Magnuson heartbeat or eldlebrock for my c6 z06
#1
Magnuson heartbeat or eldlebrock for my c6 z06
Hey guys. I just bought a 07 z06 and I love it. The car is bone stock with 20k miles on it. I first plan on putting on a set of American heritage heads to fix the head problem. After that I want to put a supercharger on it to add some extra power. I am leaning towards either the eldlebrock or the heartbeat because I like the looks they give. They look factory. I know I will get more power from a a&a or ecs but want to stay with the roots style like magnuson or heartbeat. Just curious which setup is better. Any opinions which one to go with? The car will be 100% a street driver. I will not be racing the car. Just a fun driver and burnout machine. Reliability is a must as well. I don’t want to worry about that.
Thanks for your help
Jon
Thanks for your help
Jon
Last edited by J02ws6transam; 01-21-2018 at 07:58 AM.
#2
Team Owner
For what you want, buy whichever one you get a better deal on. Both are reliable and fine out of the box, and since you are not concerned with power or racing, just save the most money and go with the cheaper or better looking of the two.
#3
Safety Car
For a burnout machine either one will get the job done.
#5
Thanks for the feedback. I mean of course the more power the better lol but going for a little more of a factory look than the centrifugal look. I had. Pro charger on a 05 c6 I had a few years ago. I loved it. Car was a animal. But with this being a z06 I figured I would go for more of a factory look. From the research I have done, it seems like the heartbeat makes a little more power. Or are they about the same? The heartbeat fits under the hood ok? I read you have to either remove the hood liner or use the lingenfelter frame adapter? Had anyone driven both to know if one had more of a supercharger whine than another. In my last truck I had a Toyota Tundra which I put a Toyota supercharger on which is made by magnuson and it had a really nice whine to it. With the corvette being louder you might not hear the whine as much though.
Thanks for the help
jon
Thanks for the help
jon
#6
Le Mans Master
The Heartbeat will fit under the stock hood (with hood liner) just fine. Only place that mine rubbed was on a clamp that held the rubber connector from the CAI to the throttle body. It was very minor. Never bothered me. You could probably clock the clamp to be at the bottom of that connection and not rub at all.
You won't get a lot of whine out of either of them. The internals are exactly the same between the two. ANY kind of exhaust noise will drown out the little bit of whine that's there. That's one of the many reasons that the OEM's like them.
Oh, and despite what you read here sometimes, you can outrun a lot of higher horsepowered rigs in curvy and straight line racing.
You won't get a lot of whine out of either of them. The internals are exactly the same between the two. ANY kind of exhaust noise will drown out the little bit of whine that's there. That's one of the many reasons that the OEM's like them.
Oh, and despite what you read here sometimes, you can outrun a lot of higher horsepowered rigs in curvy and straight line racing.
#8
Drifting
I have a max effort e-force on my Z ...car feels amazing but I do have a built motor ,head,cam and the rest of the supporting modifications also have borla exhaust and I’ll tell you one thing you will definitely hear the blower wine over the exhaust ...if I had to do it over again I would just use a centrifugal supercharger because I don’t like the wine....
#9
Le Mans Master
Originally Posted by c5mtl
I have a max effort e-force on my Z ...car feels amazing but I do have a built motor ,head,cam and the rest of the supporting modifications also have borla exhaust and I’ll tell you one thing you will definitely hear the blower wine over the exhaust ...if I had to do it over again I would just use a centrifugal supercharger because I don’t like the wine....
#10
Burning Brakes
How about the Whipple?
#11
Team Owner
Whipple is a decent blower, but doesn't fit factory hood, so add $1000-4000 for a hood.
IMO, centri kits are the way to go.
IMO, centri kits are the way to go.
#12
Burning Brakes
Originally Posted by Unreal
Whipple is a decent blower, but doesn't fit factory hood, so add $1000-4000 for a hood.
IMO, centri kits are the way to go.
IMO, centri kits are the way to go.
#13
Team Owner
IMO the heartbeat is a better choice. Fits under stock hood, fits great, makes good power, and just works. The extra cost and power cap of the whipple just doesn't work well on a vette like other platforms.
#14
1st Gear
Member Since: Feb 2018
Location: Manhattan Montana
Posts: 1
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I have an 06 z that had an eforce installed at 20k and is now nearly at 65k. Runs great, fits under the hood without removing the heat shield and makes killer power. Have a custom tune done to it though, tuned on the dyno for torque made 601ftlbs and 572 hp. Only downside is you can barely hear a light whine.
#15
Heartbeat of the two.
#16
Burning Brakes
Doesn't Chevrolet sell a COPO with a Whipple on an LS?
Last edited by petsur; 02-01-2018 at 09:25 PM.
#17
Le Mans Master
Yes, I think that is the case. Still need a new hood on a C6 though.
A Heartbeat running an 81 mm pulley on a Z06 with headers would be a good option. You're looking at mid to upper 600's at the wheels with only 8ish psi of boost. A Heartbeat spinning at that speed will have little to no whine.
That's how mine was pullied and it was virtually silent in and out of boost. When you spin them up way past that, you do get more whine.
A Heartbeat running an 81 mm pulley on a Z06 with headers would be a good option. You're looking at mid to upper 600's at the wheels with only 8ish psi of boost. A Heartbeat spinning at that speed will have little to no whine.
That's how mine was pullied and it was virtually silent in and out of boost. When you spin them up way past that, you do get more whine.
#18
Team Owner
That is one of the issues people don't get. A blower is more than just a blower. It has a manifold, intercooler, heat exchanger, etc. A whipple is a good set blower, but if it is packaged on top of a tiny restrictrive intercooler, crap manifold, etc it doesn't matter. Same thing with some of the centri kits. Some have much better brackets, belt setups, intakes, etc.
A PD blower on a mustang can crack out huge numbers with ease because the DOHC setup gives a huge valley, and tons of hood room to make an awesome PD setup. Similar with the camaro, much more room for better packaging. Vette is limited, and suffers from it. So comparing to a camaro doesn't mean much.
A PD blower on a mustang can crack out huge numbers with ease because the DOHC setup gives a huge valley, and tons of hood room to make an awesome PD setup. Similar with the camaro, much more room for better packaging. Vette is limited, and suffers from it. So comparing to a camaro doesn't mean much.
#19
Burning Brakes
Originally Posted by Unreal
That is one of the issues people don't get. A blower is more than just a blower. It has a manifold, intercooler, heat exchanger, etc. A whipple is a good set blower, but if it is packaged on top of a tiny restrictrive intercooler, crap manifold, etc it doesn't matter. Same thing with some of the centri kits. Some have much better brackets, belt setups, intakes, etc.
A PD blower on a mustang can crack out huge numbers with ease because the DOHC setup gives a huge valley, and tons of hood room to make an awesome PD setup. Similar with the camaro, much more room for better packaging. Vette is limited, and suffers from it. So comparing to a camaro doesn't mean much.
A PD blower on a mustang can crack out huge numbers with ease because the DOHC setup gives a huge valley, and tons of hood room to make an awesome PD setup. Similar with the camaro, much more room for better packaging. Vette is limited, and suffers from it. So comparing to a camaro doesn't mean much.
#20
maggy
i have a 2012 base unit that i had Lingenfleter put on a tvs2300 magnason dyno at 518 rwhp quite and power. Lingenfleter has a 1/4" shim to fix hood clearance. just my 2 cents