16x9.5 stock wheels
What year is the car? I thought the stock wheels were mostly 16x8.5 on 1988 and under or 17x9.5 on 1989 and up. I could be wrong though. There's a ton of sites with contradicting info.
I've posted many times on here that the Toyo Proxes RA1 is available in 255/50/16. While ostensibly a track tire, it's not a super-hard-core one, so it will hold up for some street miles. And it has legit tread at 8/32" and is good in the rain, the point that some racers use it as a rain tire (because it's honestly not a very fast dry tire these days). I would recommend it for any early C4 owner who isn't putting 15k miles on his car every year. Also, you can safely mount 245/50/16 on either 16x8.5 or 16x9.5. It's just that tire manufacturers don't recommend a 9.5" rim width for that size tire, but you can still do it.
Tyler, from 84-87, the base C4s all had 16x8.5. The first Z51s had 9.5 in back, and then from 85-87 they had 9.5 front and rear. I don't think they sold tons of Z51s in the early years because they had a reputation of having a way-too-stiff ride, so most early C4s have 8.5s.









