Dexos vs Mobil 1 in 2012 GS?
#21
Advanced
Member Since: Jan 2011
Location: Union County New Jersey
Posts: 60
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
$14/quart?
Appears DEXOS1 that GM markets is synthetic blend. That's why it's cheaper.
http://www.smittysinc.net/SiteFlyers...exos1Flyer.pdf
I did find on the GM dealer network where DEXOS was costing them about 1800 for a 55 gallon drum. They mark it
up to 3100.
http://www.smittysinc.net/SiteFlyers...exos1Flyer.pdf
I did find on the GM dealer network where DEXOS was costing them about 1800 for a 55 gallon drum. They mark it
up to 3100.
#22
Team Owner
#23
Team Owner
Member Since: Jun 2005
Location: Northern, VA
Posts: 46,100
Received 2,478 Likes
on
1,941 Posts
St. Jude Donor '15
"In honor of jpee"
Dexos is not an oil, it is a set of standards. Many oils meet the Dexos standard. These will have the logo right on the bottle.
If the service tech is confused, one remedy would be to buy the oil at Walmart and bring it with the car for him to use. He can then match up the logo on the oil cap with the logo on the bottle.
If the service tech is confused, one remedy would be to buy the oil at Walmart and bring it with the car for him to use. He can then match up the logo on the oil cap with the logo on the bottle.
To answer Mike's "need for .." question tho, no, not all Dexos-standard oils are synthetic blends. As Chris cclive says above, many existing oils, including full synthetics, meet (or exceed) the Dexos standard. Possibly for that little bit of added protection, it may be worth it to use full synthetic vs. a synthetic blend even if both meet the Dexos standard (as mentioned by hairbag in post #2).
Last edited by AORoads; 02-12-2012 at 11:02 PM.
#24
The question was WHY?
I think someone hit it on the head - Profit. here is an interesting read:
http://www.tireindustry.org/dexos.asp
A quick check on Google found the DEXOS oil retails for $593/55 gallon drum as compared to Mobil 1 at approx $1700/barrel.
And no the Tech was not confused as his dealership has a bulk oil labeled DEXOS on the overhead oil supply and his dealership sells it as "DEXOS" to its customers, not XYZ oil that meets DEXOS standards.
I think we really have beat this one to death now.
George
I think someone hit it on the head - Profit. here is an interesting read:
http://www.tireindustry.org/dexos.asp
A quick check on Google found the DEXOS oil retails for $593/55 gallon drum as compared to Mobil 1 at approx $1700/barrel.
And no the Tech was not confused as his dealership has a bulk oil labeled DEXOS on the overhead oil supply and his dealership sells it as "DEXOS" to its customers, not XYZ oil that meets DEXOS standards.
I think we really have beat this one to death now.
George
#25
Melting Slicks
Member Since: Nov 2005
Location: Belleville Illinois
Posts: 2,022
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
#26
Race Director
Member Since: Sep 2007
Location: Peoria/Phoenix AZ
Posts: 16,555
Received 2,060 Likes
on
1,505 Posts
C6 of Year Finalist (performance mods) 2019
It just goes to show that you shouldn't believe everything you read on the internet.
#27
Le Mans Master
Not sure why the spec was changed, but I'll use oil that meets either one. Picked up a five quart jug of Castrol Edge and K&N filter that meet spec from Advance Auto for $30 bucks over the holidays, and what's going in. Also sent me an NFL football and $7 check. No cheapskate here, but nothing wrong with having a little fun doing an oil change.
#28
Premium Supporting Vendor
Collation Seeks FTC Review of Dexos
There are aftermarket alternatives to dexos1:
AMSOIL Signature Series 5w30
__________________
C66 Racing #66 NASA ST2, SCCA T2
AMSOIL Dealer (Forum Vendor)
AMSOIL Ordering Information (Retail sales using reference #1206638 benefit the forum.)
AMSOIL Preferred Customer Program (Members buy at Wholesale - a savings of about 25%)
AMSOIL Catalog
C66 Racing #66 NASA ST2, SCCA T2
AMSOIL Dealer (Forum Vendor)
AMSOIL Ordering Information (Retail sales using reference #1206638 benefit the forum.)
AMSOIL Preferred Customer Program (Members buy at Wholesale - a savings of about 25%)
AMSOIL Catalog
Last edited by C66 Racing; 02-13-2012 at 10:29 PM.
#29
Burning Brakes
http://www.redlineoil.com/
#30
Burning Brakes
No, far from it. Here's the straight dope from our local expert!
All of the oils that are constantly discussed on the forum are varying blends of group 2, group 3, and group 4 base oils. Groups 2 and 4 are very easy to define. Group 2 is conventional “dino” oil, simply refined from crude oil. Group 4 is made up of various synthetic, manufactured polymers, mostly poly alpha olefins or PAO. Almost all experts would agree that group 2 are lowest quality of the base oil groups. Group 3 are the toughest to define, both in terms of origin and quality. They start out as group 2, but are then subjected to extremely severe processing called hydrocracking, where hydrogen is added over a catalyst at pressures of about 2500 psi and temperatures of about 700F. During that process, most of the lower quality ring compounds, and essentially all of the heteroatoms like sulfur and nitrogen are removed. Most experts agree that group 3 oils are considerably closer to group 4 than to group 2 in quality, but most would also agree that they are not quite as good as group 4. But in terms of cost to manufacture, group 3 is closer to group 2 than to group 4. Knowing that, you can guess where this is headed.
Mobil 1 was originally group 4. Castrol started marketing a group 3 oil as being fully synthetic, on the basis that the severe hydrocracking of group 3 scrambled the hydrocarbons enough to call them synthetic in the sense that the resulting molecules are not naturally occurring. Mobil sued them, but lost. So now, in the USA, both group 3 and 4 oils can be advertised as being fully synthetic. As a result, even if the oil is advertised as fully synthetic, unless they specifically say it is group 4 (Mobil 1 does not), you do not know how much, if any group 4 oil it contains. Since they lost the lawsuit, Mobil refuses to answer the group 3 vs 4 question, so it is pretty clear that rather than label Mobil 1 as group 4 and continue making it as they originally did, they are using at least some group 3 base in Mobil 1. Just like any other oil that is labeled fully synthetic, but not labeled group 4, you cannot rule out the possibility that it is 100% group 3.
Before you start screaming that Mobil 1 is no longer any good, remember that it still meets 4718M spec. That spec doesn’t say anything about group 3, group 4, or synthetic, it simply sets standards for thermal stability and wear in engine testing. Those standards are so stringent that it is essentially impossible for a group 2 oil to meet. But now you ask the question, is a group 4 oil that meets 4718M better than a group 3 oil that meets 4718M? Beats the heck out of me. I’m sure both GM and Mobil have run such tests on original versus current Mobil 1, so they know that answer. But they aren’t talking. My guess would be that original Mobil 1 which was group 4 probably tests a smidgen better than current Mobil 1 which is a group 3-4 blend, but the difference is hardly enough to notice. They are both excellent oils, and had Mobil not gone to some group 3 in Mobil 1, you can be sure its price would have risen.
As far as the consumer, once the courts and lawyers put their ugly stamp on things by making the therm fully synthetic cover both group 3 and 4, it would be nice if the companies had responded by voluntarily labeling by group number like most do in Europe. Unfortunately, that hasn’t happened here yet, so as of now, unless the oil is one of the few that are labeled group 4, you have no way of knowing whether your synthetic is group 3 or 4. But you can hang your hat on the fact that both groups are excellent oils, so I really don’t think it’s worth too much worry.
Mobil 1 was originally group 4. Castrol started marketing a group 3 oil as being fully synthetic, on the basis that the severe hydrocracking of group 3 scrambled the hydrocarbons enough to call them synthetic in the sense that the resulting molecules are not naturally occurring. Mobil sued them, but lost. So now, in the USA, both group 3 and 4 oils can be advertised as being fully synthetic. As a result, even if the oil is advertised as fully synthetic, unless they specifically say it is group 4 (Mobil 1 does not), you do not know how much, if any group 4 oil it contains. Since they lost the lawsuit, Mobil refuses to answer the group 3 vs 4 question, so it is pretty clear that rather than label Mobil 1 as group 4 and continue making it as they originally did, they are using at least some group 3 base in Mobil 1. Just like any other oil that is labeled fully synthetic, but not labeled group 4, you cannot rule out the possibility that it is 100% group 3.
Before you start screaming that Mobil 1 is no longer any good, remember that it still meets 4718M spec. That spec doesn’t say anything about group 3, group 4, or synthetic, it simply sets standards for thermal stability and wear in engine testing. Those standards are so stringent that it is essentially impossible for a group 2 oil to meet. But now you ask the question, is a group 4 oil that meets 4718M better than a group 3 oil that meets 4718M? Beats the heck out of me. I’m sure both GM and Mobil have run such tests on original versus current Mobil 1, so they know that answer. But they aren’t talking. My guess would be that original Mobil 1 which was group 4 probably tests a smidgen better than current Mobil 1 which is a group 3-4 blend, but the difference is hardly enough to notice. They are both excellent oils, and had Mobil not gone to some group 3 in Mobil 1, you can be sure its price would have risen.
As far as the consumer, once the courts and lawyers put their ugly stamp on things by making the therm fully synthetic cover both group 3 and 4, it would be nice if the companies had responded by voluntarily labeling by group number like most do in Europe. Unfortunately, that hasn’t happened here yet, so as of now, unless the oil is one of the few that are labeled group 4, you have no way of knowing whether your synthetic is group 3 or 4. But you can hang your hat on the fact that both groups are excellent oils, so I really don’t think it’s worth too much worry.
#31
Mobil1 vs Dexos1
Well being a proud owner of the new 2015 Z06 and actually reading the owners manual, they say if you plan to track the car or race it to upgrade to Mobil1
Dexos is the 2-year old oil performance spec for GM vehicles. AC Delco Dexos is a syn blend. Both Mobil 1 & AC Delco Dexos are available to GM dealers in qts, 55 gallon drums or bulk as needed by the dealer. AC Delco Dexos spec oil is the minimum performance oil standard for your 2011-2012 GM vehicle including your vette. Mobil 1 5w30 does meet the Dexos performance standards and would be a step up oil performance over the AC delco Dexos product.
AC Delco Dexos---Good
Mobil 1 5W30------Better/Best
AC Delco Dexos---Good
Mobil 1 5W30------Better/Best
#32
Melting Slicks
All LS3 dry sump, LS7 and LS9 corvette engines were factory filled with Mobile 1. Currently, all C7 LT1 dry sump and LT4(Z06) corvette engines are factory filled with Moble 1. C7 Stingray LT1s are factory filled with Dexos standard synthetic blend oil. This information came from GM Factory Rep.
#33
Oh contraire
The LT4 is filled with Dexos and labled so on the new Z06. I know first hand. Wish i knew how to post pics here...
All LS3 dry sump, LS7 and LS9 corvette engines were factory filled with Mobile 1. Currently, all C7 LT1 dry sump and LT4(Z06) corvette engines are factory filled with Moble 1. C7 Stingray LT1s are factory filled with Dexos standard synthetic blend oil. This information came from GM Factory Rep.
#34
Tech Contributor
The following users liked this post:
Vyper340 (01-04-2017)
#36
Melting Slicks
If you do a little more research you will find that Mobil 1 is not true synthetic oil, I believe their only true syn oil is their 0W-40 weight. That being said, if you change your oil when or before indicated it's hard to find better oil for the money. I love the Redline of products but they are pricey.
#40
Damn and i have free oil changes for the next 22 months from the dealer and it makes me think if i should just do my own lol