over thinking rear suspension. Inner strut rod heim position
#1
Race Director
Thread Starter
over thinking rear suspension. Inner strut rod heim position
Way over thinking here. Having a choice of either fully in, or fully out, does it make a difference where the inner heim is positioned in the strut bracket slots? Thinking of a trapezoid it doesn't make sense to have both the strut rod heims outside of both half shaft pivots....if that possible at all. I finally have all the parts and will be assembling my heim strut rods tomorrow. I fabricated (use that term very loosely) square washers with off center holes. I can mount the washers to either extreme by flipping.
Red dots on top are u-joints. lower left red dot is strut rod/spindle joint. Red dots are in a fixed position. Nothing can be done. But the lower inner pivot is moveable. I know the pics not to scale, its 'representative'.
Thanks-
Jim
Red dots on top are u-joints. lower left red dot is strut rod/spindle joint. Red dots are in a fixed position. Nothing can be done. But the lower inner pivot is moveable. I know the pics not to scale, its 'representative'.
Thanks-
Jim
Last edited by jim2527; 06-12-2019 at 05:35 PM.
#2
Safety Car
Member Since: May 2004
Location: los altos hills california
Posts: 3,598
Received 1,116 Likes
on
726 Posts
What do you know about suspension geometry? Picking either A or B changes the radius of one leg of the quadrilateral that is the rear suspension. And that changes a parameter called 'camber gain'. Moving the bracket attachment point up or down, as well as changing to a different design bracket (so called 'Smart Struts' from defunct VBP) also changes that parameter.
I would suggest a good place to start with your strut rods is to match the original hole to hole dimension, with the heim joints threads at about their midpoint.
I would suggest a good place to start with your strut rods is to match the original hole to hole dimension, with the heim joints threads at about their midpoint.
Last edited by ignatz; 06-13-2019 at 12:15 PM.
#3
Team Owner
I seem to recall that the now defunct, VB&P sold their "smart struts" with an "improved" inner mount bracket. To me, it looked simply like an OE bracket turned "upside down", dropping the inner pivot point down about 3/4". This change, according to them, vastly reduced the camber change throughout the wheel travel.
One thing to remember, the C-2, C-3 IRS was designed in the late 50s, working with 6.70-15 tires....tires with about a 4", if that, tread width. In other words, camber change wasn't as critical to that narrow a tire.
One thing to remember, the C-2, C-3 IRS was designed in the late 50s, working with 6.70-15 tires....tires with about a 4", if that, tread width. In other words, camber change wasn't as critical to that narrow a tire.
#4
Race Director
Thread Starter
What do you know about suspension geometry? Picking either A or B changes the radius of one leg of the quadrilateral that is the rear suspension. And that changes a parameter called 'camber gain'. Moving the bracket attachment point up or down, as well as changing to a different design bracket (so called 'Smart Struts' from defunct VBP) also changes that parameter.
I would suggest a good place to start with your strut rods is to match the original hole to hole dimension, with the heim joints threads at about their midpoint.
I would suggest a good place to start with your strut rods is to match the original hole to hole dimension, with the heim joints threads at about their midpoint.
I seem to recall that the now defunct, VB&P sold their "smart struts" with an "improved" inner mount bracket. To me, it looked simply like an OE bracket turned "upside down", dropping the inner pivot point down about 3/4". This change, according to them, vastly reduced the camber change throughout the wheel travel.
One thing to remember, the C-2, C-3 IRS was designed in the late 50s, working with 6.70-15 tires....tires with about a 4", if that, tread width. In other words, camber change wasn't as critical to that narrow a tire.
One thing to remember, the C-2, C-3 IRS was designed in the late 50s, working with 6.70-15 tires....tires with about a 4", if that, tread width. In other words, camber change wasn't as critical to that narrow a tire.
I have good understanding how the suspension works with camber gain and toe changes etc.. All original hole dimensions are correct, I didn't relocate any. Switching over to heim ends I can have the bolt at either end of the horizontal bracket slot, about a 1" difference in strut rod length. Does it matter?
I fabricated a 1/2" aluminum spacer to drop the bracket down from the diff.....a home made 'smart strut'.
#5
Le Mans Master
Member Since: May 2003
Location: Fernandina Beach FL
Posts: 8,476
Received 3,218 Likes
on
1,730 Posts
2023 Restomod of the Year finalist
2020 C3 of the Year Winner - Modified
Danny Pops set up-
#6
Drifting
Member Since: Aug 2015
Location: NSW, Australia
Posts: 1,939
Received 472 Likes
on
344 Posts
C3 of Year Finalist (track prepared) 2019
I mounted mine at the outside extremity, just to keep my heims further engaged in the strut rods. I do not think there is a significant difference in camber gain, but keeping the strut rod longer (I.e. making the inner point at the innermost extremity) will increase camber gain very slightly. I just tack welded the rear washer in place to prevent it moving. I also removed the spacer that I had previously used between diff and strut rod bracket during my last round of modifications, and pictures show the outside wheel sitting better mid corner (upright or slightly negative instead of rolling into positive camber). It does feel twitchier mid corner, but as I made a number of changes at once I have not yet isolated what is causing what. But the car is significantly quicker than it was before the work. Possibly more static camber and retaining the spacer (that reduces camber gain) would provide a better result overall, but I was concerned that too much static neg camber would result in less traction off the line (and though less of a concern, will increase tyre wear also). It's all a compromise!
#7
Melting Slicks
Note that Danny is running VBP's Smart Strut. There is no movement of the pivot location in or out, only up and down. He has it set to the extreme down position.
#9
Le Mans Master
Member Since: May 2003
Location: Fernandina Beach FL
Posts: 8,476
Received 3,218 Likes
on
1,730 Posts
2023 Restomod of the Year finalist
2020 C3 of the Year Winner - Modified
#10
Race Director
Thread Starter