Tadge explains why 6 vs 8 speed auto...
#22
DRC--- A person can post a message very clearly and yet it seems people don't read it or don't understand it. In my post #9 I clearly said that me Z4 runs at 2,000 to 2,300 at 70 MPH. I do not drive a Honda S2000. My Z4 does not operate at 8 or 9,000 RPM. My Z4 is in storage at this time, but I will check my rpm's at 70 MPH the next time I get it out.
Why is it that GM seems to be one of the few without an 8 speed auto tarns? Most premium brands have an 8 speed auto. GM's Cadillac XTS does not. Everything else in the XTS is new and very nice. GM just simply didn't get it done. The mags are bringing up the lack of an 8 speed.
Why is it that GM seems to be one of the few without an 8 speed auto tarns? Most premium brands have an 8 speed auto. GM's Cadillac XTS does not. Everything else in the XTS is new and very nice. GM just simply didn't get it done. The mags are bringing up the lack of an 8 speed.
#23
Le Mans Master
DRC--- A person can post a message very clearly and yet it seems people don't read it or don't understand it. In my post #9 I clearly said that me Z4 runs at 2,000 to 2,300 at 70 MPH. I do not drive a Honda S2000. My Z4 does not operate at 8 or 9,000 RPM. My Z4 is in storage at this time, but I will check my rpm's at 70 MPH the next time I get it out.
Why is it that GM seems to be one of the few without an 8 speed auto tarns? Most premium brands have an 8 speed auto. GM's Cadillac XTS does not. Everything else in the XTS is new and very nice. GM just simply didn't get it done. The mags are bringing up the lack of an 8 speed.
Why is it that GM seems to be one of the few without an 8 speed auto tarns? Most premium brands have an 8 speed auto. GM's Cadillac XTS does not. Everything else in the XTS is new and very nice. GM just simply didn't get it done. The mags are bringing up the lack of an 8 speed.
#25
Racer
Member Since: Dec 2012
Location: Espoo, Finland
Posts: 346
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Ford is developing the 10 gear automatic for GM and Ford 2wd cars: http://www.autoblog.com/2012/10/01/f...eed-gearboxes/
#26
My 2012 BMW Z4 with the 4 cyl turbo engine and 8 speed auto trans runs about 2,000 to 2,200 RPM at 70 MPH. It is not "wound up" by any means. When I go from comfort mode to sport the RPM's increase about 300 or so. On a recent rally of 200 to 300 miles all of it at altitude, I got around 40 MPG. That's one of the benifits of an 8 speed auto transmission. Of course the Vette doesn't need no stinking 8 speed. That's good because you don't have one avaliable.
GM is behind the 8 ball once again.
Vehicles that currently have an 8 speed auto transmission include. BMW 5 6 and 7 series. Lexus LS series. BMW X5. Jaguar F roadster 8 speed auto. INfinity IR G coupe 7 speed auto.
If you don't have an 8 speed auto, and ev erybody else does, then you have to say something like we don't need it.
GM is behind the 8 ball once again.
Vehicles that currently have an 8 speed auto transmission include. BMW 5 6 and 7 series. Lexus LS series. BMW X5. Jaguar F roadster 8 speed auto. INfinity IR G coupe 7 speed auto.
If you don't have an 8 speed auto, and ev erybody else does, then you have to say something like we don't need it.
A lot of programs got put on hold or canceled during GM's reconstruction. The 8 speed auto was one of them. That being said, I'll be surprised if its not in the new CTS coming out this spring.
#28
Drifting
Member Since: Feb 2002
Location: Chapel Hill NC
Posts: 1,260
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Interesting
Also the he said they cant find an auto trans that can plug and play with Corvettes HUGE amount of torque? I thought it was 450 lbs of torque? I see several automatic trans handling much more torque than 450 my CTS V for one? Unless it is a fitment issue or maybe it will have much more than 450lbs of torque?
#29
Yes! At least my tranny isn't out of date! Just my car.
Seriously, 99% of my driving could be done in just 2nd gear. They could have a direct drive and I wouldn't even notice.
I noticed in the 7 spd DCT it tends to jump all over the place. You can't feel it but man it must wear out parts quicker with so much going on.
Seriously, 99% of my driving could be done in just 2nd gear. They could have a direct drive and I wouldn't even notice.
I noticed in the 7 spd DCT it tends to jump all over the place. You can't feel it but man it must wear out parts quicker with so much going on.
#30
Le Mans Master
There's tons of other improvements and we don't know for a fact what the MPG will be until real users get them on the road.....and great MPG in a Corvette is just "low hanging fruit" if you will...IMO all other performance aspects take precedence. It would be odd to hear that someone bought a Corvette only because it got great gas mileage.
#31
Le Mans Master
#32
Race Director
While he dismisses the 8-speed auto and states the 6-speed auto is sufficient, then how could he also support their decision to abandon the 6-speed manual to go with a 7-speed manual?
Apparently they feel more gears are better if you look at the change to the manual transmission. It sounds like he's just covering for GM not having a DC or new/better offering for the automatic over the existing A6.
Anyone know what the shift times are for the A6 in the C6? I wasn't aware there was an improvement to such in 2012.
Apparently they feel more gears are better if you look at the change to the manual transmission. It sounds like he's just covering for GM not having a DC or new/better offering for the automatic over the existing A6.
Anyone know what the shift times are for the A6 in the C6? I wasn't aware there was an improvement to such in 2012.
I do wish he would just say what we all KNOW, that the GM 8 speed auto isn't ready yet.
In the end, I will order a manual (like always), but the automotive press sure didn't do him any favors with the Aisin 8 speed auto rumor, since almost 3/4ths of Corvettes are ordered with automatics.
Jimmy
#33
Racer
Member Since: Dec 2012
Location: Espoo, Finland
Posts: 346
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
#34
Race Director
Thread Starter
#35
AIR FORCE VETERAN
With big torque you do not need more gears. The drag racing Corvettes use the 4 speed automatic. My C5 equipped with 3:15 gears, an LS3 and four speed automatic has not lost to a 6 speed automatic Vet. But I have not raced yours so I concede yours is faster before you tell me that. I run on the street heads up for money so your not going to get me to tell you my et. Great interview thanks to all who brought it to this thread.
#36
Pro
Member Since: Feb 2002
Location: ATLANTIC HIGHLANDS NJ
Posts: 675
Likes: 0
Received 26 Likes
on
18 Posts
DRC--- A person can post a message very clearly and yet it seems people don't read it or don't understand it. In my post #9 I clearly said that me Z4 runs at 2,000 to 2,300 at 70 MPH. I do not drive a Honda S2000. My Z4 does not operate at 8 or 9,000 RPM. My Z4 is in storage at this time, but I will check my rpm's at 70 MPH the next time I get it out.
Why is it that GM seems to be one of the few without an 8 speed auto tarns? Most premium brands have an 8 speed auto. GM's Cadillac XTS does not. Everything else in the XTS is new and very nice. GM just simply didn't get it done. The mags are bringing up the lack of an 8 speed.
Why is it that GM seems to be one of the few without an 8 speed auto tarns? Most premium brands have an 8 speed auto. GM's Cadillac XTS does not. Everything else in the XTS is new and very nice. GM just simply didn't get it done. The mags are bringing up the lack of an 8 speed.
But, Tadge was quite clear I thought, said an 8 speed is heavier, costlier, and in testing suggested the 6 speed held up better, said with a wide band of torque the 6 speed did the job well.
GM just simply did not get it done? Good Lord buddy, aluminum frame, carbon fiber hood / roof, all info suggests the most fuel effecient 450 HP (maybe more) engine in the world, launch control, take it to the drag track of road race track, beat the crap out of it and your 100,000 mile warranty is in tact, probably costs in the mid 50's, etc., etc.
Get a piece of paper and a pencil and make a list of all the cars on the planet that accomplish the above. Hint: You won't need a very big piece of paper.
#37
Le Mans Master
With big torque you do not need more gears. The drag racing Corvettes use the 4 speed automatic. My C5 equipped with 3:15 gears, an LS3 and four speed automatic has not lost to a 6 speed automatic Vet. But I have not raced yours so I concede yours is faster before you tell me that. I run on the street heads up for money so your not going to get me to tell you my et. Great interview thanks to all who brought it to this thread.
#38
Le Mans Master
The trans for the Corvette mounts to the front of the rear axel. What is needed is a transmission, in production, that can handle the torque and that can be mounted in that position. From "All Corvettes are Red" you'll learn that a transmission that is designed for four wheel drive meets the mounting requirement with minor mods. So, GM needs to have a four wheel drive automatic transmission in production that can handle 450 lbs of torque and better that the Vett team can modify for Corvette use. The RPM range of the transmission must also meet the LS1 needs. I keep saying in production because the Corvette can not afford to develop a unique transmission. I am not aware of any such four wheel drive intended automatic transmission that GM has in production or coming. Perhaps the transmission wars that he mentions will lead to such a development.
#39
Team Owner
The optional 3.15:1 ring gear and pinion in a 20 equates to 1930 RPM at 70 MPH.
The 2006 A6 with it's .67:1 6th gear overdrive and standard 2.56 rear gear sees 1500 RPM at 70 MPH.
1450 RPM in a 2005 C6 with the A4 and base 2.73 rear gear equates to 60 MPH.
I sometimes wonder if you really do have a Corvette, or just pull crap off the Internet to post.
You can bet that a 8 speed auto will run at lower RPM at a given speed then your A4 or the newer C6's A6, while delivering better gas mileage.
My 505 HP 7L C6 will equal your 400 HP 6L C6 in highway gas mileage. But then I have a 6 speed with a higher final gear ratio(1.71:1) then your C6(1.91:1 or 2.45:1).
That's what a 8 speed auto will bring to the table over a 4 or 6 speed auto, plus the lower gears in 1 thru 5, will give better performance.
#40
Race Director
Thread Starter
That's odd. When I do the math on a 2005 C6 with 285/35ZR-19 rear tires and the A4 with .7:1 overdrive 4th gear and the base 2.73:1 differential gear I come up with 1675 RPM at 70 MPH.
The optional 3.15:1 ring gear and pinion in a 20 equates to 1930 RPM at 70 MPH.
The 2006 A6 with it's .67:1 6th gear overdrive and standard 2.56 rear gear sees 1500 RPM at 70 MPH.
1450 RPM in a 2005 C6 with the A4 and base 2.73 rear gear equates to 60 MPH.
I sometimes wonder if you really do have a Corvette, or just pull crap off the Internet to post.
You can bet that a 8 speed auto will run at lower RPM at a given speed then your A4 or the newer C6's A6, while delivering better gas mileage.
My 505 HP 7L C6 will equal your 400 HP 6L C6 in highway gas mileage. But then I have a 6 speed with a higher final gear ratio(1.71:1) then your C6(1.91:1 or 2.45:1).
That's what a 8 speed auto will bring to the table over a 4 or 6 speed auto, plus the lower gears in 1 thru 5, will give better performance.
The optional 3.15:1 ring gear and pinion in a 20 equates to 1930 RPM at 70 MPH.
The 2006 A6 with it's .67:1 6th gear overdrive and standard 2.56 rear gear sees 1500 RPM at 70 MPH.
1450 RPM in a 2005 C6 with the A4 and base 2.73 rear gear equates to 60 MPH.
I sometimes wonder if you really do have a Corvette, or just pull crap off the Internet to post.
You can bet that a 8 speed auto will run at lower RPM at a given speed then your A4 or the newer C6's A6, while delivering better gas mileage.
My 505 HP 7L C6 will equal your 400 HP 6L C6 in highway gas mileage. But then I have a 6 speed with a higher final gear ratio(1.71:1) then your C6(1.91:1 or 2.45:1).
That's what a 8 speed auto will bring to the table over a 4 or 6 speed auto, plus the lower gears in 1 thru 5, will give better performance.
I have a 6 speed manual 3.42. I was making a point about torque and the relative lack of need for an 8 spd, even in my old LS2. So what rpm will the LT1 in the C7 run at 70 mph with the 7 speed manual? How about the 6 speed auto? The 8 speed auto?
Mr.z4 runs at 2200rpm with his 8 speed at 70. I consider that high.
Last edited by BlueOx; 01-23-2013 at 02:14 PM.