04 C5 Harmonic Balancer HELP !
#1
Racer
Thread Starter
04 C5 Harmonic Balancer HELP !
In two years I have had 3 Harmonic Balancers installed by the dealership. The first one failed and started wobbling bad at about 10 months. Under warranty they installed a new balancer and bolt. Then about two months out of the one year warranty the Balancer bolt worked its way completly loose and was resting on the PS rail. I was out on vacation and had another dealer install a new bolt and then one month later the balancer was wobbling very bad. The service manager just shook his head and said maybe a different balancer and bolt would work as the GM parts kept failing. So I bought a API Balancer from Summit Racing along with an ARP Bolt. About 435.00 total parts. Now I was asked by the tech that installed the API balancer and ARP Bolt if I wanted locktite or to used the lube that came with the ARP Bolt. After talking with the guys at ARP in Cali. we decided to go with the lube that came with the ARP Bolt. NOW>>>> if this does not work what would be next, outside of taking a gas can and a match to the vette? Any suggestions would be greatly appreciated as I am at wits end. Thanks.......
#2
Team Owner
Are you sure that someone, in the past, didn't strip the threads in the snout of the crank? If installed PROPERLY, there's no good reason for the crank bolt to simply fall out, unless the threads are bad.
FWIW, I installed an ATI balancer, using an ARP bolt, 2-3 years ago, on my C-5. I will admit that it's a low mileage car, but the bolt is still in place, after about 2000 miles. Keep in mind, 237 ft/lbs is a LOT of torque to apply to a bolt. It should not back out.......
FWIW, I installed an ATI balancer, using an ARP bolt, 2-3 years ago, on my C-5. I will admit that it's a low mileage car, but the bolt is still in place, after about 2000 miles. Keep in mind, 237 ft/lbs is a LOT of torque to apply to a bolt. It should not back out.......
#3
Racer
Thread Starter
Are you sure that someone, in the past, didn't strip the threads in the snout of the crank? If installed PROPERLY, there's no good reason for the crank bolt to simply fall out, unless the threads are bad.
FWIW, I installed an ATI balancer, using an ARP bolt, 2-3 years ago, on my C-5. I will admit that it's a low mileage car, but the bolt is still in place, after about 2000 miles. Keep in mind, 237 ft/lbs is a LOT of torque to apply to a bolt. It should not back out.......
FWIW, I installed an ATI balancer, using an ARP bolt, 2-3 years ago, on my C-5. I will admit that it's a low mileage car, but the bolt is still in place, after about 2000 miles. Keep in mind, 237 ft/lbs is a LOT of torque to apply to a bolt. It should not back out.......
I forgot to mention that in Feb. 2005 there was a TSB released by GM that stated that there were reports of Harmonic Balancer Bolts backing completly out and the TSB gives complete instructions on how to fix the problem. BUT>>>>>that GM fix did not work. Then in 2012 GM released another TSB about the Bolt backing out. I don't think that fix worked either.
Last edited by nmbsun; 09-15-2017 at 09:10 AM.
The following users liked this post:
smoothsailing (03-05-2018)
#5
Racer
Thread Starter
I forgot to mention that at this point price is not an issue. I just want the vette fixed period! That is why I spend the 435.00 for the ATI and ARP bolt.
Last edited by nmbsun; 09-15-2017 at 09:46 AM.
#6
Team Owner
The ATI and ARP bolt are top of the line products. As long as they were correctly installed, you shouldn't have an issue. However, if it does come loose there may be some damage to the crank itself as a result of prior issues. If that is the case, get the ATI pin kit and use that for the re-installation. That will keep it from spinning on the crank.
Note that removal of the ATI is done with different tools than the GM so if the service department is doing the work they need to be made aware of this.
Note that removal of the ATI is done with different tools than the GM so if the service department is doing the work they need to be made aware of this.
#7
The balancer bolt is a TTY (torque to yield) bolt meaning it stretches slightly when final torque is reached and thus is NOT reusable. So if someone told me their newly installed balancer bolt was backing out, my first instinct is that they didn't use a new bolt. (What dealership mechs say and do are rarely in alignment in my experience) So I suspect now that you've purchased a new ARP bolt (and top of the line balancer) your problems will disappear.
Last edited by wcsinx; 09-15-2017 at 12:13 PM.
#8
Burning Brakes
I replaced mine about 7 years ago.. At the time, I wasn't real educated on the differences.
I used the GM balancer and bolt.. I kinda figured if the OEM lasted 10 years *& 100K miles.. I could certainly deal with it..
Now I've only put about 20K on this replacement one, but all is good..
I suspect the original dealer that did your install F'ed up your crank threads..
OR just did the procedure incorrectly totally... Causing all your issues afterwards..
Good luck with the aftermarket stuff.. It's WAY Better.. just make sure they
really check the threads on the crank... And I'd PIN IT like suggested to add insurance that
this is the last time you have to deal with this issue
I used the GM balancer and bolt.. I kinda figured if the OEM lasted 10 years *& 100K miles.. I could certainly deal with it..
Now I've only put about 20K on this replacement one, but all is good..
I suspect the original dealer that did your install F'ed up your crank threads..
OR just did the procedure incorrectly totally... Causing all your issues afterwards..
Good luck with the aftermarket stuff.. It's WAY Better.. just make sure they
really check the threads on the crank... And I'd PIN IT like suggested to add insurance that
this is the last time you have to deal with this issue
#9
Race Director
Member Since: Dec 2010
Location: Atlanta, GA
Posts: 10,426
Received 1,261 Likes
on
1,056 Posts
2020 Corvette of the Year Finalist (performance mods)
C5 of Year Winner (performance mods) 2019
I agree with having it pinned if they haven't already put the car back together... it will prevent the balancer from spinning on the crank as well as keeping the bolt from backing it's way out assuming that it is torqued properly
#10
Melting Slicks
The original factory bolts can become loose, but usually under certain conditions, the vette was extensively used at a drag strip, heavy autocross use or HPDE use. When you run the engine for long periods at high rpms, the bolt was know to walk (come loose). Those who autocross in the street classes have to run OEM balancer and bolt, so when my bolt walked and I threw my serpentine belt, I replaced it my self. However, I made double sure it was torqued correctly and the balancer pinned. Thousands of autocross runs and several thousand miles of HPDE runs and it still is intact. If I did not have to have everything stock, I would have put in the ATI damper. Biggest problem is mechanics who tried to use a torque value to tighten the bolt. When I was turning it the extra 140 degrees, my beam torque wrench and extension pipe exceeded 300 lb-ft.
#11
How do you "pin" the balancer? What is the correct torgue? Will be doing this at home with my son a diesel tech. Noise coming from lower unit. Changed pullies already, still have the noise. Stock car no racing. Recommendations on brand?
Last edited by smoothsailing; 02-21-2018 at 01:27 PM.
#12
Safety Car
Member Since: Apr 2013
Location: Oregon
Posts: 4,616
Received 971 Likes
on
783 Posts
St. Jude Donor '14-'15-'16-'17-'18-'19-'20-'21-'22-'23
Since your car is stock, I would use the Power bond PB1117N and the ARP bolt 234-2503 and a new front cover seal. The torque spec on the ARP bolt 235ft/lb
The following users liked this post:
smoothsailing (02-21-2018)
#13
Sure this is a dumb question, my son will know what you meant. But I don't, what cover seal are you referring to? Didn't think would be taking any covers off replacing the balancer. Again thanks for your help.
The following users liked this post:
smoothsailing (02-22-2018)
#16
Race Director
Member Since: Dec 2010
Location: Atlanta, GA
Posts: 10,426
Received 1,261 Likes
on
1,056 Posts
2020 Corvette of the Year Finalist (performance mods)
C5 of Year Winner (performance mods) 2019
to add to that, since you have no need to take the cover off stop there and replace the seal with the cover still installed... if you remove the cover it will need to be properly centered around the crank or you risk your balancer hub chewing up the seal and causing an oil leak... been there done that
The following users liked this post:
smoothsailing (02-22-2018)
#17
Drifting
Improper installation can easily be the cause. I've seen way too many people stating they wrapped a belt around the balancer or put a block under it. Both of these methods put abnormal stress into the rubber bond between the inner hub and the outer ring.
Also, the crank is what needs to be held as that is what the bolt is turning into. Holding the balancer is not the correct way to do it.
If they have damaged the crank at this point, that is not good. I would find out exactly how they have been holding assembly when tightening the bolt.
Also, the crank is what needs to be held as that is what the bolt is turning into. Holding the balancer is not the correct way to do it.
If they have damaged the crank at this point, that is not good. I would find out exactly how they have been holding assembly when tightening the bolt.
Last edited by Ed Ramberger; 02-21-2018 at 09:50 PM.
The following users liked this post:
smoothsailing (02-22-2018)
#19
Install done
Thank you all for your help on this. Somken1 used the parts you recommended. The install went well, several hours in my garage, the real pain on this install was the removal and reinstall of the rack and pinion assembly. Like a jig saw puzzle. Did not need to take off the sway bar. We were not positive the noise was the balancer, turned out it was. No noise after install.