2017 Grand Sport with confirmed torque converter failure
#1
2017 Grand Sport with confirmed torque converter failure
Hey all,
My GS has about 3500 miles on it so far and I think I may have the dreaded torque converter issue. Reading the forums for a bit now and it seems that PIP 5337E describes a driveline shudder when in V4 mode and fluctuating RPM's as the TCC slips.
Well, for the past few days mine has been doing exactly that. In V4 mode, under constant speed and slight load the engine RPM's will vary by 100-200 RPM every couple of seconds and I get this hitch in the driveline. Does not do it in V8 mode.
Problem is that this was all supposed to be solved in November of 2015 with an updated TC design. My GS was built 8/12/2016. It shouldn't be exhibiting these issues.
Not getting the abrupt shifting when cold. At least not regularly. Might have happened a couple of times. But the RPM fluctuations and the shuddering is happening pretty consistently at this point.
I'm going to wait until after the new year to take it in to the dealer with PIP 5337E in hand. My concern is that since my car is newer than the vehicles affected, they may tell me to pound sand. We shall see. I'll take it to Stingray Chevrolet here in Plant City and ask to speak with the service director. He's dealt with me before about my factory tire swap.
I'm not happy about this at all. Thought I'd be safe with a 2017 since GM brought a bunch of improvements and all of the early C7 bugs were worked out. Maybe not. Wish me luck.
UPDATE:
Car is confirmed to have a bad torque converter. What surprised me is that I dropped it off on 1/5 around 430 PM and I just got a phone call from the service manager on 1/6 around 3 PM saying the car is done and I can pick it up at any time! I asked if they replaced the TC and she replied yes. Now it is at Stingray Chevrolet which has done quite a few of these but I heard this was a 14 hour job. Can they really have done it this quickly?
Guess I'll find out tomorrow morning when I go pick my baby up!
My GS has about 3500 miles on it so far and I think I may have the dreaded torque converter issue. Reading the forums for a bit now and it seems that PIP 5337E describes a driveline shudder when in V4 mode and fluctuating RPM's as the TCC slips.
Well, for the past few days mine has been doing exactly that. In V4 mode, under constant speed and slight load the engine RPM's will vary by 100-200 RPM every couple of seconds and I get this hitch in the driveline. Does not do it in V8 mode.
Problem is that this was all supposed to be solved in November of 2015 with an updated TC design. My GS was built 8/12/2016. It shouldn't be exhibiting these issues.
Not getting the abrupt shifting when cold. At least not regularly. Might have happened a couple of times. But the RPM fluctuations and the shuddering is happening pretty consistently at this point.
I'm going to wait until after the new year to take it in to the dealer with PIP 5337E in hand. My concern is that since my car is newer than the vehicles affected, they may tell me to pound sand. We shall see. I'll take it to Stingray Chevrolet here in Plant City and ask to speak with the service director. He's dealt with me before about my factory tire swap.
I'm not happy about this at all. Thought I'd be safe with a 2017 since GM brought a bunch of improvements and all of the early C7 bugs were worked out. Maybe not. Wish me luck.
UPDATE:
Car is confirmed to have a bad torque converter. What surprised me is that I dropped it off on 1/5 around 430 PM and I just got a phone call from the service manager on 1/6 around 3 PM saying the car is done and I can pick it up at any time! I asked if they replaced the TC and she replied yes. Now it is at Stingray Chevrolet which has done quite a few of these but I heard this was a 14 hour job. Can they really have done it this quickly?
Guess I'll find out tomorrow morning when I go pick my baby up!
Last edited by KrikGS; 01-06-2017 at 03:20 PM. Reason: Updated
The following 11 users liked this post by KrikGS:
767guy (12-22-2016),
bjones7131 (12-22-2016),
cjlinares (12-23-2016),
HoustonMidtown (12-22-2016),
joemessman (12-23-2016),
and 6 others liked this post.
Popular Reply
01-12-2017, 04:28 PM
Hello!
We see many of you are experiencing similar concerns with your Corvette torque converter/shudder noise. For anyone interested in bringing this matter to the attention of their local dealer and would like an additional layer of assistance during the diagnosis, please feel free to send us a private message. Be sure to include your VIN, mileage, contact info and preferred dealer.
Best,
Erica W.
Chevrolet Customer Care
We see many of you are experiencing similar concerns with your Corvette torque converter/shudder noise. For anyone interested in bringing this matter to the attention of their local dealer and would like an additional layer of assistance during the diagnosis, please feel free to send us a private message. Be sure to include your VIN, mileage, contact info and preferred dealer.
Best,
Erica W.
Chevrolet Customer Care
#2
Drifting
V4 mode?
The following 2 users liked this post by mracer14:
SilverScorp (04-30-2017),
Tommyleo (02-26-2017)
#6
Team Owner
Member Since: Jun 2005
Location: Northern, VA
Posts: 46,104
Received 2,481 Likes
on
1,944 Posts
St. Jude Donor '15
"In honor of jpee"
Hey, you probably have more things to do, but why not give the Serv. Dir a call and just ask him about it? At the least, he may be able to ease your mind that it's something they can fix easily and willingly whenever you bring it in. Could possibly make for a less stressful time of year for you seeing as how you have weather on your side where you live (not that the two go hand in hand).
#7
Melting Slicks
My 2015 is in the shop now for a TC swap after 18 months of sporadic V4-shuttering issues that got worse over the past two months. I'm currently talking to dealers about ordering a 2017 GS...with an M7. Like you I can't deal with this any longer and will just chalk it up to experience. I've had only manuals for the previous 35 years before my 2015 and must've had a major senior moment when deciding on an A8. This experience may well snuff out any inclination of getting a slushbox again regardless of brand.
Last edited by iclick; 12-22-2016 at 08:53 AM.
The following users liked this post:
pdiddy972 (12-22-2016)
#8
Safety Car
Member Since: Jan 2014
Location: Walhalla South Carolina
Posts: 4,450
Received 845 Likes
on
592 Posts
I just went through the BBB lemon law buy back on my 16 stingray but for a different reason than the tranny/TC and I went back with a GS A8 and if it gives me trouble I will go that route again and never buy another corvette. Read your warranty book, it states if after ample opportunity to repair and they are can't repair, they will replace or buy it back. These are great cars but not without issues. I know all vehicles can have issues but not like this.
The following 2 users liked this post by bjones7131:
corvette-22 (12-22-2016),
disoswam (02-24-2017)
#9
Le Mans Master
Member Since: Sep 2012
Location: Hagerstown MD
Posts: 6,876
Received 1,738 Likes
on
1,174 Posts
St. Jude Donor '15-'16,'18
OP: Sorry to hear about your issue. I feel your pain. My car was in the shop for 30+ days for the same issues. It seems fine now and I hope it stays that way. Try to find a dealer who has some experience with the TC swaps. Good luck.
#10
Tech Contributor
Member Since: Oct 1999
Location: Charlotte, NC (formerly Endicott, NY)
Posts: 40,089
Received 8,928 Likes
on
5,333 Posts
Hey all,
My GS has about 3500 miles on it so far and I think I may have the dreaded torque converter issue. Reading the forums for a bit now and it seems that PIP 5337E describes a driveline shudder when in V4 mode and fluctuating RPM's as the TCC slips.
Well, for the past few days mine has been doing exactly that. In V4 mode, under constant speed and slight load the engine RPM's will vary by 100-200 RPM every couple of seconds and I get this hitch in the driveline. Does not do it in V8 mode.
Problem is that this was all supposed to be solved in November of 2015 with an updated TC design. My GS was built 8/12/2016. It shouldn't be exhibiting these issues.
Not getting the abrupt shifting when cold. At least not regularly. Might have happened a couple of times. But the RPM fluctuations and the shuddering is happening pretty consistently at this point.
I'm going to wait until after the new year to take it in to the dealer with PIP 5337E in hand. My concern is that since my car is newer than the vehicles affected, they may tell me to pound sand. We shall see. I'll take it to Stingray Chevrolet here in Plant City and ask to speak with the service director. He's dealt with me before about my factory tire swap.
I'm not happy about this at all. Thought I'd be safe with a 2017 since GM brought a bunch of improvements and all of the early C7 bugs were worked out. Maybe not. Wish me luck.
My GS has about 3500 miles on it so far and I think I may have the dreaded torque converter issue. Reading the forums for a bit now and it seems that PIP 5337E describes a driveline shudder when in V4 mode and fluctuating RPM's as the TCC slips.
Well, for the past few days mine has been doing exactly that. In V4 mode, under constant speed and slight load the engine RPM's will vary by 100-200 RPM every couple of seconds and I get this hitch in the driveline. Does not do it in V8 mode.
Problem is that this was all supposed to be solved in November of 2015 with an updated TC design. My GS was built 8/12/2016. It shouldn't be exhibiting these issues.
Not getting the abrupt shifting when cold. At least not regularly. Might have happened a couple of times. But the RPM fluctuations and the shuddering is happening pretty consistently at this point.
I'm going to wait until after the new year to take it in to the dealer with PIP 5337E in hand. My concern is that since my car is newer than the vehicles affected, they may tell me to pound sand. We shall see. I'll take it to Stingray Chevrolet here in Plant City and ask to speak with the service director. He's dealt with me before about my factory tire swap.
I'm not happy about this at all. Thought I'd be safe with a 2017 since GM brought a bunch of improvements and all of the early C7 bugs were worked out. Maybe not. Wish me luck.
A good trouble shooter only listens to the what is happening and when story and shouldn't listen to the why but it is hard to keep that out of your mind after you see or hear it voiced by the Customer.
Bill
The following 3 users liked this post by Bill Dearborn:
#11
Safety Car
Good idea to take your car to Stingray Chev, I am sure they have replaced plenty of A8 TC's and can properly diagnose your problem. Sounds like your diagnoses of a TC causing your problems is correct. Hard to believe this problem has not been solved by GM. That being said, when my new TC was installed in February, 2016, my A8 has been flawless and I now have an additional 13K more miles on it. Keep us posted with Stingray's diagnoses.
#12
Pro
OP, very sorry to hear about the driveline issues with your new car.
Although I have never dealt with Stingray Chevrolet they are a high volume dealer with lots of Vette experience, I assume, so you are off to a good start. I have spoken with the SM there about bringing my car in some time in January and he sounded very positive about trying to get it fixed.
I have had the rear end and tranny torn out of my car two times so far in 2016, well after the late 2015 revised TC date and my driveline has deteriorated yet again.My symptoms are:
1) hard 1-2 shifting first drive of the day
2) would not go into reverse the other morning....had to turn the car off and restart then it shifted into reverse
3) bad bump/slip accelerating in manual 3rd gear
4) loud groaning noise/vibration occasionally when in V4 mode at 1500 rpm. Accelerating or pulling the shift selector into manual to force V8 operation makes the groan/vibration go away ( this is brand new as of a month ago, 24000 miles on the car)
5) sometime on a rolling stop , down to about 3mph or so, when I step on the gas I get a very hard downshift into first gear, probably from third gear or maybe from second gear, not sure which but the down shift feels like being rear ended.
Although I have never dealt with Stingray Chevrolet they are a high volume dealer with lots of Vette experience, I assume, so you are off to a good start. I have spoken with the SM there about bringing my car in some time in January and he sounded very positive about trying to get it fixed.
I have had the rear end and tranny torn out of my car two times so far in 2016, well after the late 2015 revised TC date and my driveline has deteriorated yet again.My symptoms are:
1) hard 1-2 shifting first drive of the day
2) would not go into reverse the other morning....had to turn the car off and restart then it shifted into reverse
3) bad bump/slip accelerating in manual 3rd gear
4) loud groaning noise/vibration occasionally when in V4 mode at 1500 rpm. Accelerating or pulling the shift selector into manual to force V8 operation makes the groan/vibration go away ( this is brand new as of a month ago, 24000 miles on the car)
5) sometime on a rolling stop , down to about 3mph or so, when I step on the gas I get a very hard downshift into first gear, probably from third gear or maybe from second gear, not sure which but the down shift feels like being rear ended.
Last edited by Steve Garrett; 12-22-2016 at 03:53 PM.
#13
Racer
A8 TC problems
I really hate to hear about all my fellow Corvette owners having so much trouble with their cars. Not only the mechanical part but also the inability or reluctance of GM to aggressively repair or solve the problem. How could a company who made a fantastic A4 and A6 system fail so spectacularly with the A8. I have a 2014 A6 and although I was considering buying a 2017, the A8 problem is keeping me doing so. Going to the M7 is not an option. I quit manual shifting in 1989 due to the convenience and minimal loss of performance.
#14
I just don't get why people continue to buy the A8's. Clearly there is a major problem.
#15
Burning Brakes
A8 cars are an annoyance now since they have warranties ... I don't see how anybody would take chance of buying a used A8 car several years from now when warranty is gone ... Never hear of A6 issues ...
What is total labor and parts cost for replacing the TC ???
What is total labor and parts cost for replacing the TC ???
Last edited by dmhines; 12-22-2016 at 03:49 PM.
#20
Pro
It's a big time bummer hearing about these. I've been sitting on the fence thinking that the MY17's would be ok, but probably not. Maybe they should give you the option for an A6 from your A8. Still I wish you guys luck and a speedy fix to your cars and will await in the stands. I was looking to buy in the Spring.