Will the ME have a DCT
#61
Le Mans Master
Member Since: Jul 2000
Location: North Dallas 40 TX
Posts: 6,450
Received 4,373 Likes
on
2,065 Posts
People seem to overlook that Tremec has had a DCT for years:
http://www.tremec.com/anexos/Literat...ansmission.pdf
I would suspect that this was meant for the C7 (Z06 perhaps?) but cut due to costs.
http://www.tremec.com/anexos/Literat...ansmission.pdf
I would suspect that this was meant for the C7 (Z06 perhaps?) but cut due to costs.
What was available, at development time, that could handle the torque in the C7 did not fit the space.
#62
Team Owner
That transmission does not meet the torque requirements of the high performance Corvettes. The top transmission is rated at 664 lb/ft the announced ZR1 is rated at 713 lb/ft. The projected engine is at 720 lb/ft. With a new design they could size the transmission space to fit this transmission if it had the torque rating.
What was available, at development time, that could handle the torque in the C7 did not fit the space.
What was available, at development time, that could handle the torque in the C7 did not fit the space.
Last edited by JoesC5; 12-01-2017 at 12:21 PM.
#63
Race Director
Of course it is possible to limit torque by engine manage,ent to keep the transmission together.
Still the 6 or 7 DCT s tested by GM from other manufacturers did not hold up under GM requirements for the 7 th gen.
I have my doubts that a very cool dct transmission can be offered by GM for the c8.
I wish GM would figure out a way to make the dct transmission to work in the c8 chassis.
I'd like that technology in my next corvette so I hope I'm wrong.
Still the 6 or 7 DCT s tested by GM from other manufacturers did not hold up under GM requirements for the 7 th gen.
I have my doubts that a very cool dct transmission can be offered by GM for the c8.
I wish GM would figure out a way to make the dct transmission to work in the c8 chassis.
I'd like that technology in my next corvette so I hope I'm wrong.
#64
Racer
But I honestly don’t feel DCT is anymore than a paper bragging point. My Gallardo is just a single clutch and it shifts pretty fast and is fun. You are talking millisecond, maybe 0.04 seconds quicker to 60 with a DCT vs a single clutch (assuming 1 shift). I would prefer a good single clutch with good longevity to a complicated DCT.
#65
Race Director
The single clutch auto manual were notorious for wear. To extend mileage of clutch manually shifting helped extend mileage a little bit.
Replacement clutches were of different material.
Replacement clutches were of different material.
#66
Drifting
The Tremec DCT TR-9007 is rated at 664 lb-ft of torque, so I'm assuming it could be used behind a 750 HP LT5, without breaking since the TR-6070 can, in a mid engine car and surely the TR-9007 DCT can be used behind either a 4.2L or a 5.5L V8 with much less than 715 lb-ft of torque in a mid engine Corvette.
.
.
#67
Race Director
It should be noted that both BMW and Audi are phasing out DCT's in their entire range and going to TC Autos. This was announced some time ago.
The upcoming M5 has a TC Auto as the first shot across the bow.
I have always been of the opinion that DCT's should be reserved for sports cars. I think TC autos make more sense on luxury/suv vehicles. 2017 saw 77% of Corvettes built with automatics.
All that said, I'll buy a 3 pedal Corvette as long as they offer one. I am afraid, however, that the sun is setting on 3 pedals.
The upcoming M5 has a TC Auto as the first shot across the bow.
I have always been of the opinion that DCT's should be reserved for sports cars. I think TC autos make more sense on luxury/suv vehicles. 2017 saw 77% of Corvettes built with automatics.
All that said, I'll buy a 3 pedal Corvette as long as they offer one. I am afraid, however, that the sun is setting on 3 pedals.
Last edited by jimmyb; 12-04-2017 at 05:40 PM.
The following users liked this post:
JerriVette (12-04-2017)
#68
Race Director
You may be the first Gallardo owner to get more than fifty thousand miles out of the clutch. As you know, the Gallardo is a manual transmission shifted by automated solenoids- not really an automatic. Any lambo I've driven with over twenty-five thousand miles on it has not had a smooth, quarter second shift.
Single or dual clutch the biggest wear issue is starting out from a dead stop. But software and clutch materials have improved. I drove a McLaren 570s and yes that car made mine feel old. Did it shift faster I am sure it did but is it perceivable that it was faster shifting ... not really.
Last edited by rgregory; 12-04-2017 at 06:47 PM.
#69
Race Director
It should be noted that both BMW and Audi are phasing out DCT's in their entire range and going to TC Autos. This was announced some time ago.
The upcoming M5 has a TC Auto as the first shot across the bow.
I have always been of the opinion that DCT's should be reserved for sports cars. I think TC autos make more sense on luxury/suv vehicles. 2017 saw 77% of Corvettes built with automatics.
All that said, I'll buy a 3 pedal Corvette as long as they offer one. I am afraid, however, that the sun is setting on 3 pedals.
The upcoming M5 has a TC Auto as the first shot across the bow.
I have always been of the opinion that DCT's should be reserved for sports cars. I think TC autos make more sense on luxury/suv vehicles. 2017 saw 77% of Corvettes built with automatics.
All that said, I'll buy a 3 pedal Corvette as long as they offer one. I am afraid, however, that the sun is setting on 3 pedals.
#70
Le Mans Master
Member Since: Dec 2004
Location: AZ
Posts: 5,754
Received 536 Likes
on
279 Posts
St. Jude Donor '06-'08-'10-'11-'12-'13 '14-'15-'16-'17-'18-'19
I do agree Audi is moving away from the DCT in SOME applicatins and according to them it's mostly a torque issue. While a DCT can be built to handle the torque, the newest TC trannies seem to provide an excellent drive and feel during the drive that Audi likes for their bigger cars. My A6 TDI has the 8-speed tiptronic which is a TC tranny and seems to fit the car very well.
Last edited by ByByBMW; 12-04-2017 at 08:47 PM.
#71
Race Director
New BMW m5 review with torque converter automatic to replace dct and autocar says no big deal...?
Wasn't the m series supposed to be the ultimate driving machine?
Are torque converter automatics better than dct s according to BMW?
https://www.autocar.co.uk/car-review...m5-2018-review
Wasn't the m series supposed to be the ultimate driving machine?
Are torque converter automatics better than dct s according to BMW?
https://www.autocar.co.uk/car-review...m5-2018-review
#72
New BMW m5 review with torque converter automatic to replace dct and autocar says no big deal...?
Wasn't the m series supposed to be the ultimate driving machine?
Are torque converter automatics better than dct s according to BMW?
https://www.autocar.co.uk/car-review...m5-2018-review
Wasn't the m series supposed to be the ultimate driving machine?
Are torque converter automatics better than dct s according to BMW?
https://www.autocar.co.uk/car-review...m5-2018-review
Those are the benchmarks, and they all run DCT.
DCT is the standard for performance cars.
BMW has been a pathetic joke for a long time and is no longer a performance car brand.
Shaking my head that you even brought BMW up on this website.
#73
Le Mans Master
Originally Posted by JerriVette
New BMW m5 review with torque converter automatic to replace dct and autocar says no big deal...?
Wasn't the m series supposed to be the ultimate driving machine?
Are torque converter automatics better than dct s according to BMW?
https://www.autocar.co.uk/car-review...m5-2018-review
Wasn't the m series supposed to be the ultimate driving machine?
Are torque converter automatics better than dct s according to BMW?
https://www.autocar.co.uk/car-review...m5-2018-review
#74
Race Director
I agree with you guys that a dct would be preferred still there is a possibility the torque converter automatic advances have come so far in the latest iteration that even BMW M division has moved from dct s to planetary torque converter automatics...
I'm willing to keep an open mind as we get to see and hear road test reviews...
You never know..technological advances and evolutionary updates often times can possibly have created a dct equal ...
I'm willing to keep an open mind as we get to see and hear road test reviews...
You never know..technological advances and evolutionary updates often times can possibly have created a dct equal ...
#77
Race Director
For all of you that wish for the car to be manual or paddle shift this is one way it can be possible. Same transmission utilized for either manual configuration or for automated clutch (single). Lambo and Ferrari all did away with the manual options once they went to DCT why?? Because A DCT transmission cannot be used in a manual setup.
#78
Melting Slicks
And why is that? Just because of marketing?
For all of you that wish for the car to be manual or paddle shift this is one way it can be possible. Same transmission utilized for either manual configuration or for automated clutch (single). Lambo and Ferrari all did away with the manual options once they went to DCT why?? Because A DCT transmission cannot be used in a manual setup.
For all of you that wish for the car to be manual or paddle shift this is one way it can be possible. Same transmission utilized for either manual configuration or for automated clutch (single). Lambo and Ferrari all did away with the manual options once they went to DCT why?? Because A DCT transmission cannot be used in a manual setup.
#79
Race Director
#80
Race Director
Supposedly and I wish we could have a dct in the c8... the internals of the 7 different dct transmissions tested by GM for the c7 could not handle the massive low end torque of GMs ohv engines.
Today I would imagine limiting power in early gearing might resolve the issue of the dct breaking apart during GM testing...
Just not sure having to program down the power in the lower gears of a dct allowed for better acceleration compared to the planetary torque converter gearbox.
Don't shoot the messenger...
As I believe if the new E63 AMG can put down 600 hp and tq....through its dct..GM should be able to do the same..
Again it is interesting the BMW m5 released this week drives 600 hp through a torque converter automatic....remember the m5 is supposedly the "ultimate driving machine"
Zero to sixty in 3.1 seconds according to autocar....1 th of a second quicker than the Mercedes AMG e63 with a dct.
Latest and greatest supposedly is the m5 even with the fact it's got a torque converter automatic versus the dct of the Mercedes..
Today I would imagine limiting power in early gearing might resolve the issue of the dct breaking apart during GM testing...
Just not sure having to program down the power in the lower gears of a dct allowed for better acceleration compared to the planetary torque converter gearbox.
Don't shoot the messenger...
As I believe if the new E63 AMG can put down 600 hp and tq....through its dct..GM should be able to do the same..
Again it is interesting the BMW m5 released this week drives 600 hp through a torque converter automatic....remember the m5 is supposedly the "ultimate driving machine"
Zero to sixty in 3.1 seconds according to autocar....1 th of a second quicker than the Mercedes AMG e63 with a dct.
Latest and greatest supposedly is the m5 even with the fact it's got a torque converter automatic versus the dct of the Mercedes..
Last edited by JerriVette; 12-06-2017 at 12:40 PM.