C7 ZR1 M7 or A8 for track?
#101
Race Director
Member Since: Oct 2000
Location: Deal's Gap 2004 NCM Motorsports track supporter
Posts: 13,915
Received 1,103 Likes
on
717 Posts
"General Motors faced tough challenge when searching for the proper transmission to pair with its all-new 625 horsepower supercharged LT4 engine in the 2015 Corvette Z06. The General wanted to match the lightning-fast shifts offered by Porsche’s PDK transmission, but no dual gearbox existed that met both of GM’s requirements — compact size and the ability to handle the LT4’s 635 lb.-ft. of torque.
The answer? Build one that could. The 8L90 eight-speed automatic transmission found in the new Z06 was developed entirely within GM. It’s a traditional automatic gearbox in its design, but GM says it shifts not only faster than any dual-clutch, but smoother as well."
I addition to the above excerpt, the transmission in the '19 ZR1 also had a few extras added including different algorithms.
The answer? Build one that could. The 8L90 eight-speed automatic transmission found in the new Z06 was developed entirely within GM. It’s a traditional automatic gearbox in its design, but GM says it shifts not only faster than any dual-clutch, but smoother as well."
I addition to the above excerpt, the transmission in the '19 ZR1 also had a few extras added including different algorithms.
#102
Timing is pulled above 194 coolant temp. Properly cool for full power is keeping coolant <194. Not 220,230. Just because the car doesn't hit limp mode doesn't mean it's not overheating.
Last edited by BrunoTheMellow; 05-26-2019 at 12:10 PM.
#103
Pro
That you use the term "lead globules" has me thinking you may never seen a spark plug with deposits left by combustion of TEL, but opining is a waste of our time, here.
Why not prove me wrong by doing the following:
1) AVGAS 100 has 4.25-grams of tetraethyllead (TEL) per gallon. AVGAS LL100 has half that, or 2.125-g/gal. TEL. For reference AVGAS 115, if you could find it, has 4.85-g/gal. TEL. Post the amount of TEL in those VP fuels you cited?
2) Post pictures of the spark plugs, piston tops and combustion chambers from these leaded-fuel racing engines you have disassembled.
3) Tell us how these engines were raced, what kind of leaded fuel they used and how long they were run before they were disassembled.
4) Volunteer to be one of the first to run your LT5 on AVGAS LL100 for three months then pull a spark plug or two, shoot some close-up photos and post them. Even better...after that three months on low lead 100, bring your car by my shop and I'll borescope the engine. We'll examine the imagery together and see if there are any deposits from combustion of TEL and, heck, just for laughs we'll pull an O2S and borescope the front of one of your cats.
Why not prove me wrong by doing the following:
1) AVGAS 100 has 4.25-grams of tetraethyllead (TEL) per gallon. AVGAS LL100 has half that, or 2.125-g/gal. TEL. For reference AVGAS 115, if you could find it, has 4.85-g/gal. TEL. Post the amount of TEL in those VP fuels you cited?
2) Post pictures of the spark plugs, piston tops and combustion chambers from these leaded-fuel racing engines you have disassembled.
3) Tell us how these engines were raced, what kind of leaded fuel they used and how long they were run before they were disassembled.
4) Volunteer to be one of the first to run your LT5 on AVGAS LL100 for three months then pull a spark plug or two, shoot some close-up photos and post them. Even better...after that three months on low lead 100, bring your car by my shop and I'll borescope the engine. We'll examine the imagery together and see if there are any deposits from combustion of TEL and, heck, just for laughs we'll pull an O2S and borescope the front of one of your cats.
I am not the one that made the claim that LL100 is damaging, therefore the burden of proof does not lie with me, it lies with the person or persons that made such claims. I just think it's hilarious that much of the racing world uses HIGHLY leaded fuel and these deposits never seem to shorten the life of the engine in amy measurable way! Yet here we are on the ZR1 forum and the mystical LT5 is somehow "different" and lead will DESTROY IT! Again, no ACTUAL first hand experience. Just alot of conjecture, because people love to appear/sound smarter and more learned than they actually are.
#104
Pro
Don't pretend you know what you are talking about when it comes to leaded aviation fuel. You don't.
http://www.flight-mechanic.com/spark...nance-fouling/
http://www.flight-mechanic.com/spark...nance-fouling/
wait. No? I didn't think so. You are funny to me, trying to sound smarter than you actually are. You are predictable. Oh well.
#105
Race Director
Member Since: Oct 2000
Location: Deal's Gap 2004 NCM Motorsports track supporter
Posts: 13,915
Received 1,103 Likes
on
717 Posts
Don't tell what I know or do not know. You don't know anything about me. And we are talking AUTOMOTIVE ENGINES. Instead of linking generic issues with airplane engines how about some personal FIRST HAND knowledge with auto engines? Go ahead. I'll
wait. No? I didn't think so. You are funny to me, trying to sound smarter than you actually are. You are predictable. Oh well.
wait. No? I didn't think so. You are funny to me, trying to sound smarter than you actually are. You are predictable. Oh well.
#106
Le Mans Master
Sir, I only used the term "LEAD GLOBULES" because another poster used PRECISELY that term--that is why I originally put quotations around it! I know what I have seen with my own eyes and my own experience in automotive engines. I don't understand why there is overwhelming fear and paranoia that leaded fuel will somehow "ruin" your precious engines. Doesn't happen. The cats and 02s, sure--they will be remdered useless eventually. The rest of the engine will not be hurt in any way, shape or form. I am hearing conjecture and internet claims but no ACTUAL first hand experience.
I am not the one that made the claim that LL100 is damaging, therefore the burden of proof does not lie with me, it lies with the person or persons that made such claims. I just think it's hilarious that much of the racing world uses HIGHLY leaded fuel and these deposits never seem to shorten the life of the engine in amy measurable way! Yet here we are on the ZR1 forum and the mystical LT5 is somehow "different" and lead will DESTROY IT! Again, no ACTUAL first hand experience. Just alot of conjecture, because people love to appear/sound smarter and more learned than they actually are.
I am not the one that made the claim that LL100 is damaging, therefore the burden of proof does not lie with me, it lies with the person or persons that made such claims. I just think it's hilarious that much of the racing world uses HIGHLY leaded fuel and these deposits never seem to shorten the life of the engine in amy measurable way! Yet here we are on the ZR1 forum and the mystical LT5 is somehow "different" and lead will DESTROY IT! Again, no ACTUAL first hand experience. Just alot of conjecture, because people love to appear/sound smarter and more learned than they actually are.
#107
Pro Mechanic
Pro Mechanic
IndyCar: Methanol
F1: unleaded fuel similar to "Euro 95" pump gasoline
FIA World Endurance (ie: 24hrs of Le Mans and etc) unleaded, 105-oct E20
FIA World Touring Cars: 93-oct E5
IMSA: 100-oct unleaded
Australian Supercar Series: unleaded E85
Those are the fuels used by some of what "d16dcoe45" terms "the racing world".
The only racing series I could find which could be called "major" which uses leaded fuel is NHRA drag racing allows a limited amount of NHRA-approved leaded racing gasolines supplied by either SUNOCO or VP to be used in Pro Stock, Pro Stock Motorcycle and Comp Eliminator.
It is likely that use of "HIGHLY leaded fuel" in motorsports is far less widespread than "d16dcoe45" may believe.
Last edited by Hib Halverson; 05-27-2019 at 03:31 PM.
The following users liked this post:
sidewinder77 (09-26-2019)
#108
Don't tell what I know or do not know. You don't know anything about me. And we are talking AUTOMOTIVE ENGINES. Instead of linking generic issues with airplane engines how about some personal FIRST HAND knowledge with auto engines? Go ahead. I'll
wait. No? I didn't think so. You are funny to me, trying to sound smarter than you actually are. You are predictable. Oh well.
wait. No? I didn't think so. You are funny to me, trying to sound smarter than you actually are. You are predictable. Oh well.
The following users liked this post:
serpent (05-28-2019)
#109
NASCAR, MECS, Xfinity, Gander Mtn. truck series: unleaded E15 gasoline
IndyCar: Methanol
F1: unleaded fuel similar to "Euro 95" pump gasoline
FIA World Endurance (ie: 24hrs of Le Mans and etc) unleaded, 105-oct E20
FIA World Touring Cars: 93-oct E5
IMSA: 100-oct unleaded
Australian Supercar Series: unleaded E85
Those are the fuels used by some of what "d16dcoe45" terms "the racing world".
The only racing series I could find which could be called "major" which uses leaded fuel is NHRA drag racing allows a limited amount of NHRA-approved leaded racing gasolines supplied by either SUNOCO or VP to be used in Pro Stock, Pro Stock Motorcycle and Comp Eliminator.
It is likely that use of "HIGHLY leaded fuel" in motorsports is far less widespread than "d16dcoe45" may believe.
IndyCar: Methanol
F1: unleaded fuel similar to "Euro 95" pump gasoline
FIA World Endurance (ie: 24hrs of Le Mans and etc) unleaded, 105-oct E20
FIA World Touring Cars: 93-oct E5
IMSA: 100-oct unleaded
Australian Supercar Series: unleaded E85
Those are the fuels used by some of what "d16dcoe45" terms "the racing world".
The only racing series I could find which could be called "major" which uses leaded fuel is NHRA drag racing allows a limited amount of NHRA-approved leaded racing gasolines supplied by either SUNOCO or VP to be used in Pro Stock, Pro Stock Motorcycle and Comp Eliminator.
It is likely that use of "HIGHLY leaded fuel" in motorsports is far less widespread than "d16dcoe45" may believe.
#110
Pro
NASCAR, MECS, Xfinity, Gander Mtn. truck series: unleaded E15 gasoline
IndyCar: Methanol
F1: unleaded fuel similar to "Euro 95" pump gasoline
FIA World Endurance (ie: 24hrs of Le Mans and etc) unleaded, 105-oct E20
FIA World Touring Cars: 93-oct E5
IMSA: 100-oct unleaded
Australian Supercar Series: unleaded E85
Those are the fuels used by some of what "d16dcoe45" terms "the racing world".
The only racing series I could find which could be called "major" which uses leaded fuel is NHRA drag racing allows a limited amount of NHRA-approved leaded racing gasolines supplied by either SUNOCO or VP to be used in Pro Stock, Pro Stock Motorcycle and Comp Eliminator.
It is likely that use of "HIGHLY leaded fuel" in motorsports is far less widespread than "d16dcoe45" may believe.
IndyCar: Methanol
F1: unleaded fuel similar to "Euro 95" pump gasoline
FIA World Endurance (ie: 24hrs of Le Mans and etc) unleaded, 105-oct E20
FIA World Touring Cars: 93-oct E5
IMSA: 100-oct unleaded
Australian Supercar Series: unleaded E85
Those are the fuels used by some of what "d16dcoe45" terms "the racing world".
The only racing series I could find which could be called "major" which uses leaded fuel is NHRA drag racing allows a limited amount of NHRA-approved leaded racing gasolines supplied by either SUNOCO or VP to be used in Pro Stock, Pro Stock Motorcycle and Comp Eliminator.
It is likely that use of "HIGHLY leaded fuel" in motorsports is far less widespread than "d16dcoe45" may believe.
It is far less widespread than I would be believe? Are you being serious now? I almost think you are pulling my leg.
Do you have any idea why every sanctioning body uses unleaded fuel or ethanol based fuel nowadays, sunshine? (BTW I was waiting for you to bring up F1, Nascar and the others because you are very easy to figure out/predicatable) It is because of the EPA and politics, Lead is an ABSOLUTE NO NO in Europe--it is not found in solder, fishing lures, figurines, nothing! So naturally F1 and the FIA specs a quality unleaded. Same with Nascar! Nascar had a 12:1 compression limit, and didn't (or still don't) NEED super high octane fuel but WITHOUT A DOUBT EVERY TEAM WOULD RUN A LEADED RACING FUEL IF GIVEN A CHOICE!
I only took issue with you and Southern Son because you made blanket statements that leaded fuel is more/less the devil for your exotic and precious pushrod, Roots blown (yes SUPER HIGH-TECH🙄LT5 miracle motors. And anyone who had different experience you inferred that they were 100% incorrect and your knowledge was superior to all. You weren't trying to teach, you were trying to "win". Seriously, get off your high-horse. Some people post to learn AND/OR teach, some others post to get the ego massage of appearing more learned than they actually are. You and Southern Son are the former.
Every weekend, 90% of Sportsman AND Professional drag racers fill their tanks with racing fuels containing ENORMOUS AMOUNTS OF TETRAETHYL LEAD! And their engines are as clean at teardown than the guys running pump gas! The fact is, lead is a VERy SMALL part (albeit an important one) of the overall makeup of fuel, and lead alone is not going to define that fuel or how clean it burns in the combustion chamber.
Oh, btw what is the name of your shop? The one you invited me to in your other post?
Last edited by d16dcoe45; 05-28-2019 at 09:43 AM.
#111
Pro
It's just not NHRA but all of drag racing from Pro to test and tune nights in which anyone uses VP's C-11 - C-16, not to mention off roaders, Sand drags, Boats and a ton of other high HP cars. I have a 850 hp Gen 1 car that runs on 102 octane for street use, 110 for the track. Leaded fuels are used much more than you think.
#112
Race Director
Member Since: Oct 2000
Location: Deal's Gap 2004 NCM Motorsports track supporter
Posts: 13,915
Received 1,103 Likes
on
717 Posts
Realize race engines are rebuild frequently. Spark plugs used to be replaced after 12,000 miles in the old days with leaded gas. Exhaust valves were completely covered with lead residues in the leaded gas days. I think Hib misdirected the credit for the "lead globules" term.
#113
Pro Mechanic
Pro Mechanic
It's just not NHRA but all of drag racing from Pro to test and tune nights in which anyone uses VP's C-11 - C-16, not to mention off roaders, Sand drags, Boats and a ton of other high HP cars. I have a 850 hp Gen 1 car that runs on 102 octane for street use, 110 for the track. Leaded fuels are used much more than you think.
Not to say that lots of horsepower can't be made with unleaded fuels. Until recently, NASCAR Cup engines were making 800-hp on non-restrictor plate tracks using unleaded 105-oct E15 gasoline. The top engine guy at TRD was quoted just last week as saying that the engines TRD currently builds for MECS racing's current engine package, would make 900-hp, if they ran without the airflow restrictions NASCAR puts on them.
That said, I get it that some of the larger displacement engines seen in high-performance/racing marine applications and in drag racing need higher octane because of how large their chamber volumes and so forth are making them more detonation sensitive. I also get it that to get much above 105-oct, leaded fuel is required.
But the fact remains...leaded gasoline in applications where 1) normal street driving is part of the equation as well as 2) teardown and rebuilds with far less frequency that you'd see with all-out racing engines can result in lead deposits on spark plugs, valve heads, chamber walls and piston tops.
You say you have an 850-hp Gen 1 car you run on the street on 102-oct leaded fuel....what do your spark plugs look like after 10,000 street miles?
#114
Melting Slicks
Quick question - If a driver left the ZR1 in auto (D mode) and did not use the paddle shifters, do you think that these other PDK cars will be faster on a road course or drag strip?
Stop reading GM biased BS. A8 does not shifter faster than a pdk. The gm a8 is possibly the slowest shifting 8 speed transmission in a high hp car. Why do you think a stock c7z can lose to a stock hellcat, despite the hellcat weight over 900lbs more? Also, the zr1 loses to the Ford gt despite the 100hp and huge tq advantage. Lol I love people who quote biased articles. They do not live in the real world.
Gm really screwed up not putting a dct in the zr1. It will be hilarious if the new gt500 smokes the zr1. I think the zr1 is bad *** but GM should have went out with a bang for the FE zr1 and put a dct transmission in it.
Gm really screwed up not putting a dct in the zr1. It will be hilarious if the new gt500 smokes the zr1. I think the zr1 is bad *** but GM should have went out with a bang for the FE zr1 and put a dct transmission in it.
#115
But I am sure you are old enough to remember when that's all we had was leaded fuel. Even back then I never saw lead build up on any teardowns, plug changes or anything. It was basically just blow by build up due to tolerances back then. Leaded fuel is not a "Engine" problem it's an "environmental" problem and I know VP is working to make more fuels without lead, not because of deposits. I believe they have C-20 now unleaded that handles 30 PSi of boost or up to 12:1 compression.
#116
Pro Mechanic
Pro Mechanic
Now, back to our regularly-scheduled A8 thread...
Occasionally, I assist an oil blender in testing new products in a performance street duty cycle.
In the last half of 2018, we briefly tested an aftermarket Dexron 6, mPAO-based, full-synthetic ATF in an 8L45 eight-speed automatic. The 8L45 and the 8L90 much the same inside with the main difference between the two being the L45 has rotating parts which are smaller in diameter that those in the L90, allowing the transmission case to be smaller and the overall weight of the transmission to be lower, however, the two versions use the same type of torque converter clutches and have the same clutch materials inside the transmission. 8L45s are common in V6-powered light trucks and V6-powered, rear drive passenger cars such as the Camaro and the Cadillac ATS and CTS.
Just before we began this test, I had one of my sources in the service world advise against it because he had heard anecdotal information about dealers who had mistakenly filled eight-speeds with Dexron 6 rather Dexron HP and, subsequently, had those transmissions fail. Feeling the information was too anecdotal, I discounted that intel and proceeded with the test.
I had this transmission flushed and refilled with this aftermarket Dexron 6 fluid. In a 2655 mile test, I could perceive no difference in fluid temperatures or transmission performance. At the 2655 mile mark and several months after the change to the test fluid, the manufacturer of the aftermarket Dexron 6 contacted me and said to end the test because some lab work they had been doing at the same time with the OE fluids indicated that, while the two fluids, Dexron 6 and Dexron HP, were quite similar in base stock and viscosity, their additive packages were vastly different. The feeling was that because of this vast difference in additive packages, use of a Dex 6 spec. fluid in a transmission designed for Dex HP could eventually damage the transmission.
Further research, which included the several GM service bulletins in re: fluid for 8L45s and 8L90, indicates that the factory fill and ACDelco replacement fluids had had their formulations changed two or three times since the transmission was introduced for the 2015 model year. Additionally, at the time we decided to end our test, GM was telling its dealers not to use the ACDelco fluid at all and use only Mobil 1 "Synthetic LV ATF HP" (low-viscosity automatic transmission fluid high-performance) in both 8L45s and 8L90s. We ended the test of the Dex 6 fluid then flushed and refilled the trans with M1 Synthetic LV ATF HP.
The lesson in all this is: don't run any fluid in an eight-speed but either Mobil 1 Synthetic LV ATF HP or other ATF which meets the current Dexron HP specification. I will add that there are very few fluids other than the Mobil 1 which meets that spec.
Occasionally, I assist an oil blender in testing new products in a performance street duty cycle.
In the last half of 2018, we briefly tested an aftermarket Dexron 6, mPAO-based, full-synthetic ATF in an 8L45 eight-speed automatic. The 8L45 and the 8L90 much the same inside with the main difference between the two being the L45 has rotating parts which are smaller in diameter that those in the L90, allowing the transmission case to be smaller and the overall weight of the transmission to be lower, however, the two versions use the same type of torque converter clutches and have the same clutch materials inside the transmission. 8L45s are common in V6-powered light trucks and V6-powered, rear drive passenger cars such as the Camaro and the Cadillac ATS and CTS.
Just before we began this test, I had one of my sources in the service world advise against it because he had heard anecdotal information about dealers who had mistakenly filled eight-speeds with Dexron 6 rather Dexron HP and, subsequently, had those transmissions fail. Feeling the information was too anecdotal, I discounted that intel and proceeded with the test.
I had this transmission flushed and refilled with this aftermarket Dexron 6 fluid. In a 2655 mile test, I could perceive no difference in fluid temperatures or transmission performance. At the 2655 mile mark and several months after the change to the test fluid, the manufacturer of the aftermarket Dexron 6 contacted me and said to end the test because some lab work they had been doing at the same time with the OE fluids indicated that, while the two fluids, Dexron 6 and Dexron HP, were quite similar in base stock and viscosity, their additive packages were vastly different. The feeling was that because of this vast difference in additive packages, use of a Dex 6 spec. fluid in a transmission designed for Dex HP could eventually damage the transmission.
Further research, which included the several GM service bulletins in re: fluid for 8L45s and 8L90, indicates that the factory fill and ACDelco replacement fluids had had their formulations changed two or three times since the transmission was introduced for the 2015 model year. Additionally, at the time we decided to end our test, GM was telling its dealers not to use the ACDelco fluid at all and use only Mobil 1 "Synthetic LV ATF HP" (low-viscosity automatic transmission fluid high-performance) in both 8L45s and 8L90s. We ended the test of the Dex 6 fluid then flushed and refilled the trans with M1 Synthetic LV ATF HP.
The lesson in all this is: don't run any fluid in an eight-speed but either Mobil 1 Synthetic LV ATF HP or other ATF which meets the current Dexron HP specification. I will add that there are very few fluids other than the Mobil 1 which meets that spec.
The following 3 users liked this post by Hib Halverson:
#117
Race Director
Member Since: Oct 2000
Location: Deal's Gap 2004 NCM Motorsports track supporter
Posts: 13,915
Received 1,103 Likes
on
717 Posts
I like changing my own fluids so I appreciate the info on the transmission fluid, Hib.
Here is another little ditty I found on the other topic of interest:
https://www.shell.com/business-custo...-30071600.html
Here is another little ditty I found on the other topic of interest:
https://www.shell.com/business-custo...-30071600.html
#118
Pro Mechanic
Pro Mechanic
With the 8L90, you can only "change" the fluid that's in the pan. Even then, with a Corvette and the trans having no dip stick or fill tube, it's a f@#king bitch of a job to do. Fluid level has to be checked with the trans fluid at 95-115° and the engine running which is impossible to accomplish without burning your arms, so you need some Kevlar gloves and wrist protectors. If you have to add fluid, you need a pump of some sort with a hose long enough to snake around the exhaust and then go up and then bend 180° down into the fill opening which is sealed with a rubber plug which you first must pop out.
I have not actually done that. but I've had the car up in the air looking at how I'd do it.
That coupled with my experiences checking/adding fluid to both an ATS-V with the 8L90 and a Chevy Colorado with an 8L45, has me knowing the above description is pretty close to reality.
To flush and replace all the fluid, you need special equipment dealers and some trans shops have.
I have not actually done that. but I've had the car up in the air looking at how I'd do it.
That coupled with my experiences checking/adding fluid to both an ATS-V with the 8L90 and a Chevy Colorado with an 8L45, has me knowing the above description is pretty close to reality.
To flush and replace all the fluid, you need special equipment dealers and some trans shops have.
The following users liked this post:
SouthernSon (05-30-2019)
#120
"General Motors faced tough challenge when searching for the proper transmission to pair with its all-new 625 horsepower supercharged LT4 engine in the 2015 Corvette Z06. The General wanted to match the lightning-fast shifts offered by Porsche’s PDK transmission, but no dual gearbox existed that met both of GM’s requirements — compact size and the ability to handle the LT4’s 635 lb.-ft. of torque.
The answer? Build one that could. The 8L90 eight-speed automatic transmission found in the new Z06 was developed entirely within GM. It’s a traditional automatic gearbox in its design, but GM says it shifts not only faster than any dual-clutch, but smoother as well."
I addition to the above excerpt, the transmission in the '19 ZR1 also had a few extras added including different algorithms.
The answer? Build one that could. The 8L90 eight-speed automatic transmission found in the new Z06 was developed entirely within GM. It’s a traditional automatic gearbox in its design, but GM says it shifts not only faster than any dual-clutch, but smoother as well."
I addition to the above excerpt, the transmission in the '19 ZR1 also had a few extras added including different algorithms.
The following users liked this post:
serpent (05-31-2019)