17" vs 18" rear rims - racers step inside
#1
Pro
Thread Starter
17" vs 18" rear rims - racers step inside
Posting here caause I know a lot of you FI guys are drag racers. I'm doing a FI build that hopefully will be around 750 Flywheel HP in a car with all the standard bolt on's. It a 2003 that will have a LS2 forged lower transplanted. Running gas as fuel, a RPM A6 and 3.42 rear.
Now to the problem. I have polished thin spokes on stock stagger - 17" front, 18" rears. I want to keep these wheels. Yes I like them and will keep them. I want stealth for the street as well as the strip. The car will do occasional duty at the local 1/8 mile drag. I will be fitting drag radials to what ever rear rims I use. I will be keeping the 17" fronts but I have access to another set of 17" thin spoke fronts that could be widened for duty on the rear.
I think it about $250 per rim to widen. Is the 17" rims worth the cost in terms of traction and tire availability or should I just say good enough and run the origial 18's
Now to the problem. I have polished thin spokes on stock stagger - 17" front, 18" rears. I want to keep these wheels. Yes I like them and will keep them. I want stealth for the street as well as the strip. The car will do occasional duty at the local 1/8 mile drag. I will be fitting drag radials to what ever rear rims I use. I will be keeping the 17" fronts but I have access to another set of 17" thin spoke fronts that could be widened for duty on the rear.
I think it about $250 per rim to widen. Is the 17" rims worth the cost in terms of traction and tire availability or should I just say good enough and run the origial 18's
#2
Le Mans Master
Posting here caause I know a lot of you FI guys are drag racers. I'm doing a FI build that hopefully will be around 750 Flywheel HP in a car with all the standard bolt on's. It a 2003 that will have a LS2 forged lower transplanted. Running gas as fuel, a RPM A6 and 3.42 rear.
Now to the problem. I have polished thin spokes on stock stagger - 17" front, 18" rears. I want to keep these wheels. Yes I like them and will keep them. I want stealth for the street as well as the strip. The car will do occasional duty at the local 1/8 mile drag. I will be fitting drag radials to what ever rear rims I use. I will be keeping the 17" fronts but I have access to another set of 17" thin spoke fronts that could be widened for duty on the rear.
I think it about $250 per rim to widen. Is the 17" rims worth the cost in terms of traction and tire availability or should I just say good enough and run the origial 18's
Now to the problem. I have polished thin spokes on stock stagger - 17" front, 18" rears. I want to keep these wheels. Yes I like them and will keep them. I want stealth for the street as well as the strip. The car will do occasional duty at the local 1/8 mile drag. I will be fitting drag radials to what ever rear rims I use. I will be keeping the 17" fronts but I have access to another set of 17" thin spoke fronts that could be widened for duty on the rear.
I think it about $250 per rim to widen. Is the 17" rims worth the cost in terms of traction and tire availability or should I just say good enough and run the origial 18's
that being said the MTs and other drag radials work well.
I went with both 17s and 16s and the 16s have more sidewall and hook much better
look more at the aspect ratio and see what sizes will fit
I'm running older RA1 335 18s and ran cup 18s 345 and when fresh they hook pretty good too but not enough for the digs
I like the MTs and the Hoosier DRs
#3
Pro
Thread Starter
17" vs 18" rims
for all out the bigger sidewalls and taller tires can help with traction
that being said the MTs and other drag radials work well.
I went with both 17s and 16s and the 16s have more sidewall and hook much better
look more at the aspect ratio and see what sizes will fit
I'm running older RA1 335 18s and ran cup 18s 345 and when fresh they hook pretty good too but not enough for the digs
I like the MTs and the Hoosier DRs
that being said the MTs and other drag radials work well.
I went with both 17s and 16s and the 16s have more sidewall and hook much better
look more at the aspect ratio and see what sizes will fit
I'm running older RA1 335 18s and ran cup 18s 345 and when fresh they hook pretty good too but not enough for the digs
I like the MTs and the Hoosier DRs
#4
Melting Slicks
Would something like this work rather than sending your OE wheels out to be widened?
https://www.jegs.com/i/OE-Wheels/494/5910210/10002/-1
https://www.jegs.com/i/OE-Wheels/494/5910210/10002/-1
The following users liked this post:
BURL (05-01-2018)
#5
Disregarding tire brands etc. in general if we get down to the heart of the question, do you feel the 17" rims will provide a pronounced advantage due to a little more sidewall.This won't be cheap to do - with shipping it'd gonna be about $300.00 per wheel to widen the 17"'s
I wouldn't pay 500 to widen 17s for the rear. If your dead set on using the stock y2k wheels, I would try to fit the tallest tire you can on the 18.
#6
Pro
Thread Starter
Would something like this work rather than sending your OE wheels out to be widened?
https://www.jegs.com/i/OE-Wheels/494/5910210/10002/-1
https://www.jegs.com/i/OE-Wheels/494/5910210/10002/-1
#7
Pro
Thread Starter
Posting here caause I know a lot of you FI guys are drag racers. I'm doing a FI build that hopefully will be around 750 Flywheel HP in a car with all the standard bolt on's. It a 2003 that will have a LS2 forged lower transplanted. Running gas as fuel, a RPM A6 and 3.42 rear.
Now to the problem. I have polished thin spokes on stock stagger - 17" front, 18" rears. I want to keep these wheels. Yes I like them and will keep them. I want stealth for the street as well as the strip. The car will do occasional duty at the local 1/8 mile drag. I will be fitting drag radials to what ever rear rims I use. I will be keeping the 17" fronts but I have access to another set of 17" thin spoke fronts that could be widened for duty on the rear.
I think it about $250 per rim to widen. Is the 17" rims worth the cost in terms of traction and tire availability or should I just say good enough and run the origial 18's
Now to the problem. I have polished thin spokes on stock stagger - 17" front, 18" rears. I want to keep these wheels. Yes I like them and will keep them. I want stealth for the street as well as the strip. The car will do occasional duty at the local 1/8 mile drag. I will be fitting drag radials to what ever rear rims I use. I will be keeping the 17" fronts but I have access to another set of 17" thin spoke fronts that could be widened for duty on the rear.
I think it about $250 per rim to widen. Is the 17" rims worth the cost in terms of traction and tire availability or should I just say good enough and run the origial 18's
Anyone know how these rims would fit ad if I will run into a "protrusion" problem?
Last edited by BURL; 05-01-2018 at 12:22 PM. Reason: Text correction
#8
Race Director
Member Since: Dec 2010
Location: Atlanta, GA
Posts: 10,426
Received 1,261 Likes
on
1,056 Posts
2020 Corvette of the Year Finalist (performance mods)
C5 of Year Winner (performance mods) 2019
c4 zr1 wheels are 17x11 and will fit but the oems are harder to find, personally I wouldn't want replicas for anything other than driving on... you can use your 17x9.5 and use a 275 tire with a bigger sidewall, sidewall is more important than width
#9
Melting Slicks
A 17" tire and wheel combo is almost always going to provide better traction than an 18" tire and wheel combo especially if the 17" combo is taller or as tall as the 18" combo. There are some situations where people make 18s and even 19s work but it involves aftermarket ECUs and traction control.
What tire sizes are you planning to use?
You didn't mention your power adder of choice in this build but if it is a supercharger, the 18 inch combo may work ok with 750hp as torque will most likely be lower 6xx to the rw? One thing to be careful with is the torque converter. An aggressive stall to torque ratio on the converter will annihilate the tires and make the combo weak on the street without traction.
What tire sizes are you planning to use?
You didn't mention your power adder of choice in this build but if it is a supercharger, the 18 inch combo may work ok with 750hp as torque will most likely be lower 6xx to the rw? One thing to be careful with is the torque converter. An aggressive stall to torque ratio on the converter will annihilate the tires and make the combo weak on the street without traction.
#10
Pro
Thread Starter
I may be misunderstanding your post but I'm keeping my polished thin spokes so that's the reason I'm considering widening 2 17"' OEM thin spokes for the rear - but only if 17's are a big advantage to the stock 18's. Alternately I might go to after market 17 X 9.5 or 18 X 10.5 rears if they are a close match to my polished wheels. Won't be doing C4 wheels. My current 17's are only 8.5" by the way. My original post may clear up what I'm trying to say.
#11
Race Director
Member Since: Dec 2010
Location: Atlanta, GA
Posts: 10,426
Received 1,261 Likes
on
1,056 Posts
2020 Corvette of the Year Finalist (performance mods)
C5 of Year Winner (performance mods) 2019
I understand you are keeping your 17s up front but if you had another set you could still run a good enough tire without having to widen them... but I thought they were 9.5" wide, 8.5" might be too narrow... oem c5z front wheels are 17x9.5 and will also work but if you are concerned about them matching then you would need a complete set... you can always run rear 18s up front with 17s in the rear... if you don't want it to disrupt the tc/ah then keep the rear tire at least 1/2" taller than the front but if you are only using them for racing then it doesn't matter since you will most likely have tc/ah off anyway
#12
Melting Slicks
Member Since: Dec 2003
Location: Near Jacksonville Fl.
Posts: 3,314
Likes: 0
Received 12 Likes
on
11 Posts
I may be misunderstanding your post but I'm keeping my polished thin spokes so that's the reason I'm considering widening 2 17"' OEM thin spokes for the rear - but only if 17's are a big advantage to the stock 18's. Alternately I might go to after market 17 X 9.5 or 18 X 10.5 rears if they are a close match to my polished wheels. Won't be doing C4 wheels. My current 17's are only 8.5" by the way. My original post may clear up what I'm trying to say.
#13
Pro
Thread Starter
A 17" tire and wheel combo is almost always going to provide better traction than an 18" tire and wheel combo especially if the 17" combo is taller or as tall as the 18" combo. There are some situations where people make 18s and even 19s work but it involves aftermarket ECUs and traction control.
What tire sizes are you planning to use?
You didn't mention your power adder of choice in this build but if it is a supercharger, the 18 inch combo may work ok with 750hp as torque will most likely be lower 6xx to the rw? One thing to be careful with is the torque converter. An aggressive stall to torque ratio on the converter will annihilate the tires and make the combo weak on the street without traction.
What tire sizes are you planning to use?
You didn't mention your power adder of choice in this build but if it is a supercharger, the 18 inch combo may work ok with 750hp as torque will most likely be lower 6xx to the rw? One thing to be careful with is the torque converter. An aggressive stall to torque ratio on the converter will annihilate the tires and make the combo weak on the street without traction.
I don't know about tires until I settle the rim thing but I realize tire availability for 17 vs 18 is part of the equation but I don't have the experience to pick tire sizes. When I settle on 17 vs 18 then I guess I'll move on to tire size
What you mention about torque converts is interesting also. I been reading for a year about people with 3600 ad 3800 torque converters and I'm thinking what's keeping these cars from going up in smoke on the line? If you do slicks you chance drive line failure and I just don't see how drag radials, especially with the deep low gear of the A4 can hold these 700, 800, 900 HP cars. In the back of my mind I've about settled on a 2800 stall. This is to be a street car occasionally raced. It's not a race car occasionally to be driven on the street.
I was hoping to find someone who has been through the 17 vs 18 rear rim issue to give some experienced advice. Now that I see how inexpensive some of these after market rims are the Jegs 17 X 9.5 and the 18 X 10.5 look interesting but as I said I don't know if the 10.5 will fit (with proper tire) under the car without sticking out on the sides. That 18 X 10.5 might be the way to go.
#14
Pro
Thread Starter
17" tire width
I understand you are keeping your 17s up front but if you had another set you could still run a good enough tire without having to widen them... but I thought they were 9.5" wide, 8.5" might be too narrow... oem c5z front wheels are 17x9.5 and will also work but if you are concerned about them matching then you would need a complete set... you can always run rear 18s up front with 17s in the rear... if you don't want it to disrupt the tc/ah then keep the rear tire at least 1/2" taller than the front but if you are only using them for racing then it doesn't matter since you will most likely have tc/ah off anyway
#15
Pro
Thread Starter
Early vs late thin spokes
My car is an 03. Have always assumed they were the thinner spokes. Maybe not. What year was the change made?
#17
Pro
Thread Starter
Rims
1. The 1st gear in the A4 is extremely low (too low) so the tall tire would slightly reduce the gear ratio in first.
2. The taller tire will have more sidewall ad more flex and provide better traction than a shorter stiffer sidewall.
Which is the reason you say get the tallest tire? Or is it a combination of both?
Thanks
#18
Instructor
A taller tire will give you more sidewall. The larger sidewall will allow for more flex in the tire, which will be more effective at getting traction and transferring power to the ground. Watch a slo-mo launch of a top fuel dragster, same concept, just not nearly as extreme.
If I was in your shoes and looking for max traction, I would get the 17" wheels widened. You've already invested thousands of dollars into the build, what's a few hundred more. No point in cutting corners now. It gives you the wider wheels you want and keeps the look of the thin spokes that you are after. I would outfit them with some 28x11.50 MT Street R bias ply tires. Bias ply's aren't as street friendly as a radial, but you will get better traction from them.
If I was in your shoes and looking for max traction, I would get the 17" wheels widened. You've already invested thousands of dollars into the build, what's a few hundred more. No point in cutting corners now. It gives you the wider wheels you want and keeps the look of the thin spokes that you are after. I would outfit them with some 28x11.50 MT Street R bias ply tires. Bias ply's aren't as street friendly as a radial, but you will get better traction from them.
Last edited by fivelitrecobra; 05-10-2018 at 03:51 PM.
#19
I have an 01 Z06TT and also want to keep the stock wheel look. Stock I have front 17x9.5 and rear 18x10.5. Im going to switch these and put the 18s on front and 17s on rear. I have a friend that did this and runs M&H 275/50/17 and it fits. Im going to try MT ET street R 305/45/17.
#20
Pro
Thread Starter
wheel tire sizes
I have an 01 Z06TT and also want to keep the stock wheel look. Stock I have front 17x9.5 and rear 18x10.5. Im going to switch these and put the 18s on front and 17s on rear. I have a friend that did this and runs M&H 275/50/17 and it fits. Im going to try MT ET street R 305/45/17.