How good are the 4+3 manual trans?
#2
Melting Slicks
Member Since: Dec 2004
Location: Obama=death for America
Posts: 2,954
Likes: 0
Received 1 Like
on
1 Post
My 85 HAD the 4+3 and now a Keisler 5-speed TKO-600 resides in there. The 4+3 acts like an automatic. It will automatically downshift to another gear depending what gear you're in. It can do this 3 times, hence the name 4+3. It's a 4 speed with 3 other gears that automatically shift.
They're prone to breakage, are finicky and expensive to repair.
They're prone to breakage, are finicky and expensive to repair.
#3
Burning Brakes
Here is a link to an older thread that is very informative. I love my 4+3
http://forums.corvetteforum.com/c4-g...-using-it.html
http://forums.corvetteforum.com/c4-g...-using-it.html
#4
Tech Contributor
Member Since: Jun 2004
Location: I tend to be leery of any guy who doesn't own a chainsaw or a handgun.
Posts: 18,343
Received 767 Likes
on
549 Posts
My 85 HAD the 4+3 and now a Keisler 5-speed TKO-600 resides in there. The 4+3 acts like an automatic. It will automatically downshift to another gear depending what gear you're in. It can do this 3 times, hence the name 4+3. It's a 4 speed with 3 other gears that automatically shift.
They're prone to breakage, are finicky and expensive to repair.
They're prone to breakage, are finicky and expensive to repair.
#5
Race Director
Actually it's a 4speed trans with an overdrive on the back of it that works in the top 3 gears. It will shift in and out of overdrive manually or automatically. Most of them are "prone to breakage, are finicky, and all are expensive to repair". Kinda like the lottery, very few win, most lose.
#6
Safety Car
Member Since: Sep 2002
Location: The reason time exists is so everything doesn't happen at once
Posts: 4,971
Likes: 0
Received 7 Likes
on
6 Posts
It's a strong transmission, good enough to be installed in the Calloway Twin Turbo cars. But the overdrive unit (which is essentially an automatic) required more frequent servicing and fluid changes. Many owners neglected this and that unit is prone to failure. Hence the bad reputation.
#7
Melting Slicks
I've always been happy with mine. As of now, its configured more like a 3+2 in my 88, but is off by default.
I've modified the programming so that when OD is enabled its now very unlikely to upshift to OD in 2nd gear on drive off (unless the throttle was always below 5% in first gear prior the the shift).
It will upshift normally in 3rd gear (instead of 4th) after a 2.5 second delay, if also above 34 mph. I can drive normally 1st->2nd->3rd->3rd OD. I can always manually shift to 4th OD if desired.
For me, 3rd OD seems to be a better overall choice for normal driving below 60 mph.
The ratio drop from 3rd to 3rd OD and the 2.5 second delayed shift timing also feels pretty natural and is well suited for my current 3.73 gears.
I've experimented with just about every possible variation of the control logic, and I'm reasonably happy with the current arrangement.
I've modified the programming so that when OD is enabled its now very unlikely to upshift to OD in 2nd gear on drive off (unless the throttle was always below 5% in first gear prior the the shift).
It will upshift normally in 3rd gear (instead of 4th) after a 2.5 second delay, if also above 34 mph. I can drive normally 1st->2nd->3rd->3rd OD. I can always manually shift to 4th OD if desired.
For me, 3rd OD seems to be a better overall choice for normal driving below 60 mph.
The ratio drop from 3rd to 3rd OD and the 2.5 second delayed shift timing also feels pretty natural and is well suited for my current 3.73 gears.
I've experimented with just about every possible variation of the control logic, and I'm reasonably happy with the current arrangement.
#8
#10
Safety Car
I agree that the lack of fluid changes doomed many a OD. But another problem is the bearing in the OD that is lubed by the factory and can't be lubed again except if you take the OD out.
#11
Safety Car
Member Since: Nov 2004
Location: going faster miles an hour...with the radio on in browns mills new jersey
Posts: 4,152
Likes: 0
Received 71 Likes
on
45 Posts
I had one in an '84 that I bought new and kept for about 6 years.
Other than having it replaced under warranty after about a year, I had no problems with it.
If you're unfamiliar with its operation, it'll scare the crap out of you when it automatically engages at 115 MPH.
Other than having it replaced under warranty after about a year, I had no problems with it.
If you're unfamiliar with its operation, it'll scare the crap out of you when it automatically engages at 115 MPH.
Last edited by nassau66427; 05-15-2009 at 10:03 PM.
#12
Burning Brakes
I agree that the lack of fluid changes doomed many a OD. But another problem is the bearing in the OD that is lubed by the factory and can't be lubed again except if you take the OD out.
Combine this ball bearing (not tapered) with Doug Nash Engineering's poor assembly tolerances (some had too much lash, some had zero lash, some were preloaded ) you had a recipie for disaster.
#13
Le Mans Master
As to how good they are, I think I'd put it like this: No one swaps a 4+3 into anything.
That said, I wouldn't shy away from a car with one if I liked the car and the trans worked properly.
That said, I wouldn't shy away from a car with one if I liked the car and the trans worked properly.
#14
#15
Melting Slicks
Member Since: Feb 2006
Location: backwoods upstate ny
Posts: 2,753
Likes: 0
Received 12 Likes
on
10 Posts
4-3 is a couple inches longer than most other trans, needs fluid piping/cooler, no "std" rear mount, minimal tech savy for control scares newbs away.
have seen a few in "high end" rods.
4-3 is good, o/d clutch packs are marginal but "real" driver can avoid their short, "genius" that did ecm interplay was bad.
#17
Le Mans Master
Well aurora, i swapped one into a 57 Chevy pickup, and it's manually engaged by a switch on the shfter, and manually disengaged through a switch on the clutch pedal. I love that thing.
My ol' pickup is a hoot to drive now. I concur with tequilaboy in that 3rd overdrive is an around town cruising gear.
I installed an 87 power steering cooler in line with a spin on oil filter adapter on the cooler lines, a K&N breather filter, and the thing seems real happy in the old hauler.
What's funny, is that sometimes I get paced by people that like my truck, and I ham it up by shifting about 7 times, and at stoplights I get questions like "is that a semi trans in there?" or "Geez dude, how many gears does that thing have?" or " is that one of those new 6 speed automatics?" or my favorite "Hey dude, pick a gear and stick with it" There's more, but those are the funniest.
I can't do burnouts as well since my old 4 speed had a lower first gear. The overdrive outweights shortening my rear tire life by offering 1800 RPM @75 mph in overdrive vs the 3400 RPM @ 75 mph before. Hey, now I can hear the radio on the freeway!!!!
I just have a ZZ4 hanging on the input shaft of the trans, 3.38:1 gears, but If I had more power, it would handle it.
See my "corvette photos" ....albums..."cars" for a pic of my '57
My ol' pickup is a hoot to drive now. I concur with tequilaboy in that 3rd overdrive is an around town cruising gear.
I installed an 87 power steering cooler in line with a spin on oil filter adapter on the cooler lines, a K&N breather filter, and the thing seems real happy in the old hauler.
What's funny, is that sometimes I get paced by people that like my truck, and I ham it up by shifting about 7 times, and at stoplights I get questions like "is that a semi trans in there?" or "Geez dude, how many gears does that thing have?" or " is that one of those new 6 speed automatics?" or my favorite "Hey dude, pick a gear and stick with it" There's more, but those are the funniest.
I can't do burnouts as well since my old 4 speed had a lower first gear. The overdrive outweights shortening my rear tire life by offering 1800 RPM @75 mph in overdrive vs the 3400 RPM @ 75 mph before. Hey, now I can hear the radio on the freeway!!!!
I just have a ZZ4 hanging on the input shaft of the trans, 3.38:1 gears, but If I had more power, it would handle it.
See my "corvette photos" ....albums..."cars" for a pic of my '57
Last edited by coupeguy2001; 05-17-2009 at 10:38 PM. Reason: info
#18
Melting Slicks
Member Since: Feb 2006
Location: backwoods upstate ny
Posts: 2,753
Likes: 0
Received 12 Likes
on
10 Posts
4-3 currently in the car...present 'weapon of choice'
"under the bench":
NOS 4-3 complete trans, dated 88.
super t-10, 2.43 first (complete good trans , poss gear change for 4-3).
chevy case NPG 4 speed, o/d in high gear (426 hemi torque capable ?).
t-5 W.C. from v-8 camo(future project liteweight 4-3 replacement).
t-5 with 4.00 first gear from s-10 4-banger (too cheap to pass by).
two complete muncies and parts enuf for at least two more (old gold).
researched zf 6-speeds and rejected same due to useless "second" overdrive, 1-4 gear ratios same (for all practical) as stock 4-3 and "wide" t-10 (why bother), torque rating same or less than other choices, parts and service unavailable locally...low, low price of NOS zf's is ?????
tk-600 looks interesting, 'feedback' limited.
richmomd has poor customer support history.
t-56 next on research list, rumors of headaches at install are discouraging...another useless 'second o/d' ???
"under the bench":
NOS 4-3 complete trans, dated 88.
super t-10, 2.43 first (complete good trans , poss gear change for 4-3).
chevy case NPG 4 speed, o/d in high gear (426 hemi torque capable ?).
t-5 W.C. from v-8 camo(future project liteweight 4-3 replacement).
t-5 with 4.00 first gear from s-10 4-banger (too cheap to pass by).
two complete muncies and parts enuf for at least two more (old gold).
researched zf 6-speeds and rejected same due to useless "second" overdrive, 1-4 gear ratios same (for all practical) as stock 4-3 and "wide" t-10 (why bother), torque rating same or less than other choices, parts and service unavailable locally...low, low price of NOS zf's is ?????
tk-600 looks interesting, 'feedback' limited.
richmomd has poor customer support history.
t-56 next on research list, rumors of headaches at install are discouraging...another useless 'second o/d' ???
Last edited by redrose; 05-18-2009 at 10:18 AM.
#19
Le Mans Master
I give. The world is divided into two types of people. Those with 4+3's, and those that wish they had 4+3's.
To the OP, if you find a 4+3 car for sale, buy it. Worst case if the car is junk, you can sell the 4+3 for big bucks to someone looking to upgrade their ride. Also, I apologize to you on behalf of all 4+3 owners for previously trying to answer your question honestly.
To the OP, if you find a 4+3 car for sale, buy it. Worst case if the car is junk, you can sell the 4+3 for big bucks to someone looking to upgrade their ride. Also, I apologize to you on behalf of all 4+3 owners for previously trying to answer your question honestly.
#20