Benefits between manufacturers
#1
Instructor
Thread Starter
Benefits between manufacturers
So I'm new to supercharging - been reading a bit here and there online. The Corvette platform benefits from numerous manufacturers of bolt on SC's ... that's a good thing, given that these are fairly expensive i would hate to make a mistake therefore looking for suggestions from folks who have already done this and what your opinions are in regards to the various platforms of SC units - Procharger vs Whipple vs Edelbrock vs Magnuson...?
I see one of the Vendors on here is having a sale on some of these units and a fellow at RDP Victor claims that the Edelbrock is the way to go any idea on this ...?
Please comment thanks
I see one of the Vendors on here is having a sale on some of these units and a fellow at RDP Victor claims that the Edelbrock is the way to go any idea on this ...?
Please comment thanks
#2
I think you need to first figure out which type of blower you want, PD or centrifugal. Different power delivery. Then you can narrow it down to manufacturer. Tuning is as important as the type as well.
I went with an ECS , meth, headers setup. I also have the benefit of having ECS near me.
I went with an ECS , meth, headers setup. I also have the benefit of having ECS near me.
The following users liked this post:
DOUG @ ECS (04-11-2018)
#3
I think you need to first figure out which type of blower you want, PD or centrifugal. Different power delivery. Then you can narrow it down to manufacturer. Tuning is as important as the type as well.
I went with an ECS , meth, headers setup. I also have the benefit of having ECS near me.
I went with an ECS , meth, headers setup. I also have the benefit of having ECS near me.
I would not personally choose any besides those two but im happy with my ECS because my engine bay looks "kinda" stock and living in california having a procharger with a huge air intake is a dead give away to hood popping happy cops. ECS is a smooth power delivery while procharger dynos look like they come in more like turbo power towards the end.
The following users liked this post:
DOUG @ ECS (04-11-2018)
#5
I have also been told the Eforce is the most reliable and the best complete kit available by more than one forum vendor on here. One of them happens to sell and install just about every option. RDP sells more than Eforce btw. Steve at RDP is a great resource and honest vendor. The Eforce is defenitely not the cheapest option and is $2k more than Procharger, ECS etc.
The following users liked this post:
RDP Store (04-18-2018)
#6
Instructor
Thread Starter
So I have a local speed shop here in my area who will do Stainless Works long tubes, high flow cats, X pipe for a very, very, very good price - also, doing ECS kit for $5400 thought that was a tad high - any thoughts...?
Also, what should an average install cost approx for both these units...?
Thoughts on the best CAI for C7 StingRay ...?
Also, what should an average install cost approx for both these units...?
Thoughts on the best CAI for C7 StingRay ...?
The following users liked this post:
DOUG @ ECS (04-11-2018)
The following users liked this post:
DOUG @ ECS (04-11-2018)
#8
Sounds like based on your last post you are leaning toward a centrifugal. The big three A&A, ECS and Procharger are quality units. If you think you might want more power in the future I would opt for the larger head unit offered. A&A would be a TI, Procharger would be the D1X. These two are similar to the base head unit 1500 ECS offers. This is one of the reasons you see dyno differences between the manufactures because it is not a apples to apples comparison.
The following users liked this post:
DOUG @ ECS (04-11-2018)
#9
Premium Supporting Vendor
Member Since: Oct 2004
Location: Providing the most proven supercharger kits for your C5/6/7 609-752-0321
Posts: 23,314
Received 1,084 Likes
on
656 Posts
Sounds like based on your last post you are leaning toward a centrifugal. The big three A&A, ECS and Procharger are quality units. If you think you might want more power in the future I would opt for the larger head unit offered. A&A would be a TI, Procharger would be the D1X. These two are similar to the base head unit 1500 ECS offers. This is one of the reasons you see dyno differences between the manufactures because it is not a apples to apples comparison.
I'm glad that it is known that we start with the larger head unit with our base kit, we feel it "fits" better and obviously is more upgradable down the line.
Thank you to those with our supercharger kit or considering it, we greatly appreciate it!
__________________
C5/C6 and C7 Supercharging Specialist
ECS Supercharger Kits / Mantic Clutches
www.EastCoastSupercharging.com
Facebook Page
ECS YouTube Channel
C5/C6 and C7 Supercharging Specialist
ECS Supercharger Kits / Mantic Clutches
www.EastCoastSupercharging.com
Facebook Page
ECS YouTube Channel
#10
Former Vendor
We use the ECS Novi 1500 kits primarily on vehicles like yours looking for a good jump in power at a value. The kits are extremely high quality with literally everything needed for a complete install and work very well on stock or lightly modified cars. The restrictor plate design works well also in keeping mid-range torque, and the ability to upgrade to a larger head unit for more power down the road is very simple with their systems. You really can't go wrong with any of them, but for a bang for the buck setup the ECS gets my vote
The following users liked this post:
Chazzmania (04-12-2018)
#11
Pro
I am pretty much in your same shoes right now. I have Kook LT's with catless mid pipe, halltech CAI, and MSD intake manifold. I have been throwing the idea around of doing a cam and supercharger kit. I have heard great things about the ECS Kit and Procharger Kits. A lot of people swear by the ECS kits and a lot of shops speak highly of them. I think when the time comes that's the kit I will choose. Especially the simple head upgrade, cause we all know you always want more power eventually. Also what is the totally cost for the kit and install at your local shop plus tuning. Is 5400 just the cost for the kit?
#13
The A&A kit is fantastic and comes with the Innovators West balancer while the others don’t. The was the selling point for me. Installation is very easy and I was very impressed with the entire kit. Make sure you get the Ti and not the Si (same price) as you are likely gonna want more psi at some point in the future. A&A support is great and they answer the phone at all hours if you ever need help.
#14
I'm Batman..
Pro Mechanic
Member Since: Apr 2014
Location: Lehigh Acres FL
Posts: 6,130
Received 908 Likes
on
561 Posts
Tech Contributor
The A&A kit is fantastic and comes with the Innovators West balancer while the others don’t. The was the selling point for me. Installation is very easy and I was very impressed with the entire kit. Make sure you get the Ti and not the Si (same price) as you are likely gonna want more psi at some point in the future. A&A support is great and they answer the phone at all hours if you ever need help.
Ant
#15
I have also been told the Eforce is the most reliable and the best complete kit available by more than one forum vendor on here. One of them happens to sell and install just about every option. RDP sells more than Eforce btw. Steve at RDP is a great resource and honest vendor. The Eforce is defenitely not the cheapest option and is $2k more than Procharger, ECS etc.
#16
So I have a local speed shop here in my area who will do Stainless Works long tubes, high flow cats, X pipe for a very, very, very good price - also, doing ECS kit for $5400 thought that was a tad high - any thoughts...?
Also, what should an average install cost approx for both these units...?
Thoughts on the best CAI for C7 StingRay ...?
Also, what should an average install cost approx for both these units...?
Thoughts on the best CAI for C7 StingRay ...?
Put a base kit on it and leave it for ~560-600 rwhp?
Do some track days but want a bit more power and worried about cooling?
Do 580 rwhp now but hope for more in the near future?
Maybe move to california?
Ability to easily return car to stock without having to re-buy parts?
Want a smooth linear powerband that screams up top?
Want a torque shove at 2k rpm + meaty tires to handle it?
All these questions will define which kit to use.