CorvetteForum - Chevrolet Corvette Forum Discussion

CorvetteForum - Chevrolet Corvette Forum Discussion (https://www.corvetteforum.com/forums/)
-   C8 General Discussion (https://www.corvetteforum.com/forums/c8-general-discussion-175/)
-   -   First use of PDR in (near) crash reconstruction! (https://www.corvetteforum.com/forums/c8-general-discussion/4681584-first-use-of-pdr-in-near-crash-reconstruction.html)

Bird67 10-24-2022 10:57 AM

First use of PDR in (near) crash reconstruction!
 
So this (almost) happened yesterday. I was slowing to a stop at a T intersection when another driver cut the corner coming from my right. I caught it on my PDR. NOTHING HAPPENED. He missed me. You can hear a quick "chirp" of my tires when I stopped in time. (NOTE: you'll also hear I was listening to Unnamed Automotive Podcast at the time...). This is my first personal use of PDR to confirm what happened in traffic. Let's assume there was contact between our vehicles and fault had to be sorted based on this video. What do you think? Who would "win"?

Thankfully this was a non-event! I got lucky either way. NOTE: I trimmed the video so you'll only have to watch it for 30 seconds. ;)


jimjimsC7 10-24-2022 11:03 AM

I'm surprised we didn't hear something like "you f'g dumbass!". Close for sure. I was sideswiped and knocked over like that several years ago on my motorcycle.

DaBlues 10-24-2022 11:04 AM

Was it a female?

WDWC8 10-24-2022 11:06 AM

I would say the car turning definitely took the turn too tightly and looks like they probably would have slightly crossed into your lane. However, from the video it also appears that you didn't come to a complete stop at the stop sign and before entering the crosswalk. No idea on who would win.

Vetteman Jack 10-24-2022 11:24 AM

Just my opinion, but if the car had hit you, I would say he would have been at fault for not properly making the turn. However, no telling what a lawyer could make from the incident.

feeder82 10-24-2022 11:28 AM

from the angle of the video it looked like you didn't stop before the cross walk, in that case your fault.

plmmd 10-24-2022 12:35 PM

in most states making a left turn makes you liable- though not fully stopped intersection that a moot issue

JDSKY 10-24-2022 01:04 PM

Interesting video. As has already been stated it does not look like you stopped prior to the cross walk. To be fair the driver in front you did not stop either and just rolled through. Any attorney worth their salt would advise you not to use the video in court.

undecided1965 10-24-2022 02:01 PM

Rolling stop....See it so often. This could go either way.

CP 10-24-2022 03:01 PM

That wasn't even close.

Amoreloba 10-24-2022 03:14 PM


Originally Posted by DaBlues (Post 1605824153)
Was it a female?

ha ha women drivers bad! :U

Glad the jail bird is still intact. Stay safe out there, keep your stick on the ice.

Bird67 10-24-2022 09:06 PM

Other than the "women driver" crack (it was a dude FTW), I agree with the conflicting comments. The video does show that he cut the corner and does suggest a rolling stop. In truth the stop at that corner is just past the crosswalk...so good thing no impact.

NA Screamer 10-25-2022 12:46 AM


Originally Posted by Bird67 (Post 1605826555)
Other than the "women driver" crack (it was a dude FTW), I agree with the conflicting comments. The video does show that he cut the corner and does suggest a rolling stop. In truth the stop at that corner is just past the crosswalk...so good thing no impact.

Negative, ghost rider. That stop sign is several feet before that crosswalk. You definitely rolled right through the stop sign and into the crosswalk. Its a good thing no pedestrians were around!

Greg00Coupe 10-25-2022 07:37 AM

Don’t think the crosswalk is an issue. There was no one in the cross walk so that is a non factor. He cut across you before you had a chance to make a full stop. He crossed solid lines. With that being said I’d guess the insurance company would argue shared fault, because that is what they do.

That situation is an issue with folks turning shaving the corners.

Rich Mickol 10-25-2022 08:26 AM

The point and place of impact would have been better for your case. The video, I’m not so sure. Thank goodness it was just a near miss.

Atlantan 10-25-2022 09:39 AM

PDR story
 
I record every drive and here's an interesting story.

Downside of having a personalized plate on a bright yellow sports car is anyone can remember it easily and track you down. A plate investigator was able to provide the driver my phone number and Friday morning I received a random text message...

The driver texted me that my Vette was in front of his car, both cars making a left turn. After I made the left turn, his car made the left turn and was struck by a car who was allegedly running a red light resulting in totaling his car. Driver claimed that we had a left turn green arrow, lady who struck him claimed she had a green light, there were no witnesses or intersection footage. The driver asked if I had dash cam footage to validate his claim. I was able to send him a clip of my PDR footage which showed that when I made the left turn the arrow was not green, but the light was green with a yield on green sign. The PDR footage proved that the driver was at fault, he was hoping the PDR footage would prove otherwise. He was very appreciative of my help.

I will continue to record every drive.

ev1156 10-25-2022 10:30 AM

You might have had problem also as there was a stop sign which you didn't stop at.

jackfrostpdx 10-25-2022 11:36 AM

OP is a bad driver lucky enough not to be hit by a worse driver

Bird67 10-25-2022 01:05 PM


Originally Posted by Rich Mickol (Post 1605827439)
The point and place of impact would have been better for your case. The video, I’m not so sure. Thank goodness it was just a near miss.

That is my take on it too. the contact point on the face of the earth alone is a favorable fact. Adding the video makes it look like a California stop before a right turn, just like the Porsche did. It wasn’t - it was to be a left turn, not a right - but it looks that way on the video. To make a left there you have to stop beyond the crosswalk in order to see if traffic was clear. The crosswalk itself is a non-issue - you have to stop for people in crosswalks, not for crosswalks. The Porsche in front had just gone through so obviously there was no one in the crosswalk.

As said already, SO glad this turned out the way it did.

DaBlues 10-25-2022 01:12 PM

With no fault insurance does it even matter. If a cop were present then it appears he could ticket the turning automobile for crossing his center yellow line making the turn early and he could ticket the vette for not coming to a complete stop. This was all explained in driver's training is it time for remediation?


All times are GMT -4. The time now is 05:53 PM.


© 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands