Aluminum Upper Control Arms
#1
Safety Car
Thread Starter
Aluminum Upper Control Arms
Anyone using these?.....Speed Direct aluminum A-arms.....any concerns (strengthwise)? Upgrading some things (Borgeson box), and am consider these for some weight reduction.
#2
I would ask them the material, temper, and if they are cast or forged.
I am curious, but will not compromise safety. The stamped steel ones are quite durable, and not that heavy.
I am curious, but will not compromise safety. The stamped steel ones are quite durable, and not that heavy.
The following users liked this post:
C3 Stroker (04-28-2017)
#3
The major advantage to these is not the weight savings but rather the additional caster you get from the slotted mounting holes
The following users liked this post:
C3 Stroker (04-28-2017)
#4
Drifting
Member Since: Aug 2015
Location: NSW, Australia
Posts: 1,939
Received 472 Likes
on
344 Posts
C3 of Year Finalist (track prepared) 2019
I'll be honest, that big flat area with no reinforcement against flex/bend where the ball joint is mounted scares me a bit. I guess it might be fine with the correct materials, but I don't like the look of it. Compare it with the Global West arm, that has tubing tying that area from multiple directions, or the factory arms that are pressed with deep flanges around that area. Is there bracing underneath that's not visible in the picture?
#5
I'll be honest, that big flat area with no reinforcement against flex/bend where the ball joint is mounted scares me a bit. I guess it might be fine with the correct materials, but I don't like the look of it. Compare it with the Global West arm, that has tubing tying that area from multiple directions, or the factory arms that are pressed with deep flanges around that area. Is there bracing underneath that's not visible in the picture?
A quick Google of their website says:
"Heat treated cast. Design strength safety factor of 5X - Stress / failure analysis results in 5X required load strength."
And here is a picture of the underside from the linked Super Chevy installation article
http://www.superchevy.com/how-to/vem...arms/#photo-12
Last edited by Dynra Rockets; 04-26-2017 at 08:21 PM.
The following users liked this post:
C3 Stroker (04-28-2017)
#6
I'll be honest, that big flat area with no reinforcement against flex/bend where the ball joint is mounted scares me a bit. I guess it might be fine with the correct materials, but I don't like the look of it. Compare it with the Global West arm, that has tubing tying that area from multiple directions, or the factory arms that are pressed with deep flanges around that area. Is there bracing underneath that's not visible in the picture?
I would NOT use a cast piece in that position. On that I agree.
One of our Vette group is an engineer. That piece scares the hell out of him.
#7
#8
Drifting
Member Since: Aug 2015
Location: NSW, Australia
Posts: 1,939
Received 472 Likes
on
344 Posts
C3 of Year Finalist (track prepared) 2019
I'm an engineer also, though electrical, not mechanical or structural etc. But yeah, looking at it, I don't like it. That's not to say that they might not be ok - I'm not doing any modelling or anything - but I probably wouldn't run them on my car, and I'm a big fan both of extra caster and lighter weight.
There are plenty of OEM cast alloy suspension arms - done right it shouldn't be a problem. Here's the upper control arms from an rx7, but look at the difference in design.:
There are plenty of OEM cast alloy suspension arms - done right it shouldn't be a problem. Here's the upper control arms from an rx7, but look at the difference in design.:
Last edited by Metalhead140; 04-27-2017 at 12:41 AM.
The following users liked this post:
C3 Stroker (04-28-2017)
#9
Safety Car
Thread Starter
I see what everyone's saying about the possible weakness of the cast tab area.......I'm now leaning toward VBP's arms........similar weight savings and caster adjustment, but more strongly built tubular.....
The following users liked this post:
C3 Stroker (04-28-2017)
#12
Le Mans Master
Member Since: May 2003
Location: Fernandina Beach FL
Posts: 8,476
Received 3,218 Likes
on
1,730 Posts
2023 Restomod of the Year finalist
2020 C3 of the Year Winner - Modified
I'm running and a fan of Vansteel's tubular A-arms.
They have been making for at least 12 years- haven't heard of any issues and that includes a LOT of track time.
This guy runs them- and if they could be broken- he's the guy that could do it...
and some others-
They have been making for at least 12 years- haven't heard of any issues and that includes a LOT of track time.
This guy runs them- and if they could be broken- he's the guy that could do it...
and some others-
The following 2 users liked this post by Richard454:
C3 Stroker (04-28-2017),
Illegal Vette (06-04-2017)
#13
So are they any lighter than stock? Look kinda heavy.
#16
Race Director
The following users liked this post:
C3 Stroker (04-28-2017)
#17
Race Director
#18
Drifting
Member Since: Aug 2015
Location: NSW, Australia
Posts: 1,939
Received 472 Likes
on
344 Posts
C3 of Year Finalist (track prepared) 2019
Your picture didn't work for me, but I googled to have a look. The c4 corvette upper arm looks more like the Speed Direct arm except in the very area I'm most concerned about. Around the ball joint the c4 arm maintains extra thickness and has nice tapers between the ball joint mount area and the arms. Compare that with the Speed Direct arm that has that big unbraced plate hanging out in space.
I dunno, obviously it works for some people. I feel sure it is an area of weakness, I guess it's more just a question of how likely it is to cause an issue in normal use, which I can't answer.
I dunno, obviously it works for some people. I feel sure it is an area of weakness, I guess it's more just a question of how likely it is to cause an issue in normal use, which I can't answer.
#19
Race Director
The c4 corvette upper arm looks more like the Speed Direct arm except in the very area I'm most concerned about. Around the ball joint the c4 arm maintains extra thickness and has nice tapers between the ball joint mount area and the arms. Compare that with the Speed Direct arm that has that big unbraced plate hanging out in space.
I could understand your concern for a lower control arm, but not the upper.
The following users liked this post:
C3 Stroker (04-28-2017)
#20
I have been in an old car that hit a curb going too fast around a corner. We almost flipped. (Kids then). All it did was bend an a arm. No cracks.
$25 for a new arm, and back on the road. It absorbed all the impact, and nothing else was damaged.