Strange noise = cracked diff cover and broken ring gear
#1
Drifting
Thread Starter
Strange noise = cracked diff cover and broken ring gear
It was nice out this weekend, so I decided to take my C3 for a spin. Probably cruised around for an hour or so and then on my way home took a hard left a little more spirited than usual and heard a loud clunk from the rear end. I had replaced all the U-joints maybe 200-300 miles ago, so I kind of ruled that out. Pulled into the garage and let it cool down for a bit, and when I came out to check there was a small puddle of gear oil. So I get under the car and can see the cracked differential case...not good.
Dropped the differential tonight and here is what I find. Something about that ring gear just doesn't seem right.
Not the best news, but at least I made it home without being stranded. I guess I see a rebuild in my near future.
Dropped the differential tonight and here is what I find. Something about that ring gear just doesn't seem right.
Not the best news, but at least I made it home without being stranded. I guess I see a rebuild in my near future.
#2
Tech Contributor
You'll want to check the posi case for cracks as well. Use a quality RG set from Tom's and I would recommend posi tuning at a minimum. If you need a case don't use a new loaded Eaton.
#3
Drifting
Thread Starter
Thanks for the tips!
#4
Tech Contributor
Most times the cracks are effident with brake cleaner and an air line. If you look up my threads on the diff it will show you a lot on what to look for and how to build the best out there.
#5
Drifting
Thread Starter
I spent a few hours reading through your posts and found a long detailed doc about rebuilding the differential. I had an idea that it would be more than I can get done without a lot of specialized tools I doubt I'd ever use again. I can see this is something I will have to send out to have rebuilt.
#7
Drifting
Thread Starter
#8
Drifting
Member Since: Apr 2006
Location: gold coast queensland
Posts: 1,911
Likes: 0
Received 2 Likes
on
2 Posts
No idea. I guess the loud noise it made was the gear tooth breaking. Nothing extra came out of the case after I took the differential out of the car. I ran a magnet around inside the gear oil and only shavings of what used to be part of the gear were in it. Wife had to correct me and remind me it was a right turn.
#9
Tech Contributor
you can stamp the brg caps and then take it apart to take a closer look. I have walked guys through this job at home. If I can help let me know.
#10
Team Owner
There had to be something else in the diffy...or another part in the unit broke off first. Something hard got into the teeth of the ring gear and broke off that tooth. It was such a violent break, that the ring gear is fractured through! (look at the crack on the OD of the ring at the base of the next tooth. You need to check the pinion to see how bad it looks. It must have been involved when the break happened.
#11
Le Mans Master
There had to be something else in the diffy...or another part in the unit broke off first. Something hard got into the teeth of the ring gear and broke off that tooth. It was such a violent break, that the ring gear is fractured through! (look at the crack on the OD of the ring at the base of the next tooth. You need to check the pinion to see how bad it looks. It must have been involved when the break happened.
#12
Race Director
#13
Team Owner
The only possibility would be that just the tip of that tooth broke off...then it got lodged in the gears at that same tooth and broke the rest of it. And I think that is a big stretch in probabilities. The broken tooth, and cracked ring gear indicate that something got lodged in the ring/pinion teeth and cause an instantaneous fracture.
Anyone else have a possible cause for this failure mode?
Anyone else have a possible cause for this failure mode?
#14
Le Mans Master
I can't be sure, but that doesn't look like a fracture to me. It doesn't go clear through. Might be nicks or scratches. Or maybe you're seeing something I'm not.
#15
Drifting
Thread Starter
I'll probably take it apart somewhat to get a closer look inside. Definitely going to have to send this out to be rebuilt. In searching around for info about this I saw mention of Bair's. Someone on the C1 board mentioned sending one off to them for rebuild. Any thoughts on Bair's? I hadn't heard of them before.
#17
Tech Contributor
FYI,Tom is no longer building anything.
#18
Team Owner
The only possibility would be that just the tip of that tooth broke off...then it got lodged in the gears at that same tooth and broke the rest of it. And I think that is a big stretch in probabilities. The broken tooth, and cracked ring gear indicate that something got lodged in the ring/pinion teeth and cause an instantaneous fracture.
Anyone else have a possible cause for this failure mode?
Anyone else have a possible cause for this failure mode?
That silly SOB, locked up tight, and I slid all over the dry road coming to a stop, lucky the lady behind me locked em up or I would have been hit....I remember the total scoule on her face from the panel mirror.....
anyway, there was only ONE thing to cause that kind of damage.....and instant destruct....I backed it up and dropped the broken cross shaft into the bottom of the case, and limped home for some 10 miles at 0 mph.....
dropped it outta there and put in a 9.25 Posi rear, pulled the cover, and WOW what a shrapnel patch.....:yes nod:
#20
Administrator
Member Since: Jul 2000
Location: About 1100 miles from where I call home. Blue lives matter.
Posts: 51,410
Received 5,329 Likes
on
2,775 Posts