[Z06] pretty disenchanted with my z
#41
Race Director
If Lexus can do it why can't GM?
Oh, wait. Its a performance car so it should come from the factory with flaws. So, that the purchaser can have a better inner race car driver experience.
Racers understand things break.
I think things like the ashtray and roof shouldnt happen on any $70k+ car, period.
Oh, wait. Its a performance car so it should come from the factory with flaws. So, that the purchaser can have a better inner race car driver experience.
Racers understand things break.
I think things like the ashtray and roof shouldnt happen on any $70k+ car, period.
#42
Le Mans Master
Apparently all you that criticize the problems with the Z06 run a perfect life and companies you work for must cherish and pay you well for no mistakes. I've been in Manufacturing for many years and I can't remember ever working with anyone waking up in the morning planning to do a bad job full of mistakes that day. I have worked with people and including myself make mistakes now and then, it happens. Or do the Lexus workers work error free while the Corvette guys screw up
#43
Le Mans Master
Member Since: Oct 2005
Location: Fallston Maryland
Posts: 6,635
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Apparently all you that criticize the problems with the Z06 run a perfect life and companies you work for must cherish and pay you well for no mistakes. I've been in Manufacturing for many years and I can't remember ever working with anyone waking up in the morning planning to do a bad job full of mistakes that day. I have worked with people and including myself make mistakes now and then, it happens. Or do the Lexus workers work error free while the Corvette guys screw up
Many small businesses are very successful even though they are not the best. If they understand customer service, they will then maintain a value perception.
The whole Lexus thing is interesting. They spend a lot of effort kissing your a** at the service department. They understand that is where it ends. If they maintain the perception by emotions, They Win!
#45
Melting Slicks
I'm not crazy about this, I love the car. But I'm not indifferent to it either, and I'm not excusing GM. As for the people that imply this is expecting perfection from the line workers, it isn't. Fact is though, these things aren't one time occurrences. They're common, and they are failures in quality control. That makes GM look bad, and it hurts them. They are now no longer the #1 automaker in the world in sales. Is that because they don't know how to build a performance car? Of course not. While I realize there are a lot of reasons for this, lack of quality is one of them. If we give them a mulligan for these dumb problems, they will be less motivated to fix them, and the cycle will continue.
#46
Drifting
Member Since: Mar 2004
Location: Chandler AZ
Posts: 1,749
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Foosh, while I understand and generally agree with you, most of the probs I hear about from other makes are a little easier to swallow. A roof panel flying off is a pretty dramatic thing as is drivetrain noises and failures. I would gladly trade a sensor failure or a power window module blowing out than either one of those two things. Reliability ratings do not isolate specific problems, they only count the incidences.
I have had some problematic cars, Mercedes in particular, but they never left me stranded or had any major failures of drivetrain or components. While I no longer drive them and thought the same probably worse of Mercedes, it would be very hypocritical to wave off these problems on the Vette that leave the car inoperable even though in truth I really like it and am very happy to see GM so successful with the car.
I do think GM is taking this stuff seriouysly and while they appear to be slow to react, I think they are making substantially better cars.
Last edited by 05C6spdvert; 04-30-2007 at 09:01 PM.
#47
I'm not crazy about this, I love the car. But I'm not indifferent to it either, and I'm not excusing GM. As for the people that imply this is expecting perfection from the line workers, it isn't. Fact is though, these things aren't one time occurrences. They're common, and they are failures in quality control. That makes GM look bad, and it hurts them. They are now no longer the #1 automaker in the world in sales. Is that because they don't know how to build a performance car? Of course not. While I realize there are a lot of reasons for this, lack of quality is one of them. If we give them a mulligan for these dumb problems, they will be less motivated to fix them, and the cycle will continue.
What are the other "dumb problems?" Roof? Clutch packs? Shifter rattle?
On the roof, yes GM pushed the envelope in number of places to save weight. Every weight-saving component matters on an entire car. People here are fond of punishing them for it (see also hatch pull-down threads). They went to a new roof material, tried to bond it to the light weight aluminum structure, and got burned..........bad GM. I give them points for trying to save weight. They learned a lesson and went back to a tried and true heavier SMC formula. There are tens of thousands of cars with perfectly fine polycarbonate roofs, going on 3 years, but the failure rate was unacceptable, and they admitted it. Just for the record, I've heard of fewer than 5 roofs here actually flying off, for the hysterical crowd.
However, I'd rather have them continue to try to explore the performance envelope on the Corvette line. Porsches does. Ferrari does. Lambo does. BMW does. Mercedes does. They've all made mistakes in the process. Was it dumb? Not according to my definition.
On the clutch packs, remarks of the hysterical poster several posts above notwithstanding, we're not talking about "transmission failure." We're talking about a noise that only occurs below 5mph, when the differential fluid is cold, and when performing a very tight turn. Wow................ It has nothing to do with the functionality of the differential or transmission, and can be left alone forever! Some people would rather toss out a proven design that can handle a supercar levels of torque, so they can have Lexus quiet at 5mph on a tight turn, with skinny tires. The laws of unintended consequences apply here, and if people here want to see differential failure, tossing out a bullet proof diff. that happens to make a little noise under very arcane circumstances with very fat tires is insane.
On the shifter **** noise, see paragraph above.
The reason for comparing the Z06 to other performance cars is that they get abused more often, by definition. People buying Camry, Lexus and Honda don't tend to beat up those cars. Duh...........
What are the other "dumb problems?" And BTW, the reason GM is not #1 is that most people want a cheaper, better econo-box. Toyota delivers that very nicely, with considerably lower labor rates and cost-structure. They are relatively new to the U.S. Check back in 30 years, and some other country will be kicking Japan out of the U.S. Korea is working on it.
However, this is a "performance car" forum.
Last edited by Foosh; 04-30-2007 at 09:16 PM.
#48
Melting Slicks
#49
Melting Slicks
As I've said, the ashtray is a dumb problem, and also a trivial one.....bad GM!
What are the other "dumb problems?" Roof? Clutch packs? Shifter rattle?
On the roof, yes GM pushed the envelope in number of places to save weight. Every weight-saving component matters on an entire car. People here are fond of punishing them for it (see also hatch pull-down threads). They went to a new roof material, tried to bond it to the light weight aluminum structure, and got burned..........bad GM. I give them points for trying to save weight. They learned a lesson and went back to a tried and true heavier SMC formula. There are tens of thousands of cars with perfectly fine polycarbonate roofs, going on 3 years, but the failure rate was unacceptable, and they admitted it. Just for the record, I've heard of fewer than 5 roofs here actually flying off, for the hysterical crowd.
However, I'd rather have them continue to try to explore the performance envelope on the Corvette line. Porsches does. Ferrari does. Lambo does. BMW does. Mercedes does. They've all made mistakes in the process. Was it dumb? Not according to my definition.
On the clutch packs, remarks of the hysterical poster several posts above notwithstanding, we're not talking about "transmission failure." We're talking about a noise that only occurs below 5mph, when the differential fluid is cold, and when performing a very tight turn. Wow................ It has nothing to do with the functionality of the differential or transmission, and can be left alone forever! Some people would rather toss out a proven design that can handle a supercar levels of torque, so they can have Lexus quiet at 5mph on a tight turn, with skinny tires. The laws of unintended consequences apply here, and if people here want to see differential failure, tossing out a bullet proof diff. that happens to make a little noise under very arcane circumstances with very fat tires is insane.
On the shifter **** noise, see paragraph above.
What are the other "dumb problems?"
What are the other "dumb problems?" Roof? Clutch packs? Shifter rattle?
On the roof, yes GM pushed the envelope in number of places to save weight. Every weight-saving component matters on an entire car. People here are fond of punishing them for it (see also hatch pull-down threads). They went to a new roof material, tried to bond it to the light weight aluminum structure, and got burned..........bad GM. I give them points for trying to save weight. They learned a lesson and went back to a tried and true heavier SMC formula. There are tens of thousands of cars with perfectly fine polycarbonate roofs, going on 3 years, but the failure rate was unacceptable, and they admitted it. Just for the record, I've heard of fewer than 5 roofs here actually flying off, for the hysterical crowd.
However, I'd rather have them continue to try to explore the performance envelope on the Corvette line. Porsches does. Ferrari does. Lambo does. BMW does. Mercedes does. They've all made mistakes in the process. Was it dumb? Not according to my definition.
On the clutch packs, remarks of the hysterical poster several posts above notwithstanding, we're not talking about "transmission failure." We're talking about a noise that only occurs below 5mph, when the differential fluid is cold, and when performing a very tight turn. Wow................ It has nothing to do with the functionality of the differential or transmission, and can be left alone forever! Some people would rather toss out a proven design that can handle a supercar levels of torque, so they can have Lexus quiet at 5mph on a tight turn, with skinny tires. The laws of unintended consequences apply here, and if people here want to see differential failure, tossing out a bullet proof diff. that happens to make a little noise under very arcane circumstances with very fat tires is insane.
On the shifter **** noise, see paragraph above.
What are the other "dumb problems?"
In my case, a driver's seat that creaks whenever I move, gaps between interior panels, some stereo issues (like it blows). I hear what you're saying Foosh, and the car is wonderful. Still, for something in this price range, quality should be better. Period.
#50
Race Director
Member Since: Nov 2004
Location: Kick "A" then takin' a nap
Posts: 10,064
Received 755 Likes
on
306 Posts
Apparently all you that criticize the problems with the Z06 run a perfect life and companies you work for must cherish and pay you well for no mistakes. I've been in Manufacturing for many years and I can't remember ever working with anyone waking up in the morning planning to do a bad job full of mistakes that day. I have worked with people and including myself make mistakes now and then, it happens. Or do the Lexus workers work error free while the Corvette guys screw up
By the way, Good debate never hurts anything. It will only make cars better if the company will listen. This is why Dodge sits down with its owners group once a year and asks for their in put as to the production of the Viper. This is why certain colors (popular colors) will not be on the '08, to keep the value of those cars in that selection higher.
Last edited by BlaznZ06; 04-30-2007 at 09:23 PM.
#51
Ken, that wasn't the point...believe me I hold GM accountable for their stuff. My point was they spent the $$ where it counts...on hand built race engines for the street and not on exotic leather ashtrays.
#52
Le Mans Master
Member Since: Oct 2005
Location: Fallston Maryland
Posts: 6,635
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
One thing for sure, all cars have problems. They wouldn't have service departments if they didn't. They only have an in house Jiffy lube.
#53
06Z vs. 07Z
I had the roof replaced on my 06Z with the new panel and the job was perfect. The diff noise is a common problem that Vettes have had for years. My 73' did the same thing way back then. They have a fix for it, either change out the fluid or replace the clutch packs with the up dated part number. I did both of these as well and the new part number performed perfectly until the time I traded for a 07Z. The ash door on my car was fine. Its a great car, don't let a few minor issues make you dislike the car. First years are famous for these issues and the best part is they are all under warranty!
#55
I guess you forgot that the valves dropping and toasting the engine is "OK" for a performance car bargain.
Bargains are a bargain if you get your moneys worth.
Stop making excuses for sub standard manufacturing.
They need to get it right and it's clear why they are now the second largest auto maker on the planet.
I love Vettes as much as anyone of you. Have spent countless hours building and modding them.
GM get your act together
Shifters, Half Shafts, Roofs, Water Pumps, Valves, Ash Trays, etc....what a bargain. Phaleeeeeeze.
Bargains are a bargain if you get your moneys worth.
Stop making excuses for sub standard manufacturing.
They need to get it right and it's clear why they are now the second largest auto maker on the planet.
I love Vettes as much as anyone of you. Have spent countless hours building and modding them.
GM get your act together
Shifters, Half Shafts, Roofs, Water Pumps, Valves, Ash Trays, etc....what a bargain. Phaleeeeeeze.
#57
Drifting
Member Since: Mar 2004
Location: Chandler AZ
Posts: 1,749
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
#58
Le Mans Master
I guess you forgot that the valves dropping and toasting the engine is "OK" for a performance car bargain.
Bargains are a bargain if you get your moneys worth.
Stop making excuses for sub standard manufacturing.
They need to get it right and it's clear why they are now the second largest auto maker on the planet.
I love Vettes as much as anyone of you. Have spent countless hours building and modding them.
GM get your act together
Shifters, Half Shafts, Roofs, Water Pumps, Valves, Ash Trays, etc....what a bargain. Phaleeeeeeze.
Bargains are a bargain if you get your moneys worth.
Stop making excuses for sub standard manufacturing.
They need to get it right and it's clear why they are now the second largest auto maker on the planet.
I love Vettes as much as anyone of you. Have spent countless hours building and modding them.
GM get your act together
Shifters, Half Shafts, Roofs, Water Pumps, Valves, Ash Trays, etc....what a bargain. Phaleeeeeeze.
#59
Melting Slicks
Member Since: Jan 2007
Location: SOUTHERN CALI - Most of the time California
Posts: 2,749
Likes: 0
Received 2 Likes
on
2 Posts
First off... I love my Z06
Always been a big fan of German sports cars, they build excellent quality cars (to some extent)
I still love my Z06
My Vette is built by GM , but I love me Z06
Does the vette have issues, yes, there is a lot more I could add to the list (fenders popping out, interior panels poping)
I still love my Z06
My logic, it's a beast and I love what it has to offer, what I don't like, I modify... I have changed parts of the interior for better quality
But it does not bother me, I got a killer car for the money,
I have changed lots of parts of the car and will change a lot more, to custom it the way I want, that is the best part of having a muscle car..
The car has minor issues, and like many have said, if has too much to offer than to go crazy on small issues, if GM charged an extra $10k for better quality, I would pay it....
but I still love my Z06
I just got back from a two day event at the track It felt so good to kill almost ever car out there, and it was so fun to drive, it's an animal
I wish the thread starter the best of luck and hope you resolve your issues and enjoy the beast and appreciate what it has to offer, be carefull
A toast to all other Z06 owners and pride of ownership
Always been a big fan of German sports cars, they build excellent quality cars (to some extent)
I still love my Z06
My Vette is built by GM , but I love me Z06
Does the vette have issues, yes, there is a lot more I could add to the list (fenders popping out, interior panels poping)
I still love my Z06
My logic, it's a beast and I love what it has to offer, what I don't like, I modify... I have changed parts of the interior for better quality
But it does not bother me, I got a killer car for the money,
I have changed lots of parts of the car and will change a lot more, to custom it the way I want, that is the best part of having a muscle car..
The car has minor issues, and like many have said, if has too much to offer than to go crazy on small issues, if GM charged an extra $10k for better quality, I would pay it....
but I still love my Z06
I just got back from a two day event at the track It felt so good to kill almost ever car out there, and it was so fun to drive, it's an animal
I wish the thread starter the best of luck and hope you resolve your issues and enjoy the beast and appreciate what it has to offer, be carefull
A toast to all other Z06 owners and pride of ownership