Timken vs. AC Delco
I need to buy a front hub assembly/bearing for my car. 94 coupe. Corvette Recycling has original NOS AC delco for $199.99 plus shipping of $12.00. Of course the local Autozone has Timken for $185 and with tax it is $198.00 So the prices are oh so close...So now it is a question of Timken quality vs. AC Delco quality? The car is mainly a weekend toy with some autocrossing planned one day. I do not plan on road racing the car right now. What is the take on Timken??
|
Timkens
Installed them as a precautionary, all 4 corners, in my 94 6sp, 143K, 4 months ago...no runs, drips, or errors so far. Mines a toy too, no heavy demands.
Cheers |
Originally Posted by jim_hewett
(Post 1565851136)
Installed them as a precautionary, all 4 corners, in my 94 6sp, 143K, 4 months ago...no runs, drips, or errors so far. Mines a toy too, no heavy demands.
Cheers http://forums.corvetteforum.com/show...ghlight=timken |
PM Sent
|
Timken has been around for eons, good bearings.
|
A/C Delco is not a manufacturer anymore, just a re-boxer, getting their
various parts from other manufacturers. I can't claim to know who the bearing supplier is to them, but it's either Timken or BCA. BCA is owned by Federal-Mogul, once a proud American name, now made in Mexico. :ack: |
Do your homework first.I just bought some front hub bearings for my XJR Jag and although it said Timken on the box the bearings were stamped made in South Korea.I'm afraid we will see more of this every day.I don't know where the originals were manufactured but they failed at under 30,000 which doesn't say much for them either.
|
Originally Posted by staugur
(Post 1565857098)
Do your homework first.I just bought some front hub bearings for my XJR Jag and although it said Timken on the box the bearings were stamped made in South Korea.I'm afraid we will see more of this every day.I don't know where the originals were manufactured but they failed at under 30,000 which doesn't say much for them either.
|
Originally Posted by 'Shifter
(Post 1565853395)
A/C Delco is not a manufacturer anymore, just a re-boxer, getting their
various parts from other manufacturers. I can't claim to know who the bearing supplier is to them, but it's either Timken or BCA. BCA is owned by Federal-Mogul, once a proud American name, now made in Mexico. :ack: |
Timken makes good stuff. I put them on my rear wheel bearings almost 20,000 miles ago.......no problems.
They came very highly reccommended. |
Originally Posted by staugur
(Post 1565857098)
Do your homework first.I just bought some front hub bearings for my XJR Jag and although it said Timken on the box the bearings were stamped made in South Korea.I'm afraid we will see more of this every day.I don't know where the originals were manufactured but they failed at under 30,000 which doesn't say much for them either.
Today the right front failed.. 610 miles after install. This imported offshore junk being parmed off on us is getting beyong irritating. |
The Timken bearings won't last 2 auto-x's.
The old GM bearings were good, now the GM bearings look like Timken, but reboxed. SFK seems to take a beating on the race track, and stand up to serious abuse. |
Originally Posted by RC45
(Post 1565878718)
Bingo... I just bought front and rear bearings. They only had Timken rears and we had to settle for Automotive International Caddie XLR/C5 "OEM Equivalents" for the fronts.
Today the right front failed.. 610 miles after install. This imported offshore junk being parmed off on us is getting beyong irritating. |
Years ago I had good luck with Timken. The last two sets I've had lasted less than 1 track day.
I have GM bearings on there now, and they at least survived their first weekend of track use. We'll see if they survive an upcoming event in a couple weeks. |
One plus at least, Timken does have a lifetime warranty....
|
Originally Posted by 'Shifter
(Post 1565888274)
One plus at least, Timken does have a lifetime warranty....
|
Originally Posted by 96GS#007
(Post 1565889319)
Not much of a consolation prize if you lose half of a weekend that may cost upwards of $1,000 by the time you factor in travel, hotel, etc.
I have never lost track time over a bearing. just real annoyed that they loosen up & develop play. |
Originally Posted by the blur
(Post 1565891843)
I have never lost track time over a bearing. just real annoyed that they loosen up & develop play.
|
This is my Timken experience w/ roughly 5 weekends of abuse.......
http://s33.photobucket.com/albums/d9...akeduct006.flv Unfortunately, it cost me $1000+ in lost contingency............. |
After researching bearings on this forum, I went with HP tapered rear bearings from Wheel Bearings Inc. I replaced both with around 7,000 miles on them after one failed. The HP ones cost a lot more, but should hold up better than my last ones.
My front bearings were tight when I got the car and still seem OK. 113,000 miles. Not sure if they are original or not. |
All times are GMT -4. The time now is 04:25 AM. |
© 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands