ECS vs. A&A
#1
Advanced
Thread Starter
Member Since: Aug 2007
Location: Houston TX
Posts: 71
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
ECS vs. A&A
And before i get all the responses of can't go wrong either way or your beating a dead horse or use the search button I understand all of these things and have searched and am still having some trouble deciding so just trying to explain my plans and see what you guys think. I've had a heads/cam ls1 before but this would be my first time dealing with FI so I just wanna do it right the first time and not be adjusting things a lot like I did with my last car.
At first I was all about A&A b/c of the options and lower initial price, but if I went with A&A I would probably want to upgrade to a diff head unit etc which makes the cost difference pretty small in the big picture. After doing some research I found out the paxton is really quiet which is what is now getting my attention b/c I want it to be as much of a sleeper as possible, and I have plans to build a motor like a ls2 402 down the road so the paxton would really be able to stretch its legs with that set up. Also I was thinking A&A with the V3 b/c i was going to try to install it myself and i've read that the install is easier, but now i've decided that I would def. screw it up so I'll just leave it to the professionals.
I guess with that said I'm leaning toward ECS right now but my im going back and forth so much its giving me a headache ha. So am I overlooking anything in this decision???
any info is appreciated.
At first I was all about A&A b/c of the options and lower initial price, but if I went with A&A I would probably want to upgrade to a diff head unit etc which makes the cost difference pretty small in the big picture. After doing some research I found out the paxton is really quiet which is what is now getting my attention b/c I want it to be as much of a sleeper as possible, and I have plans to build a motor like a ls2 402 down the road so the paxton would really be able to stretch its legs with that set up. Also I was thinking A&A with the V3 b/c i was going to try to install it myself and i've read that the install is easier, but now i've decided that I would def. screw it up so I'll just leave it to the professionals.
I guess with that said I'm leaning toward ECS right now but my im going back and forth so much its giving me a headache ha. So am I overlooking anything in this decision???
any info is appreciated.
#2
Le Mans Master
They both make great kits, with that being said I prefer the ECS head unit bracket myself. So I would pick the ECS unit but you cant lose with A&A quality and customer service. Good luck on your selection
#4
Drifting
And before i get all the responses of can't go wrong either way or your beating a dead horse or use the search button I understand all of these things and have searched and am still having some trouble deciding so just trying to explain my plans and see what you guys think. I've had a heads/cam ls1 before but this would be my first time dealing with FI so I just wanna do it right the first time and not be adjusting things a lot like I did with my last car.
At first I was all about A&A b/c of the options and lower initial price, but if I went with A&A I would probably want to upgrade to a diff head unit etc which makes the cost difference pretty small in the big picture. After doing some research I found out the paxton is really quiet which is what is now getting my attention b/c I want it to be as much of a sleeper as possible, and I have plans to build a motor like a ls2 402 down the road so the paxton would really be able to stretch its legs with that set up. Also I was thinking A&A with the V3 b/c i was going to try to install it myself and i've read that the install is easier, but now i've decided that I would def. screw it up so I'll just leave it to the professionals.
I guess with that said I'm leaning toward ECS right now but my im going back and forth so much its giving me a headache ha. So am I overlooking anything in this decision???
any info is appreciated.
At first I was all about A&A b/c of the options and lower initial price, but if I went with A&A I would probably want to upgrade to a diff head unit etc which makes the cost difference pretty small in the big picture. After doing some research I found out the paxton is really quiet which is what is now getting my attention b/c I want it to be as much of a sleeper as possible, and I have plans to build a motor like a ls2 402 down the road so the paxton would really be able to stretch its legs with that set up. Also I was thinking A&A with the V3 b/c i was going to try to install it myself and i've read that the install is easier, but now i've decided that I would def. screw it up so I'll just leave it to the professionals.
I guess with that said I'm leaning toward ECS right now but my im going back and forth so much its giving me a headache ha. So am I overlooking anything in this decision???
any info is appreciated.
What year car are you putting it on?
#6
Burning Brakes
Member Since: Nov 2006
Location: Pittsburgh PA
Posts: 892
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Prochargers aren't for everyone due to the whine, but if your looking to make some serious power then they are for you. I'm also fond of vortech units as well.
I'm waiting for response from cartek to see if they will sell their new bracket separately because that is a supercharging master piece right there.
I'm waiting for response from cartek to see if they will sell their new bracket separately because that is a supercharging master piece right there.
The following users liked this post:
streetstrip (05-16-2020)
#9
Tech Contributor
You should definitely call each vendor and discuss it with them.
Then sit down, consider your goals and make a decision.
After doing that I chose A&A and have no regrets. Andy was great to me before the sale. Even better afterwards, which is rare these days.
It all came down to product, price and comfort level with the vendor after our discussion and it was a difficult decision. ECS has a great product as well.
Then sit down, consider your goals and make a decision.
After doing that I chose A&A and have no regrets. Andy was great to me before the sale. Even better afterwards, which is rare these days.
It all came down to product, price and comfort level with the vendor after our discussion and it was a difficult decision. ECS has a great product as well.
#10
Le Mans Master
I've struggled with this decision before too. I had an A&A Prochrager P1 kit on my old '99 and I have an ECS 1500 kit on my C6. It will probably come down to you finding a good deal on one or the other. I have gotten good/excellent service from both vendors.
Vortech = Paxton. While there are more options with Vortech they are very much the same. I will say that my Paxton is very quiet. Like sleeper quiet. If quiet is what you want you definitely do not want a Procharger. Since Paxton~=Vortech could start with an ECS 1500 or 2200 kit and if you need more air change the head unit out for a Ysi and it will bolt right up. Or you could get an A&A S or T trim and upgrade to a Ysi later. I would recommend a self contained unit rather than engine oil fed but that is my personal preference.
Vortech = Paxton. While there are more options with Vortech they are very much the same. I will say that my Paxton is very quiet. Like sleeper quiet. If quiet is what you want you definitely do not want a Procharger. Since Paxton~=Vortech could start with an ECS 1500 or 2200 kit and if you need more air change the head unit out for a Ysi and it will bolt right up. Or you could get an A&A S or T trim and upgrade to a Ysi later. I would recommend a self contained unit rather than engine oil fed but that is my personal preference.
#11
I've struggled with this decision before too. I had an A&A Prochrager P1 kit on my old '99 and I have an ECS 1500 kit on my C6. It will probably come down to you finding a good deal on one or the other. I have gotten good/excellent service from both vendors.
Vortech = Paxton. While there are more options with Vortech they are very much the same. I will say that my Paxton is very quiet. Like sleeper quiet. If quiet is what you want you definitely do not want a Procharger. Since Paxton~=Vortech could start with an ECS 1500 or 2200 kit and if you need more air change the head unit out for a Ysi and it will bolt right up. Or you could get an A&A S or T trim and upgrade to a Ysi later. I would recommend a self contained unit rather than engine oil fed but that is my personal preference.
Vortech = Paxton. While there are more options with Vortech they are very much the same. I will say that my Paxton is very quiet. Like sleeper quiet. If quiet is what you want you definitely do not want a Procharger. Since Paxton~=Vortech could start with an ECS 1500 or 2200 kit and if you need more air change the head unit out for a Ysi and it will bolt right up. Or you could get an A&A S or T trim and upgrade to a Ysi later. I would recommend a self contained unit rather than engine oil fed but that is my personal preference.
#13
Melting Slicks
Both are great companies, I have bought stuff from both but got my blower from ECS. they have been great to work with. My Novi 2K is very quiet and makes tons of power.
One thing for you to remember. If you are having a shop do the install, I would talk with the shop and get their opinions. They may have more experience with one versus the other. Plus you do need to find a good shop to do your tuning. This is key.
Either way, you will find tons of people on here who have had success with both companies. So it is hard to go wrong with something that is proven and been around. Personally I stay away from the latest thing on the market, because there are always bugs that have to be worked out.
One thing for you to remember. If you are having a shop do the install, I would talk with the shop and get their opinions. They may have more experience with one versus the other. Plus you do need to find a good shop to do your tuning. This is key.
Either way, you will find tons of people on here who have had success with both companies. So it is hard to go wrong with something that is proven and been around. Personally I stay away from the latest thing on the market, because there are always bugs that have to be worked out.
The following users liked this post:
Bobole04 (04-12-2016)
#15
Melting Slicks
Member Since: Jan 2008
Location: Nathalie VA
Posts: 2,590
Likes: 0
Received 47 Likes
on
45 Posts
St. Jude Donor '15-'16-'17-'18
I picked up an A&A v3-SI 2 months ago, and thought it was very easy to install. Mike Yeager @ East Coast Performance gave me a great price on the kit with gauges and trans brace. Both Mike and the guys at A&A have always taken the time to answer any questions I've had.
#17
Former Vendor
Member Since: Apr 1999
Location: ECS Sales & Service Advisor
Posts: 7,607
Likes: 0
Received 1 Like
on
1 Post
Cruise-In III Veteran
Cruise-In V Veteran
Ours is $5995 (actually $5745 with the carlisle sale pricing) comes with a bigger head unit, steel idlers, 4 in ducting, new injectors, and a HD tensioner. And enough power potential to do this. .
Ask you shop thier opinion and if I can help with your research, feel free to shoot me a pm.
#18
Safety Car
With either kit you will want more power in the end. Get a big head unit with either kit. I have a Ysi on one car, not a sleeper, and Novi 2000 on another, close to a sleeper. Both are great blowers with the Ysi flowing a little more.
Be ready to spend $$ on a new driveline, rear, and fuel system if you plan on a 402 in the future.
Be ready to spend $$ on a new driveline, rear, and fuel system if you plan on a 402 in the future.