Hydraulic Clutch vs Auto Trans
#21
Melting Slicks
Personally, I wouldn't even consider a 700R4 unless you BOTH don't plan on using the go pedal much and will only run such poor tires you never have traction. It has certain limits that no aftermarket improvements can fully address, which means it's simply not the right transmission for your application no matter what anyone else says about being able to build one for high HP use.
There are also C4's running 9's with 700's and 4L60E's. On drag racing web sites you see a lot of people with street strip cars using them, sometimes even with trans brakes. They can be built to withstand a lot of abuse.
Mike
#22
Drifting
This is just plain wrong. I bought my Art Carr 700R4 from George (gkull). This tranny was built to handle 850 HP and was behind Georges 383 then his 427 for several years. He raced the car on the track and on the drag strip with slicks. I then put it behind my 406 600 plus HP engine in my 80 vette and was not kind to it. It has never given so much as a hickup. After so many years of abuse, it may someday give up the ghost, but I just had the pan off and the fluid was pink and no signs of anything wearing.
There are also C4's running 9's with 700's and 4L60E's. On drag racing web sites you see a lot of people with street strip cars using them, sometimes even with trans brakes. They can be built to withstand a lot of abuse.
Mike
There are also C4's running 9's with 700's and 4L60E's. On drag racing web sites you see a lot of people with street strip cars using them, sometimes even with trans brakes. They can be built to withstand a lot of abuse.
Mike
#24
Team Owner
There are other companies that know how to build these up to 850 hp units that are very bullet proof. speed costs money. I actually felt sorry for my rear end and drive line because of the rock hard shifts and I had it toned down to make 1350 u-joints last a little longer
#25
Melting Slicks
Mike
#26
Race Director
Member Since: Apr 2007
Location: South Western Ontario
Posts: 11,061
Received 845 Likes
on
721 Posts
Which is the preferred transmission for high power and reliability, TH350 or TH400? Well, the same applies to 4L60(e) vs 4L80e. It's amazing how many people want to argue otherwise despite it being a fact that the 4L80e starts life as a heavier duty transmission which makes it much easier to build for reliable >500ft-lb applications. The prices for a built 700R4 vs a built 4L80e are similar so the transmission itself it's that much difference in cost. The difference is in the controller, unless you get a manual 4L80e built.
Besides any arguments about strength, The 4L80e has BETTER gear ratios than the 4l60(e) making it nicer to drive. If you're willing to work with the shift controller, you can also make it shift pretty much exactly how you want it to. A few people have one here and have reported that it fits right into the car. I wished I remembered the one members user name because you could get his opinion.
Besides any arguments about strength, The 4L80e has BETTER gear ratios than the 4l60(e) making it nicer to drive. If you're willing to work with the shift controller, you can also make it shift pretty much exactly how you want it to. A few people have one here and have reported that it fits right into the car. I wished I remembered the one members user name because you could get his opinion.
Last edited by lionelhutz; 12-03-2017 at 03:34 PM.
#27
Le Mans Master
Another thought. Don't worry too much about dropping out of the "cam specs". The "cam specs" are written for a 454 and 496 will tame a bigger cam. Also, in OD, if you floor it, it will just drop a gear or two right back into the power band.
For example, my cam (if I remember correctly) is about 240/245 duration at .050" and right around .625" lift. With EFI, it idles at 850 rpm using 15 degrees of advance and pulls 14" of vacuum at idle. It will pull it 6200 rpm but starts to drop off above 5500 rpm (according to my tuner, that is caused by the exhaust).
Here is my chassis dyno pull when the car was tuned. T-56 Magnum in 4th gear, 3.73 12 bolt rear.
For example, my cam (if I remember correctly) is about 240/245 duration at .050" and right around .625" lift. With EFI, it idles at 850 rpm using 15 degrees of advance and pulls 14" of vacuum at idle. It will pull it 6200 rpm but starts to drop off above 5500 rpm (according to my tuner, that is caused by the exhaust).
Here is my chassis dyno pull when the car was tuned. T-56 Magnum in 4th gear, 3.73 12 bolt rear.
Last edited by SteveG75; 12-03-2017 at 04:06 PM.
#28
Melting Slicks
Which is the preferred transmission for high power and reliability, TH350 or TH400? Well, the same applies to 4L60(e) vs 4L80e. It's amazing how many people want to argue otherwise despite it being a fact that the 4L80e starts life as a heavier duty transmission which makes it much easier to build for reliable >500ft-lb applications. The prices for a built 700R4 vs a built 4L80e are similar so the transmission itself it's that much difference in cost. The difference is in the controller, unless you get a manual 4L80e built.
Besides any arguments about strength, The 4L80e has BETTER gear ratios than the 4l60(e) making it nicer to drive. If you're willing to work with the shift controller, you can also make it shift pretty much exactly how you want it to. A few people have one here and have reported that it fits right into the car. I wished I remembered the one members user name because you could get his opinion.
Besides any arguments about strength, The 4L80e has BETTER gear ratios than the 4l60(e) making it nicer to drive. If you're willing to work with the shift controller, you can also make it shift pretty much exactly how you want it to. A few people have one here and have reported that it fits right into the car. I wished I remembered the one members user name because you could get his opinion.
Mike
PS: You can get closer ratio gear sets for the 700R4/4L60E transmissions. The maker claims big improvements in quarter mile times, but from people's actual experience on race forums, they saw little or no improvement in performance.
Last edited by v2racing; 12-03-2017 at 04:02 PM.
#29
Race Director
I put the 5 speed in with .6 TKO 600 from Silver Sport - included driveshaft, overdrive and a 3:55 rear - great combo.
Approximately 2k at 80 MPH.
Good fun around town and great highway mileage.
Approximately 2k at 80 MPH.
Good fun around town and great highway mileage.
#30
Race Director
Member Since: Apr 2007
Location: South Western Ontario
Posts: 11,061
Received 845 Likes
on
721 Posts
Put your transmission behind a built 496 big block and let us know how it's working in 5 years.
I've seen 9 seconds cars running 4L60e's. 4L60e transmissions in high HP use get pulled A LOT to be "freshened up".
I've seen 9 seconds cars running 4L60e's. 4L60e transmissions in high HP use get pulled A LOT to be "freshened up".
#31
Melting Slicks
Monster builds a transmission rated at 1000 HP & TQ, others do too. Again, my 700R4 is rated for 850 HP. Most 496's do not make 850 HP, it would be fine behind one.
Mike
#32
Le Mans Master
Not sure of your age, I'll be 52 soon. I plan to stick with a manual until I no longer enjoy it.
I was commuting from Lincoln to Vacaville for several months. A manual would have been the death of me. Now that I'm in Davis the traffic is light.
So it really comes down to how often and the traffic you have to deal with.
If I was going to do an auto I'd do the 4L80E.
I was commuting from Lincoln to Vacaville for several months. A manual would have been the death of me. Now that I'm in Davis the traffic is light.
So it really comes down to how often and the traffic you have to deal with.
If I was going to do an auto I'd do the 4L80E.
#34
Melting Slicks
I know monster doesn't have the best reputation, but it was just an example. A quick google search will find several builders claiming 700's built for 1000 plus HP.
Mike
Last edited by v2racing; 12-04-2017 at 02:56 AM.
#35
Race Director
Member Since: Apr 2007
Location: South Western Ontario
Posts: 11,061
Received 845 Likes
on
721 Posts
Whatever, we'll never agree. Just looking at the current state of hard parts I still don't see enough completely new components that have been improved enough to actually expect them to be reliable behind 1000hp. Sure, anyone can build one, but having it work for a while vs having it work for a long time are 2 different things. And using one transmission as proof they don't break at higher power isn't really proving anything. You're not pushing the limits of that 850hp or else you'd be breaking rear-ends....
#36
Race Director
I'm using the American Powertrain hydraulic master cylinder setup with an OEM booster (78 'vette), no problems here.
It doesn't matter what transmission you go to, the master cylinder will mount the same.
I'm running a single disc CenterForce setup (dual friction) and doing just fine(450hp 400ci small block). I don't really notice the pedal effort - it feels "normal" to me. But most modern car clutches feel light to me.
As to the feel of a hydraulic clutch - I'm not sure I really buy into loss of feel vs a mechanical setup. If both systems are working perfectly, the feel should be the same. If not, the only extra "feel" you'd get is binding joints in a mechanical setup. That said, I'm a member of the "younger" crowd and learned how to drive on hydraulic clutches.
Also, I think your concern about RPM drop with the 4L60 is a little unfounded.
1. You're running a pretty high displacement engine.
2. The 1-2 drop will be much worse (47% on a 4L60, 43% on a 2004R)
3. You'll be flying at these speeds. I'm assuming you're running a 3.36 ratio now from your OP, but you'd be doing 143mph assuming you shifted from 3rd-4th at 6000 RPM. It just doesn't seem to me that you'd be exercising powershifts at those speeds very often. But, I don't know what you'll actually be doing with the car, of course.
If you're down in the south bay and would like to see the pedal effort in my car, you're more than welcome to, BTW.
It doesn't matter what transmission you go to, the master cylinder will mount the same.
I'm running a single disc CenterForce setup (dual friction) and doing just fine(450hp 400ci small block). I don't really notice the pedal effort - it feels "normal" to me. But most modern car clutches feel light to me.
As to the feel of a hydraulic clutch - I'm not sure I really buy into loss of feel vs a mechanical setup. If both systems are working perfectly, the feel should be the same. If not, the only extra "feel" you'd get is binding joints in a mechanical setup. That said, I'm a member of the "younger" crowd and learned how to drive on hydraulic clutches.
Also, I think your concern about RPM drop with the 4L60 is a little unfounded.
1. You're running a pretty high displacement engine.
2. The 1-2 drop will be much worse (47% on a 4L60, 43% on a 2004R)
3. You'll be flying at these speeds. I'm assuming you're running a 3.36 ratio now from your OP, but you'd be doing 143mph assuming you shifted from 3rd-4th at 6000 RPM. It just doesn't seem to me that you'd be exercising powershifts at those speeds very often. But, I don't know what you'll actually be doing with the car, of course.
If you're down in the south bay and would like to see the pedal effort in my car, you're more than welcome to, BTW.
The following users liked this post:
OldCarBum (12-05-2017)
#37
Le Mans Master
Member Since: Dec 2009
Location: Saskatoon Saskatchewan
Posts: 6,397
Received 640 Likes
on
463 Posts
Another thing to consider how light of a clutch pedal feel do you want.
To handle the torque of the motor you will need a pretty heavy single disc clutch. With Mechanical clutch or Hydraulic it will be a heavy clutch pedal. Now if you want the feel of a C6 or C7 corvette then you will need to choose a twin disc setup. I started with a single disc.
GM6-HDSS ACT unit (735 Torque), and now I have a mcleod RST Twin disc, Higher Torque rating. Day and night difference. I will not use a single disc again for my aging body.
To handle the torque of the motor you will need a pretty heavy single disc clutch. With Mechanical clutch or Hydraulic it will be a heavy clutch pedal. Now if you want the feel of a C6 or C7 corvette then you will need to choose a twin disc setup. I started with a single disc.
GM6-HDSS ACT unit (735 Torque), and now I have a mcleod RST Twin disc, Higher Torque rating. Day and night difference. I will not use a single disc again for my aging body.
The following users liked this post:
OldCarBum (12-08-2017)
#38
Melting Slicks
A 4L80E is like using a Callies USA crankshaft.
A 700R4, 4L60E & 200R4 are like using a Eagle China bull$hit crankshaft.
One you don't have to worry about, with the others you wonder when they're gonna fail, not pleasant. I use a Callies crank and 4L80e so I don't have to wonder/worry about crap breaking. I also use Oliver, Diamond, AFR, Crower, & World and flip the middle finger to that Chinese crap/slop/junk they sell.
A 700R4, 4L60E & 200R4 are like using a Eagle China bull$hit crankshaft.
One you don't have to worry about, with the others you wonder when they're gonna fail, not pleasant. I use a Callies crank and 4L80e so I don't have to wonder/worry about crap breaking. I also use Oliver, Diamond, AFR, Crower, & World and flip the middle finger to that Chinese crap/slop/junk they sell.
Last edited by jimvette999; 12-08-2017 at 04:09 PM.
The following 2 users liked this post by jimvette999:
lionelhutz (12-08-2017),
OldCarBum (12-08-2017)