GS vs. 911 Motor Trend review
10-27-2016, 04:05 PM
#201
Burning Brakes
Fun factor...I've never driven a car more fun than the Z06...including Ferrari's, Lambo's and Ruf Porsche's. Were some higher quality fit and finish, YES...but were they 'better'? Not necessarily.
The following 2 users liked this post by ZoratZ06:
23/C8Z (10-28-2016),
Mike Campbell (10-27-2016)
10-27-2016, 04:33 PM
#202
Le Mans Master
If these tests were "apples to apples" rather than "apples to oranges" they would be more fair. However, the car mags can't really chance that since their real goal is to sell magazines and aggravate readers so they write in. A 911 should be tested against a ZO6. Same price range. The Grand Sport against a Cayman, same price range and the Stingray vs the Boxster. Simple as that. 
Now remember guys that Porsche makes even higher priced sports cars so we'll have to wait for the next ZR1 and/or the Zora.
Now remember guys that Porsche makes even higher priced sports cars so we'll have to wait for the next ZR1 and/or the Zora.
The following users liked this post:
sdurg24 (10-27-2016)
10-27-2016, 05:00 PM
#203
10-27-2016, 05:07 PM
#204
If these tests were "apples to apples" rather than "apples to oranges" they would be more fair. However, the car mags can't really chance that since their real goal is to sell magazines and aggravate readers so they write in. A 911 should be tested against a ZO6. Same price range. The Grand Sport against a Cayman, same price range and the Stingray vs the Boxster. Simple as that. Now remember guys that Porsche makes even higher priced sports cars so we'll have to wait for the next ZR1 and/or the Zora.
Now remember guys that Porsche makes even higher priced sports cars so we'll have to wait for the next ZR1 and/or the Zora.
10-27-2016, 05:21 PM
#205
Le Mans Master
If these tests were "apples to apples" rather than "apples to oranges" they would be more fair. However, the car mags can't really chance that since their real goal is to sell magazines and aggravate readers so they write in. A 911 should be tested against a ZO6. Same price range. The Grand Sport against a Cayman, same price range and the Stingray vs the Boxster. Simple as that. Now remember guys that Porsche makes even higher priced sports cars so we'll have to wait for the next ZR1 and/or the Zora.
Now remember guys that Porsche makes even higher priced sports cars so we'll have to wait for the next ZR1 and/or the Zora.
10-27-2016, 05:59 PM
#206
Melting Slicks
10-27-2016, 06:17 PM
#207
Team Owner
I like how everybody pats themselves on their backs and gives high fives to MT when the Corvette beats the Porsche but are up in arms when the Mustang beat the Corvette and gives the old "WTF do they know".
10-27-2016, 09:50 PM
#208
Moderator
It's true that magazines have been doing Vette vs. Porsche road test comparisons since day one. It's a great way to get increase magazine sales. Every time it happens, people go crazy. I have attached an early MOTOR TREND comparison of the two makes from their April 1959 issue. I'd say not much has changed when it comes to how the two cars compare. I love reading these test reports and can say, there is little doubt in my mind that the Vette is an all American winner.
Attachment 48031240
Attachment 48031241
Attachment 48031242
Attachment 48031243
Attachment 48031244
Attachment 48031245
Attachment 48031240
Attachment 48031241
Attachment 48031242
Attachment 48031243
Attachment 48031244
Attachment 48031245
10-27-2016, 09:59 PM
#209
Drifting
I thought about a used 911 during one of my new car "itch" periods, but found so many transmission oil leak issues and high cost of repair, that I just couldn't do it, as much as I admire the car. I've had 5 used Corvettes in my lifetime and never had a serious problem with any of them. Worst problem was a blown head gasket on my 84 which I repaired myself. As badly as I flogged my C5 coupe while living and working in Germany and Italy, it never let me down. I've heard Porsches referred to as "bulletproof" but I couldn't take the chance.
I am certain the Porsche deserves it's recognition as a superb sports car, but the Corvette is a better performer in my opinion.
I am certain the Porsche deserves it's recognition as a superb sports car, but the Corvette is a better performer in my opinion.
10-27-2016, 10:23 PM
#210
Moderator
I thought about a used 911 during one of my new car "itch" periods, but found so many transmission oil leak issues and high cost of repair, that I just couldn't do it, as much as I admire the car. I've had 5 used Corvettes in my lifetime and never had a serious problem with any of them. Worst problem was a blown head gasket on my 84 which I repaired myself. As badly as I flogged my C5 coupe while living and working in Germany and Italy, it never let me down. I've heard Porsches referred to as "bulletproof" but I couldn't take the chance.
I am certain the Porsche deserves it's recognition as a superb sports car, but the Corvette is a better performer in my opinion.
I am certain the Porsche deserves it's recognition as a superb sports car, but the Corvette is a better performer in my opinion.
That being said, maintenance costs compared to Corvettes are significantly higher.
10-28-2016, 02:48 AM
#211
Le Mans Master
$100k
mid engine
450-500hp
good brakes
nice interior
Last edited by village idiot; 10-28-2016 at 02:48 AM.
10-28-2016, 02:50 AM
#212
Noticed the Emoticon I used?
Huh?
Which Mustang has beaten the GS around a track?
Mmmmmm, that's right...none of 'em.
Huh?
Which Mustang has beaten the GS around a track?
Mmmmmm, that's right...none of 'em.
10-28-2016, 07:13 AM
#214
Pro
Member Since: Oct 2008
Posts: 661
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I notice that the article says the interior of the Corvette still lacks quality. The headliner fell down at 3,000 miles. Forget all of the performance figures and build a better quality car like Porsche.
10-28-2016, 05:20 PM
#215
Race Director
I admire both sports cars. I'd lean towards owning the corvette but I am dam impressed by the Porsche 911s
10-28-2016, 08:32 PM
#216
Le Mans Master
10-28-2016, 08:47 PM
#217
Team Owner
Last edited by themonk; 10-28-2016 at 11:02 PM.
10-28-2016, 10:53 PM
#218
Race Director
ps. maybe a Veyron or Chiron..
Last edited by 23/C8Z; 10-28-2016 at 10:54 PM.
10-29-2016, 03:36 AM
#219
10-29-2016, 08:05 AM
#220
Race Director
The new 911s is dam impressive...I prefer the corvette grand sport ...
Literally for half the price I'd buy the corvette...
Porsches cost to purchase and maintain is ridiculous in my opinion.
I still haven't wrapped my head around cars costing over 100 grand...
I could easily afford it but find the pricing ridiculous.
Unless the cars going to bl w me...I'm not spending that kind of money...
Even 92 is insane in my opinion..
Literally for half the price I'd buy the corvette...
Porsches cost to purchase and maintain is ridiculous in my opinion.
I still haven't wrapped my head around cars costing over 100 grand...
I could easily afford it but find the pricing ridiculous.
Unless the cars going to bl w me...I'm not spending that kind of money...
Even 92 is insane in my opinion..