Harmonic Balancer: SLP (Powerbond) vs Trick Flow vs Summit Racing
#21
Advanced
Member Since: Oct 2008
Location: Nova Scotia
Posts: 80
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Powerbond is a great choice. High quality and reasonably priced. I installed 25% UD unit last year. No charging or cooling issues whatsoever. Incidentally, only my main belt (alternator, water pump, etc.) is UD. A/C is stock length.
I used Goodyear Gatorbacks. Main (long) belt #4060775. A/C belt#4040420.
No more chirping, squeaking/squaking sounds!
Best of luck. I'm confident that you'll be happy with this setup.
I used Goodyear Gatorbacks. Main (long) belt #4060775. A/C belt#4040420.
No more chirping, squeaking/squaking sounds!
Best of luck. I'm confident that you'll be happy with this setup.
#23
Tech Contributor
Member Since: Dec 1999
Location: Anthony TX
Posts: 32,736
Received 2,180 Likes
on
1,583 Posts
CI 6,7,8,9,11 Vet
St. Jude Donor '08
I have the 25% UD pulley. ZERO charging problems on a heavily modded engine with lots of lope!
BC
BC
#24
Burning Brakes
If for no other reason, installing an aftermarket damper has to be good for the adjacent parts (belts, accessories, seal, oil pump) since the GM units invariably wobble like an arthritic wino. My ASP is super smooth, and the stocker on my new Caddy wobbles at least 1/8 inch, sending the belt tensioner into a frenzy. I'm going to try to get GM to replace it (wish me luck).
DG
DG
#26
Tech Contributor
#27
Racer
Thread Starter
The point if the UD is to reduce torsional vibration in the crankshaft, right? I just want make sure that I'm not upsetting the balance of the crankshaft by going with a lighter pully.
#28
Tech Contributor
#29
Safety Car
My stock damper was squeeking and comming apart, so when I did my mods last summer, I installed a Power Bond 25% UD damper... no charging or cooling issues, couple dozen laps at the strip, a 3,000 mile road trip etc....only have about 4,000 miles on it total so far....
#30
Racer
Thread Starter
#32
Burning Brakes
I used the Summit 25%UD when I did my cam swap 2 years ago and no problems.
#33
Team Owner
25% Powerbond - pinned crank - Goodyear # 4060775 Gator-Back belt.
No charging issues. Happy camper.
No charging issues. Happy camper.
#34
Race Director
Member Since: Oct 2002
Location: Gone
Posts: 16,477
Likes: 0
Received 18 Likes
on
15 Posts
CI 6-7-8-9-10 Veteran
St. Jude Donor '03
You were already given the reason for the underdrive ratio (to slow down the speed of the driven accessories)...But you actually did touch on a good point about the weight.
The Powerbond is not lighter than the stock balancer....If I recall, it weighs a touch more. For a balancer, this is a good thing, as it's primary function is to dampen engine harmonics. Driving the accessories is the secondary function.
A lighter balancer reduces it's ability to dampen, and the ASP is a good example of this, as it is aluminum and lighter than stock, and there are quite an alarming number of people that have broken timing chains with the ASP balancer.
Some may say there's no proof or direct correlation between the two components, or cause of failure, but personally, it almost seems a sure bet the next person to post a chain failure will likely be running a lighter balancer too... It's just gone beyond coincidence IMO.
Of course I could be 100% wrong, just something to think about.
As for the 25% underdrive ratio - no problems with charging, coolant temps, or power steering. But also consider most people installing one are also doing it with a cam, and that usually means increased idle speeds, which will kind of cancel it out in idling conditions, the one and only engine speed where underdriving could be a factor in accessory performance.
#35
Melting Slicks
Member Since: Jul 2007
Location: Simpsonville SC
Posts: 2,939
Likes: 0
Received 4 Likes
on
4 Posts
St. Jude Donor '09-'10
Interesting Information. The Innovator's West balancer that I post a picture of, is actually a 10% OVERDRIVE pulley! I had to place a larger pulley on my ProCharger unit to keep from building too much boost. I do not have ANY charging issues.
#36
Racer
Since it appears that there are no issues regarding charging etc. whit an under drive pulley aswell being good insurance before the original fail,I'll be ordering one of the POWERBOND unit.
Still undecided ...do I go whit the 10% or the 20% why one over the other?
Do they really provide more HP,If not I probably will stick whit there standard size replacement .
Also whit all 3 model I do retain the same AC belt correct,
and any special bolts required for the install.
Thank you for helping in my selection.
Still undecided ...do I go whit the 10% or the 20% why one over the other?
Do they really provide more HP,If not I probably will stick whit there standard size replacement .
Also whit all 3 model I do retain the same AC belt correct,
and any special bolts required for the install.
Thank you for helping in my selection.
#37
Tech Contributor
Just curious. Why would you install an overdrive balancer if you were concerned with making too much boost ?....kinda defeats the purpose.
#38
Racer
Since it appears that there are no issues regarding charging etc. whit an under drive pulley aswell being good insurance before the original fail,I'll be ordering one of the POWERBOND unit.
Still undecided ...do I go whit the 10% or the 20% why one over the other?
Do they really provide more HP,If not I probably will stick whit there standard size replacement .
Also whit all 3 model I do retain the same AC belt correct,
and any special bolts required for the install.
Thank you for helping in my selection.
Still undecided ...do I go whit the 10% or the 20% why one over the other?
Do they really provide more HP,If not I probably will stick whit there standard size replacement .
Also whit all 3 model I do retain the same AC belt correct,
and any special bolts required for the install.
Thank you for helping in my selection.
#39
Race Director
Member Since: Apr 2007
Location: South Western Ontario
Posts: 11,061
Received 845 Likes
on
721 Posts
The 10% will be fine and the 25% should be too. Still, I'm finding it hard to believe the battery voltage isn't dropping more at idle with a 25%.
If the car doesn't idle much then it doesn't matter. If it idles a fair bit then it could and it could really matter if you live in a really hot climate where the high speed fans run a lot and the car is iding a lot. Like driving in a lot of stop and go traffic in Arizona for example. An auto that idles will be worse since the idle speed is lower compared to a standard.
Peter
If the car doesn't idle much then it doesn't matter. If it idles a fair bit then it could and it could really matter if you live in a really hot climate where the high speed fans run a lot and the car is iding a lot. Like driving in a lot of stop and go traffic in Arizona for example. An auto that idles will be worse since the idle speed is lower compared to a standard.
Peter
#40
Since it appears that there are no issues regarding charging etc. whit an under drive pulley aswell being good insurance before the original fail,I'll be ordering one of the POWERBOND unit.
Still undecided ...do I go whit the 10% or the 20% why one over the other?
Do they really provide more HP,If not I probably will stick whit there standard size replacement .
Also whit all 3 model I do retain the same AC belt correct,
and any special bolts required for the install.
Thank you for helping in my selection.
Still undecided ...do I go whit the 10% or the 20% why one over the other?
Do they really provide more HP,If not I probably will stick whit there standard size replacement .
Also whit all 3 model I do retain the same AC belt correct,
and any special bolts required for the install.
Thank you for helping in my selection.