Warble sound occasionally
#121
Pro
Plastic as i thought. I am with u, i would be pleasantly surprised if the AFM valves is the problem. I will suggest we pull fuse 32 tomorrow and see what happens. Supposibly u can drive in manual and render the valves open and do the same thing as pulling fuse 32. I tried this and still got the noise but the valves may rattle in any position, who knows.
The following users liked this post:
bjones7131 (05-26-2016)
#122
Safety Car
Thread Starter
Member Since: Jan 2014
Location: Walhalla South Carolina
Posts: 4,450
Received 845 Likes
on
592 Posts
UPDATE: Took my vette in this morning for the appt the Chevy Customer Support helped set up although U don't need them to do that, was good to have another layer of support for our problem. My dealer and I talked about everything I have read on this forum post and he said they had contacted tech support and there was no issues or resolution as of yet. Tech support instructed the dealer to go through a short process while driving the car and see what results they got. Tech did this without me being in the car, I was up front office BS'ing, my bad. I think all it was was driving the car in different modes to see it there was any difference in the noise. They are satisfied that it is the AFM valves fluttering and making this noise we are hearing. Tech said he recalls another vehicle with similar valves having a recall that basically did a computer upgrade or flash that put more opening and closing force on the valves thereby eliminating the flutter/noise. This could be the fix but GM will have to make that call and their wheels turn slow. I like arctic think there supplier had a bad run of valves and we are the unlucky ones. They ruled out any drive train issues based on the way the car sounded and responded after driving it. Mine like all the others seems to be present and louder at 1500 RPM. I played with the car on the way to dealer and if I was in manual and using the paddles at times the noise went completely away and at other times the noise was greatly deminished in the manual mode. I told them about pulling fuse 32 which removes power from the valves and renders them open all the time and they said pull it and see what happens and i said you pull it and they said they didn't have time so I wasn't happy about that. I pulled it when I got home and I got no code like others said they did and but still a little noise but not as bad. My take is the valves are not seating tightly enough in the open or closed position and I think this baffle is inconsistant, meaning sometimes it closes or opens to a different positions and makes the noise. Artic mentioned the GM eng packed the actuator with grease and that may provide a fix but it didn't for his. This tells me the grease would act like a buffer and provide more resistance for the baffle valve to osilate or chatter. This grease is packed in the actuator side of the valve not on the actual damper as U might guess. Dealer said they couldn't do anything until a recall was issued by GM and the more complaints they had would speed the process up. I can buy that meaning why replace a bad exhaust system with another bad system. SO GUYS WE ARE UP TO 122 HITS ON THIS POST AND I KNOW SOME ARE JUST ME AND OTHERS SHARING BUT ANYONE WITH THIS NOISE ON THIS POST NEEDS TO CONTACT THE CUSTOMER SERVICE FOLKS AND GENERATE A TICKET AND TAKE THEIR CAR IN SO YOUR DEALER CAN GENERATE A TICKET FROM THEIR END AND THIS WILL HELP GM COME UP WITH A FIX OTHERWISE THEY WILL NOT DO ANYTHING IF ONLY A HANDFUL OF GUYS COMPLAIN SO PLEASE FOLLOW UP ON THIS. ALL IT TAKES AN EMAIL TO CUSTOMER SUPPORT OR JUST TAKE YOUR CAR INTO THE DEALER AND GET ON RECORD AND MENTION THE FORUM POST. Sorry for the long post but I wanted all to know where we are on this issue. Remember there is strength in numbers and the squeaking wheel gets the grease. Keep us posted on any activity you have. I am going to bug customer support and my dealer every so often so they know I am not going away. I didn't pay 60K Plus to hear this noise on my vette. Good luck
The following 4 users liked this post by bjones7131:
#123
Drifting
Ed,
Were you able to reach GM Customer Service rep through the Sticky "Track my order" Thread?
I posted last night and Steph B replied quickly to me this morning..... I replied to her via PM and provided my detailed contact info and she assigned a case # and asked me which dealership I preferred to go to. By the time I stopped by that local dealer this afternoon, they had been contacted by GM and had a full stack of papers on this. The Service Advisor took a ride, heard the noise and I'm scheduled to take the car in Monday morning.
Please try to reach out to them. I know there's got to be at least a dozen of us experiencing this and the more of us that officially document this and request action by GM Tech support through our dealers, the quicker we will all find resolution.
thanks,
Richard
Were you able to reach GM Customer Service rep through the Sticky "Track my order" Thread?
I posted last night and Steph B replied quickly to me this morning..... I replied to her via PM and provided my detailed contact info and she assigned a case # and asked me which dealership I preferred to go to. By the time I stopped by that local dealer this afternoon, they had been contacted by GM and had a full stack of papers on this. The Service Advisor took a ride, heard the noise and I'm scheduled to take the car in Monday morning.
Please try to reach out to them. I know there's got to be at least a dozen of us experiencing this and the more of us that officially document this and request action by GM Tech support through our dealers, the quicker we will all find resolution.
thanks,
Richard
Ed
The following users liked this post:
Strake (05-25-2016)
#125
The Consigliere
Member Since: May 2006
Location: 2023 Z06 & 2010 ZR1
Posts: 22,243
Received 5,432 Likes
on
2,268 Posts
If this bothers you, just go with the M7 transmission. It only goes into V4 mode when you affirmatively tell it to, so would be easy to avoid this.
#126
Heel & Toe
Purchased 2016 stingray in Dec. 2015. on way home had a Whoop, Whoop, Whoop noise, about 2/per second @ about 1500 rpm. Any gear 4V 8V or any mode. noise came from back of car, yet this noise, which sounds like a drive train rotational noise is consistent with a noise from the input to the tranny (based on timing and speed). always @ 1500 rpm doesn't matter road speed or gearing. What do You folks recommend, is this the same thing you folks are discussing here?
took car to dealer and we spent a lot of time looking a stuff on lift and driving, which they where eager to do, but didn't find anything. I'm scheduled to drive a demo unit to see if it makes same sound or not.
not worried about it , but a $70k car shouldn't be like this.
took car to dealer and we spent a lot of time looking a stuff on lift and driving, which they where eager to do, but didn't find anything. I'm scheduled to drive a demo unit to see if it makes same sound or not.
not worried about it , but a $70k car shouldn't be like this.
#127
So this is 100% caused by switching of V8 to V4? If so, I can scratch this con of my list
#128
The Consigliere
Member Since: May 2006
Location: 2023 Z06 & 2010 ZR1
Posts: 22,243
Received 5,432 Likes
on
2,268 Posts
If this is due to going from V8 to V4 then that is not a problem. Someone on here showed me a neat little OBDII reader thing you can plug that removes that going automatically and anyways staying in manual mode won't allow it.
So this is 100% caused by switching of V8 to V4? If so, I can scratch this con of my list
So this is 100% caused by switching of V8 to V4? If so, I can scratch this con of my list
And yes, these issues are associated with the AFM exhaust valves that actuate then going into/out of V4 mode.
#129
Melting Slicks
Member Since: Nov 2012
Location: Gettysburg PA
Posts: 3,329
Received 1,864 Likes
on
1,003 Posts
2020 C8 of the Year Finalist - Unmodified
Plastic as i thought. I am with u, i would be pleasantly surprised if the AFM valves is the problem. I will suggest we pull fuse 32 tomorrow and see what happens. Supposibly u can drive in manual and render the valves open and do the same thing as pulling fuse 32. I tried this and still got the noise but the valves may rattle in any position, who knows.
Purchased 2016 stingray in Dec. 2015. on way home had a Whoop, Whoop, Whoop noise, about 2/per second @ about 1500 rpm. Any gear 4V 8V or any mode. noise came from back of car, yet this noise, which sounds like a drive train rotational noise is consistent with a noise from the input to the tranny (based on timing and speed). always @ 1500 rpm doesn't matter road speed or gearing. What do You folks recommend, is this the same thing you folks are discussing here?
took car to dealer and we spent a lot of time looking a stuff on lift and driving, which they where eager to do, but didn't find anything. I'm scheduled to drive a demo unit to see if it makes same sound or not.
not worried about it , but a $70k car shouldn't be like this.
took car to dealer and we spent a lot of time looking a stuff on lift and driving, which they where eager to do, but didn't find anything. I'm scheduled to drive a demo unit to see if it makes same sound or not.
not worried about it , but a $70k car shouldn't be like this.
#130
Ok thanks.
AFM or NPP? I just learned NPP is the sports exhaust. What is the AFM?
#131
Melting Slicks
Member Since: Nov 2012
Location: Gettysburg PA
Posts: 3,329
Received 1,864 Likes
on
1,003 Posts
2020 C8 of the Year Finalist - Unmodified
Plastic as i thought. I am with u, i would be pleasantly surprised if the AFM valves is the problem. I will suggest we pull fuse 32 tomorrow and see what happens. Supposibly u can drive in manual and render the valves open and do the same thing as pulling fuse 32. I tried this and still got the noise but the valves may rattle in any position, who knows.
UPDATE: Took my vette in this morning for the appt the Chevy Customer Support helped set up although U don't need them to do that, was good to have another layer of support for our problem. My dealer and I talked about everything I have read on this forum post and he said they had contacted tech support and there was no issues or resolution as of yet. Tech support instructed the dealer to go through a short process while driving the car and see what results they got. Tech did this without me being in the car, I was up front office BS'ing, my bad. I think all it was was driving the car in different modes to see it there was any difference in the noise. They are satisfied that it is the AFM valves fluttering and making this noise we are hearing. Tech said he recalls another vehicle with similar valves having a recall that basically did a computer upgrade or flash that put more opening and closing force on the valves thereby eliminating the flutter/noise. This could be the fix but GM will have to make that call and their wheels turn slow. I like arctic think there supplier had a bad run of valves and we are the unlucky ones. They ruled out any drive train issues based on the way the car sounded and responded after driving it. Mine like all the others seems to be present and louder at 1500 RPM. I played with the car on the way to dealer and if I was in manual and using the paddles at times the noise went completely away and at other times the noise was greatly deminished in the manual mode. I told them about pulling fuse 32 which removes power from the valves and renders them open all the time and they said pull it and see what happens and i said you pull it and they said they didn't have time so I wasn't happy about that. I pulled it when I got home and I got no code like others said they did and but still a little noise but not as bad. My take is the valves are not seating tightly enough in the open or closed position and I think this baffle is inconsistant, meaning sometimes it closes or opens to a different positions and makes the noise. Artic mentioned the GM eng packed the actuator with grease and that may provide a fix but it didn't for his. This tells me the grease would act like a buffer and provide more resistance for the baffle valve to osilate or chatter. This grease is packed in the actuator side of the valve not on the actual damper as U might guess. Dealer said they couldn't do anything until a recall was issued by GM and the more complaints they had would speed the process up. I can buy that meaning why replace a bad exhaust system with another bad system. SO GUYS WE ARE UP TO 122 HITS ON THIS POST AND I KNOW SOME ARE JUST ME AND OTHERS SHARING BUT ANYONE WITH THIS NOISE ON THIS POST NEEDS TO CONTACT THE CUSTOMER SERVICE FOLKS AND GENERATE A TICKET AND TAKE THEIR CAR IN SO YOUR DEALER CAN GENERATE A TICKET FROM THEIR END AND THIS WILL HELP GM COME UP WITH A FIX OTHERWISE THEY WILL NOT DO ANYTHING IF ONLY A HANDFUL OF GUYS COMPLAIN SO PLEASE FOLLOW UP ON THIS. ALL IT TAKES AN EMAIL TO CUSTOMER SUPPORT OR JUST TAKE YOUR CAR INTO THE DEALER AND GET ON RECORD AND MENTION THE FORUM POST. Sorry for the long post but I wanted all to know where we are on this issue. Remember there is strength in numbers and the squeaking wheel gets the grease. Keep us posted on any activity you have. I am going to bug customer support and my dealer every so often so they know I am not going away. I didn't pay 60K Plus to hear this noise on my vette. Good luck
So the only thing I'm a bit confused about is the "pulling the fuse #32"....
If I am hearing the noise in BOTH V4 and V8 modes, is there any point in me trying to pull the fuse? Now, I can hear the WARBLE noise when the car is in Automatic and switching from V4 to V8. I can also hear the noise when I'm in paddle shift Manual. Would I gain info from still pulling the fuse to keep it in V8 mode...... assuming that is what it does? I already KNOW the car makes the noise in V8 mode.
#132
The Consigliere
Member Since: May 2006
Location: 2023 Z06 & 2010 ZR1
Posts: 22,243
Received 5,432 Likes
on
2,268 Posts
On the Stingray, there are two sets of valves in the exhaust for cars with the performance exhaust (NPP). The NPP valves are the ones at the back end of the exhaust system that modulate sound b/n quiet and loud. Those valves are robust and trouble-free - and easy to get to in order to clean etc even if they do act up. The AFM (active fuel management) exhaust valves are further upstream on the exhaust and they activate when the engine goes from V8 to V4 operation to keep the exhaust from sounding weird in V4 mode.
The Z06s don't have these AFM exhaust valves. All Stingrays have them (and I presume the GS will too). Most are trouble-free, but some folks have experience these weird noises caused by the AFM valves, mostly A8 cars, as the M7 crowd doesn't use eco mode (which is the only way those cars go into V4 mode) as often as the A8 guys see V4 mode activated.
The following 2 users liked this post by OnPoint:
Strake (05-25-2016),
TheMidnightNarwhal (05-25-2016)
#133
On the Stingray, there are two sets of valves in the exhaust for cars with the performance exhaust (NPP). The NPP valves are the ones at the back end of the exhaust system that modulate sound b/n quiet and loud. Those valves are robust and trouble-free - and easy to get to in order to clean etc even if they do act up. The AFM (active fuel management) exhaust valves are further upstream on the exhaust and they activate when the engine goes from V8 to V4 operation to keep the exhaust from sounding weird in V4 mode.
The Z06s don't have these AFM exhaust valves. All Stingrays have them (and I presume the GS will too). Most are trouble-free, but some folks have experience these weird noises caused by the AFM valves, mostly A8 cars, as the M7 crowd doesn't use eco mode (which is the only way those cars go into V4 mode) as often as the A8 guys see V4 mode activated.
The Z06s don't have these AFM exhaust valves. All Stingrays have them (and I presume the GS will too). Most are trouble-free, but some folks have experience these weird noises caused by the AFM valves, mostly A8 cars, as the M7 crowd doesn't use eco mode (which is the only way those cars go into V4 mode) as often as the A8 guys see V4 mode activated.
I will also opt for the NPP Exhaust.
#134
Safety Car
Thread Starter
Member Since: Jan 2014
Location: Walhalla South Carolina
Posts: 4,450
Received 845 Likes
on
592 Posts
Thank you for the update !!!
So the only thing I'm a bit confused about is the "pulling the fuse #32"....
If I am hearing the noise in BOTH V4 and V8 modes, is there any point in me trying to pull the fuse? Now, I can hear the WARBLE noise when the car is in Automatic and switching from V4 to V8. I can also hear the noise when I'm in paddle shift Manual. Would I gain info from still pulling the fuse to keep it in V8 mode...... assuming that is what it does? I already KNOW the car makes the noise in V8 mode.
So the only thing I'm a bit confused about is the "pulling the fuse #32"....
If I am hearing the noise in BOTH V4 and V8 modes, is there any point in me trying to pull the fuse? Now, I can hear the WARBLE noise when the car is in Automatic and switching from V4 to V8. I can also hear the noise when I'm in paddle shift Manual. Would I gain info from still pulling the fuse to keep it in V8 mode...... assuming that is what it does? I already KNOW the car makes the noise in V8 mode.
The following 2 users liked this post by bjones7131:
ron landgraf (03-10-2017),
Strake (05-25-2016)
#136
Melting Slicks
Member Since: Nov 2012
Location: Gettysburg PA
Posts: 3,329
Received 1,864 Likes
on
1,003 Posts
2020 C8 of the Year Finalist - Unmodified
Plastic as i thought. I am with u, i would be pleasantly surprised if the AFM valves is the problem. I will suggest we pull fuse 32 tomorrow and see what happens. Supposibly u can drive in manual and render the valves open and do the same thing as pulling fuse 32. I tried this and still got the noise but the valves may rattle in any position, who knows.
#137
Melting Slicks
Member Since: Nov 2012
Location: Gettysburg PA
Posts: 3,329
Received 1,864 Likes
on
1,003 Posts
2020 C8 of the Year Finalist - Unmodified
Plastic as i thought. I am with u, i would be pleasantly surprised if the AFM valves is the problem. I will suggest we pull fuse 32 tomorrow and see what happens. Supposibly u can drive in manual and render the valves open and do the same thing as pulling fuse 32. I tried this and still got the noise but the valves may rattle in any position, who knows.
#138
Safety Car
Thread Starter
Member Since: Jan 2014
Location: Walhalla South Carolina
Posts: 4,450
Received 845 Likes
on
592 Posts
Thank you for the update !!!
So the only thing I'm a bit confused about is the "pulling the fuse #32"....
If I am hearing the noise in BOTH V4 and V8 modes, is there any point in me trying to pull the fuse? Now, I can hear the WARBLE noise when the car is in Automatic and switching from V4 to V8. I can also hear the noise when I'm in paddle shift Manual. Would I gain info from still pulling the fuse to keep it in V8 mode...... assuming that is what it does? I already KNOW the car makes the noise in V8 mode.
So the only thing I'm a bit confused about is the "pulling the fuse #32"....
If I am hearing the noise in BOTH V4 and V8 modes, is there any point in me trying to pull the fuse? Now, I can hear the WARBLE noise when the car is in Automatic and switching from V4 to V8. I can also hear the noise when I'm in paddle shift Manual. Would I gain info from still pulling the fuse to keep it in V8 mode...... assuming that is what it does? I already KNOW the car makes the noise in V8 mode.
The following users liked this post:
Strake (05-25-2016)
#139
Safety Car
Thread Starter
Member Since: Jan 2014
Location: Walhalla South Carolina
Posts: 4,450
Received 845 Likes
on
592 Posts
Dealer says to wait until GM does a recall on the valves. Only way to get them to do a recall is to get as many as possible to complain, take your car into your dealer and let them check it and they will do the follow up with GM and hopefully if enough complain they will do a recall.
#140
Drifting
Same noise and they want me to keep driving it. One thing I did notice. They had the car jacked up by the rear before it went up on the rack. I thought the warble noise changed immediately upon leaving, but I heard it again tonight. I swear something shifted and it's severity changed slightly - after it was jacked by the floor jack. I'm tuned into it now and can tell you when it's changing tone. Tonight it was pretty loud again. Both noises are still there. The growl at 1000 and the warble around 1500. I was initially wondering if something shifted when they jacked it up - I did not see what crossmember or where they jacked it on but it was a center point.
I also wonder what the effect will be as the exhaust gets mileage and some carbon in it as well as a little more throttle. Perhaps that will quiet things down - only the shadow knows. Either way, It's been frustrating, but at this point I am going to enjoy the car and let the warranty take care of it when the fix comes out.
Every morning when I back out, I hear a quick growl (sounds like exhaust) as it passes 1,000. When I get stuck in slow traffic and the trans stays in 3rd and we're creeping I hear it. I can duplicate it by being in 1st, and applying brake and moving forward at 1,000 rpm. Sounds like it comes from rear right. Odd thing is the car MUST be moving for it to growl.
Dealer is trying - I think this is beyond all of our dealer's ability to diagnose and prove out the diagnosis because I believe it's in a component they don't just have laying around to swap out. I believe firmly that someone at GM knows what we are talking about and we need to find that person.
I truly feel for the guys who have had driveline components replaced only to keep hearing it. I'm not going down that road. If you follow the Camaro forums, those guys have had massive complaints about active exhaust noise for several years.
I started finding myself turning down the radio and capturing recordings - that's taking the fun away from the car. I just want to enjoy it so as I've gotten several recordings and it's documented, I need to just drive it.
Last edited by Ed Ramberger; 05-27-2016 at 12:04 AM.
The following 2 users liked this post by Ed Ramberger:
Highplains (05-26-2016),
Strake (05-26-2016)