Driving experience between base 6sp & Z516sp?
#1
Drifting
Thread Starter
Driving experience between base 6sp & Z516sp?
I've driven an 09 base coupe Z51 6sp with 19,000 miles on it. Would have bought it if it was a convertible on the spot! I'm finding it extremely difficult finding an 08 and up 3lt z51 6sp convertible with reasonable mileage, and a nice driver car!
I found an 08 base 3lt 6sp convertible with only 17,000 miles on!
It's fully loaded, and has factory navigation, and dual mode exhaust!
Clean Carfax for under $29K. I'm going to look at it tomorrow.
What I would like to know is how much of a difference can I expect from a base minus Z51 package, and the car I already drove?
Will I be disappointed?
I found an 08 base 3lt 6sp convertible with only 17,000 miles on!
It's fully loaded, and has factory navigation, and dual mode exhaust!
Clean Carfax for under $29K. I'm going to look at it tomorrow.
What I would like to know is how much of a difference can I expect from a base minus Z51 package, and the car I already drove?
Will I be disappointed?
Last edited by marinablu67; 11-09-2017 at 03:31 PM.
#2
Instructor
The Z51 will be a little bumpier. Unless you road race the car and are a very skilled driver, you will not see a difference in performance. Base third gear is longer.
The following users liked this post:
marinablu67 (11-09-2017)
The following users liked this post:
marinablu67 (11-09-2017)
#4
Race Director
Pro Mechanic
Member Since: Apr 2014
Location: Washington Township Michigan
Posts: 14,521
Received 3,952 Likes
on
2,470 Posts
2024 Corvette of the Year Finalist - Unmodified
2023 C6 of the Year Winner - Unmodified
2020 C6 of the Year Finalist - Unmodified
2019 C6 of Year Finalist (appearance mods)
The following users liked this post:
marinablu67 (11-09-2017)
#6
Safety Car
It all depends what YOU like. We can argue all day about different suspensions. It comes down to your preference.
In 2008, I test drove both the base and Z51 suspensions before purchasing. The difference between the two suspensions is quite noticeable. For me, hands down I prefer the Z51 because I enjoy a sports car that handles. Yes, the ride might be a little firmer, but that's what I like and would do the same today. For those who think the Z51 is strictly for road racing, they are wrong. The Z51 is for drivers who enjoy a sports car with greater street handling capabilities.
There is no wrong or right car, just the car YOU prefer driving.
In 2008, I test drove both the base and Z51 suspensions before purchasing. The difference between the two suspensions is quite noticeable. For me, hands down I prefer the Z51 because I enjoy a sports car that handles. Yes, the ride might be a little firmer, but that's what I like and would do the same today. For those who think the Z51 is strictly for road racing, they are wrong. The Z51 is for drivers who enjoy a sports car with greater street handling capabilities.
There is no wrong or right car, just the car YOU prefer driving.
Last edited by Mike's LS3; 11-09-2017 at 09:33 PM.
The following users liked this post:
FortMorganAl (11-12-2017)
#7
Instructor
It all depends what YOU like. We can argue all day about different suspensions. It comes down to your preference.
In 2008, I test drove both the base and Z51 suspensions before purchasing. The difference between the two suspensions is quite noticeable. For me, hands down I prefer the Z51 because I enjoy a sports car that handles. Yes, the ride might be a little firmer, but that's what I like and would do the same today. For those who think the Z51 is strictly for road racing, they are wrong. The Z51 is for drivers who enjoy a sports car with greater street handling capabilities.
There is no wrong or right car, just the car YOU prefer driving.
In 2008, I test drove both the base and Z51 suspensions before purchasing. The difference between the two suspensions is quite noticeable. For me, hands down I prefer the Z51 because I enjoy a sports car that handles. Yes, the ride might be a little firmer, but that's what I like and would do the same today. For those who think the Z51 is strictly for road racing, they are wrong. The Z51 is for drivers who enjoy a sports car with greater street handling capabilities.
There is no wrong or right car, just the car YOU prefer driving.
Lets put it this way. A base car with a good tire will beat a Z51 with stock rubber (or similar rubber). It's THAT small of a difference. 99% of the population wont do anything to touch the limits of either of the cars.
Again, if you want that FEEL, then go for it. But I promise you that you wont NEED or be missing out on performance if you get a base.
#8
Race Director
It's all in the feel though. Literally that is IT. There is no way you're pushing the car hard enough on the street (let me guess, you have stock-like tires on it too) to actually have a difference in handling. Both the base and Z51 suspension aren't even remotely working to their limits on the street. IF you are even skilled enough to test those limits, you'd be a moron and endangering your life as well as others even attempting it on the STREET.
Lets put it this way. A base car with a good tire will beat a Z51 with stock rubber (or similar rubber). It's THAT small of a difference. 99% of the population wont do anything to touch the limits of either of the cars.
Again, if you want that FEEL, then go for it. But I promise you that you wont NEED or be missing out on performance if you get a base.
Lets put it this way. A base car with a good tire will beat a Z51 with stock rubber (or similar rubber). It's THAT small of a difference. 99% of the population wont do anything to touch the limits of either of the cars.
Again, if you want that FEEL, then go for it. But I promise you that you wont NEED or be missing out on performance if you get a base.
The following 2 users liked this post by Corvette_Ed:
FortMorganAl (11-12-2017),
jmeirhofer (11-12-2017)
#9
Instructor
2. You mention different. As in feel. Which I TOTALLY agree with. It's a different feel. And that's 99% of the reason why someone should or should not get the Z51. It's what they want to FEEL. Because 99% of people wont be able to push the car to it's limits to actually generate a difference in PERFORMANCE between a base and Z51 car.
Again, the difference in PERFORMANCE is so minute that a better set of tires on the base car would make a bigger difference between the two. It's all about what feel you want.
#10
Race Director
Member Since: Mar 2010
Location: T-Town WA
Posts: 15,100
Received 3,626 Likes
on
2,348 Posts
2016 C6 of Year Finalist
#11
Melting Slicks
1. Literally the only SINGLE gear that is different is 3rd (and it's shorter). The other 5 are the same. So your lack of understanding my point is obvious.
2. You mention different. As in feel. Which I TOTALLY agree with. It's a different feel. And that's 99% of the reason why someone should or should not get the Z51. It's what they want to FEEL. Because 99% of people wont be able to push the car to it's limits to actually generate a difference in PERFORMANCE between a base and Z51 car.
Again, the difference in PERFORMANCE is so minute that a better set of tires on the base car would make a bigger difference between the two. It's all about what feel you want.
2. You mention different. As in feel. Which I TOTALLY agree with. It's a different feel. And that's 99% of the reason why someone should or should not get the Z51. It's what they want to FEEL. Because 99% of people wont be able to push the car to it's limits to actually generate a difference in PERFORMANCE between a base and Z51 car.
Again, the difference in PERFORMANCE is so minute that a better set of tires on the base car would make a bigger difference between the two. It's all about what feel you want.
Looks like only one gear IS the same.
Last edited by extrapilot; 11-10-2017 at 10:00 AM.
#12
Race Director
As proven above, WRONG.
#13
Melting Slicks
Member Since: Jul 2010
Location: Tacoma, Wa/Surprise, Az
Posts: 2,849
Received 193 Likes
on
166 Posts
Mtarr07 sounds like a troll.
Having owned Z51 optioned cars and a GS, IMHO the Z51 is the performance version of the base model and handling is much improved, though it does ride a bit rougher. If you go the Z51 route, you could improve ride qualities with GS shocks and retain the flat cornering aspects. The Supercar tires that came on the Z51 are much improved over the base model too.
I love my track days, so the Z51 is my lowest rung on the ladder, and I've found the GS to for both my pocketbook and desires in a dual use car.
lastly, there is a difference in the cars that is usable and perceptible, you don't have to take it to the track to feel the difference, though it sure is a lot of fine when you do.
HTH.
Having owned Z51 optioned cars and a GS, IMHO the Z51 is the performance version of the base model and handling is much improved, though it does ride a bit rougher. If you go the Z51 route, you could improve ride qualities with GS shocks and retain the flat cornering aspects. The Supercar tires that came on the Z51 are much improved over the base model too.
I love my track days, so the Z51 is my lowest rung on the ladder, and I've found the GS to for both my pocketbook and desires in a dual use car.
lastly, there is a difference in the cars that is usable and perceptible, you don't have to take it to the track to feel the difference, though it sure is a lot of fine when you do.
HTH.
#14
Instructor
Honestly, total brain fart on my end. You're right. I mixed up only one gear being different with only one gear being the same. It's been a while since I compared ratios and obviously I was thinking the exact opposite.
Chill man. Glad you know what you have. Calm down before you give your old *** a heart attack. I still stand by my statement that all you're FEELING in a z51 car versus a base is the FEEL. A Z51 car doesn't handle WORLDS better than a base vette. Around a track, the better tires from the factory (stock versus stock) make a bigger difference. It's primarily the bumpier/ more firm ride that gives you the impression it handles better. I'm not saying it handles WORSE. I'm saying the ride is firmer and AGREEING with you on FEEL. But nobody is going to be pushing the car hard enough on the street to MAKE a difference in performance. You're going to take that on ramp at 50mph in a base and Z51 car.
Have you ever raced anything, ever? I don't mean 1/4 mile, I mean actually race. There's totally stock squishy suspension cars that autoX with sticky *** tires and nothing else and WRECK dudes with really stiff suspensions. Why? Because traction (tires). A squishy suspension (the base vette in this example) will have more travel in the suspension. The stiffer suspension (the Z51 in this example) will feel like it handles better because you're going to feel every bump in the road and there isn't as much travel. But I promise you, 99% of people will register the same times around the track in both cars if equipped with the same tires. The Z51 car will FEEL more firm though.
Now, go look at your car in your garage that has never seen track time and give yourself a pat on the back for having a Z51 car.
And you sound like a dufas.
You even bring up the different tires yourself. You are literally saying the SAME thing I am.
I am AGREEING there is a difference in FEEL. Jesus Christ.
I'm merely saying to the OP that he should go with whichever FEEL he prefers because there might be a HANDFUL of people on this entire forum that have the skill to actually push both versions to the limits enough to show the discrepancy between the two.
At the end of the day we are talking about a ~3200lb Corvette. Pick whatever makes you feel happy and whatever you prefer because there's a very good chance you don't have the skill to utilize the advantages of any of the versions. It is literally all for bragging rights. And if that's what makes you happy, then good for you.
Have you ever raced anything, ever? I don't mean 1/4 mile, I mean actually race. There's totally stock squishy suspension cars that autoX with sticky *** tires and nothing else and WRECK dudes with really stiff suspensions. Why? Because traction (tires). A squishy suspension (the base vette in this example) will have more travel in the suspension. The stiffer suspension (the Z51 in this example) will feel like it handles better because you're going to feel every bump in the road and there isn't as much travel. But I promise you, 99% of people will register the same times around the track in both cars if equipped with the same tires. The Z51 car will FEEL more firm though.
Now, go look at your car in your garage that has never seen track time and give yourself a pat on the back for having a Z51 car.
Mtarr07 sounds like a troll.
Having owned Z51 optioned cars and a GS, IMHO the Z51 is the performance version of the base model and handling is much improved, though it does ride a bit rougher. If you go the Z51 route, you could improve ride qualities with GS shocks and retain the flat cornering aspects. The Supercar tires that came on the Z51 are much improved over the base model too.
I love my track days, so the Z51 is my lowest rung on the ladder, and I've found the GS to for both my pocketbook and desires in a dual use car.
lastly, there is a difference in the cars that is usable and perceptible, you don't have to take it to the track to feel the difference, though it sure is a lot of fine when you do.
HTH.
Having owned Z51 optioned cars and a GS, IMHO the Z51 is the performance version of the base model and handling is much improved, though it does ride a bit rougher. If you go the Z51 route, you could improve ride qualities with GS shocks and retain the flat cornering aspects. The Supercar tires that came on the Z51 are much improved over the base model too.
I love my track days, so the Z51 is my lowest rung on the ladder, and I've found the GS to for both my pocketbook and desires in a dual use car.
lastly, there is a difference in the cars that is usable and perceptible, you don't have to take it to the track to feel the difference, though it sure is a lot of fine when you do.
HTH.
You even bring up the different tires yourself. You are literally saying the SAME thing I am.
I am AGREEING there is a difference in FEEL. Jesus Christ.
I'm merely saying to the OP that he should go with whichever FEEL he prefers because there might be a HANDFUL of people on this entire forum that have the skill to actually push both versions to the limits enough to show the discrepancy between the two.
At the end of the day we are talking about a ~3200lb Corvette. Pick whatever makes you feel happy and whatever you prefer because there's a very good chance you don't have the skill to utilize the advantages of any of the versions. It is literally all for bragging rights. And if that's what makes you happy, then good for you.
Last edited by mtarr07; 11-10-2017 at 04:00 PM.
#15
Race Director
Member Since: Sep 2007
Location: Peoria/Phoenix AZ
Posts: 16,555
Received 2,061 Likes
on
1,505 Posts
C6 of Year Finalist (performance mods) 2019
Hey wait a minute. Can I get in on this suspension thread with a F55 and Z51 sways? JK
To the OP. Your quest is difficult because you limit yourself to '08 and '09 3lt verts with an M6 and Z51 option. Only about 10% of verts had both the M6 and Z51 option and another 10% had the M6 without Z51. Neither of them are always 3lt equipped. About 30% of verts had the Z51 option with an A6. That leaves 60% with either the base or F55 suspension and an A6.
As far as the performance is concerned, the base with Z51 sways and some better than OEM tires should satisfy the driving experience.
It's a good thing you don't have a color mandate.
To the OP. Your quest is difficult because you limit yourself to '08 and '09 3lt verts with an M6 and Z51 option. Only about 10% of verts had both the M6 and Z51 option and another 10% had the M6 without Z51. Neither of them are always 3lt equipped. About 30% of verts had the Z51 option with an A6. That leaves 60% with either the base or F55 suspension and an A6.
As far as the performance is concerned, the base with Z51 sways and some better than OEM tires should satisfy the driving experience.
It's a good thing you don't have a color mandate.
The following users liked this post:
marinablu67 (11-10-2017)
#16
Team Owner
Member Since: Aug 2006
Posts: 22,997
Received 2,887 Likes
on
1,910 Posts
C6 of Year Finalist (appearance mods) 2019
Hey wait a minute. Can I get in on this suspension thread with a F55 and Z51 sways? JK
To the OP. Your quest is difficult because you limit yourself to '08 and '09 3lt verts with an M6 and Z51 option. Only about 10% of verts had both the M6 and Z51 option and another 10% had the M6 without Z51. Neither of them are always 3lt equipped. About 30% of verts had the Z51 option with an A6. That leaves 60% with either the base or F55 suspension and an A6.
As far as the performance is concerned, the base with Z51 sways and some better than OEM tires should satisfy the driving experience.
It's a good thing you don't have a color mandate.
To the OP. Your quest is difficult because you limit yourself to '08 and '09 3lt verts with an M6 and Z51 option. Only about 10% of verts had both the M6 and Z51 option and another 10% had the M6 without Z51. Neither of them are always 3lt equipped. About 30% of verts had the Z51 option with an A6. That leaves 60% with either the base or F55 suspension and an A6.
As far as the performance is concerned, the base with Z51 sways and some better than OEM tires should satisfy the driving experience.
It's a good thing you don't have a color mandate.
My 07 is a base car. I upgraded the sways to Z06 first. Felt great at normal speeds but unforgiving at their limit. No tell tell signs just a sudden switch of which end was at front.
Changed the rear sway to Z51 spec (fronts are the same for Z06 and Z51). Much better for stock sized tires with advance notice of rear end getting loose. Went with Z06 shocks after trying 4 different makes ( just my preference).
So OP, you can easily and fairly inexpensively change the suspension to Z51 speck. The more expensive change will be the gears and diff gearing.
All things being equal a Z51 should be faster off the line.
Last edited by wayback; 11-10-2017 at 05:36 PM.
#17
Melting Slicks
Member Since: Jul 2010
Location: Tacoma, Wa/Surprise, Az
Posts: 2,849
Received 193 Likes
on
166 Posts
My 07 is a base car. I upgraded the sways to Z06 first. Felt great at normal speeds but unforgiving at their limit. No tell tell signs just a sudden switch of which end was at front.
Changed the rear sway to Z51 spec (fronts are the same for Z06 and Z51). Much better for stock sized tires with advance notice of rear end getting loose. Went with Z06 shocks after trying 4 different makes ( just my preference).
So OP, you can easily and fairly inexpensively change the suspension to Z51 speck. The more expensive change will be the gears and diff gearing.
All things being equal a Z51 should be faster off the line.
I've driven an 09 base coupe Z51 6sp with 19,000 miles on it. Would have bought it if it was a convertible on the spot! I'm finding it extremely difficult finding an 08 and up 3lt z51 6sp convertible with reasonable mileage, and a nice driver car!
I found an 08 base 3lt 6sp convertible with only 17,000 miles on!
It's fully loaded, and has factory navigation, and dual mode exhaust!
Clean Carfax for under $29K. I'm going to look at it tomorrow.
What I would like to know is how much of a difference can I expect from a base minus Z51 package, and the car I already drove?
Will I be disappointed?
I found an 08 base 3lt 6sp convertible with only 17,000 miles on!
It's fully loaded, and has factory navigation, and dual mode exhaust!
Clean Carfax for under $29K. I'm going to look at it tomorrow.
What I would like to know is how much of a difference can I expect from a base minus Z51 package, and the car I already drove?
Will I be disappointed?
#18
Intermediate
Base C6 w/Z51 is a Different Ride
I've driven an 09 base coupe Z51 6sp with 19,000 miles on it. Would have bought it if it was a convertible on the spot! I'm finding it extremely difficult finding an 08 and up 3lt z51 6sp convertible with reasonable mileage, and a nice driver car!
I found an 08 base 3lt 6sp convertible with only 17,000 miles on!
It's fully loaded, and has factory navigation, and dual mode exhaust!
Clean Carfax for under $29K. I'm going to look at it tomorrow.
What I would like to know is how much of a difference can I expect from a base minus Z51 package, and the car I already drove?
Will I be disappointed?
I found an 08 base 3lt 6sp convertible with only 17,000 miles on!
It's fully loaded, and has factory navigation, and dual mode exhaust!
Clean Carfax for under $29K. I'm going to look at it tomorrow.
What I would like to know is how much of a difference can I expect from a base minus Z51 package, and the car I already drove?
Will I be disappointed?
#19
Safety Car
It's all in the feel though. Literally that is IT. There is no way you're pushing the car hard enough on the street (let me guess, you have stock-like tires on it too) to actually have a difference in handling. Both the base and Z51 suspension aren't even remotely working to their limits on the street. IF you are even skilled enough to test those limits, you'd be a moron and endangering your life as well as others even attempting it on the STREET.
Lets put it this way. A base car with a good tire will beat a Z51 with stock rubber (or similar rubber). It's THAT small of a difference. 99% of the population wont do anything to touch the limits of either of the cars.
Again, if you want that FEEL, then go for it. But I promise you that you wont NEED or be missing out on performance if you get a base.
Lets put it this way. A base car with a good tire will beat a Z51 with stock rubber (or similar rubber). It's THAT small of a difference. 99% of the population wont do anything to touch the limits of either of the cars.
Again, if you want that FEEL, then go for it. But I promise you that you wont NEED or be missing out on performance if you get a base.
The Z51 came with stickier tires and has softer rear spring rate than the base.
BTW: You guessed wrong, I do not have the stock size tires or rims.
To each his own.
#20
Race Director
Member Since: Sep 2007
Location: Peoria/Phoenix AZ
Posts: 16,555
Received 2,061 Likes
on
1,505 Posts
C6 of Year Finalist (performance mods) 2019
Your missing my point, the Z51 option doesn't need to be pushed to the limits to feel the difference, if it did it is not worth buying. I test drove both suspensions on the same day back to back. It took the first turn at the speed limit to "feel" the difference, more responsive and no body roll.
The Z51 came with stickier tires and has softer rear spring rate than the base.
BTW: You guessed wrong, I do not have the stock size tires or rims.
To each his own.
The Z51 came with stickier tires and has softer rear spring rate than the base.
BTW: You guessed wrong, I do not have the stock size tires or rims.
To each his own.
However, once you change one suspension part, including tires, the whole balance changes and not always for the better. The surprising part to me about spring rates is that the Z51 option and a GS use the same springs, but have significantly different tires and weight.
Spring Rates for C6
factory Front/Rear:
base 420/657
z51 525/645
GS 525/645
z06 531/782
T1 racing 582/850
The following users liked this post:
FortMorganAl (11-12-2017)