Could it be just a fluke ?
#1
Racer
Thread Starter
Could it be just a fluke ?
Last year had new trailing arms , springs , shocks etc . Also bought all new u-joints . Mechanic said only one needed to be replaced . With about 300 miles i heard a pop and when I came to a stop I could feel it grinding . Took it slow over to the shop around 5 miles . Put it up on the hoist and the new joint was broke . The cap was off one side and the other had chips in the base and the flange had a groove cut in it .We had the parts and had it back together in no time . He says he thinks maybe the clip broke allowing the cap to come off . Ever heard of that ? I have seen him do u-joints and he makes sure the clips are set at least the ones I watched .
#2
Drifting
Last year had new trailing arms , springs , shocks etc . Also bought all new u-joints . Mechanic said only one needed to be replaced . With about 300 miles i heard a pop and when I came to a stop I could feel it grinding . Took it slow over to the shop around 5 miles . Put it up on the hoist and the new joint was broke . The cap was off one side and the other had chips in the base and the flange had a groove cut in it .We had the parts and had it back together in no time . He says he thinks maybe the clip broke allowing the cap to come off . Ever heard of that ? I have seen him do u-joints and he makes sure the clips are set at least the ones I watched .
Wes
#3
Le Mans Master
Member Since: May 2003
Location: Fernandina Beach FL
Posts: 8,481
Received 3,220 Likes
on
1,732 Posts
2023 Restomod of the Year finalist
2020 C3 of the Year Winner - Modified
What Wes said
And depending where the u-joint was made- anything is possible!!!
I put the caps in the freezer for an hour or so then the frozen grease helps keep the the little needles in their place.
Richard
And depending where the u-joint was made- anything is possible!!!
I put the caps in the freezer for an hour or so then the frozen grease helps keep the the little needles in their place.
Richard
The following 2 users liked this post by Richard454:
Andy Tuttle (06-08-2016),
Go Vette Go (06-05-2016)
#5
Nam Labrat
Member Since: Sep 2013
Location: New Orleans Loo-z-anna
Posts: 33,897
Received 4,174 Likes
on
2,736 Posts
Rookie here: Also...........A driveshaft specialist told me that the cap should fit/press in tightly even when lock rings are used.......otherwise the u-joint will fail early.
#6
Race Director
I can 'say' this...I have done countless U-joints ...and if a needle falls down inside the cap....there is NO WAY with the the SPICER U-joints I use that I can get the clips to engage and lock in place WITHOUT breaking something. It just is not going to happen.
And..I personally use a thin film of grease to hold the needle bearings in place....and I do not use U-joints with grease (zerk) fittings in them.
DUB
And..I personally use a thin film of grease to hold the needle bearings in place....and I do not use U-joints with grease (zerk) fittings in them.
DUB
#7
Le Mans Master
I can 'say' this...I have done countless U-joints ...and if a needle falls down inside the cap....there is NO WAY with the the SPICER U-joints I use that I can get the clips to engage and lock in place WITHOUT breaking something. It just is not going to happen.
And..I personally use a thin film of grease to hold the needle bearings in place....and I do not use U-joints with grease (zerk) fittings in them.
DUB
And..I personally use a thin film of grease to hold the needle bearings in place....and I do not use U-joints with grease (zerk) fittings in them.
DUB
#8
Former Vendor
Member Since: Aug 2006
Location: Jeffersonville Indiana 812-288-7103
Posts: 76,656
Received 1,813 Likes
on
1,458 Posts
St. Jude Donor '08-'09-'10-'11-'12-'13-'14-'15
There is just enough room if the cap is all the way on to get the clips on . If even one needle falls down into the cap it's not going together. Sounds like that could have happened and he didn't get the clip on . That needle in the bottom of the cap would have torn things up in a hurry.
Willcox
#10
Race Director
If we take this comment at face value...then the mechanic was not paying attention to what he/she was doing.
Cleaning out the groove for the clips is a required step.
If the 'ears' were bent...then the person did not use the inner bearing flange to bolt to the U-joint flange and give it strength. This is a MUST! If it was not done...then they simply do not know about this and that can be a problem.
Not knowing which cap fell off....if they did not cage the caps of the U-joint in the side yokes of the rear end...then...they were not paying attention.
And if they 'tweaked' the U-joint areas on the half shafts....then...they were either not doing it correctly or with the correct tools.
WHO KNOWS????
DUB
Cleaning out the groove for the clips is a required step.
If the 'ears' were bent...then the person did not use the inner bearing flange to bolt to the U-joint flange and give it strength. This is a MUST! If it was not done...then they simply do not know about this and that can be a problem.
Not knowing which cap fell off....if they did not cage the caps of the U-joint in the side yokes of the rear end...then...they were not paying attention.
And if they 'tweaked' the U-joint areas on the half shafts....then...they were either not doing it correctly or with the correct tools.
WHO KNOWS????
DUB