CorvetteForum - Chevrolet Corvette Forum Discussion

CorvetteForum - Chevrolet Corvette Forum Discussion (https://www.corvetteforum.com/forums/)
-   C7 General Discussion (https://www.corvetteforum.com/forums/c7-general-discussion-142/)
-   -   Giant sinkhole eatting cars at the Corvette Museum in Bowling Green! {MEGA MERGER} (https://www.corvetteforum.com/forums/c7-general-discussion/3419099-giant-sinkhole-eatting-cars-at-the-corvette-museum-in-bowling-green-mega-merger.html)

Rad22 02-14-2014 02:46 PM


Originally Posted by DALE#3 (Post 1586173413)
I will agree on your it's going to be alot of unknowns.Check this photo out:https://plus.google.com/photos/10414...64400556036641
My experience (30 yrs.+) Under that black car is the cave.Or washout or whatever.All the soil followed in that path.Notice all slopping.How deep is that void?How long?What direction?That void will have to be filled with crushed stone for the water to flow threw or it will keep collating.Got to go.Chew on this thought for a while.


NOT to be a doomsayer, seriously, but I would not be surprised at all for there to be a rumble and a puff of dust arising out of that void in the dome and for someone to go look down there and see nothing but blackness, the bottom having fallen out and the cars all washing into Mammoth Cave or some other underground locale a year or so from now.

This place (Lost River Cave) is only about 6 miles away as the crow flies...

http://lostrivercave.com/wp-content/.../boat_tour.png

...with this note on their website currently:

Heavy rainfall has impacted our ability to provide cave tours; please call 270-393-0077 to get the most up to date tour status.


Hmmmm.....

Mecholova 02-14-2014 02:53 PM


Originally Posted by Rad22 (Post 1586173571)

NOT to be a doomsayer, seriously, but I would not be surprised at all for there to be a rumble and a puff of dust arising out of that void in the dome and for someone to go look down there and see nothing but blackness with the bottom falling out and the cars all washing into Mammoth Cave or some other underground locale a year or so from now.

And in 20, 000 years when the Cylons are mining our planet for trillium, they'll be puzzled as to how those mammoths could polish those cars so well

Cruiter 02-14-2014 02:53 PM

Here is mention of an mail speaking of 'A' plan to begin tomorrow.
http://forums.corvetteforum.com/1586168945-post1.html

Originally Posted by Rad22 (Post 1586172969)
Invalid If-Then statement.

Like saying "If we sent a man to the moon, we can cure cancer." Different challenges, different risks, different technologies.

It is interesting to hear them state affirmatively that these cars will be recovered, implying a plan is in place, and yet not hear any mention of the actual plan. Surely they must have some idea how this will be done.

****EDIT: Just read where Mr. Strode said some of the skin would be removed from the dome and a crane used to retrieve the cars. Makes sense if the crane can be safely positioned on firm ground outside the dome.****


Some may not see a parallel, but in the case of a recent sinkhole in Florida which swallowed up a bedroom and the occupant of the bed, no attempts to recover the body were made ("too dangerous") and the house was bulldozed into the void. (I would only hope that the vacant lot was then converted into a proper grave.)


hifi875 02-14-2014 03:12 PM


Originally Posted by Rad22 (Post 1586173571)
NOT to be a doomsayer, seriously, but I would not be surprised at all for there to be a rumble and a puff of dust arising out of that void in the dome and for someone to go look down there and see nothing but blackness, the bottom having fallen out and the cars all washing into Mammoth Cave or some other underground locale a year or so from now.

This place (Lost River Cave) is only about 6 miles away as the crow flies...

http://lostrivercave.com/wp-content/.../boat_tour.png

...with this note on their website currently:

Heavy rainfall has impacted our ability to provide cave tours; please call 270-393-0077 to get the most up to date tour status.


Hmmmm.....

it prolly has water up to the ceiling in it right now. ive been down there and that whole area would be under water. There is a place to have parties and everything down there. its quite large.

Skid Row Joe 02-14-2014 03:23 PM


Originally Posted by DALE#3 (Post 1586173413)
I will agree on your it's going to be alot of unknowns.Check this photo out:https://plus.google.com/photos/10414...64400556036641
My experience (30 yrs.+) Under that black car is the cave.Or washout or whatever.All the soil followed in that path.Notice all slopping.How deep is that void?How long?What direction?That void will have to be filled with crushed stone for the water to flow threw or it will keep collating.Got to go.Chew on this thought for a while.


Originally Posted by Rad22 (Post 1586172614)
I have really resisted jumping into this discussion, openly acknowledging that I have no experience in the fields of engineering, architecture, geology or construction, but I do ponder this...

I would assume that whatever process caused the void beneath the dome and eroded away the earth is likely still ongoing (probably flowing water through a cave system, from what I gather) and can it be diverted or mitigated?

What steps are taken to ensure that the fill that is used to fill the void won't just be washed away over time and the problem not recur?

How is it determined...what process is used...without someone actually going down to explore the void (not me, thank you), how far it extends horizontally, possibly under other museum structures?

How are the cars going to be lifted out?

NOTE: I am NOT questioning anybody's judgement or "calling anybody out". I'm sure there are good answers to these questions. The people in charge there are not ignorant and they know the area and its geology very well. I am just being inquisitive and wish to be informed.


Originally Posted by Rad22 (Post 1586173571)
NOT to be a doomsayer, seriously, but I would not be surprised at all for there to be a rumble and a puff of dust arising out of that void in the dome and for someone to go look down there and see nothing but blackness, the bottom having fallen out and the cars all washing into Mammoth Cave or some other underground locale a year or so from now.

This place (Lost River Cave) is only about 6 miles away as the crow flies...

http://lostrivercave.com/wp-content/.../boat_tour.png

...with this note on their website currently:

Heavy rainfall has impacted our ability to provide cave tours; please call 270-393-0077 to get the most up to date tour status.


Hmmmm.....

All, agreed......

I don't blame anyone for trying to put a positive spin on the earth collapse underneath the CS, but it's abundantly clear that some of them are without any validity to the engineering unknowns going forward. The creepy black holes visible in the photo from the precipice in the spire room from the edge of the collapse are not to be underestimated.

NVR2L8 02-14-2014 04:48 PM


Originally Posted by Rad22 (Post 1586173571)
NOT to be a doomsayer, seriously, but I would not be surprised at all for there to be a rumble and a puff of dust arising out of that void in the dome and for someone to go look down there and see nothing but blackness, the bottom having fallen out and the cars all washing into Mammoth Cave or some other underground locale a year or so from now.

This place (Lost River Cave) is only about 6 miles away as the crow flies...

http://lostrivercave.com/wp-content/.../boat_tour.png

...with this note on their website currently:

Heavy rainfall has impacted our ability to provide cave tours; please call 270-393-0077 to get the most up to date tour status.


Hmmmm.....

Lost River Cave is less than a mile from my house. My daughter was a tour guide there when she was in college. It is very normal that the cave is closed after big rains. Most all of the caves in this region can be very dangerous after large rainfall, as the water in the caves rises very fast.

Lost River, which comes into the Lost River Cave, is known as the deepest underground river in the world, also known as a "blue hole". On a side note, the local legend is that the Jesse James Gang hid out at Lost River Cave after robbing a bank about 30 miles west of there (Russellville, KY).

General Motors made the announcement yesterday that they will retrieve all the cars, and restore them at their facility in Warren, MI that maintains their cars at the Heritage Center. This effort will be led by Ed Wilburn.

At this point, as mentioned by SR Joe, no one knows all the answers, and only time will tell. I am very confident, however, that brighter days are ahead for the museum. We will not allow this isolated event to define us as a victim, but rather as an opportunity to show how resilient and committed the folks at the museum (and the Corvette community) truly are.

:cheers:

DALE#3 02-14-2014 05:05 PM


Originally Posted by Skid Row Joe (Post 1586173836)
All, agreed......

I don't blame anyone for trying to put a positive spin on the earth collapse underneath the CS, but it's abundantly clear that some of them are without any validity to the engineering unknowns going forward. The creepy black holes visible in the photo from the precipice in the spire room from the edge of the collapse are not to be underestimated.

Holy BAT CAVE,BATMAN..Yup a couple loads of stone will tighten that up.Yup underestimated.Taking the roof of to hoist a couple of cars seen would be the least of their goals.It was stated here where is the crane going to be guaranteed to be safe and stable.Cars aren't heavy so crane size will be determined on reach and pick distances to dome to stable ground.Ok where is that?I witnessed and was part of the big dig in Boston.Crazy engineered h-ways floated and sunk,freezing ground to support about 10 live rail tracks so 6 lanes of road could be jacked underneath.It's all about $$$$.That new floor will have to be made into a bridge type construction for liability.The floor will have to be spanned.OK were do the piers go.All done under a canopy?It's not going to be easy.Forum is probably sick of people ranting.OK Good bye. :yesnod:

Rad22 02-14-2014 05:05 PM


Originally Posted by NVR2L8 (Post 1586174451)
I am very confident, however, that brighter days are ahead for the museum. We will not allow this isolated event to define us as a victim, but rather as an opportunity to show how resilient and committed the folks at the museum (and the Corvette community) truly are.

The only thing I fear is in a quote used by my daughter's Environmental Science professor at NC State:

"Nature always bats last."

That said, I sincerely hope everything turns out well.

I stayed with Mr. Strode and his wife at their B&B back in September when I picked up my car and visited with them in their home with my son. He is as fine a person as I have met and I know in my heart that if anyone has the background, wisdom and ability to pull together the right resources and minds to come back from this it would be him.

Good luck Wendell...my thoughts and prayers are with you.

SteveMcGuire 02-14-2014 05:18 PM

One thing for sure this is a fascinating natural phenomena and I'm really enjoying the technical commentary in this thread. This will no doubt be ongoing for some time to come. Just glad no one got hurt.

cor28vettes 02-14-2014 05:29 PM

Hey, why mess with Mother Nature. Make it a side show tourist attraction, esp given the free worldwide press this has gotten.



:rock:

Skid Row Joe 02-14-2014 05:56 PM


Originally Posted by DALE#3 (Post 1586174570)
Holy BAT CAVE,BATMAN..Yup a couple loads of stone will tighten that up.Yup underestimated.Taking the roof of to hoist a couple of cars seen would be the least of their goals.It was stated here where is the crane going to be guaranteed to be safe and stable.Cars aren't heavy so crane size will be determined on reach and pick distances to dome to stable ground.Ok where is that?I witnessed and was part of the big dig in Boston.Crazy engineered h-ways floated and sunk,freezing ground to support about 10 live rail tracks so 6 lanes of road could be jacked underneath.It's all about $$$$.That new floor will have to be made into a bridge type construction for liability.The floor will have to be spanned.OK were do the piers go.All done under a canopy?It's not going to be easy.Forum is probably sick of people ranting.OK Good bye. :yesnod:

Those of us in architecture and contracting/construction have a really good grasp on exactly what you're writing here. The known unknowns are what is any engineering and contracting companies are going to up against in even retrieving the cars that can be latched on to here. Excellent Q; where would the crane be safe in doing the retrieval? If the bridge gap is spanned by girders, where is the beginning and end points? I believe it will take a lot more engineering studies, I'm afraid. Until we learn more about the geology of this specific site, not even those simple Qs can be answered......


Don't know if they're into this type of work, but, PKS, Peter Kiewit Sons, Omaha, NE. worldwide contracting in earthmoving and mining operations sound like a company that might have a handle on what's going on/expected here - and perhaps experienced in this type of project.

prinzSD455 02-14-2014 11:24 PM


Originally Posted by DLWIGGINS (Post 1586157651)

In this video of the collapse, is the gold car that goes first into the hell pit the 1993 ZR1 "Spyder" or the 1984 PPG Pace car? I don't recognize that car and have not been to the museum.

Four of the 8 cars were C4s...ouch

DALE#3 02-15-2014 12:22 AM


Originally Posted by Skid Row Joe (Post 1586174958)
Those of us in architecture and contracting/construction have a really good grasp on exactly what you're writing here. The known unknowns are what is any engineering and contracting companies are going to up against in even retrieving the cars that can be latched on to here. Excellent Q; where would the crane be safe in doing the retrieval? If the bridge gap is spanned by girders, where is the beginning and end points? I believe it will take a lot more engineering studies, I'm afraid. Until we learn more about the geology of this specific site, not even those simple Qs can be answered......


Don't know if they're into this type of work, but, PKS, Peter Kiewit Sons, Omaha, NE. worldwide contracting in earthmoving and mining operations sound like a company that might have a handle on what's going on/expected here - and perhaps experienced in this type of project.

Appreciate the :thumbs:Doing it right will take time.Can't understand a deadline already.Could be a big challenge?Especially engineering like you said and $$$$$.My brother has been traveling with KIEWIT doing a couple cooling tower stacks.They froze the ground in Boston for that h-way.Their engineers must eat alot of fish?Very smart and capable.Another thought:It may be cheaper to move the canopy hopefully on site to a defiantly fully TESTED area.The liability these days..Especially open to the public may kill a backfill and repair.Guess it all depends on the bottom of that cave and the big deciding factor again $$$$$$$

DALE#3 02-15-2014 12:33 AM


Originally Posted by prinzSD455 (Post 1586177265)
In this video of the collapse, is the gold car that goes first into the hell pit the 1993 ZR1 "Spyder" or the 1984 PPG Pace car? I don't recognize that car and have not been to the museum.

Four of the 8 cars were C4s...ouch

I went on the off topic page on the main forum here and read alot about this thread their.To make a disaster funny?Over there the c4 corvettes should be used as backfill? Not knocking your liking of them,the entertaining factor over there is pretty comical.Check it out:
http://forums.corvetteforum.com/off-...post1586177568

Skid Row Joe 02-15-2014 12:54 AM


Originally Posted by DALE#3 (Post 1586177495)
Appreciate the :thumbs:Doing it right will take time.Can't understand a deadline already.Could be a big challenge?Especially engineering like you said and $$$$$.My brother has been traveling with KIEWIT doing a couple cooling tower stacks.They froze the ground in Boston for that h-way.Their engineers must eat alot of fish?Very smart and capable.Another thought:It may be cheaper to move the canopy hopefully on site to a defiantly fully TESTED area.The liability these days..Especially open to the public may kill a backfill and repair.Guess it all depends on the bottom of that cave and the big deciding factor again $$$$$$$

There's been quite a number of brainiacs work for Kiewit Construction over the decades. That's a high compliment! I'm glad to hear your Brother and you are aware of their expertise. They EARN their money with good people as employees. The Corvette building now have an opportunity to put together the greatest minds available in America to solve their engineering and construction design needs in BG. I am frankly alarmed that they're continuing business as usual, including public foot traffic just feet away from such a calamity. I don't understand that, when knowing the voids that already exist under there.

DALE#3 02-15-2014 01:04 AM


Originally Posted by Skid Row Joe (Post 1586177587)
There's been quite a number of brainiacs work for Kiewit Construction over the decades. That's a high compliment! I'm glad to hear your Brother and you are aware of their expertise. They EARN their money with good people as employees. The Corvette building now have an opportunity to put together the greatest minds available in America to solve their engineering and construction design needs in BG. I am frankly alarmed that they're continuing business as usual, including public foot traffic just feet away from such a calamity. I don't understand that, when knowing the voids that already exist under there.

Check out the photo in the link.After looking at photo i'm with ya.But i'm not their and i don't have a stamp.If you know what i mean.Check the bottom of that spire photo.Footing??????LEAN!!!!:
http://forums.corvetteforum.com/off-...post1586177568

prinzSD455 02-15-2014 01:10 AM


Originally Posted by DALE#3 (Post 1586177525)
I went on the off topic page on the main forum here and read alot about this thread their.To make a disaster funny?Over there the c4 corvettes should be used as backfill? Not knocking your liking of them,the entertaining factor over there is pretty comical.Check it out:
http://forums.corvetteforum.com/off-...post1586177568

I know what you mean. In off topic a C4 owner needs some very thick skin to lurk their. Still it is very entertaining.

DALE#3 02-15-2014 01:14 AM


Originally Posted by prinzSD455 (Post 1586177640)
I know what you mean. In off topic a C4 owner needs some very thick skin to lurk their. Still it is very entertaining.

Yea buddy! So you know how it is on THE OTHER SIDE :lol:

R23HTC 02-15-2014 09:06 AM


Originally Posted by prinzSD455 (Post 1586177265)
In this video of the collapse, is the gold car that goes first into the hell pit the 1993 ZR1 "Spyder" or the 1984 PPG Pace car? I don't recognize that car and have not been to the museum.

Four of the 8 cars were C4s...ouch

It's the PPG Pace Car. The 1993 ZR1 Spyder was sitting on a rack above the 1962 car I believe. From the security footage of when it first happened, it appears the PPG Pace car and the 1.5m were the 1st to go in, and are probably under the rest.

PaulB 02-15-2014 04:18 PM

In all the different websites I have watched the collapse on I have never seen anything other than when the first 2 Corvettes went down into the sinkhole. Are there any other videos from that camera or any other camera that shows the rest of the cars going down specifically the Blue Devil/ZR1. I just get the feeling that I am mising something. If I missed this somewhere my apoligies for asking.


All times are GMT -4. The time now is 11:42 AM.


© 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands