Why is there even a Key Fob anyway?
#22
Safety Car
Member Since: Feb 2016
Location: Bainbridge Island WA
Posts: 4,980
Received 3,818 Likes
on
1,614 Posts
#23
Le Mans Master
The Tesla Model 3 opens the doors and starts the car with the presence of your smartphone. Recently, Lincoln announced that the upcoming Aviator will do the same thing. I see no reason for the key fob anymore. Everyone has a smartphone. Why are we seeing pictures of this outdated key fob for the C8? That's supposed to impress us? What's next, a leaked picture of a C8 Compact Disk player?
Seemingly benign proposals to make one technology dependent on another have unfortunate consequences:
If you use an app to start the car, every single smartphone bug and foible becomes a problem with your car. Dead phone battery? (they last about 1/1000 as long as fob batteries) Bad firmware update? Unpatched security hole? Car won't start. Apple or Google make an API change and GM doesn't keep up? Now it's your car's problem. Replace your phone with the latest thing (like an iWatch 4) but the car app doesn't support it? Oh well.
Chevy isn't going to maintain development of apps forever, so after a decade you'd see owners forced to carry around old phones just to get into their car. People will buy obsolete phones on eBay just to use as spare keys. Eventually the network protocols will change and you won't even be able to load the old apps at all. Talk about "outdated."
The last thing I want standing between me and successfully starting my car is a flaky Bluetooth-based consumer electronics gadget. The standard of quality is so much lower. On a phone, failed connections and even lockups are par for the course. On a car, those sort of malfunctions are a big deal that can force a recall.
Proximity sensing is a crapshoot with phones as the primary key. Phones are fragile. Fobs are tough. One could go on.
The following 3 users liked this post by torquetube:
#24
without the fob gm would lose out on a lot of profit.. i doubt the fob and programming cost anywhere near what they charge..: "According to Consumer Reports, If you lose the key and fob, “you can expect a dealer replacement and programming to cost $200 or more, depending on the vehicle and the key's design."
I dont think they should get rid of the fob, but if it could primarily use my phone I would like that, and then have a slim fob that fits in a wallet as a backup, and also have a traditional fob for people that carry key chains and they can continue to charge them the ridiculous amount.
I dont think they should get rid of the fob, but if it could primarily use my phone I would like that, and then have a slim fob that fits in a wallet as a backup, and also have a traditional fob for people that carry key chains and they can continue to charge them the ridiculous amount.
Last edited by z8ra; 12-01-2018 at 03:49 PM.
#25
Race Director
The Tesla Model 3 opens the doors and starts the car with the presence of your smartphone. Recently, Lincoln announced that the upcoming Aviator will do the same thing. I see no reason for the key fob anymore. Everyone has a smartphone. Why are we seeing pictures of this outdated key fob for the C8? That's supposed to impress us? What's next, a leaked picture of a C8 Compact Disk player?
#26
After replying once, and reading the rest of the posts in this thread I have come to a conclusion. The OP expects the 2020 Corvette ME to be state of the art, on top of all the new tech, etc. And one of those ways is by advancing past the traditional key fob. As many have pointed out, there are many issues with this idea. I think eventually down the line, there could/ should still be a key fob of course but also the option to use your phone. We already have the Chevy app that let's you start your car, unlock your doors. But not as an NFC device. Also the new Cadilalc XT4 uses this new NFC feature, which puts it not beyond the realm of possibility for expansion across other GM models.
The following users liked this post:
Zaro Tundov (12-02-2018)
#28
Le Mans Master
Tesla's smartphone app is so buggy, they had to design, certify and start selling fobs to pissed off Model 3 owners.
https://www.inverse.com/article/4921...tphone-anxiety
This is the same reason I don't have smartphone controlled door locks for my house. I love technology, but sometimes there's nothing wrong with the old way of doing things.
https://www.inverse.com/article/4921...tphone-anxiety
This is the same reason I don't have smartphone controlled door locks for my house. I love technology, but sometimes there's nothing wrong with the old way of doing things.
The following 3 users liked this post by Jeff V.:
#29
Le Mans Master
Thread Starter
I feel like I am reading a transcript to a GM product planning meeting. My gosh! I can't believe all the naysayers on here when it comes to anything new. Rather than making suggestions to improve things, it is "It can't done", "It will never work", "What if the battery goes dead?", "What if...".
I can only imagine the response on here when the passive entry system was proposed.
By the way, Porsche has already figured out how to open the frunk with your hand being in proximity.
I'm really going to throw a wrench into the works. I think they should be looking at biometrics, too. The iPhone XS uses facial recognition to unlock the phone.
If GM doesn't improve their quality, and start innovating, there won't be a GM, and there won't be a Corvette. GM is failing. It is estimated by 2025, Ford will surpass them in sales. GM has a finite number of car lines to cancel, and plants to close. I doubt the Corvette will be the last car line to be cancelled.
I can only imagine the response on here when the passive entry system was proposed.
By the way, Porsche has already figured out how to open the frunk with your hand being in proximity.
I'm really going to throw a wrench into the works. I think they should be looking at biometrics, too. The iPhone XS uses facial recognition to unlock the phone.
If GM doesn't improve their quality, and start innovating, there won't be a GM, and there won't be a Corvette. GM is failing. It is estimated by 2025, Ford will surpass them in sales. GM has a finite number of car lines to cancel, and plants to close. I doubt the Corvette will be the last car line to be cancelled.
#30
^^^^ let me guess you want all the best things for the Corvette but you only want to pay $60K for it?? Going by all your posts, you seem to be praying the C8 does not go up in price! I too want the best GM has to offer for the Corvette and tired of some corners being cut just to keep the price around a base of $60K. I am hoping GM pays attention to all the finer details and they can charge me whatever they reasonably want. I am ok with paying more for a better Corvette! If it happens to price out some of the bottom 10-20% so be it! Maybe they can still offer an updated FE as well (which is currently an amazing car) and appease the people that want to pay $60K+.
#31
^^^^ let me guess you want all the best things for the Corvette but you only want to pay $60K for it?? Going by all your posts, you seem to be praying the C8 does not go up in price! I too want the best GM has to offer for the Corvette and tired of some corners being cut just to keep the price around a base of $60K. I am hoping GM pays attention to all the finer details and they can charge me whatever they reasonably want. I am ok with paying more for a better Corvette! If it happens to price out some of the bottom 10-20% so be it! Maybe they can still offer an updated FE as well (which is currently an amazing car) and appease the people that want to pay $60K+.
#32
Tech Contributor
Member Since: Oct 1999
Location: Charlotte, NC (formerly Endicott, NY)
Posts: 40,087
Received 8,927 Likes
on
5,332 Posts
The Tesla Model 3 opens the doors and starts the car with the presence of your smartphone. Recently, Lincoln announced that the upcoming Aviator will do the same thing. I see no reason for the key fob anymore. Everyone has a smartphone. Why are we seeing pictures of this outdated key fob for the C8? That's supposed to impress us? What's next, a leaked picture of a C8 Compact Disk player?
Bill
#33
Team Owner
A battery powered Tesla not having any power......now that's pretty ironic.
You need a physical key to at least get to the power system, plain and simple........for now anyways.
You need a physical key to at least get to the power system, plain and simple........for now anyways.
#34
Melting Slicks
Member Since: Oct 2005
Location: Hailing From The Mean Streets Of Irvine, California
Posts: 3,100
Received 4,153 Likes
on
1,314 Posts
What If You Still Carry This In Your Back Pocket....
Save The Wave,
Corvette_Nut
Save The Wave,
Corvette_Nut
The following users liked this post:
Michael A (12-02-2018)
The following users liked this post:
ByByBMW (12-03-2018)
#37
#38
Drifting
As someone that just got a Model 3, I like the card. However, the bluetooth unlock on the car is spotty from what I read (mine doesn't work yet). I find it frustrating to open the trunk or unlock all the doors on the vehicle without a simple push of a button. For this reason I am going to be buying the Model 3 FOB (they are optional).
Last edited by Chrisrokc; 12-03-2018 at 10:23 AM.
#39
Race Director
I feel like I am reading a transcript to a GM product planning meeting. My gosh! I can't believe all the naysayers on here when it comes to anything new. Rather than making suggestions to improve things, it is "It can't done", "It will never work", "What if the battery goes dead?", "What if...".
I can only imagine the response on here when the passive entry system was proposed.
By the way, Porsche has already figured out how to open the frunk with your hand being in proximity.
I'm really going to throw a wrench into the works. I think they should be looking at biometrics, too. The iPhone XS uses facial recognition to unlock the phone.
If GM doesn't improve their quality, and start innovating, there won't be a GM, and there won't be a Corvette. GM is failing. It is estimated by 2025, Ford will surpass them in sales. GM has a finite number of car lines to cancel, and plants to close. I doubt the Corvette will be the last car line to be cancelled.
I can only imagine the response on here when the passive entry system was proposed.
By the way, Porsche has already figured out how to open the frunk with your hand being in proximity.
I'm really going to throw a wrench into the works. I think they should be looking at biometrics, too. The iPhone XS uses facial recognition to unlock the phone.
If GM doesn't improve their quality, and start innovating, there won't be a GM, and there won't be a Corvette. GM is failing. It is estimated by 2025, Ford will surpass them in sales. GM has a finite number of car lines to cancel, and plants to close. I doubt the Corvette will be the last car line to be cancelled.
#40
yes. Two ways according to the owners manual.
1. Use cell phone to online order a crowbar to pry open door.
2. If faster service is needed, - Grasp the cell phone firmly and swiftly strike the side glass repeatedly until the window breaks. If cell phone breaks first stop and call for hel... oh wait....
The following users liked this post:
Michael A (12-02-2018)