Whats up with all these "WCCH Heads Shot" treads all of a sudden
#1
Drifting
Thread Starter
Whats up with all these "WCCH Heads Shot" treads all of a sudden
Did they have a bad batch? What's going on with them?
#3
To elaborate on what 03BlkZ said, its also a combination of improper rocker arm concentricity (some LS7 heads, not all), too aggressive of a cam profile, improper valve AND valve guide material... I could be wrong though.
#4
Drifting
Fixed heads do not fix the geometry issue. The best fix is roller rockers and fixed heads.
The following users liked this post:
~STOLEN~ (04-11-2018)
#5
Melting Slicks
i think it will happen on every set of heads eventually, fixed not fixed, no one is free from the problem.
#7
Team Owner
There's more to the story than just "WCCH heads". I have every bit of confidence that my AHP/MS90 heads with stock cam, stock rockers with live to see 100K miles or more. Do I think WCCH heads can do that as well given the same parameters...yes. Start changing variables to the equation, and I would expect there will be a different outcome.
#9
Melting Slicks
Member Since: Nov 2002
Location: North shore,Ma./Naples Florida
Posts: 3,059
Received 272 Likes
on
144 Posts
There's more to the story than just "WCCH heads". I have every bit of confidence that my AHP/MS90 heads with stock cam, stock rockers with live to see 100K miles or more. Do I think WCCH heads can do that as well given the same parameters...yes. Start changing variables to the equation, and I would expect there will be a different outcome.
Anyway I still have not found any threads pointing to the above stated heads coming back with bad wear issues yet as I have been seeing with the WCCH heads with bronze guides. I really feel this issue would have been completely solved by now if everyone didn’t mod the hell out of the car when re doing the heads.
I still can’t understand however why Katech is not using MS90 guides though if they are as good as they are supposed to be and why they still continue on with the bronze guides.
#10
Team Owner
Because it is more complex than just swapping heads.
Can WCCH be a good long term fix, yes, with ther proper setup.
Roller rockers are not needed, fancy guides are not needed. Unless you have a setup that does need them. People are finding out that you can't just run a huge aggressive cam and think because heads are "fixed" that guides won't wear.
Now if your concern is valve drop, and you did some upgrades valves, then yes, they are probably fixed, and the only concern is really if you may burn some oil as they get extremely out of spec.
Can WCCH be a good long term fix, yes, with ther proper setup.
Roller rockers are not needed, fancy guides are not needed. Unless you have a setup that does need them. People are finding out that you can't just run a huge aggressive cam and think because heads are "fixed" that guides won't wear.
Now if your concern is valve drop, and you did some upgrades valves, then yes, they are probably fixed, and the only concern is really if you may burn some oil as they get extremely out of spec.
The following users liked this post:
FSTFRC (04-12-2018)
#11
Team Owner
This is pretty much what I have been thinking also. Everyone seems to want to start throwing higher lift cams, milling, retuning etc when they do the heads so it is near impossible to get a reading on what’s really going on. Then I have heard lately that there were actually two companies manufacturing these heads and one was good geometry and the other not? Not sure about that one.
Anyway I still have not found any threads pointing to the above stated heads coming back with bad wear issues yet as I have been seeing with the WCCH heads with bronze guides. I really feel this issue would have been completely solved by now if everyone didn’t mod the hell out of the car when re doing the heads.
I still can’t understand however why Katech is not using MS90 guides though if they are as good as they are supposed to be and why they still continue on with the bronze guides.
Anyway I still have not found any threads pointing to the above stated heads coming back with bad wear issues yet as I have been seeing with the WCCH heads with bronze guides. I really feel this issue would have been completely solved by now if everyone didn’t mod the hell out of the car when re doing the heads.
I still can’t understand however why Katech is not using MS90 guides though if they are as good as they are supposed to be and why they still continue on with the bronze guides.
#13
Burning Brakes
#14
Burning Brakes
Fact of the matter is no one knows what the main issues are so I don't see how you can say bronze guides are fine if setup properly. What exactly is this magical bronze guide setup you speak of so more people can try it?
Last edited by rio95; 04-12-2018 at 12:58 AM.
#16
Drifting
Thread Starter
I put more than 30k mile on my old Z06 after the "fix" and Brian Tooley recommends to change the BTR platinums after 25k miles. So I replaced them after 30k and checked the guides and everything checked out good. I had Frankenstein Heads.
#17
Melting Slicks
Member Since: Jun 2005
Location: Rochester NY
Posts: 2,734
Received 1,678 Likes
on
878 Posts
2018 C6 of Year Finalist
St. Jude Donor '10, '17
WCCH used bronze guides in 2009/2010 when they started replacing the guides and fixing LS7 heads. GM did not let them just purchase new replacement OEM guides (which would have been fine). They would have to purchase an entire head just to get the guides they wanted. So they were forced to go to bronze as it was the only after market solution they could find at the time. Richard has gone on record stating that he did not desire to do that, but had no choice. This is not to say bronze guides won't work, but let's not pretend that they intentionally chose bronze over another superior material. It was the only choice they had, so bronze is what you get (and they have stuck with it).
Richard stated 7 years ago this, and I quote:
"The primarly reason we use bronze valve guides is because GM will not sell the guides separately. Rather they will sell you an entire replacement head. The aftermarket parts supply only furnishes bronze alloy valve guides. I personally like the powdered metal valve guides the factory uses but the supplier does not sell piece meal to the public. Additionally we have no long term wear issues with the bronze guides and solid stem stainless steel valves."
Richard stated 7 years ago this, and I quote:
"The primarly reason we use bronze valve guides is because GM will not sell the guides separately. Rather they will sell you an entire replacement head. The aftermarket parts supply only furnishes bronze alloy valve guides. I personally like the powdered metal valve guides the factory uses but the supplier does not sell piece meal to the public. Additionally we have no long term wear issues with the bronze guides and solid stem stainless steel valves."
Last edited by Mordeth; 04-12-2018 at 07:59 AM.
#18
Drifting
WCCH used bronze guides in 2009/2010 when they started replacing the guides and fixing LS7 heads. GM did not let them just purchase new replacement OEM guides (which would have been fine). They would have to purchase an entire head just to get the guides they wanted. So they were forced to go to bronze as it was the only after market solution they could find at the time. Richard has gone on record stating that he did not desire to do that, but had no choice. This is not to say bronze guides won't work, but let's not pretend that they intentionally chose bronze over another superior material. It was the only choice they had, so bronze is what you get (and they have stuck with it).
Richard stated 7 years ago this, and I quote:
"The primarly reason we use bronze valve guides is because GM will not sell the guides separately. Rather they will sell you an entire replacement head. The aftermarket parts supply only furnishes bronze alloy valve guides. I personally like the powdered metal valve guides the factory uses but the supplier does not sell piece meal to the public. Additionally we have no long term wear issues with the bronze guides and solid stem stainless steel valves."
Richard stated 7 years ago this, and I quote:
"The primarly reason we use bronze valve guides is because GM will not sell the guides separately. Rather they will sell you an entire replacement head. The aftermarket parts supply only furnishes bronze alloy valve guides. I personally like the powdered metal valve guides the factory uses but the supplier does not sell piece meal to the public. Additionally we have no long term wear issues with the bronze guides and solid stem stainless steel valves."
Neat from an engineering perspective, not to mention a cool move from a business perspective as well.
Last edited by BigVette427; 04-12-2018 at 08:53 AM.
#19
Drifting
After reading what a good amount of people had said on the other threads I figured RR’s were the way to go? Owell, I guess that is also a myth?
#20
Drifting
But the point was that when they fresh from WCCH, they were concentric and in spec. The combination that was then run for 10k miles tells the story. As Jason from Katech points out, if you're running bronze guides without the Ti/Mo valves, standby for disappointment.