A6 Paddle Shifting Torque/Rev Loss Question
#1
Racer
Thread Starter
A6 Paddle Shifting Torque/Rev Loss Question
I searched around a bit and couldn't find a good answer. I do understand fundamentally the difference between a true manual and the A6 but would like y'alls experience.
I don't really notice this effect in Automatic or A-Sport mode (as I'm sure the computer is a wizard).
When I put my C6 into M-Sport mode with the paddle shifters, I typically shift like I would my Manual C5 (just without the stick, obviously)
I find that in Paddle mode, if I get on the gas (let's say to the floor) in 3rd/4th/whatever it loses RPM's sometimes and feels like it revs up and then whines out for a little bit. Is this due to the nature of the slushbox or torque conversion or what?
Also, downshifts don't seem to truly downshift, where it doesn't rev match. Almost as if it's in neutral in the next lowest gear.
In my C5 Manual, if I drop into third and gun it, she just goes, she's mechanically sealed, angry and stuff!
Thoughts? Does this make sense? Haha
Thanks for entertaining me!
I don't really notice this effect in Automatic or A-Sport mode (as I'm sure the computer is a wizard).
When I put my C6 into M-Sport mode with the paddle shifters, I typically shift like I would my Manual C5 (just without the stick, obviously)
I find that in Paddle mode, if I get on the gas (let's say to the floor) in 3rd/4th/whatever it loses RPM's sometimes and feels like it revs up and then whines out for a little bit. Is this due to the nature of the slushbox or torque conversion or what?
Also, downshifts don't seem to truly downshift, where it doesn't rev match. Almost as if it's in neutral in the next lowest gear.
In my C5 Manual, if I drop into third and gun it, she just goes, she's mechanically sealed, angry and stuff!
Thoughts? Does this make sense? Haha
Thanks for entertaining me!
#2
Team Owner
I searched around a bit and couldn't find a good answer. I do understand fundamentally the difference between a true manual and the A6 but would like y'alls experience.
I don't really notice this effect in Automatic or A-Sport mode (as I'm sure the computer is a wizard).
When I put my C6 into M-Sport mode with the paddle shifters, I typically shift like I would my Manual C5 (just without the stick, obviously)
I find that in Paddle mode, if I get on the gas (let's say to the floor) in 3rd/4th/whatever it loses RPM's sometimes and feels like it revs up and then whines out for a little bit. Is this due to the nature of the slushbox or torque conversion or what?
Also, downshifts don't seem to truly downshift, where it doesn't rev match. Almost as if it's in neutral in the next lowest gear.
In my C5 Manual, if I drop into third and gun it, she just goes, she's mechanically sealed, angry and stuff!
Thoughts? Does this make sense? Haha
Thanks for entertaining me!
I don't really notice this effect in Automatic or A-Sport mode (as I'm sure the computer is a wizard).
When I put my C6 into M-Sport mode with the paddle shifters, I typically shift like I would my Manual C5 (just without the stick, obviously)
I find that in Paddle mode, if I get on the gas (let's say to the floor) in 3rd/4th/whatever it loses RPM's sometimes and feels like it revs up and then whines out for a little bit. Is this due to the nature of the slushbox or torque conversion or what?
Also, downshifts don't seem to truly downshift, where it doesn't rev match. Almost as if it's in neutral in the next lowest gear.
In my C5 Manual, if I drop into third and gun it, she just goes, she's mechanically sealed, angry and stuff!
Thoughts? Does this make sense? Haha
Thanks for entertaining me!
'07 sales brochure states "Throttle automatically matches revs during downshifts for smoother transitions"
Don't know if that's true or not.
I could not find anything about it in the Corvette Black Book.
Last edited by Vette_DD; 07-07-2015 at 05:10 PM.
#3
Burning Brakes
I too have the A6 when using the paddles it does not seem to like it when you shift up from full or almost full throttle. So I do not shift it that way, around 5000 RPM is my shift point when paddling it. If I am letting it be an automatic, then the computer does full throttle shifts just fine.
#4
First and foremost, its not advisable to try and compare a C6 manual with a C-6 with paddles. Contrary to what you hear from some of the people in these threads it is not "ALMOST" the same as driving a manual. The people that say this usually are just to bias to admit that there paddled automatic isn't the same as a manual. Mine has an auto and I like it for what it is, but The paddles are really no more than a novelty. They don't make the tranny shift any quicker or harder than what a car with a typical console auto shifter does. You can however buy conversions to help the paddled tranny work better, so they say on this forum anyway. Bottom line is if you're trying to get your paddles to work like a manual....forget it.
#5
Racer
Thread Starter
First and foremost, its not advisable to try and compare a C6 manual with a C-6 with paddles. Contrary to what you hear from some of the people in these threads it is not "ALMOST" the same as driving a manual. The people that say this usually are just to bias to admit that there paddled automatic isn't the same as a manual. Mine has an auto and I like it for what it is, but The paddles are really no more than a novelty. They don't make the tranny shift any quicker or harder than what a car with a typical console auto shifter does. You can however buy conversions to help the paddled tranny work better, so they say on this forum anyway. Bottom line is if you're trying to get your paddles to work like a manual....forget it.
What this thread is about, is the way the automatic while in paddle modes handles driving, load, acceleration, etc.
I too have the A6 when using the paddles it does not seem to like it when you shift up from full or almost full throttle. So I do not shift it that way, around 5000 RPM is my shift point when paddling it. If I am letting it be an automatic, then the computer does full throttle shifts just fine.
Is there some kind of overdrive for each gear?
For example, when I go from:
60MPH and coasting with no throttle... 5th Gear to 4th Gear - It'll match revs briefly, and then drop to idle (like ~1000 RPM)
Downshift again from 4th to 3rd, it'll blip and then again, drop to idle.
I haven't owned an auto in a few years, I'm really just trying to understand exactly how it works, what's happening, etc.
Any ASE Transmission guys out there? Corvette specialists?
#6
Safety Car
I too have the A6 when using the paddles it does not seem to like it when you shift up from full or almost full throttle. So I do not shift it that way, around 5000 RPM is my shift point when paddling it. If I am letting it be an automatic, then the computer does full throttle shifts just fine.
Of course, you can just leave it in Sport Auto and the trans shifts great that way, too.
As windyc6 says... you cannot really compare it to a manual. I have two manual trans vehicles, and it is different in how the driver engages with the car. However, with a good trans tune (which includes better shift-time with the paddles), I have changed my impressions about the A6.
#7
Racer
Thread Starter
Not sure what year your car is, or if it really matters... but once I got my trans tuned, the paddle shifting is much better. It is more precise (shift quality), quicker (shift speed), and at WOT it is near instantaneous. I no longer have to worry about hitting the rev-limiter b/c I have to _guess_ as to when the trans will actually shift after I upshift with the paddle. It shifts on command. I was completely shocked.
Of course, you can just leave it in Sport Auto and the trans shifts great that way, too.
As windyc6 says... you cannot really compare it to a manual. I have two manual trans vehicles, and it is different in how the driver engages with the car. However, with a good trans tune (which includes better shift-time with the paddles), I have changed my impressions about the A6.
Of course, you can just leave it in Sport Auto and the trans shifts great that way, too.
As windyc6 says... you cannot really compare it to a manual. I have two manual trans vehicles, and it is different in how the driver engages with the car. However, with a good trans tune (which includes better shift-time with the paddles), I have changed my impressions about the A6.
I'm planning a tune but was just looking for insight as to why it revs the way it does when gassing it in a gear. Not worried about the speed of the shift or anything in this particular thread.
#8
GM tunes the trans to save the drive line, hence soften the shifts.
All this can be changed in a tune, and you can change both the standard mode, and S mode (pattern B) , or leave one stock and just change the other.
All this can be changed in a tune, and you can change both the standard mode, and S mode (pattern B) , or leave one stock and just change the other.
#9
Burning Brakes
I agree you cannot compare an m6 to an a6. For my driving style it works for me. Street driving is far different than track use. I do not drive at 100% on the street. 70% is about my limit for surviving situations. As Dano said you can do a tune, but I don't want to trash a transmission or other driveline componant . I can work around a factory tune. I am to a point in life were I am able to wear my "GOT OLD" T-shirt with pride.
Bill
Bill
#10
Racer
Thread Starter
Alright everyone, can we get back to the topic at hand now please?
In any gear using the paddles, let's say 6th gear on the highway doing 60-70
If I step on the gas (not flooring it), it seems like the transmission is de-revving itself, almost like it's shifting into an overdrive. This may be accelerating from 60mph-75mph
Is this a normal thing?
#11
Le Mans Master
Alright everyone, can we get back to the topic at hand now please?
In any gear using the paddles, let's say 6th gear on the highway doing 60-70
If I step on the gas (not flooring it), it seems like the transmission is de-revving itself, almost like it's shifting into an overdrive. This may be accelerating from 60mph-75mph
Is this a normal thing?
#12
GM throttle mapped a delay from the gas pedal response, to the TB doing anything itself.
This keeps you from bucking the car via the gas pedal, and achieving higher MPG. Worse yet, when you come off the gas pedal on the base cars, the motor will hold it revs for a moment as well before the engine rev's will start to drop down (same reason).
So keep in mind that the throttle is not going to be instant on the Vet (unless the throttle is remapped).
So after this short throttle delay of nothing happening as you press the gas pedal more down, does the revs start to climb, trans starts to shift down with the torque converter de-locking for the shift?
Also keep in mind that the motor is in closed loop, So if your air filter is dirty/you changed out to an after market intake that is wreaking havoc on a smooth flow of air past the MAF, will cause a slightly longer delay as well.
Lastly, data log the gas pedal and the TB sensors. Normally the car will throw codes if the gas pedal sensors have a problem, but could have a bad spot in the gas pedal sensor and instead of the ECM seeing the gas pedal as being depressed farther down, could be seeing the pedal being pressed down as being slightly lifted instead.
This keeps you from bucking the car via the gas pedal, and achieving higher MPG. Worse yet, when you come off the gas pedal on the base cars, the motor will hold it revs for a moment as well before the engine rev's will start to drop down (same reason).
So keep in mind that the throttle is not going to be instant on the Vet (unless the throttle is remapped).
So after this short throttle delay of nothing happening as you press the gas pedal more down, does the revs start to climb, trans starts to shift down with the torque converter de-locking for the shift?
Also keep in mind that the motor is in closed loop, So if your air filter is dirty/you changed out to an after market intake that is wreaking havoc on a smooth flow of air past the MAF, will cause a slightly longer delay as well.
Lastly, data log the gas pedal and the TB sensors. Normally the car will throw codes if the gas pedal sensors have a problem, but could have a bad spot in the gas pedal sensor and instead of the ECM seeing the gas pedal as being depressed farther down, could be seeing the pedal being pressed down as being slightly lifted instead.
#13
Team Owner
#14
Advanced
Something does not sound right.
In my '06 LS-2 A6 vert, if I am cruising at say 60 (~1350 rpm in 6th) and I step on it to pass, even moderately, it immediately shifts down to 5th, and perhaps even 4th, and quickly accelerates to 80+.
What yours is doing does not sound right at all.
In my '06 LS-2 A6 vert, if I am cruising at say 60 (~1350 rpm in 6th) and I step on it to pass, even moderately, it immediately shifts down to 5th, and perhaps even 4th, and quickly accelerates to 80+.
What yours is doing does not sound right at all.
#15
Racer
Thread Starter
Something does not sound right.
In my '06 LS-2 A6 vert, if I am cruising at say 60 (~1350 rpm in 6th) and I step on it to pass, even moderately, it immediately shifts down to 5th, and perhaps even 4th, and quickly accelerates to 80+.
What yours is doing does not sound right at all.
In my '06 LS-2 A6 vert, if I am cruising at say 60 (~1350 rpm in 6th) and I step on it to pass, even moderately, it immediately shifts down to 5th, and perhaps even 4th, and quickly accelerates to 80+.
What yours is doing does not sound right at all.
#16
Advanced
if you know the original owner, you may want to call and ask him if there was any kind of aftermarket tuning done to the car. If so you might want to pay a dealer to download the original OEM tune, so at least you know where you are starting from.
#17
Advanced
What happens if you step on it in normal auto mode?
#18
Racer
Thread Starter
I only don't downshift in the 60-75 situation because it's typically just going with traffic, not so much being aggressive.
I really think it's just an automatic transmission thing. In my manual, if I'm cruising at 60 in 6th @ 1300rpm* and accelerate to 75 in 6th @ 1425rpm* it stays there. (I'm guesstimating RPM)
In the automatic in paddle mode 6th gear, it goes from cruising RPM and drops to idle RPM, like it's just chillin' waiting for throttle input.
If none of this makes any sense, I'll try and get some video up. Nothing seems wrong, I just wanted to know why it would *technically* do that haha
#20
Racer
Thread Starter
For everyone who is apparently now concerned, I have a 30k mile/3 year, bumper to bumper warranty lol, so I'm fine taking it in.
If you really think this warrants a check-up, let me know.
If not, go drive your A6's tomorrow and let me know what they do after setting cruise control or accelerating 50%+ throttle without shifting up/down.
If you really think this warrants a check-up, let me know.
If not, go drive your A6's tomorrow and let me know what they do after setting cruise control or accelerating 50%+ throttle without shifting up/down.