in a 25" to 27" diameter range so I will go a little shorter.
This is my experience over the past 4 years of running 3.73 gears.
Also I will probably just get a blueprinted diff from Phoenix for $950.
I have a '99 coupe (stock motor) and run a 3.73 gear. Since I'm down on power compared to the z06's it does help out of the corner BUT I run out of gear everywhere! I find my self having to short shift and ending up in 5th gear in many places which with the coupe is a handicap on the long straights (over drive and low horsepower).
In a Z06 a 3.73 may not be such a bad idea as you have a higher rev limit 6500 vs. 6000 in the coupe. That 500 rpm would fix some of the shifting I have to do and with more horsepower and a lower 5th gear it may work out for the better. It may also make 1st, 2nd and 3rd to short...something to think about.
I think I have decided when I replace my rearend I'm going back to a 3.42 AND up my rev limit to 6500. I have been running slicks and I can get them in a 25" to 27" diameter range so I will go a little shorter.
This is my experience over the past 4 years of running 3.73 gears.
Also I will probably just get a blueprinted diff from Phoenix for $950.
Last edited by geerookie; 08-18-2009 at 09:59 AM.
#3
Safety Car
Member Since: Nov 2000
Location: Shenandoah Valley Virginia
Posts: 4,549
Likes: 0
Received 27 Likes
on
24 Posts
That really sucks to have the failure so early in the event. The Glen is a marvelous track. IMHO I would spend the extra $ (not that much more) and get the built RPM differential. Stay with the 3:42 gears. You can check with AlohaC5 on the forum, he also swapped back from 3:73 to the 3:43 gears for the same reasons in the first post. He had to shift into 5th too many places and it was hurting times.
#5
Melting Slicks
Member Since: Sep 2003
Location: If you don't weigh in you don't wrestle Road America
Posts: 3,031
Likes: 0
Received 73 Likes
on
54 Posts
Figure out what your minumum and maximum speeds would be for each corner of each track you drive (if you can do it) If you can't figure out the speed try to think where you were running out of rev's and had to short shift or coast.If you go to this site http://www.f-body.org/gears/ you will find out how much of a gain or drop.
All you need are the tranny ratios (MN6 1st-2.66, 2nd-1.78, 3rd-1.30, 4th-1.00, 5th-.74, 6th-.50) then put in your tire size and rev limit and compair the different axle ratios.
Hope it helps.
All you need are the tranny ratios (MN6 1st-2.66, 2nd-1.78, 3rd-1.30, 4th-1.00, 5th-.74, 6th-.50) then put in your tire size and rev limit and compair the different axle ratios.
Hope it helps.
Last edited by 96CollectorSport; 08-18-2009 at 11:06 AM.
#6
Drifting
Member Since: Dec 2005
Location: Dayton, OH
Posts: 1,822
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Figure out what your minumum and maximum speeds would be for each corner of each track you drive (if you can do it) If you can't figure out the speed try to think where you were running out of rev's and had to short shift or coast.If you go to this site http://www.f-body.org/gears/ you will find out how much of a gain or drop.
All you need are the tranny ratios (MN6 1st-2.66, 2nd-1.78, 3rd-1.30, 4th-1.00, 5th-.74, 6th-.50) then put in your tire size and rev limit and compair the different axle ratios.
Hope it helps.
All you need are the tranny ratios (MN6 1st-2.66, 2nd-1.78, 3rd-1.30, 4th-1.00, 5th-.74, 6th-.50) then put in your tire size and rev limit and compair the different axle ratios.
Hope it helps.
http://xse.com/leres/ss/calculator.html
#9
Team Owner
Member Since: Sep 2003
Location: Raleigh / Rolesville NC
Posts: 43,084
Likes: 0
Received 25 Likes
on
25 Posts
Can they do Transmissions too?
#10
Former Vendor
They don't do transmissions yet. They have been doing diffs for years. They have built all of mine and did Leighton Reese diffs when he was running World Challenge. They can even do Quaiffe diffs if you like.
Robert
#12
Collections Hold
Member Since: Aug 2002
Location: Fort Wayne Indiana
Posts: 2,899
Likes: 0
Received 5 Likes
on
5 Posts
I finally made it to Wakins Glen, a track I've always wanted to drive. 3rd lap of first session my differential starts whining horribly and smoke fills the cockpit. I pulled it into the pits and found oil dripping badly from left side, I think it may have been out of the vent. I drained the oil and it was full of metalic particles.
I've been running this car pretty hard with no cooler on the diff or trany. Don't know if this is the cause but I think I'm going to go ahead and put both coolers in now.
At any rate, I've done a little reaseach and would like some opinions on what to do:
- Gear Ratio - I've been using the 3.42 but now could go to 3.73. I drive Summit Point, Pocono, NJMSP the most. I wouldn't mind a little more jump out of the corners. Any thoughts on the ratio?
- New or "built" Rebuild - I can get a brand new GM 3.42 Diff for $1300-1500. Or I can get a DTE or RPM "Stage 2" for $1795 (3.42 or 3.73). What do you guys think, is it worth the extra money to get a "built" one.
- Based on some past posts I have read, I do not think I'm interested in the Quaife diff. It doesn't sound like a good option if you like to trail brake. But...If you have a Quaife I'd be interested in your thoughts.
EDIT: I have a 99FRC with approx 390 RWHP. Thus its the MN6 tranny
Thanks a bunch for any info - Brad
I've been running this car pretty hard with no cooler on the diff or trany. Don't know if this is the cause but I think I'm going to go ahead and put both coolers in now.
At any rate, I've done a little reaseach and would like some opinions on what to do:
- Gear Ratio - I've been using the 3.42 but now could go to 3.73. I drive Summit Point, Pocono, NJMSP the most. I wouldn't mind a little more jump out of the corners. Any thoughts on the ratio?
- New or "built" Rebuild - I can get a brand new GM 3.42 Diff for $1300-1500. Or I can get a DTE or RPM "Stage 2" for $1795 (3.42 or 3.73). What do you guys think, is it worth the extra money to get a "built" one.
- Based on some past posts I have read, I do not think I'm interested in the Quaife diff. It doesn't sound like a good option if you like to trail brake. But...If you have a Quaife I'd be interested in your thoughts.
EDIT: I have a 99FRC with approx 390 RWHP. Thus its the MN6 tranny
Thanks a bunch for any info - Brad
We've built high performance differentials that have competed and set a Corvette World Land Speed Record at the Bonneville Salt Flats in 2007 (236.66 MPH A/BGT)- not to mention making multiple 250+ MPH passes (behind 1400+ RWHP) this year there also in that same car, so we have the expertise and knowledge base to configure you a durable, low-drag, race-winning HD differential to withstand very high powered applications that operate in abusive, extreme-heat environments. In fact, a lot of what we learned building those Bonneville differentials over the years has found it's way directly into our street and road racing differentials to this very day!
Give me a call when you get a chance and we can discuss your options to configure you a HD differential that will fit your specific road racing applications.
260-407-5455
Regards,
Phil
#13
Team Owner
Member Since: Jul 2004
Location: NJ
Posts: 24,652
Received 297 Likes
on
94 Posts
St. Jude Donor '05-'08
As far as gearing with your hp I would lean towards 373 over the 342 especially with the mn6. you will find places where you will run out of gear but I think the advantage of the 373 will outweigh the extra shift that you may have. When I had 460 rwhp with my h/c 346 I thought the 373 were a nice match. It wasn't until I went with the ls7 and 560 rwhp that the 373 just ran out in far too many places way too soon.
Of course everything comes down to personal preference.