C7 GS vs 2015 Jaguar F-type R
#101
type r
Both are good cars.
I test drove a type R convertible before buying 2017 zo6 manual convertible.
Ask the dealer to let you keep the Jag for the weekend and then decide.
IMHO, I would pick the type R over the GS, unless I had to have a manual.
You are very fortunate to have this decision to make.
Make a great deal on the used Jag drive it for a year then get a Zo6.
I test drove a type R convertible before buying 2017 zo6 manual convertible.
Ask the dealer to let you keep the Jag for the weekend and then decide.
IMHO, I would pick the type R over the GS, unless I had to have a manual.
You are very fortunate to have this decision to make.
Make a great deal on the used Jag drive it for a year then get a Zo6.
Good morning all,
I know I am posting this on a site where everyone will be one sided, but I really wanted to see if anyone has come from or went to the Jag. I am SO split on the two. I know most are going to say test drive both and see which one you like but again if there are any owners or post owners I would love to hear what they say.
GS Pro's:
Removable Top
Manual Transmission
I imagine its much cheaper to maintain for its lifetime
Jag Pro's:
UNIQUE (how many R badges do you see in a month, MAYBE 1)
More power
That exhaust note tho...
PS. I know there are going to be people that say go with the Z06 but I have done insurance inquiries of all and the Z06 is outrageous.
I know I am posting this on a site where everyone will be one sided, but I really wanted to see if anyone has come from or went to the Jag. I am SO split on the two. I know most are going to say test drive both and see which one you like but again if there are any owners or post owners I would love to hear what they say.
GS Pro's:
Removable Top
Manual Transmission
I imagine its much cheaper to maintain for its lifetime
Jag Pro's:
UNIQUE (how many R badges do you see in a month, MAYBE 1)
More power
That exhaust note tho...
PS. I know there are going to be people that say go with the Z06 but I have done insurance inquiries of all and the Z06 is outrageous.
The following users liked this post:
Sivtec (12-28-2016)
#102
Le Mans Master
on to why i got the car and gave up a sportscar legend that is Z06.
10 years on daily driving a manual takes it toll. Im not 18 anymore thats for sure lol. Need something i was comfy using more often than not. Turning radius is better, the ride, the infotainment system is great and the interior feels fresh. In other words i wanted a better daily driver without giving up what makes cars look and feel special. And the F type fit my budget and criteria for the most part
My dad has a 2016 stingray and when i drive it here and there im amazed at how viseral a sportscar is supose to be. The jag although beautiful is just pne big ***** cat cruiser 😸😹
The following users liked this post:
Sivtec (12-28-2016)
#103
Burning Brakes
I also thought of the Jag before I bought the Z06.
Went to the dealer to look at them and they never came out to help me. Helped others that pulled in after me. (I was driving my 2000 F250)
That made my mind up that I would buy the Z06 instead.
Glad the dealer helped me make the choice!! lol
Went to the dealer to look at them and they never came out to help me. Helped others that pulled in after me. (I was driving my 2000 F250)
That made my mind up that I would buy the Z06 instead.
Glad the dealer helped me make the choice!! lol
I really dislike (using gentle, forum-happy words) salespeople who can't even afford the car you want to buy thinking they have something on you. This isn't a social climbing event, it's a business transaction. Those who don't understand that should be asking if I want fries with that.
The following users liked this post:
Sivtec (12-28-2016)
#104
Burning Brakes
The following users liked this post:
Sivtec (12-28-2016)
#106
#107
Advanced
Thread Starter
biggest gripe is steering and weight. They switched to electric power steering in 2016. Ive driven a type S coupe with hydraulic andnit was fantastic. This new sytem blows and is not different than something id conpare to a luxury sedan from Mercedes or Audi. It just doesnt firm up or wiggle in my hands the way i want it to. The C6 Z06 steering wasnt perfect either but it is noticably better for spirited driving.
on to why i got the car and gave up a sportscar legend that is Z06.
10 years on daily driving a manual takes it toll. Im not 18 anymore thats for sure lol. Need something i was comfy using more often than not. Turning radius is better, the ride, the infotainment system is great and the interior feels fresh. In other words i wanted a better daily driver without giving up what makes cars look and feel special. And the F type fit my budget and criteria for the most part
My dad has a 2016 stingray and when i drive it here and there im amazed at how viseral a sportscar is supose to be. The jag although beautiful is just pne big ***** cat cruiser 😸😹
on to why i got the car and gave up a sportscar legend that is Z06.
10 years on daily driving a manual takes it toll. Im not 18 anymore thats for sure lol. Need something i was comfy using more often than not. Turning radius is better, the ride, the infotainment system is great and the interior feels fresh. In other words i wanted a better daily driver without giving up what makes cars look and feel special. And the F type fit my budget and criteria for the most part
My dad has a 2016 stingray and when i drive it here and there im amazed at how viseral a sportscar is supose to be. The jag although beautiful is just pne big ***** cat cruiser 😸😹
Always drive to the dealer with your oldest, dirtiest car/truck. If they don't help you because they turn their noses up at what you drove in, to hell with them. They surely won't help you when you really need it.
I really dislike (using gentle, forum-happy words) salespeople who can't even afford the car you want to buy thinking they have something on you. This isn't a social climbing event, it's a business transaction. Those who don't understand that should be asking if I want fries with that.
I really dislike (using gentle, forum-happy words) salespeople who can't even afford the car you want to buy thinking they have something on you. This isn't a social climbing event, it's a business transaction. Those who don't understand that should be asking if I want fries with that.
Wait what?? Have any more info on this? Credit option?
#108
I think he meant the manual V6 is cheaper than the current V6 automatics, which used to be standard before the manual became available in the '16 MY.
The following users liked this post:
Sivtec (12-28-2016)
#109
Advanced
Thread Starter
#110
The V6 is still available in RWD, manual or auto. The V6 is also available in AWD, auto only. The V8s starting in '16 are only available as AWD, and there is no manual option.
The ZF6 manual will not handle the V8's torque. As a matter of fact, when they came out, they didn't even handle the V6's torque, and a whole bunch of the early cars suffered both pressure-plate and flywheel failure. They've upgraded the parts, and I believe that problem is behind them.
The ZF6 manual will not handle the V8's torque. As a matter of fact, when they came out, they didn't even handle the V6's torque, and a whole bunch of the early cars suffered both pressure-plate and flywheel failure. They've upgraded the parts, and I believe that problem is behind them.
Last edited by Foosh; 12-28-2016 at 01:39 PM.
The following users liked this post:
Sivtec (12-28-2016)
#111
I went from a c6z06 to an R coupe (RWD). Styling is subjective but I think the Jag wins hands down. I just don't feel the c7 looks cohesive at all.
I've had mine for two years with not a single issue it's even been the the track 4 times with no overheating issues.
My two biggest issues with the car are 1. the weight. There is no reason an aluminum 2 seater should weigh close to two tons. And 2. the lack of manual. I miss driving a stick and will probably be back in a vette this year because of it.
That said the c7 is a far superior car in terms of engineering. GM has the development $$$ the JLR doesn't. A stingray would decimate an R around a track with the same driver. The c7 has a ton of tech that the Jag lacks. For example, you can't get real time tire pressure readings in the Jag while the car is moving. Bizarre for a "performance" car.
Ive spent a lot of time in the c7 and z06 and around town the performance difference is negligible. If the car isn't going to be tracked and you want something different and rarer then the Jag is the way to go...
MC
I've had mine for two years with not a single issue it's even been the the track 4 times with no overheating issues.
My two biggest issues with the car are 1. the weight. There is no reason an aluminum 2 seater should weigh close to two tons. And 2. the lack of manual. I miss driving a stick and will probably be back in a vette this year because of it.
That said the c7 is a far superior car in terms of engineering. GM has the development $$$ the JLR doesn't. A stingray would decimate an R around a track with the same driver. The c7 has a ton of tech that the Jag lacks. For example, you can't get real time tire pressure readings in the Jag while the car is moving. Bizarre for a "performance" car.
Ive spent a lot of time in the c7 and z06 and around town the performance difference is negligible. If the car isn't going to be tracked and you want something different and rarer then the Jag is the way to go...
MC
The following users liked this post:
Sivtec (12-28-2016)
#112
Advanced
Thread Starter
I went from a c6z06 to an R coupe (RWD). Styling is subjective but I think the Jag wins hands down. I just don't feel the c7 looks cohesive at all.
I've had mine for two years with not a single issue it's even been the the track 4 times with no overheating issues.
My two biggest issues with the car are 1. the weight. There is no reason an aluminum 2 seater should weigh close to two tons. And 2. the lack of manual. I miss driving a stick and will probably be back in a vette this year because of it.
That said the c7 is a far superior car in terms of engineering. GM has the development $$$ the JLR doesn't. A stingray would decimate an R around a track with the same driver. The c7 has a ton of tech that the Jag lacks. For example, you can't get real time tire pressure readings in the Jag while the car is moving. Bizarre for a "performance" car.
Ive spent a lot of time in the c7 and z06 and around town the performance difference is negligible. If the car isn't going to be tracked and you want something different and rarer then the Jag is the way to go...
MC
I've had mine for two years with not a single issue it's even been the the track 4 times with no overheating issues.
My two biggest issues with the car are 1. the weight. There is no reason an aluminum 2 seater should weigh close to two tons. And 2. the lack of manual. I miss driving a stick and will probably be back in a vette this year because of it.
That said the c7 is a far superior car in terms of engineering. GM has the development $$$ the JLR doesn't. A stingray would decimate an R around a track with the same driver. The c7 has a ton of tech that the Jag lacks. For example, you can't get real time tire pressure readings in the Jag while the car is moving. Bizarre for a "performance" car.
Ive spent a lot of time in the c7 and z06 and around town the performance difference is negligible. If the car isn't going to be tracked and you want something different and rarer then the Jag is the way to go...
MC
#113
My two biggest issues with the car are 1. the weight. There is no reason an aluminum 2 seater should weigh close to two tons. And 2. the lack of manual. I miss driving a stick and will probably be back in a vette this year because of it.
That said the c7 is a far superior car in terms of engineering. GM has the development $$$ the JLR doesn't. A stingray would decimate an R around a track with the same driver. The c7 has a ton of tech that the Jag lacks. For example, you can't get real time tire pressure readings in the Jag while the car is moving. Bizarre for a "performance" car.
Ive spent a lot of time in the c7 and z06 and around town the performance difference is negligible. If the car isn't going to be tracked and you want something different and rarer then the Jag is the way to go...
MC
That said the c7 is a far superior car in terms of engineering. GM has the development $$$ the JLR doesn't. A stingray would decimate an R around a track with the same driver. The c7 has a ton of tech that the Jag lacks. For example, you can't get real time tire pressure readings in the Jag while the car is moving. Bizarre for a "performance" car.
Ive spent a lot of time in the c7 and z06 and around town the performance difference is negligible. If the car isn't going to be tracked and you want something different and rarer then the Jag is the way to go...
MC
#114
Race Director
Member Since: Jul 2000
Location: Out Where the Buses Don't Run, Eglin AFB/ Niceville FL
Posts: 15,249
Received 1,433 Likes
on
778 Posts
2022 Corvette of the Year Finalist -- Modified
2021 C6 of the Year Winner - Modified
Finalist 2020 C7 of the Year -- Modified
2020 C6 of the Year Finalist - Modified
I've had my 2016 F Type R convertible for almost a year. I can honestly say that I have enjoyed every minute with this car. I test drove a new 2014 V8S and was impressed. Two years later I test drove the R with AWD and was impressed enough to trade my 2007 F430 for one. I will concede that the Jag is heavier, wider, and taller than the C7 but the ride and handling do not make it feel as such. The car handles like a cat on carpet. As for the C7, I bought a 2017 Z06 coupe in October. The OP can't go wrong with either decision in my opinion.
#115
Pro
Have you decided yet?
Also, I too am in Phoenix and my husband is a Farmer's Insurance agent so if you are still bouncing the idea of a C7Z and want a quote, or want a new quote for the Jag/GS, PM me for his contact info.
I personally LOVE the F-Type R's and agree with other posters that the availability of RWD in '15 is a high selling point. Great looking cars, probably the only other car on the road that I think can match the looks with my Vette for this price range.
Also, I too am in Phoenix and my husband is a Farmer's Insurance agent so if you are still bouncing the idea of a C7Z and want a quote, or want a new quote for the Jag/GS, PM me for his contact info.
I personally LOVE the F-Type R's and agree with other posters that the availability of RWD in '15 is a high selling point. Great looking cars, probably the only other car on the road that I think can match the looks with my Vette for this price range.
The following users liked this post:
Sivtec (12-29-2016)
#116
Advanced
Thread Starter
Have you decided yet?
Also, I too am in Phoenix and my husband is a Farmer's Insurance agent so if you are still bouncing the idea of a C7Z and want a quote, or want a new quote for the Jag/GS, PM me for his contact info.
I personally LOVE the F-Type R's and agree with other posters that the availability of RWD in '15 is a high selling point. Great looking cars, probably the only other car on the road that I think can match the looks with my Vette for this price range.
Also, I too am in Phoenix and my husband is a Farmer's Insurance agent so if you are still bouncing the idea of a C7Z and want a quote, or want a new quote for the Jag/GS, PM me for his contact info.
I personally LOVE the F-Type R's and agree with other posters that the availability of RWD in '15 is a high selling point. Great looking cars, probably the only other car on the road that I think can match the looks with my Vette for this price range.
Appreciate the assistance! This forum continues to impress me!
The following users liked this post:
LDYSTIG (12-29-2016)